Ndlovu trial: How could security guard sister afford hefty insurance policy payments?

© Provided by Times Live

Alleged killer cop Nomia Rosemary Ndlovu got hot under the collar when she was asked about how her sister, Audrey Somisa Ndlovu, had managed to pay substantial amounts for life and funeral cover while she only made R2,700 in her job as a security guard.

An irate Ndlovu fanned herself, responded loudly and spoke faster than she usually did as she replied. She was being questioned by prosecutor Riana Williams in the high court sitting in Johannesburg on Monday.

“Are you angry with me?” Williams asked Ndlovu, with the tension now palpable in the courtroom.

“I am not angry. I just took my pills, I did not get enough food. I am dizzy and finding it difficult to concentrate,” said Ndlovu after a 15-minute lunch break given by the court.

Ndlovu is accused of killing six people, including her sister Audrey, in June 2013, allegedly so she could pocket large insurance payouts.  Audrey was found dead in her rented room in Thembisa. She had apparently been given a poisonous substance and later strangled to death.

“How much did you make [in insurance payouts]?” Williams had asked Ndlovu.

“I am not sure because the policies did not all pay out at the same time.  Others were opened by Audrey. Some took several months to pay out,” said Ndlovu.

The state claimed she had pocketed over R717,000.

“I am not disputing that. I never calculated the amount because I never had the opportunity to sit in court and calculate this amount while in prison. All I am saying is that I simply did not have an opportunity to do the calculations,” she added.

It is the state’s case that on the day before Audrey died, Ndlovu had visited her Thembisa room. As the two sisters walked to the premises where Audrey lived, she stopped to make small talk with a neighbour and introduced Ndlovu to her neighbour — referred to in court as Mrs Ngoepe.

The state alleges that the sisters decided to share a meal together and Audrey then left her sister in her room to make them tea while she went to buy bread and atchar. It was then that Ndlovu was alleged to have slipped the poisonous substance into her sister’s tea. Audrey returned, they ate and Ndlovu left with a promise that she would return later. 

The state alleges Ndlovu seemingly came back to find Audrey still alive and then strangled her to death, locked the security gate behind her and went home. The next day, she returned and alerted neighbours that she was unable to reach her sister by phone and was concerned, even crying and expressing fears that her sister may be dead.

The neighbours, including Audrey’s boyfriend who lived in the back of a house opposite hers, cut through her burglar bars and found Audrey dead in the house. Her body had started to decompose under the blanket.

It was while in Audrey’s room after the  body was found, with police on the scene, that Ndlovu allegedly knocked over two cups, picked them up and put them in a basin full of water outside the room, despite being warned by police not to do so.

The state believes these were the cups the sisters had used to drink tea the previous day. 

The state said looking at Audrey’s finances, even with her side-hustle of selling Tupperware and perfume, it was almost impossible for her to have opened those life insurance policies herself as she could not afford them.

An audio recording made by the insurance companies for one of the policies was taken by the state to a voice analyst. He found that it was most likely Ndlovu’s voice that was heard on the line, fuelling the state’s claims that the policies may have been opened fraudulently by Ndlovu, with her sister knowing nothing about them.

All these points were put to Ndlovu and she refuted all the allegations against her.

On the voice analysis, she maintained her and her sister’s voice sounded very similar and she denied impersonating her. 

She said bumping over the cups was accidental and while she did put the cups in a basin, she did not know it had water in it.

“But why did you put them in the bucket?” Williams asked.

“I did mention that I bumped the cups, they fell and I took the cups as I was on my way out, but it was not done intentionally. It’s not something that I had set out to do. At the time, I was crying and hysterical,” Ndlovu answered.

Presiding judge Ramarumo Monama repeated the question.

“But the question is why did you pick them up?,” he asked Ndlovu.

“I bumped the cups and they fell. I picked them up. I was leaving the room because I had just realised what had just happened. I did not want to be in the room any more.”

Ndlovu said she did not know that at that point she was essentially tampering with evidence.

“Maybe if I had said that we had drank tea in the room, the court could see it as tampering of evidence. But we drank the tea outside because it was cold and we were basking in the sun,” said Ndlovu, now suggesting that the cups she had placed in the basin were not the same ones she and her sister had used just a day earlier to drink tea.

“I never heard [her friend and police officer, Phindile Shulube] warning me to not put the cups in the basin. I was just tidying up. The action came naturally,” she stressed.

“I put it to you, you washed those cups,” Williams said.

“I didn’t. Even the extract [from my bail application] says I put them in water. I did not wash them,” Ndlovu hit back.

Williams pressed on.

“On June 25, 2013, what did you guys drink?”

“Tea — in fact it was coffee,” answered Ndlovu.

“What was in it?” Williams asked, questioning whether it was black, white, had sugar or any other substance in it.

Ndlovu suggested she was unsure of how her sister took her coffee that day.

On how Audrey, who was employed as a security guard, had been able to survive and also pay numerous life insurance policies, Ndlovu said besides her side-hustle, Audrey had in the past had a boyfriend who had a good job, at times even supporting her financially. Ndlovu said she too would assist Audrey with rent money or with Tupperware sales.

“If we accept your version that she took out policies in her own money … Your sister had no spare money to pay for policies.  Audrey earned R2,700 a month,” Williams said.

It was then that Ndlovu put an end to Monday’s questioning.

“I am not feeling well. I am dizzy, the court is spinning, my legs are in pain [from the shackles]. I ate too quickly and now I am finding it difficult to focus or concentrate,” she told the court.

Proceedings had to be adjourned and Ndlovu made her way down to the court cells, leaning on the banister.

This week, the state has brought in a psychologist to analyse her behaviour on the stand. This is evidence that the state will use when it produces its heads of argument.

The matter returns to court on Tuesday.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


$54.5m for Vic business outdoor trading

© Erik Anderson/AAP PHOTOS Melbourne’s pubs can open for 20 fully vaccinated customers indoors, and 50 outdoors, from Friday. Businesses and councils can apply for a share in a $54.5 ... Read more »

States to end FY22 on a slightly better note

© Provided by The Financial Express As of now, the capex trends are nothing to write home about and one would need to see a smart pick up in the ... Read more »

Online fraud: Recover stolen money within 10 days - Here's how

© Provided by DNA During lockdown, instances of cybercrime such as online frauds have significantly risen. Over 2.7 crore adults have been targets of identity theft in the last year ... Read more »

ESG Investing: Relook ESG measuring for a more balanced approach

© Provided by The Financial Express The vast majority of economic activity undertaken by humans usually ends up causing some damage to the environment. By Rameesh Kailasam The vast majority ... Read more »

One dead, seven injured in second shooting at Louisiana university in a week

(Reuters) – One person died and seven others were injured in a shooting at Grambling State University in Louisiana early on Sunday, the second such deadly incident on campus in ... Read more »

Asma Khan's secret ingredient: nutmeg

Nutmeg is not something we historically had in India, it came with the spice trade. It’s a warming, winter spice. Winter is India’s family wedding season. It’s no longer hot, ... Read more »

U.S. tells Supreme Court Guantanamo detainee can give limited testimony

FILE PHOTO: The U.S. flag flies at the U.S. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba By Kanishka Singh (Reuters) – The administration of U.S. President Joe Biden informed the Supreme ... Read more »

Schiff says holding Bannon in criminal contempt 'a way of getting people's attention'

Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) on Sunday said holding ex-Trump White House strategist Steve Bannon in criminal contempt would be “a way of getting people’s attention,” as the select committee probing ... Read more »

Sen. Joe Manchin is demanding Biden's child tax credit come with a work requirement and income cap around $60,000, report says

© AP Photo/Andrew Harnik Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., speaks at a news conference outside of his office on Capitol Hill in Washington, Wednesday, Oct. 6, 2021. AP Photo/Andrew Harnik Sen. ... Read more »

Ethnic pay gap exists in third-level education, study shows

An ethnic pay gap in Irish higher education has been exposed in a ground-breaking study. Staff from ethnic minorities are more likely to be on temporary contracts and to be ... Read more »

Covid survivor: ‘I was so anti-immune compromised that I am sure it was the vaccine that saved my life'

A man (41) who was vaccinated against Covid-19 – but still ended up in ICU for six days fighting the virus – says he believes the vaccine saved his life. ... Read more »

‘There are issues across the board getting stocks of toys in'

Irish shops are working overtime to ensure as much is on offer to consumers as possible ahead of the festive season. Gareth Staunton, of Nimble Fingers toyshop, in Stillorgan, south ... Read more »

Hospitals fear surge in patients if Covid restrictions are eased

Hospitals are bracing for a spike in people being hospitalised with Covid-19 as the National Public Health Emergency Team (Nphet) meets today to discuss the easing of restrictions. The increasing ... Read more »

Principals warn that whole classes could be sent home over substitutes shortage

Primary schools will be forced to send classes home if difficulties finding substitute cover are not resolved quickly, a principals’ leader has warned. Páiric Clerkin, the CEO of the Irish Primary ... Read more »

Toys, Christmas trees and electronics added to hard-to-get list as global supplies buckle

Toys, Christmas trees, clothing, car parts and electronics are on a list of hard-to-get items as Ireland feels the knock-on effects of global supply constraints. The advice from retailers is ... Read more »

Raja penapis air kembali! Penapis Air CUCKOO KING TOP hanya RM60 sebulan sahaja

KAEDAH menjerang air masih digunapakai untuk dijadikan air minuman dan kegunaan harian. Namun, air yang dimasak boleh menimbulkan rasa klorin dan lebih membimbangkan jika punca saluran paip di rumah kotor ... Read more »

NFL Week 6 rookie QB grades: Trevor Lawrence keeps growing in first win; Mac Jones sizzles and fizzles

Week 6 was a much-needed midterm break for two of the NFL’s rookie passers. Jets QB Zach Wilson and 49ers passer Trey Lance both got early bye weeks, and it couldn’t ... Read more »

Canada's speed skaters deliver throughout national championships to begin Olympic season

© Peter Dejong/The Associated Press Canada’s Ivanie Blondin, shown in this file photo in the final of World Cup speedskating in 2020, won the women’s 1,500m event at the Canadian ... Read more »

Heads of Japan major parties to hold debate ahead of key election

© Reuters/Eugene Hoshiko Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida attends a news conference in Tokyo TOKYO (Reuters) – The heads of Japan’s major parties will hold a public debate on Monday ... Read more »

CSIRO study screens flight wastewater as a cheap way to test for Covid

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Analysing wastewater samples from long-haul flights of returning Australians could be the key to detecting COVID-19 earlier – before passengers show any symptoms. ... Read more »

HP: Cong expels ex-CM Virbhadra Singh's close aide for 6 years over ‘anti-party activities'

© Provided by The Indian Express DAYS AHEAD of the Arki Vidhan Sabha bypoll, BJP and Congress are battling fears of internal sabotage as disgruntled local leaders of both parties’ ... Read more »

13 new Covid cases in Tricity, no deaths

© Provided by The Indian Express The Tricity reported 13 new coronavirus cases on Sunday. No virus-related death was reported here. There are 66 active cases here at present. Mohali: ... Read more »

Mohali reports 143 more dengue cases in a day

© Provided by The Indian Express In only the first 17 days of this month, Mohali district has reported 1,183 positive dengue cases. The district on Sunday reported 143 positive ... Read more »

Kate Middleton dazzles in recycled McQueen gown at Earthshot awards with Prince William

Kate Middleton dazzled as she walked on the green carpet alongside Prince William at the Earthshot Prize awards ceremony. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge were pictured arriving at the ... Read more »

Oil prices climb to highest in years as COVID recovery, power generators stoke demand

By Jessica Jaganathan © Reuters/Ahmed Jadallah FILE PHOTO: General view of Saudi Aramco’s Ras Tanura oil refinery and oil terminal in Saudi Arabia SINGAPORE (Reuters) – Oil prices hit their ... Read more »

Aboriginal bush trackers have arrived to help find missing Cleo

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Cleo Smith’s family have brought in local Aboriginal bush trackers to help find the four-year-old after she disappeared from a campsite in the ... Read more »

Inside the Nats partyroom: the politicians holding Australia's climate policy to ransom

The Nationals spent four hours yesterday in a tense meeting over whether to support a largely inadequate target of net zero emissions by 2050. They reached no agreement. Four hours ... Read more »

Brooklyn woman arrested in connection with suspected arson at a Jewish school

The New York Police Department arrested a 39-year-old Brooklyn woman Sunday in connection with a suspected arson at the Jewish school Yeshiva of Flatbush, according to a tweet from the ... Read more »

Biden's Plans Raise Questions About What U.S. Can or Cannot Afford to Do

WASHINGTON — As lawmakers debate how much to spend on President Biden’s sprawling domestic agenda, they are really arguing about a seemingly simple issue: affordability. © T.J. Kirkpatrick for The ... Read more »

Cisco renews lease pact for over 2.7-million-sq-ft office space in Bangalore

American technology major Cisco Systems’ India arm has renewed its lease for 9 commercial buildings totalling over 2.7 million sq ft in the largest office lease transactions in the country ... Read more »

Mauritius may be out of FATF Grey List this month

Global investors and offshore funds entering India through Mauritius are betting that in a few weeks the tax haven will shed some of its stigma and come out of the ... Read more »

Stocks in the news: HDFC Bank, DMart, UltraTech Cement, PNB Housing & Dixon Tech

Nifty futures on the Singapore Exchange traded 47 points, or 0.26 per cent, higher at 18,451, signaling that Dalal Street was headed for a positive start on Monday. Here are ... Read more »

The Finance Ghost: JSE news that moved markets

Back when FIFA was running South Africa in the build-up to the 2010 World Cup, construction stocks were booming. Cranes dominated the skylines and exuberance filled the streets. Construction companies ... Read more »

Car, two-wheeler sales lack sparkle, Chip shortage pushing down stocks and demand

Retail sales of passenger vehicles and two-wheelers in the festive season’s initial phase appear relatively dull pan-India, in comparison with record property registrations in Mumbai. A chronic chip shortage and ... Read more »

Toyota, Suzuki tie-up may extend to EVs, green tech

(This story originally appeared in on Oct 18, 2021) New Delhi: For the first time ever, a Maruti car is expected to roll out of Toyota’s factory in India as ... Read more »

Emiliano Sala death flight: Man who organised trip goes on trial

The trial of a man charged with endangering the safety of an aircraft which crashed and killed Argentinian footballer Emiliano Sala will begin on Monday. David Henderson, of Hotham in ... Read more »

Adam Peaty's girlfriend's reaction to seeing his 'almost kiss'

Olympian Adam Peaty danced the Argentine tango with his dance partner, Katya Jones, on Strictly Come Dancing on Saturday night (October 16). The pair shared an 'almost kiss' after a ... Read more »

Bantu kami bawa masuk bakat IT luar, kata persatuan

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Persatuan PKS berkata digitalisasi akan menjadi asas dan perkara utama untuk era pasca pandemik. PETALING JAYA: Akses yang lebih baik kepada pinjaman dan kadar ... Read more »

Petanda positif liga tempatan pilihan tontonan

© Provided by Sinar Harian KEJAYAAN saingan Liga Super menarik tontonan lebih 77 juta pada saingan musim ini disifatkan satu pencapaian yang boleh dibanggakan Liga Bola Sepak Malaysia (MFL) pada ... Read more »

Perkongsian kuasa pilih calon lemahkan kedudukan Zahid?

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Ismail Sabri Yaakob (dari kiri), Mohamad Hasan dan Ahmad Zahid Hamidi akan menentukan calon dalam pemilihan Umno. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING JAYA: Proses penentuan calon ... Read more »