NBN roundtable returns focus to customer needs - and NBN Co's costs

Areas of scrutiny revealed.

released discussion papers, pdf, angling for a full breakdown, understand NBN Co’s costs

Retailers selling NBN services have sought to prioritise customers’ expectations of broadband services in critical discussions that promise to radically shake up the way NBN services are priced.

The retailers, together with other stakeholders, attended a roundtable discussion with Chatham House rules last month convened by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and NBN Co.

Both the ACCC and NBN Co released discussion papers before the roundtable, pointing to their present thinking around long-term pricing models.

The model that most retailers are advocating for is a single flat-price wholesale charge, and the removal of variable charges that create problems when trying to set retail prices.

A summary of the roundtable [pdf], released today, still shows a “preference” among “several attendees” for a flat-rate pricing model.

The issue of flat-pricing has so far been dominated by whether it can be achieved in a way that satisfies NBN Co’s economics.

However, attendees of the roundtable sought to refocus the discussion around customers’ needs, while questioning whether NBN Co’s spending – and therefore cost recovery needs – were efficient.

Both of these are important.

On needs and expectations, attendees said “consumers have certain expectations about the NBN in relation to quality of service, price and choice.”

Any changes to NBN Co’s price or non-price terms “should allow these expectations to be reasonably met,” attendees are reported as saying.

One attendee noted that “consumers still expect steady (or even falling) prices for the same (or better) service quality.”

“In particular, consumers remain reluctant to materially increase the proportion of their income that is spent on telecommunications services,” the ACCC summary notes.

“A number of attendees expressed their support for measures that would keep affordable NBN products in the market.”

Concerns were also raised around the extent to which the NBN closed the “digital divide” between cities and the bush.

“Consumers have an expectation that the NBN will narrow the digital divide and so an objective of uniform national pricing should help guide this process,” the ACCC paraphrased one attendee as saying.

On the issue of NBN Co’s costs, and its ability to recover them and make a commercial return, it appears there was considerable debate.

This has some history; Telstra has been angling for a full breakdown of NBN Co’s costs since April last year.

The ACCC has indicated it is also keen to understand NBN Co’s costs, with chair Rod Sims separately saying that NBN Co’s ability to generate financial returns should take a backseat to pricing and usability.

That, together with the roundtable discussion, sets a clear expectation that this regulatory process – to redesign the NBN special access undertaking (SAU) – is likely to be the one that finally digs into NBN Co’s financials.

“Many attendees agreed that there is a need to undertake an assessment of the efficiency of the expenditure incurred by NBN Co during the rollout of the NBN, including NBN Co’s capitalised losses,” the ACCC summary notes.

“Attendees (retail service providers, in particular) considered that the revised SAU should provide for NBN Co’s costs to be assessed on a forward looking basis (i.e., ahead of incurrence), as should the efficiency of investment plans.”

This led to a conclusion that a “new building block model should be developed.”

A building block model or BBM is used to “estimate prices that reflect efficient costs.” [pdf]

In the past, one was used by the ACCC, for example, when setting regulated prices for wholesale access to Telstra’s fixed-line network.

“Several attendees supported the development of a new BBM,” the ACCC summary states.

“They agreed with the following observations: the existing model used to assess compliance with the current SAU long term revenue constraint does not provide linkages between the efficient costs of the NBN and the prices charged for NBN services.

“The ACCC’s development of a new BBM needs to be a transparent process and access seekers should have the opportunity to be involved in its development.

“[And] the BBM should be capable of attributing costs to specific NBN services, such as between mass market services and enterprise services.”

That last point could also flush out the extent to which NBN Co has cross-subsidised its incursion into the competitive enterprise and government market using its residential business, a long-held suspicion in parts of the industry.

News Related


Queensland is fifth state to legalise euthanasia for terminally ill

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk’s Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill was on Thursday passed by 61 of the state’s 93 MPs in a conscience vote in ... Read more »

Here's why the news about Australia getting nuclear submarines with the help of the US and UK is a big deal

If you haven’t noticed, there’s been a lot of hype around today about a deal to make Australia one of the few countries in the world equipped with nuclear submarines. ... Read more »

As NSW Icac renews its investigation into Daryl Maguire, what has the watchdog uncovered so far?

At least two departments have been asked to hand over documents to the New South Wales Independent Commission Against Corruption as it renews its probe into the disgraced former MP ... Read more »

Queenslanders in home quarantine will receive randomly timed texts

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Australians in home quarantine will soon receive timed text messages to ensure they are isolating or face a visit from the cops as ... Read more »

Adelaide residents react to nuclear submarine move after Naval Group deal scuttled

© Provided by ABC NEWS Susanne Johncock lives a stone’s throw from the ASC site, and expressed deep reservations about the decision to scrap the Naval Group deal. (ABC News: Lincoln Rothall) Jobs and ... Read more »

Former minister Adam Brooks remains under interim family violence order ahead of mediation

© Provided by ABC NEWS Adam Brooks was a minister in the state government when he was in Parliament. (ABC News) The ex-partner of former Tasmanian Liberal politician Adam Brooks ... Read more »

NRL clubs get extra $7 million in funding

The NRL will hand out a combined $7 million in COVID-19 relief packages to clubs to make up for lost revenue through a lack of crowds and home games. © ... Read more »

Biloela Tamil family to be granted new three-month bridging visas to stay in Australia

The Murugappan family from Biloela will be allowed to stay in Australia for at least another three months after the immigration minister, Alex Hawke, told a court he intended to ... Read more »

Qld legalises voluntary assisted dying

Terminally ill Queenslanders will be able to end their lives at a time of their choosing from early next year after the state parliament voted to legalise voluntary assisted dying. ... Read more »

Disappointment after WA fails to snag submarine defence maintenance contract

© Provided by ABC NEWS The Collins class submarine maintenance contract will remain in Adelaide. (ABC News: Dave Weber) The WA Premier has slammed a Federal Government decision not to allow Western Australia ... Read more »

Tourism Central Australia 'thrown under the bus' by NT reopening road map, says tourism body

Tourism and hospitality businesses have raised concerns about the Northern Territory’s road map out of lockdowns, revealed by the Territory government yesterday. The road map paves the way for life ... Read more »

Brad Scott chooses AFL role over coaching

Brad Scott is out of the running for the vacant Carlton head coach role after taking up a role in the AFL’s football department. © James Ross/AAP PHOTOS Former North ... Read more »

Third time unlucky for SA rocket launch

A rocket set to lift-off from a facility on South Australia’s Eyre Peninsula has caught fire on the pad, the third time in a week it has failed to launch. ... Read more »

Queensland legalises voluntary assisted dying

Voluntary assisted dying is now law in Queensland. This afternoon the parliament voted to legalise the right of the terminally ill to choose when to end their life. The legislation ... Read more »

Australia's submarine program has truly lost its rudder

China is well on its way to achieving its goal of complete military modernisation by 2027 and already has more warships and submarines than the US. China’s shipyards launch a ... Read more »

Applause in Queensland Parliament gallery as historic bill passed legalising voluntary assisted dying

© Provided by ABC NEWS Susan Reilly and her mother who died of breast cancer in 2001. (Supplied: Susan Reilly) Queensland will become the fifth state to legalise voluntary assisted ... Read more »

Selangor State Government collaborates with Wilstech to digitalise 200 SMEs

SIDEC will offer grants on digitalisation projects for SMEs in the Malaysian state. Read more »

Students plunged into four-hour lockdown after threats

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A knife-wielding teenager has plunged an entire school and two nearby daycares into a four-hour lockdown, forcing terrified children to urinate in a ... Read more »

Fears alleged fraudster Papas ploughed Westpac millions into shares

© Getty Westpac is homing in on share investments made by colourful soccer identity Bill Papas through an online trading platform amid fears the Forum Finance boss ploughed millions he ... Read more »

Joe Biden calls Scott Morrison 'that fella Down Under' during AUKUS nuclear submarine announcement

It‘s one of the most significant strategic and defence moves in decades, cementing Australia’s alliance with the US and the UK for years to come.  But as Prime Minister Scott ... Read more »

Melbourne man jailed for almost killing neighbour over washing machine

A Melbourne man who almost stabbed his neighbour to death over a fight about a load of washing has been jailed. Brett Vaisey, 57, was sentenced to seven years’ jail ... Read more »

Tasmania pledges salmon industry 'reset'

Tasmania’s heavily scrutinised salmon industry will undergo a “reset” under a state government plan to increase land-based fish farming and operations in deeper waters. © Daniel Munoz/AAP PHOTOS The Tasmanian ... Read more »

Reprieve for Bilo family amid legal battle

A Tamil family has been granted a small reprieve in their fight to remain in Australia with the granting of another bridging visa enabling them to stay in the country ... Read more »

Biloela Tamil family's complex legal battle continues with new bridging visas

© Provided by ABC NEWS Kopika and Thranicaa Murugappan were born in central Queensland. (Supplied: HometoBilo) The Muruguppan family seeking asylum in Australia will be allowed to stay in the ... Read more »

What are nuclear-powered submarines, anyway? A guide to Australia's looming military addition

The prime minister, Scott Morrison, announced on Thursday morning that Australia would be ripping up its multi-billion dollar contract with the French shipbuilder Naval Group and sign a new deal ... Read more »

Australia on cusp of vaccination milestone

Australia is on the cusp of having 70 per cent of eligible residents receiving their first COVID-19 vaccine dose. © James Ross/AAP PHOTOS Australia is poised to reach a vaccine ... Read more »

SA posts surge in full-time jobs

Full-time employment in South Australia has hit record levels with a surge in new jobs last month, the state government says. © David Mariuz/AAP PHOTOS Nearly 4000 full-time jobs were ... Read more »

No.1 showdown to decide NRL semi-finals

It’s the NRL’s No.1 semi-final showdown some 545 days in the making. © Darren England/AAP PHOTOS NSW teammates James Tedesco and Tom Trbojevic will keep close tabs on each other ... Read more »

Fans snap up GF tickets in buying frenzy

General public tickets for the AFL grand final have sold out within nine minutes, with league boss Gillon McLachlan urging fans to take next week off in order to give ... Read more »

Supercars puts line through Winton event

The Supercars event at Winton in Victoria has been cancelled as the championship’s COVID-enforced hiatus extends into a third month. © PR HANDOUT IMAGE PHOTO Winton has been removed from ... Read more »

ASX posts biggest gains since early August

Investors have enjoyed their biggest gains on the ASX since early August despite jobs figures showing lockdown impacts on the economy. © Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS The ASX had its biggest ... Read more »

AFL prepared for all situations: McLachlan

AFL chief executive Gillon McLachlan is confident the league would find a way to navigate a doomsday scenario of COVID-19 cases appearing in Perth on the eve of the grand ... Read more »

Melbourne Cadbury workers set to strike

Hundreds of Melbourne Cadbury workers are set to go on strike as they push for the global confectionery giant to give them job security and better pay and conditions. Almost ... Read more »

Australia's bushfires triggered massive phytoplankton bloom thousands of kilometres away

Australia’s deadly bushfires two years ago triggered a phytoplankton bloom larger than the country and thousands of kilometres away, scientists say. The huge bloom was discovered in the South Pacific ... Read more »

Kaufusi backs Slater as next Qld coach

He didn’t want Paul Green to leave but Felise Kaufusi has backed Billy Slater to become the next Queensland coach, saying his ex-teammate is more than ready to step up. ... Read more »

Dan Andrews takes dig at Sydney's freedom picnics

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Daniel Andrews has says police will not be patrolling ‘every park’ checking everyone having a picnic is fully vaccinated against Covid-19, in a dig ... Read more »

Victoria's COVID restrictions are changing again. Here's what they will be from 11:59pm Friday

As Victorians hit the target of having 70 per cent of those aged over 16 single-dosed with a COVID-19 vaccine, some small changes are coming into effect. Here are all ... Read more »

APAC faces more disruption compared to other regions during pandemic

The diversity of countries and cultures within the APAC region proved a challenge when transitioning to a hybrid working arrangement. Read more »

Puppet promotes Rachel Lew to Regional Director, Asia and Japan

Lew has over 20 years of experience in channel management and developing business with Fortune 500 firms. Read more »