Nate Silver Calls Dem Strategy to Leave Newsom Recall Candidate Line Blank 'Self-Destructive'

FiveThirtyEight founder and editor-in-chief Nate Silver said Monday the strategy California Democrats are pursuing heading into next month’s gubernatorial recall election is “self-destructive” as sitting Governor Gavin Newsom faces the possibility that he may be voted out of office.

© Barbara Davidson/Getty Images FiveThirtyEight founder Nate Silver said Monday the Democrats’ strategy in California to back only Governor Gavin Newsom in next month’s recall election may be “self-destructive.” Above, hundreds of anti-vaccination protesters gathered at City Hall in Los Angeles, California on August 14, 2021.

The California Democratic Party is encouraging Californians to vote against removing Newsom from office but to refrain from selecting amongst the 46 replacement candidates who appear on the recall ballot. Newsom’s campaign has made similar recommendations in recent weeks.

On Monday, Silver responded to a tweet posted by a political reporter who suggested the strategy was “self-interested.”

“It’s self-destructive more than self-interested,” Silver tweeted. “Pretty decent chance Newsom gets recalled. Democrats could potentially keep the seat if they urged their voters to consolidate behind an alternative Democrat but instead they’re telling them not to vote on the replacement!”

It’s self-destructive more than self-interested. Pretty decent chance Newsom gets recalled. Democrats could potentially keep the seat if they urged their voters to consolidate behind an alternative Democrat but instead they’re telling them not to vote on the replacement!

— Nate Silver (@NateSilver538) August 23, 2021

Recent polls indicate California voters are split on whether they want Newsom to remain in office for the rest of his term or to be ousted and replaced by someone new. According to a polling average compiled by FiveThirtyEight and most recently updated on August 18, voters who want Newsom to remain in office lead those who want him out by an estimated 1.2 percent.

Most of the recall candidates who have polled highest in recent surveys are Republicans. Conservative radio host Larry Elder is believed to be the frontrunner among the Republican candidates, with former San Diego Mayor Kevin Faulconer, businessman John Cox, state lawmaker Kevin Kiley and television personality Caitlyn Jenner each several points behind him.

Though the state Democratic Party is supporting Newsom, there are a few self-identified Democrats who also appear on the recall ballot. Kevin Paffrath, who is best known by his YouTube name “Meet Kevin” and who is identified on the ballot as a financial educator and analyst, also gained traction among voters in recent polls.

If more than 50 percent of voters cast their ballots in favor of removing Newsom before the official end of his term, he will be replaced by whomever of his 46 challengers receives the greatest number of votes. That individual would then serve as California’s governor until voters decide during next year’s midterm elections who they want to complete the office’s next full term.

State Democrats have mostly unified behind Newsom and have emphasized to voters how important they believe it is to defend his seat. Since keeping Newsom in office is a top priority for the California Democratic Party heading into the September 14 election, the party has said voters don’t need to worry about the second question on the ballot and should focus their attention on the question pertaining to Newsom’s removal.

The California Democratic Party told voters to “leave the second question blank” in a set of instructions for voters it posted on Twitter on August 15. Party chair Rusty Hicks reiterated those instructions to “Vote NO on Q1 & leave Q2 blank” in an August 19 tweet.

Defeating the Republican recall attempt against Governor Gavin Newsom is our #1 priority.

1. Vote No on the first question.

2. Leave the second question blank.

3. Mail it back. #VoteNoOnRecall #StopTheRepublicanRecall

— California Democratic Party (@CA_Dem) August 15, 2021

Orrin Heatlie, the lead proponent behind the effort to remove Newsom from office, told Newsweek earlier this month the strategy seemed “kind of surprising” and struck him as a potential miscalculation for the Democrats.

“If he is replaced, you’d think that the Democrats would want to weigh in on who they would want to replace him with,” Heatlie said.

But the California Democratic Party is sticking with its strategy, according to the party’s communications director, Shery Yang.

“It’s simple: The California Democratic Party supports Governor Gavin Newsom,” Yang told Newsweek when contacted Monday for a response to Silver’s tweet. “There are no other candidates prepared to meet the challenges facing our state. Therefore, we’re urging voters to vote no on the recall and leave the second question blank.”

Related Articles

  • Newsom’s Advice for Voters to Skip Candidate Question ‘Miscalculated’: Recall Proponent
  • Larry Elder Vows to Repeal California Vaccine and Mask Mandates, Rally Crowd Goes Wild
  • Caitlyn Jenner Tells Larry Elder to Drop Out of California Recall After Past Comments on Women
  • California Officials Launch Probe Into Recall Candidate Larry Elder’s Income Disclosure
  • Newsom Campaign Fires Back Against Critics Who Claim He’s Ignoring Latinos

Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


East End Gallery's ‘Art Patch' Fundraises For Long Island Cares

© Provided by Long Island Press © Provided by Long Island Press long island cares By Oliver Peterson The East End is in full picking mode this fall, with U-pick apples and pumpkins drawing ... Read more »

In Montclair: APEX Ensemble To Feature Leah Hawkins At Opener

© Photo: Leah Hawkins, soprano // PC: Dario Acosta APEX Ensemble, formerly The Montclair Orchestra, returns to the stage with conductor David Chan for the first time in 18 months ... Read more »

Brewers' David Stearns, A's Billy Beane out of running for Mets' front office job

The New York Mets need a new president of baseball operations. They were linked with former Boston Red Sox and Chicago Cubs executive Theo Epstein, who ultimately decided along with ... Read more »

Jessica Simpson Is Regaining ‘Complete Ownership' of Fashion Label

© Paul Zimmerman/Shutterstock Mandatory Credit: Photo by Paul Zimmerman/Shutterstock (10550210l) Jessica Simpson at Bookends Bookshop in Ridgewood Jessica Simpson meet and greet, New Jersey, USA – 06 Feb 2020 Boss ... Read more »

The Beatles land on TikTok, and you can now officially use the band's music

The Beatles have finally Come Together on TikTok. The Fab Four’s account, titled @TheBeatles, showed up Friday on the video-sharing network. By Monday, the band’s account had chalked up more than 186,000 ... Read more »

Kanye West Legally Changes Name to “Ye”

© Ye fka Kanye Omari West, February 2020 (Robert Kamau/GC Images) NEW YORK, NY – FEBRUARY 05: Kanye West seen out and about in Manhattan on February 5, 2020 in ... Read more »

Kane Brown Shares Adorable Video of Daughter Kingsley, 23 Months, Rocking Out on Stage

Just like her dad, Kingsley Rose belongs on stage! © Provided by People Kane Brown/Instagram; Inset: Jason Kempin/Getty On Sunday, Kane Brown, 27, shared an adorable video of his 23-month-old ... Read more »

Alex Belzile placed on waivers by the Montreal Canadiens

The Montreal Canadiens placed forward Alex Belzile on waivers on Monday afternoon. © Photo by David Kirouac/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images Les Canadiens ont soumis l’attaquant Alex Belzile au ballottage. ... Read more »

Ex-NHL player Jimmy Hayes died with fentanyl, cocaine in his system

Former NHL player Jimmy Hayes had fentanyl and cocaine in his body when he died suddenly in August at the age of 31. © Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune/TNS Jimmy Hayes, seen ... Read more »

Democrats unveil doomed funding bills ahead of December shutdown cliff

Congress hits the next shutdown deadline in six weeks, and another funding punt is already fated unless Democrats stop shunning the edgy debate over boosting military spending. © Sarah Silbiger/Pool ... Read more »

Russia closes NATO mission in row over spying allegations

Russia said it was suspending its mission to NATO and closing the alliance’s offices in Moscow, October 18, 2021. DIMITAR DILKOFF/AFP via Getty Images ​The Kremlin suspended its mission at ... Read more »

Sex offender sentenced to 2 years

Oct. 18—URBANA — David W. Morlan, 66, most recently of Danville, was sentenced Monday to two years in federal prison, to be followed by five years of supervised release, for ... Read more »

4-year-old called ‘superhero' after miraculously surviving 70-ft fall

Kentucky rescuers recounted the amazing case of a 4-year-old boy who toppled 70 feet into a gorge — and came away with only minor injuries. Alamy Stock Photo Like all ... Read more »

Apple Unveils Powerful M1 Pro and M1 Max Chips For New MacBook Pro 14 and 16-inch Models

© Provided by Geek Culture After rolling out the lauded M1 chip last year, Apple’s latest M1 Pro and M1 Max chips just smashed it out of the park once ... Read more »

Commentary: Paula Badosa triumphs in battle royal with Victoria Azarenka for Indian Wells title

Paula Badosa hits a return during her women’s singles final victory over Victoria Azarenka at the BNP Paribas Open on Sunday. (John McCoy / Associated Press) Big-time tennis returned to ... Read more »

This young couple lost their income during Covid — now their start-up has $2.5 million in annual sales and a 'Shark Tank' deal

© Provided by CNBC Songlorious co-founders Ellen Hodges and Omayya Atout on ABC’s Ellen Hodges, 28, and Omayya Atout, 33, were in a bind. When the Covid-19 pandemic sent the ... Read more »

Forget Black Friday, These Shipping Deadlines Mean You Need to Shop Now

© mediaphotos / Getty Images/iStockphoto Black Friday bags. Even though the holidays are still months away, waiting until Black Friday to start shopping might be too late. FedEx, the U.S. ... Read more »

Walmart Announces Black Friday Sales — Plan Ahead for Major Deals Starting Today

© Gunnar Rathbun / AP / Walmart Black Friday In-Store Event, Bentonville, USA – 22 Nov 2018 Last year, Walmart made $264 million between Black Friday and Cyber Monday, ... Read more »

Apple Music at half the normal price? Yes, there is a catch

Apple has launched a cut-price version of its Apple Music streaming app in a new challenge to Amazon and Spotify that has a catch: users can only search for songs ... Read more »

The Trick - true story behind 'Climategate' scandal and what happened to Phil Jones

Conspiracy thriller The Trick has the sort of storyline you’d expect in a fictional Hollywood movie – but the alarming events actually happened in real life. Based on the events ... Read more »

Snake spotted on the streets of Kirkcaldy

© The image from Fife Jammers showed a snake at a clothing point Social media posts showed what appeared to be a python at a clothing donations point in Fife. ... Read more »

Women on reality TV shows get more abuse online than men, study shows

A new study has revealed that female contestants on reality television shows are far more likely to be targeted with abuse online than men. © Getty Images 2020 Saw Sharp ... Read more »

Baby Boomers Have a Big Advantage in Today's Housing Market

Homes have often been selling for thousands of dollars above asking price during the recent real estate boom. And the generation that has been winning many of these bidding wars ... Read more »

Arsenal vs. Crystal Palace: Time, TV, streaming, betting odds for Premier League Monday night football

Arsenal will host Crystal Palace to close out the Premier League Matchday 8 slate and it’s a compelling matchup that will pit Palace first-year manager Patrick Vieira against his former ... Read more »

Greta Thunberg 'Rickrolls' climate concert with crazy dance moves

Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg has “Rickrolled” an audience, all in the name of climate activism. © INA FASSBENDER/AFP via Getty Images Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg looks on as ... Read more »

NASA orbiter spots Pink Floyd album cover lookalike on Mars

When you stare at pictures of the red planet as much as the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter camera team does, you’re bound to start seeing some funny things, like class rock ... Read more »

What I Learned From Colin Powell

My favorite recollection of Colin Powell was the look he got when he was amused. He’d tilt his head up and look at you under the base of his glasses, ... Read more »

Laughter, tears but most of all cheers as the Commons paid fitting tribute to Sir David Amess

There was lots of laughter and there were some tears, but what Sir David Amess would have appreciated most were the cheers. The loud roar, from both sides of the ... Read more »

Cargo pants are back?! 13 fashionable options to shop right now

Shop TODAY is editorially independent. Our editors selected these deals and items because we think you will enjoy them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, we ... Read more »

The Guardian view on China's missile launch: the arrival of a peer competitor

Whether China tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic missile that can circle the globe or not, there is a convincing argument that the country has emerged as a serious strategic rival to ... Read more »

NDP calls for social media watchdog as scrutiny of Facebook heats up

OTTAWA — New Democrats are demanding the federal government crack down on social media giants following recent revelations by a Facebook executive that have rekindled questions around how to regulate ... Read more »

No Patrick Vieira at Arsenal (yet): How Gunners manager job has proven elusive for club legend

Patrick Vieira is an Arsenal club legend, the captain of its Invincibles team and one of the club’s leaders during his nine years playing for them. But he will be coaching ... Read more »

Chicago museum fires all of its mostly White female, financially well-off docents for lack of diversity: report

People congregate outside of the Art Institute of Chicago on June 11, 2021 in Chicago, Illinois. Getty Images The Art Institute of Chicago fired all of its trained volunteers and ... Read more »

Supreme Court Backs Police in Two 'Qualified Immunity' Cases

© KEN CEDENO/REUTERS WASHINGTON—The Supreme Court threw out two separate excessive-force lawsuits filed against police, ruling Monday that the doctrine of qualified immunity protected the officers from having to answer ... Read more »

One killed, nine injured after truck collides with horse and buggy in Virginia

A pick-up truck hit an Amish buggy injuring 9 people and killing one in Cumberland, Virginia. Shutterstock One person is dead and nine others were injured after a pick-up truck ... Read more »

Asteroid the size of Empire State Building to make ‘close' encounter with Earth

According to NASA, the asteroids or comets have “been nudged by the gravitational attraction of nearby planets into orbits that allow them to enter the Earth’s neighborhood.” Shutterstock Massive asteroids ... Read more »

This jacket has been on a prime-time TV show for over 20 years – but can you tell who it belongs to?

This coat has been on prime-time tv show for over 20 years – but can you tell who it belongs to? One soap character has been wearing it for decades, ... Read more »

Apple MacBook Pro 14 and 16 Malaysia pricing revealed, starts from RM8,799

Apple has officially unveiled its new MacBook Pro series which claims to be the world’s best pro notebook. Available in 14″ and 16″ sizes, the new MacBook Pro features Apple’s ... Read more »

Ted Cruz Blasted by Australian Minister: 'We Don't Need Your Lectures'

The chief minister of Australia’s Northern Territory has blasted Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) for decrying the “COVID tyranny” in Australia over the implementation of strict vaccine mandates. © Dan Himbrechts/Getty ... Read more »