NEET: Supreme Court asks Centre whether it would like to revisit Rs 8 lakh criteria for determining EWS

Asia's Tech News Daily

EWS, NEET, DY Chandrachud, supreme court, union ministry of social justice

The Supreme Court on Thursday asked the Centre whether it would like to revisit the limit of rupees eight lakh annual income fixed for determining the Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) category for reservation in NEET admissions for medical courses. The top court clarified that it is not embarking into the policy domain but is only trying to ascertain whether constitutional principles have adhered or not.

A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud, Vikram Nath, and BV Nagarathna was annoyed as no affidavits were filed by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and the Department of Personnel and Training (DOPT) and formulated questions to be answered by the Centre in a week.

The bench said, “Tell us if you want to revisit the criteria or not. If you want us to discharge our duties, then we are ready to do so. We are formulating questions which you need to answer them”.

It added, “We may stay the government notification fixing rupees eight lakh criteria for determining the EWS and you can keep filing the affidavits”.

The top court was hearing a batch of pleas challenging the Centre and Medical Counselling Committee (MCC) July 29 notice providing 27 per cent reservation for Other Backward Class (OBC) and 10 per cent for EWS category in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) admissions for medical courses.

The top court once again asked searching questions from Additional Solicitor General KM Nataraj, appearing for Centre, and asked whether any exercise was undertaken before fixing a limit of Rs 8 lakh annual income for determining the EWS category.

“Whether Major Gen (retd) SR Sinho commission report of 2010 was considered before ascertaining the criteria? The report of the commission has to be placed on record before the court,” the bench said.

Major Gen (retd) SR Sinho commission was constituted by the UPA government in 2010 and has recommended welfare measures for the EWS category.

Natarajan said that the commission’s report was one of the basis for determining the criteria but after that several deliberations were held and other factors were also taken into account.

“Fixing of criteria of Rs 8 lakh is a pure policy matter and the court should not interfere with it. It was decided after proper application of mind,” he said.

Natarajan submitted that the draft of the affidavit by concerned departments is ready and they will be filing it in a day or two.

The bench said that it is not going to tell the government as to what should be the limit whether it should be rupees four lakh or rupees six lakh because it is for the executive to decide but all it wants to know is what was the basis for fixing Rs 8 lakh as the limit.

“For determining creamy layer in Other Backward Classes (OBC) category the limit was fixed as Rs 8 lakh annual income and they were considered progressed class among OBCs and they were excluded from reservation benefits. Here, for the EWS category, the limit is the same Rs 8 lakh annual income but it was for inclusion in the reservation benefits,” the bench said.

It added, “You cannot just pick Rs 8 lakh out of the thin air and fix it as a criteria. There has to be some basis, some study. Tell us whether any demographic study or data was taken into account in fixing the limit. How do you arrive at this exact figure? Can the Supreme Court strike down the criteria, if no study was undertaken?”

It asked the Centre to respond to a question that since the income limit of determining the creamy layer in OBC category and EWS is the same that is Rs 8 lakh, whether it would be arbitrary to provide a similar income limit for EWS and OBC.

The top court also asked whether rural and urban purchasing power was accounted for and on what basis the asset exception was arrived at and why the residential flat criteria do not differentiate between metropolitan and non-metropolitan areas.

The bench said that as per the explanation in the 103rd constitution amendment says that criteria for EWS will be notified by the state governments, then how can the Centre notify a uniform EWS criterion for the whole of the country.

The top court then formulated the question and asked the Union Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and DOPT to file their replies by October 28.

On October 7, the top court had posed searching questions to the Centre on its decision to fix a limit of rupees eight lakh annual income for determining the EWS category for reservation in NEET admissions.

The Centre had then said fixing a limit of Rs eight lakh annual income for the EWS category is a matter of policy based on the National Cost of Living Index.

On September 17, the top court has agreed to hear a batch of pleas of students against the July 29 notice providing 27 per cent reservation for OBC and 10 per cent for EWS category in 15 per cent UG and 50 per cent PG All India Quota seats (MBBS/BDS and MD/MS/MDS) with effect from the current academic session 2021-22. PTI MNL MNL RKS RKS

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Kriti Sanon joins the cast of 'Shehzada' in Delhi

© IANS Kriti Sanon joining ‘Shehzada’. Mumbai, Dec 1 (IANS) Fresh from the success of ‘Hum Do Hamare Do’, Kriti Sanon has joined the starcast of ‘Shehzada’ in Delhi for ... Read more »

Shehnaaz Gill appears in public months after Sidharth Shukla's death, pics from orphanage visit win hearts | See here

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Entertainment Desk: Months after the demise of close friend Sidharth Shukla, actress and former Bigg Boss 13 contestant Shehnaaz Gill made ... Read more »

Jersey: Shahid Kapoor is an endearing father in a new poster, reveals why it is his favourite

© Provided by Pinkvilla Shahid Kapoor starrer Jersey already has fans counting down to the New Year for the launch of the much-awaited film. Slated to release in theatres on ... Read more »

German state reports four fully vaccinated people infected with Omicron

People visit a Christmas market as the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) continues in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) – Four people in southern Germany have tested positive for the Omicron ... Read more »

Clifford the Big Red Dog EXCLUSIVE: Jack Whitehall QUIPS One Direction split aided Darby Camp in crying scenes

© Provided by Pinkvilla We’re just a few days away from cooing with bubbling joy at the cutest giant dog named Clifford in Clifford the Big Red Dog. The talented ... Read more »

Sirivennela Seetharama Sastry funeral: Nagarjuna, Pawan Kalyan, Jr NTR attend last rites pay their respects

© Provided by Pinkvilla Telugu Sirivennela Seetharama Sastry passed away and left the Tollywood industry in huge shock. On Wednesday, his mortal was taken to the Film Chamber for public ... Read more »

Arjun Kapoor on new look for Kuttey: Have to let go of all inhibitions & really go deep into playing the role

© Provided by Pinkvilla Arjun Kapoor is sporting a sharp new look for his upcoming film ‘Kuttey’, a dark comedy. Even though he misses his long hair, the actor says ... Read more »

Young black Londoners twice as likely to be unemployed as white counterparts

The government is being called on to ‘urgently address the appalling disparity’ (Getty Images) Young black Londoners are twice as likely to be unemployed as their white counterparts with more ... Read more »

Labor to back bill forcing charities to reveal donors in deal with government for dropping voter ID laws

Photograph: Julian Smith/AAP Legal expert says legislation is ‘an effort to silence’ charities the Coalition government ‘doesn’t like’ Get our free news app; get our morning email briefing Labor will ... Read more »

Prince Andrew dragged into Maxwell trial as court hears how he flew on Epstein's jet

Prince Andrew Prince Andrew has been dragged into Ghislane Maxwell’s sex-trafficking trial after Jeffrey Epstein’s long-time pilot told a New York court that the Duke was one of a number ... Read more »

New COVID-19 Variant: Centre mandates 7-day quarantine for travellers coming from 'at-risk' countries

If tested negative, the travellers from ‘at-risk’ countries will have to follow home quarantine for seven days, the health ministry’s guidelines stated. (Representative image) Amid concerns over the Omicron variant ... Read more »

How To Cook Meat-free Dishes

© Provided by Yummy PH Are you eating less meat lately? Many households may be doing the same. With pork prices being so high that it rivals beef and the ... Read more »

Clarity on climate and health plans needed to avoid 'significant' cost to State, watchdog warns

© Alamy Stock Photo The Fiscal Advisory Council said it remains unclear what the cost to the Government will be in halving Ireland s greenhouse emissions by 2030 and there ... Read more »

U.S. military leaders in S.Korea for talks over N.Korea, alliance

© Reuters/PASCAL ROSSIGNOL FILE PHOTO: U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin with NATO partners SEOUL (Reuters) – U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin and other top military officials were set to ... Read more »

Muhyiddin silap cakap RM3 bilion beri vaksin kepada 6.4 juta orang, kata KJ

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PAC berkata, kenyataan bekas Perdana Menteri, Muhyiddin Yassin, mengenai kos memberi vaksin kepada setiap orang di negara ini mengakibatkan kekeliruan. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: ... Read more »

‘No record of farmers' death during protests': Govt informs Parliament, says no plans for compensation

© Provided by Hindustan Times Union agriculture minister Narendra Singh Tomar . (ANI File Photo) The government has no record of the farmers who had died during the year-long farmers’ ... Read more »

Yankees haven't fixed anything in disappointing start to offseason

No obligation for any of us outsiders to turn up the heat on the Yankees. Just turn back to what the ultimate insider, Hal Steinbrenner, said last month after bringing ... Read more »

PM hails BSF's contribution in securing the nation

© Provided by The Statesman PM hails BSF’s contribution in securing the nation Prime Minister Narendra Modi today hailed the significant contribution being made by the Border Security Force (BSF) ... Read more »

Commercial LPG cylinder rates hiked by Rs 100

© Provided by Business Today Commercial LPG cylinder rates hiked by Rs 100 The price of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) cylinders for commercial use has been hiked by Rs 100 ... Read more »

UP couple tortured for Hindu-Muslim love moves on from miscarriage & jail, builds a happy life

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: A year has passed since Pinky, 23, lost her baby in a miscarriage. Her husband Rashid could not comfort her at the time, ... Read more »

Upstox allows opening demat accounts, IPO applications through WhatsApp

© Provided by Business Today Upstox allows opening demat accounts, IPO applications through WhatsApp Recently turned unicorn Upstox has said that it will now allow investors to invest in initial ... Read more »

RBI payment rules not helping SaaS companies, says Freshworks' Girish Mathrubootham

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Nasdaq-listed Freshworks’ founder and CEO Girish Mathrubootham called on the Reserve Bank of India to create a whitelist of “good” companies so that they are not ... Read more »

November records lowest number of fresh COVID-19 cases in India since May, 2020

With over 3.1 lakh fresh COVID-19 cases, the month of November saw the lowest number of people contracting the viral disease in the country since May last year. The monthly ... Read more »

Chill in hills: Snow, rain forecast in Himachal Pradesh till December 4

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Shimla-based weather department has forecast disruption in essential services such as power and communication and blockade of roads in Kinnaur, Lahaul-Spiti, Chamba and the ... Read more »

Rylan Clark-Neal apologises for 'scaring people' after 4-month break

Rylan Clark-Neal has apologised for Rylan Clark-Neal has apologised for “scaring people” after he had a four-month break from the spotlight earlier this year, following his split from husband Dan ... Read more »

Sanofi to buy Origimm Biotechnology for acne vaccine candidate

FILE PHOTO: Sanofi logo is seen in Paris PARIS (Reuters) -French healthcare company Sanofi said on Wednesday it would buy Austrian group Origimm Biotechnology, a move that will add a ... Read more »

Yuvraj has a romantic message for wife Hazel on 5th wedding anniversary

© Provided by Mid-Day Former India cricketer Yuvraj Singh Instagrammed this picture with his wife Hazel Keech on the occasion of their fifth wedding anniversary yesterday and captioned it, “5 ... Read more »

'Qanon Caucus' v/s 'Jihad Squad': American politics plumbs new depths amid female firefight

© Provided by The Times of India WASHINTON: As political scrapes go, America has seen nothing like this. When the last electoral cycle resulted in the election of a record ... Read more »

FIR filed against Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg over defamatory post against Akhilesh Yadav

A case has been registered against Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg over an alleged controversial post against Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav. The case has been filed at a court in ... Read more »

Senators say US must strengthen space debris monitoring

A group of US senators on Tuesday asked the Biden administration to do more to monitor and respond to space debris following Russia’s anti-satellite test. Commerce Committee chair Maria Cantwell, ... Read more »

Jaish Militants on 'Red List', Who Planted IED in 2019, Killed in Encounter in Pulwama

© Provided by News18 Jaish Militants on ‘Red List’, Who Planted IED in 2019, Killed in Encounter in Pulwama A Pakistani militant and a local associate affiliated with Jaish-e-Mohammad were ... Read more »

Kerala Lottery Result 2021: Check Winning Numbers for Akshaya AK-526 Lottery for December 1; First Prize Rs 70 Lakh!

© Provided by News18 Kerala Lottery Result 2021: Check Winning Numbers for Akshaya AK-526 Lottery for December 1; First Prize Rs 70 Lakh! Kerala Akshaya AK-526 Lottery Result 2021 Live ... Read more »

Petrol price in Delhi to reduce by Rs 8/litre

The Delhi government has reduced the value-added tax (VAT) on petrol to 19.40% from 30% previously. This cut means petrol in the capital city will now be lesser by Rs ... Read more »

Microsoft Is Launching a Special Sweater for Christmas

© Provided by News18 Microsoft Is Launching a Special Sweater for Christmas It is the end of the year, and Microsoft has released its own Windows software theme ‘ugly sweater,’ ... Read more »

Star Health public issue sees 14% subscription on Day 2 of bidding; retail portion booked 75%

© Kshitij Anand Star Health public issue sees 14% subscription on Day 2 of bidding; retail portion booked 75% The public offer of Star Health and Allied Insurance Company has ... Read more »

Terrifying Covid variant to destroy stock market - is YOUR pension safe?

Last Friday, we had a taste of what Omicron can do to stock markets. Airline, leisure, entertainment and energy stocks collapsed as investors feared another wave of lockdowns. Indices plunged ... Read more »

Which Wildlife Photographer of the Year snap will win the public vote?

A collection of 25 stunning wildlife images have been released in the running for the Wildlife Photographer of the Year People’s Choice Award. © Thomas Peschak,/Wildlife Photographer of the Year ... Read more »

‘Doctors refused to prescribe me an EpiPen for life-threatening allergies for six months'

A woman with severe life-threatening allergies is fighting to get a letter expunged from her records that recommended doctors should not prescribe her an epinephrine injection – leaving her without ... Read more »

Manchester United hope Ralf Rangnick can follow Liverpool and Chelsea blueprint

Jonathan Greening believes Manchester United hope to emulate Liverpool and Chelsea’s success with German managers after the decision to appoint Ralf Rangnick as interim manager. Jurgen Klopp and Thomas Tuchel ... Read more »

Families face punishing tax crackdown on 'granny annexes'

© Provided by The Telegraph landlords stamp duty tax buy to let Families will be forced to pay thousands more in stamp duty for buying a property with a “granny ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic