NBN could end up as a 100Mbps network and the ACCC thinks it might be too quick

Excess pricing will push retailers and thus users towards an access-only 100Mbps plan, which will hollow out the lower end of the market, the ACCC has said.

australia, nbn

Image: Cole Bennetts/Bloomberg via Getty Images

On Monday afternoon, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) released a consultation paper on the proposed variation to the NBN Co Special Access Undertaking, which would codify NBN’s preferred pricing model of removing the loathed connectivity virtual circuit (CVC) capacity charge on plans of 100Mbps and faster.

For 12Mbps, 25Mbps, 50Mbps plans, NBN is putting forward the same type of model it currently uses, where each plan has an allocation of CVC included — often around 6% of the marketed speed or lower — and would see excess capacity at AU$8 per 1Mbps per month to retailers. For plans at 100Mbps and above, a flat access fee each month is paid.

While the flat price plans are set to increase at a rate of the consumer price index (CPI) plus 3% initially, and the greater of CPI or 3% later, which is higher than the pure CPI increases on the bundles, the ACCC believes excess usage charges will steer retailers towards the 100Mbps plan.

“As a result of the retention of CVC charging for the bundled products less than 100Mbps and the CVC cost escalation mechanism built into the SAU proposal (along with allowable CPI+X adjustments), we observe that the costs to retailers of the 50Mbps product are expected to equal those of the 100Mbps product within only a few years and similarly for the 25Mbps product before the end of SAU term [in 2040],” the ACCC said in its consultation paper.

“These dynamics indicate that … a narrowing of reasonably priced access products in the market that could be in turn damaging to the level of retail competition and result in the supply of retail products in the market at higher prices and at speeds in excess of end customer needs.”

Citing the Bureau of Communications and Arts Research, the paper said it is forecast that median household speed requirement will be a mere 29Mbps in 2028, and only 0.1% of households will need speeds greater than 78Mbps, while retailers currently only promote 100Mbps plans are for “larger households” that make up 10% of the market.

NBN is not helping the situation by predicting 13% annual increases in peak data demand while only making CVC increases at half of that level.

“The retention of CVC charging may result in access cost escalation over time, as peak data demand continues to grow. It could also expose retailers and customers to cost increases due to demand shocks, such as those observed during COVID-19 lockdowns,” the ACCC said.

“The cost escalation could occur because the CVC allowances for the bundles appear to be designed not to grow as fast as peak data demand.”

Using NBN’s forecasts, the ACCC said the wholesale cost for an entry level plan would double by 2033 and shoot towards AU$104 per month in nominal terms by 2040.

Along with having the technologies introduced by the Coalition government in 2013 brought under the SAU, the proposal seeks to separate NBN’s services into core and non-core — non-core is proposed to cover enterprise ethernet, business satellite, and satellite mobility services and would not be bound by the SAU.

In an effort to recover its initial costs to build the network — stated at AU$38 billion in real terms or AU$44.5 billion in nominal terms — NBN is putting forward a revenue cap mechanism where it would not make enough money to recover costs for some years, but would begin to rein it all back in during later years.

“The implication of this scenario is that the revenue cap would likely fail to act as a binding constraint on NBN Co or provide any basis for setting prices,” the ACCC said.

“Under NBN Co’s proposal there remains no link between underlying costs and the price structure, price levels, or projected price paths. Further, NBN Co’s proposed pricing and proposed price paths do not appear to contain any direct link to current or future demand.”

The ACCC is inviting submissions on its paper until July 8.

News Related


Funding for Indian startups continues to dip in second quarter

ETtech Illustration: Rahul Awasthi Bengaluru: Venture capital funding into Indian startups dipped 37% in the second quarter of this year to $6.9 billion, data sourced from research firm Venture Intelligence ... Read more »

Creatify Web Services sends legal notice to Trell cofounder Bimal Kartheek Rebba for unpaid dues

ETtech Illustration: Rahul Awasthi Mumbai: Creatify Web Services, which operates social media and influencer marketing agency Idiotic Media, has slapped a legal notice on Bimal Kartheek Rebba, the cofounder of ... Read more »

Tech majors see pickup in government, PSU business

Large technology companies such as Microsoft and Oracle are seeing an upswing in their public sector business as government departments and state-run companies are undertaking technology-led transformation projects. There was ... Read more »

Funding for Indian startups dips in second quarter

ETtech Illustration: Rahul Awasthi Bengaluru: Venture capital funding into Indian startups dipped 37% in the second quarter of this year to $6.9 billion, data sourced from research firm Venture Intelligence ... Read more »

4th of July Independence Day Sale: Tech Deals Still Available For You

Independence Day is an event where everyone feels the freedom that our ancestors attained for us, and most of the time, people think to splurge on this festive holiday with ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Wagga Wagga

1. Wagga Wagga Botanic Gardens 2. National Art Glass Gallery 3. Wagga Beach 4. Museum of the Riverina 5. RAAF Wagga Aviation Centre 6. Victory Memorial Gardens 7. Collins Park ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Rockhampton

1. Rockhampton Botanic Gardens 2. Mount Archer National Park 3. Rockhampton Zoo 4. Rockhampton Heritage Village 5. Archer Park Rail Museum 6. Capricorn Caves 7. Kershaw Gardens 8. CBD Heritage ... Read more »

(URGENT) Consumer prices jump 6 pct on-year in June, fastest rise in nearly 24 years

(END) Read more »

On-Grid, Off-Grid, or Hybrid — Which Type of Solar Panel Is for You?

(Photo : Ulrike Leone from Pixabay)Solar panels and other renewable energy sources are likely going to be in demand soon. There are a few factors to take into account when ... Read more »

Deep Longevity and Harvard Medical School Collaborate to Study Digital Models of Human Psychology

Deep Longevity collaborates with Harvard Medical School’s happiness and beauty authority Nancy Etcoff, Ph. D. The authors focused on Aging-US, outlining a machine learning approach to human psychology. Based on ... Read more »

Bed Bath & Beyond's July 4th Sale has up to 50% off towels, cookware and fire pits

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. July 4th is here and there are tons of deals available ... Read more »

Tips to Help You Manage Your Home Internet Plan's Data Cap Without Paying More

Are you looking to keep your monthly bill as low as possible? Follow along for ways to keep your data usage down and avoid those pesky overage fees. Read more »

NASA explains the mission to bring samples of Mars soil, rock and atmosphere back to Earth

This illustration shows a concept for multiple robots that would team up to ferry to Earth samples collected from the Mars surface by NASA’s Mars Perseverance rover. Credit: NASA/ESA/JPL-Caltech NASA’s ... Read more »

NASA says its plan to bring Mars samples back to Earth is safe, but some people are worried

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Since September, the Perseverance rover has been picking along an ancient river delta on Mars, its robotic arms reaching out with whirling steel drill bits to ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Wangaratta

1. Murray to Mountains Rail Trail 2. Merriwa Park 3. Warby-Ovens National Park 4. King Valley Wine Region 5. Ned Kelly Museum & Homestead 6. Glenrowan Heritage Siege Precinct 7. ... Read more »

6 indicted in cryptocurrency and NFT fraud schemes that netted more than $130 million

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Six people have been indicted in four separate cryptocurrency fraud cases involving more than $130 million in losses, including the single largest NFT scheme charged to ... Read more »

This dreamy, shapeshifting Wayfair couch is on sale for July 4th—but not for long

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. After a long day of celebrating 4th of July with savory ... Read more »

Individual Contractors or Subcontractors: What Is the Main Difference?

Photo : Scott Blake on Unsplash The construction sector is about ever-developing markets and orders at once. More and more commercial and residential premises are built together with other infrastructure ... Read more »

Ruling could dampen government efforts to rein in Big Tech

© Graeme Jennings FILE – Lina Khan, nominee for Commissioner of the Federal Trade Commission, speaks during a Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation confirmation hearing on Capitol Hill ... Read more »

Nextgen takes stake in Elastic Digital

Elastic founder Cameron Avery becomes Nextgen CMO. Read more »

Amazon Alexa Digital Assistant Working on New Technology to Synthesize a Person's Voice and Make Memories Last

(Photo : Nicolas J Leclercq) White portable speaker Amazon is working on new technology to synthesize a person’s voice. The technology aims to make memories last, so one can save ... Read more »

Australian gangster Tim ‘Sharky’ Ward ‘unrecognizable’ after years abroad

​Notorious money lender Tim “Sharky” Ward (pictured here before weight loss) has returned to the Gold Coast but is significantly leaner in his physical appearance. Facebook/Tim Ward Tim “Sharky” Ward, ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Adelaide

1. Visit Rundle Mall for some great shopping and stunning architecture 2. Check out the hustle and bustle of Adelaide Central Market 3. Admire the gorgeous flora at the Adelaide ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Mildura

1. Lock 11 2. Vineyards and Wineries 3. Mildura Riverfront 4. Australian Inland Botanic Gardens 5. Feast Street 6. Mungo National Park 7. Murray River Cruises 8. Mildura Arts Centre ... Read more »

UK military investigates hacks on Army social media accounts

Credit: CC0 Public Domain British military authorities are trying to find out who hacked the army’s social media accounts over the weekend, flooding them with cryptocurrency videos and posts related ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Murray Bridge

1. Monarto Safari Park 2. Sturt Reserve 3. Murray Bridge Bunyip 4. Murray Bridge Town Hall 5. Murray Bridge Regional Gallery 6. Captain’s Cottage Museum 7. Old Tailem Town Pioneer ... Read more »

This $640 Ryzen 7 ThinkPad is the cheapest 8-core laptop with 16GB RAM right now

What is it? The Lenovo ThinkPad E15 Gen 3 (opens in new tab) is the most affordable laptop on the market right now with an 8-core processor and 16GB of ... Read more »

HackerOne Employee Fired After Leaking Security Bug Reports! Here's Why His Action is Illegal

A HackerOne employee was dismissed from his position after the bug bounty company confirmed that he accessed the platform’s security bug reports. (Photo : Photo by Adam Berry/Getty Images)A participant ... Read more »

Personalised cancer vaccine trials produce 'really hopeful' results

The jab, made using similar technology to Oxford-AstraZeneca's COVID vaccine, sees DNA from an individual patient's tumour and cut and pasted into a harmless virus, which is injected into the body to train the immune system to be alert for cancer cells. Read more »

Google will delete abortion clinic location history — but don’t relax just yet

The overturning of Roe v Wade has spurred serious privacy concerns Read more »

Fallen ‘Cryptoqueen’ Ignatova added to FBI’s most wanted list but she was already notorious in China

Ruja Ignatova, the missing self-described “Cryptoqueen” who has been added to the US Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list, is also known for allegedly engineering a Ponzi ... Read more »

PayPal closes off popular loophole in business payments system

PayPal business users will now have to pay transaction fees on all their transfers, regardless of whether they are sending payments to friends and family. All PayPal payments are currently ... Read more »

Scaling the cost of government programs using a cost-per-person price tag improves comprehension by the general public

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain Government policies often are presented with hefty price tags, but people often zone out as more zeros are added to the total cost. A new study ... Read more »

15 Best Things to Do in Port Macquarie

1. Koala Hospital 2. Coastal Walk 3. Billabong Zoo: Koala and Wildlife Park 4. Tacking Point Lighthouse 5. Roto House 6. Sea Acres Rainforest Centre 7. Town Beach 8. Mid ... Read more »

These energy-packed batteries work well in extreme cold and heat

Credit: CC0 Public Domain Engineers at the University of California San Diego have developed lithium-ion batteries that perform well at freezing cold and scorching hot temperatures, while packing a lot ... Read more »

Matt Hancock backs Commons vote on legalising assisted dying

MPs should have the opportunity to vote on whether assisted dying should be legalised in the UK, former health secretary Matt Hancock has said. The Conservative former minister called for ... Read more »

Syngenta India gets govt nod to spray fungicide using drones

Representative image Agriculture company Syngenta India on Monday said it has got government approval for spraying fungicide using drones to protect paddy crops. Central Insecticide Board, regulatory authority under the ... Read more »

Amazon goes all in on eCargo bike delivery, but our cities aren’t ready

Designing cities for sidewalk ecommerce is a growing challenge Read more »

The iRobot Roomba 692 robot vacuum is on sale for less than $200 for the 4th of July

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. This 4th of July, there are sales on just about everything ... Read more »

Wisdomise Develops AI to Unlock Value in Web3 and Decentralized Economies to Share the Wisdom of Crowds

(Photo : Fardad Zand) As the world of decentralized finance continues to grow towards the frontier of web3, entrepreneurs are rising to streamline value generation for everybody. Wisdomise AI Labs ... Read more »