NATO's flirtation with adding 2 more members runs the risk of starting a war the US can't afford to fight

Asia's Tech News Daily

NATO's flirtation with adding 2 more members runs the risk of starting a war the US can't afford to fight
© REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin and NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg at a NATO Defense Ministers meeting in Brussels, October 21, 2021. REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol

  • While in Europe this month, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin made clear that Ukraine and Georgia may still join NATO.
  • Ukraine and Georgia have much in common with other NATO members – including a rivalry with their neighbor, Russia.
  • But offering them membership is a dangerous and counterproductive policy that doesn’t serve US national interests.

US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin is visiting Europe this week having said Ukraine and Georgia have an “open door to NATO” and that “no third country has a veto over NATO’s membership decisions.”

Because both countries have been on the receiving end of Russian aggression, it is natural to feel sympathy for Ukraine and Georgia – but offering them NATO membership is an extremely dangerous and counterproductive policy that does not serve the US national interest.

Rather than bolster the security of the American people, as one would expect US defense policy to do, expanding NATO increases the risk of the United States being drawn into a war with Russia. Moving forward in the process of offering NATO membership to Ukraine or Georgia risks igniting a major NATO-Russia conflict.

Should an attack follow Ukraine or Georgia’s formal acceptance into the alliance, NATO’s Article 5 would legally require the United States to militarily intervene. Such a scenario could quickly escalate to the nuclear level, making it imperative that the conceivably devastating consequences of NATO enlargement are honestly assessed.

Unfortunately, Austin’s comments are just the latest example of US policy makers failing to accept the geopolitical reality of eastern Europe.

NATO's flirtation with adding 2 more members runs the risk of starting a war the US can't afford to fight
© Irakli Gedenidze/Reuters Russian troops at a checkpoint in a village near the region of South Ossetia, roughly 62 miles from Tbilisi, Georgia, August 5, 2008 Irakli Gedenidze/Reuters

The 2008 Bucharest NATO Summit was a significant turning point for European security. There, it was formally announced that Ukraine and Georgia would eventually become members of the alliance.

In response, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov told reporters “We will do all we can to prevent Ukraine’s and Georgia’s accession into NATO and to avoid an inevitable serious exacerbation of our relations with both the alliance and our neighbors.”

Other top officials went further, with one Russian general saying, “Russia will take unambiguous action toward ensuring its interests along its borders. These will not only be military steps, but also steps of a different character.” In other words, Moscow made it clear that either country’s entry into the alliance would cross a red line and Russia would be prepared to use all facets of power, including military intervention, to enforce that red line.

Russia made good on its promise. In 2008 it fought a five-day war with Georgia and established de facto control of the breakaway regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. In 2014, Russia annexed Crimea and provided military support to pro-Russian separatists in eastern Ukraine.

Moscow effectively created buffer zones in both countries that separate Russia’s borders from Western-backed governments. It has also cunningly ensured that both conflicts remain frozen, using the threat of further escalation as a potential hedge to prevent NATO accession.

NATO's flirtation with adding 2 more members runs the risk of starting a war the US can't afford to fight
© Armed Forces of Ukraine/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images Ukrainian soldiers conduct a drill with tanks in the Donetsk region of Ukraine, April 24, 2021. Armed Forces of Ukraine/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Americans need only look at our own history to understand why Russia has acted in this manner. The United States established the Monroe Doctrine in the early 1800s, claiming that any intervention by European powers in the western hemisphere would be viewed as an act hostile to the United States.

By the end of the 19th century, the United States had successfully driven out all other great powers and established itself as the regional hegemon of the New World. When the Soviet Union challenged the US position in 1962 by deploying military assets 90 miles off the coast of Florida, the world was brought to the brink of nuclear Armageddon.

If the United States does not tolerate such behavior, why does the Biden administration believe that expanding NATO – and therefore the presence of US troops – on Russia’s borders will be viewed by Moscow as benign?

Providing hope to Kyiv and Tbilisi that NATO will come to its defense also creates a moral hazard problem. Rather than making the difficult political accommodations necessary to end their respective conflicts, Ukrainian and Georgian leaders are incentivized to shift their security burden on the United States by taking a hardline stance against Moscow.

This escalates US-Russia tensions and is not particularly kind to average Ukrainians and Georgians, who would likely bear the brunt of any renewed conflict.

The reality is that Moscow views the prevention of Ukraine and Georgia from joining NATO as a core strategic interest. As such, Russia will go to great lengths to achieve this objective. The Biden administration should conclude that it is not worth risking World War III over two countries with little geopolitical significance.

As the United States shifts its focus to the larger strategic threat of China, US policymakers would be wise to seek détente with Russia. Such an effort would start by taking Ukrainian and Georgian NATO membership off the table.

Sascha Glaeser is a research associate at Defense Priorities. He focuses on US grand strategy, international security, and transatlantic relations. He holds a master of international public affairs and a bachelor’s in international studies from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

India vs New Zealand 1st Test, Live Cricket Score: Black Caps stutter after strong start, reach 249/6 at tea

© Provided by Firstpost India vs New Zealand 1st Test, Live Cricket Score: Black Caps stutter after strong start, reach 249/6 at tea 14:20 (IST) After 118 overs,New Zealand 249/6 ... Read more »

Patna-bound GoAir flight from Bengaluru makes emergency landing in Nagpur

A Patna-bound GoAir flight from Bengaluru with 139 passengers on board made an emergency landing at Nagpur airport on Saturday. The emergency landing had to be made after the flight ... Read more »

Fünf Berufssoldaten erhalten wegen Impfverweigerung Kündigung

© KEYSTONE/TI-PRESS/CARLO REGUZZI Fünf Angehörige einer Sondereinheit der Schweizer Armee haben die Kündigung erhalten, weil sie sich nicht gegen das Coronavirus impfen lassen wollten. Die Berufssoldaten konnten laut Armee ihre ... Read more »

Coronavirus: "Auch wir stoßen beim Personal an Grenzen"

© Kevin Schrief/dpa Der Airbus A-310 MedEvac war einst auch für den Transport von Corona-Patienten aus Italien vorbereitet worden. Die Luftwaffe hilft bei der Verlegung von Covid-Patienten aus Bayern in ... Read more »

Human Rights Commission Orders MP Govt to Pay Rs 2 Lakh to Kin of Girl Killed in Attack by Stray Dogs

© Provided by News18 Human Rights Commission Orders MP Govt to Pay Rs 2 Lakh to Kin of Girl Killed in Attack by Stray Dogs In an important verdict, the ... Read more »

In Brussels demonstration on 26/11 anniversary, Pakistan slammed

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Taj Mahal Hotel was one of the targets on terrorists during 26/11 attacks. A demonstration was held in Brussels on Friday, the 13th anniversary ... Read more »

‘Too expensive' Expats reveal the reality of life in ‘exclusive' Singapore

As Singapore is a very multicultural country, expats can expect a warm welcome from residents when they arrive. An estimated 50,000 British people live in Singapore, which is one of ... Read more »

Sprawling £1.25m home with a golf course in the back garden

A £1.25m home has come on the market in Wirral – and it’s practically got a golf course in the back garden. Nestled on the appropriately named Golf Links Road, ... Read more »

Tak kira wang ihsan atau royalti, harap rakyat Kelantan dapat manfaat, kata Ahli Parlimen

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Sebelum ini, media melaporkan Petronas tidak akan membuat bayaran royalti tunai kepada mana-mana negeri di Semenanjung termasuk Kelantan. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING JAYA: Rakyat Kelantan ... Read more »

Emirati judokas suffer first-round defeats at Abu Dhabi Grand Slam

© Provided by The National Italian Assunta Scutto celebrates after striking gold at the Abu Dhabi Grand Slam at the Jiu-Jitsu Arena on Friday. Photo: IJF The first taste of ... Read more »

COVID cases are up in some Triangle counties as world watches South African variant

Heading into the Thanksgiving weekend, weekly COVID-19 cases were trending upward in some Triangle counties over the past seven days, according to the most recent data from the U.S. Centers ... Read more »

BTS: ARMY plans special surprise for Jin ahead of his 29th birthday, details inside

© Provided by DNA The South Koraen boy band BTS, also known as Bangtan Boys, is a pop culture phenomenon everyone knows about. BTS is organising its first ever live ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand Live Cricket Score, 1st Test, Day 3: Axar Patel Puts India on Top, NZ 249/6 at Tea

© Provided by News18 India vs New Zealand Live Cricket Score, 1st Test, Day 3: Axar Patel Puts India on Top, NZ 249/6 at Tea India vs New Zealand Live ... Read more »

2002 Godhra train burning case convict dies in hospital during treatment in Vadodara

A convict in the 2002 Godhra train carnage case, who was serving life sentence at a central jail in Gujarat’s Vadodara, died while undergoing treatment at a hospital, an official ... Read more »

Helen Housby exclusive: ‘We need to ensure 2018 glory was not a one-off for English netball'

(Getty Images) Helen Housby splits life into two very distinct parts: life before that goal in 2018 and life beyond that seminal moment. Repeatedly she had read and heard how ... Read more »

Producer Suresh Kamatchi Celebrates Success of Maanadu With Actor Simbu; Shares Pics

© Provided by News18 Producer Suresh Kamatchi on Friday celebrated the success of the recently released, Maanaadu, starring actor Silambarasan popularly known as Simbu. He arranged a chocolate cake to ... Read more »

Fabulous Lives of Bollywood Wives 2 teaser promises twice the drama, twice the spice!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Make room for the ladies! Glamour divas Neelam Kothari, Maheep Kapoor, Seema Khan and Bhavana Pandey are coming back with the second season of ... Read more »

What the newly discovered COVID-19 variants means for investors: Stifel chief equity strategist

Stifel Chief Equity Strategist Barry Bannister joins Yahoo Finance Live to discuss the investor implications of a newly discovered COVID-19 variant as we enter the second winter of the pandemic. ... Read more »

Ranveer Singh shines bright like a diamond in new pics; Arjun Kapoor's comment steals the show

© Provided by Pinkvilla Ranveer Singh is one of the finest actors of our time. Fans love him for his energy, vibrant style and his sense of humour. Well, the ... Read more »

‘Thank You for This Journey': Janhvi Kapoor Wraps Milli With Father Boney Kapoor

© Provided by News18 Janhvi Kapoor, with a heart full, wraps up another film. Every film bears cherished memories and Milli for Janhvi will always be special. Given it’s her ... Read more »

4 Ways to cheer your partner up if they are having a bad day

There’s nothing worse than seeing your partner feeling down and upset because of that missed promotion or a brawl at home. While it’s imperative to give your partner time and ... Read more »

From Shraddha Kapoor to Kriti Sanon: Airport fashion looks (Nov 20-27)

© Provided by The Indian Express Travelling is often spoken about in terms of vacations or work and no in-betweens. Does that mean you should only wear fun, cutesy outfits ... Read more »

Serial burglar impersonated a police officer to loot elderly people's homes

A serial burglar who posed as a police officer to get into vulnerable and old people’s homes has been locked up. David Kerrigan, 38, of no fixed address, used a ... Read more »

Japan tightening border controls on three more African countries - Foreign Ministry

© Reuters/ANDRONIKI CHRISTODOULOU FILE PHOTO: Passengers walk at the Haneda airport, in Tokyo TOKYO (Reuters) – Japan will tighten border controls for the southern African nations of Mozambique, Malawi and ... Read more »

Das plant die schwangere Sarah Engels

© imago images/Future Image Sarah Engels wird bald Mutter einer Tochter. Sarah Engels wird in Kürze wieder Mutter. Zusammen mit Ehemann Julian hat sie schon das Weihnachtsfest zu viert geplant. ... Read more »

Why 'Omicron', Not 'Nu' or 'Xi'? WHO Says Two Letters in Greek Alphabet Jumped to 'Avoid Stigma'

© Provided by News18 Why ‘Omicron’, Not ‘Nu’ or ‘Xi’? WHO Says Two Letters in Greek Alphabet Jumped to ‘Avoid Stigma’ The World Health Organization on Friday, in an emergency ... Read more »

Harry Potter star Scarlett Byrne expecting twins with Hugh Hefner's son Cooper

(@scarletthefner/Instagram) Harry Potter star Scarlett Byrne is expecting twins with her husband, Hugh Hefner's son Cooper. The actress, who played Slytherin student Pansy Parkinson in the films, announced the news ... Read more »

Europe seeks southern Africa travel ban amid fears over alarming Covid strain

The European Union is looking to halt air travel from the southern African region amid rising concern over a highly mutated new Covid-19 variant detected in South Africa and Botswana. ... Read more »

Adel Haddadi: Would-be Paris attacker 'caught in a moral dilemma'

Wednesday's evidence at the Paris attacks trial focused for the second successive day on Adel Haddadi and Muhammed Usman, both accused of planning a terrorist action in France. They were ... Read more »

Salman reveals how the song 'Oh Oh Jane Jaana' was rejected for 6 years

© IANS Salman Khan. Mumbai, Nov 27 (IANS) Bollywood star Salman Khan has revealed how the song ‘Oh Oh Jane Jaana’ was rejected several times before he decided to use ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif-Vicky Kaushal wedding: Will Shah Rukh Khan, Gauri Khan attend?

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: With every passing day, buzz about Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal’s rumoured wedding seems to be getting stronger. According to numerous reports, the ... Read more »

Safe waste disposal, street sweeping at night: Take a look at how Indore became ‘cleanest city'

© Provided by The Print Indore: Last week, Indore retained the cleanest city tag for the fifth consecutive year in the Swachh Survekshan (cleanliness survey) 2021 announced by the Modi ... Read more »

Imlie, November 27, 2021, Written Update: Aryan warns Imlie to do her activities outside the office

© Provided by Pinkvilla As the episode starts, Aditya returns to office to get his files but he decides to leave as he doesn’t find them on his table. Aditya ... Read more »

Malala Yousafzai's husband Asser Malik shares heartwarming post after she graduates from Oxford. Read here

Nobel laureate Malala Yousafzai graduated from the University of Oxford in philosophy, politics, and economics on Friday. Malala graduated from the esteemed institution back in May, 2020, but due to ... Read more »

Andhra Pradesh Flood: Death toll reaches 44 as heavy rains continue to lash state | All you need to know in 6 points

© Provided by Jagran English Visakhapatnam | Jagran News Desk: The Andhra Pradesh government on Friday said that 44 people have lost their lives while 16 are still missing due ... Read more »

Breaking News, Latest Updates Highlights of November 27

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: In our today’s Jagran English’s ‘Latest Updates, Breaking News’ blog, we will keep a tab on Priyanka Gandhi Vadra’s ... Read more »

Neha Bhasin to Rakhi Sawant: Newsmakers of the week from Bigg Boss 15

© Provided by Pinkvilla The recent week of the reality show Bigg Boss 15 was high on action and drama in the house. The contestants were seen losing their calm ... Read more »

Chiranjeevi's offers financial help for Sivasankar Master's Covid treatment

© IANS Chiranjeevi. Hyderabad, Nov 27 (IANS) National Award-winning choreographer Sivasankar Master is fighting Covid-19. The dance master is currently hospitalised and it is reported that 75 per cent of ... Read more »

Iona suffers letdown loss to Belmont after big Alabama win

KISSIMMEE, Fla. — What a difference a day makes. Iona, who pulled off a stunning upset over No. 10 Alabama on Thursday, fell to Belmont 72-65 on Friday night at ... Read more »

Archeologists Uncover Pile of Artefacts in Egypt Over 3,500-year-old

© Provided by News18 Archeologists Uncover Pile of Artefacts in Egypt Over 3,500-year-old A team of Polish archeologists have excavated a heap of artifacts, believed to be used as offerings ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic