Narcotic Jihad | Can science and reason defeat religious polarisation in Kerala?

#Jihad, #Kerala, #Love Jihad, #Narcotic Jihad, #opinion, #Politics, #science, contemporary events in Kerala, including the National Investigation Agency

Bertrand Russell, the great mathematician-philosopher and polymath had famously held that “Religion is something left over from the infancy of our intelligence; it will fade away as we adopt reason and science as our guidelines”. When we reflect on Russell’s quotation and introspect the religious realm in India per se, not to talk about contemporary events in Kerala, it is quite disconcerting and distressing; and a few crucial issues ensue from there.

First and foremost, either Russell was wrong in his assertion as regards the fading away of religion in the wake of adoption of reason and science by humans, or his understanding and definition of ‘religion’, ‘intelligence’, ‘reason’ and ‘science’ were at variance with the general, and usually acceptable, notions/definitions that are prevalent in civic society at large.

It is rather surprising that in today’s Kerala the well-educated religious lot, the clergy, who are expected to have had a smattering of science, and who are expected to be the ones who see reason, are the ones who are raising the bogeys of ‘love jihad’ and ‘narcotic jihad’, notwithstanding the fact that probes by different agencies, including the National Investigation Agency, have debunked such allegations.

The clergy concerned, particularly the bishop of Pala and other priest(s) who have indulged in such rhetoric, may not necessarily have played on into the hands of the Sangh parivar, but have certainly touched the hearts and endeared themselves to the latter to the extent that the latter are ecstatic. Also, they have, along with other Right-wing groups, extolled the bishop of Pala, and have extended their support to him.

However, something that has been very heartening and positive in this dark and murky scenario has been the bold and defiant stand of a group of nuns who not only spoke out against the bishop, but also walked out of the mass of the priest who preached hate by going to the extent of beseeching his flock to boycott Muslims traders as also Muslim autorickshaw drivers.

One would not have been surprised if insinuations and allegations of ‘love jihad’ and ‘narcotic jihad’ were made by Right-wing extremist groups because it is, inevitably, their wont to do so. But coming from the clergy in a state which has historically seen relatively amicable and amiable relations between Muslims and Christians wherein they have prospered together, belies logic.

Pre-Islamic Arab contact with Kerala and rest of the west coast of India dates back to the ‘Before Christ’ era, which gradually transformed into the Islamic one from the seventh century AD onwards.

The oldest mosque to be built in the Indian subcontinent was the Cheramaan Juma Mosque in Methala, Thrissur district, in 629 CE. It is significant to point out that the north-centric way of looking at and referring to Islam in India by certain historians is quite misplaced. By the time Islam made any impact in the northwest and north of India, full-fledged Islamic societies had been formed in Kerala that extended beyond and along the Coromandel Coast in Tamil Nadu and spread towards South East Asia.

Similarly, the Christian connection and the advent of Christianity in Kerala goes back to 52 CE. For centuries, these religious groups, namely, Christians and Muslims, have coexisted and inhabited common spaces all over Kerala, along with the pre-existing indigenous communities. Also, there has been a high degree of acculturation between the various religious groups in terms of language, food, clothing, and other cultural practices including in the religious realm.

There were, no doubt, skirmishes between the Christians and Muslims with the arrival of the Portuguese during the late fifteenth and early sixteenth century, but these have to be treated more as aberrations for economic gains than something that disturbed the overall ambience of peace and communal harmony. The erstwhile situation as regards peaceful coexistence between the different religious communities prevailed in Kerala in spite of quite a few communal riots in other parts of India, both before and after the Independence.

It is felt in some circles in Kerala that due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the restrictions as regards congregations, the footfalls have declined resulting in drastically reduced revenues in the churches, and that has made some clergy feel insecure; and one way of getting back the faithful could be to polarise the communities in the expectation that would help in consolidating their own followers.

Of late, the anti-Muslim rant that has emanated in Kerala is not confined to the borders of the state. The overt and manifest support in social media and through videos, for Israel’s bombing of Gaza during the recent conflict vis-à-vis the Palestinians, too, is, at one level quite disturbing, and at another level, points to the mindset that such perpetrators are embedded in.

The proclivity to reduce the Palestinian identity to just a Muslim/Islamic one is one of the most irrational way of looking at a people and explicating their ethnicity. Christian Palestinians too are in the forefront in their resistance to Israeli imperialism, and the occupation of Palestine. The well-known academic and crusader for peace, late Professor Edward Said, was one such.

MA Kalam, a social anthropologist, is Visiting Professor, Centre for Economic and Social Studies, Hyderabad.

Views are personal and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Donald Trump creates his own media group and social network - statement

The Trump Media and Technology Group will launch the TRUTH Social network soon Read more »

Asian Paints Q2 Preview | Volume growth may lift revenue, inflation to weigh on margins

Asian Paints, one of the largest paint companies in India, is expected to see more than 20 percent growth in sales volume for the quarter ended September 2021 due to ... Read more »

Monetisation avenues open up for Indian short video apps, ad revenues triple in 6 months

Representative Image Indian short video apps are seeing monetisation opportunities with ad revenues tripling in the last six months, and live commerce and virtual gifting picking up as time spent ... Read more »

Exclusive: Neobank Fi aims for $200-million valuation in new funding round

Fi, a new-age app-only banking startup founded by former Google Pay executives, is in talks to raise about $50 million, taking its valuation fourfold to $200 million, said two people ... Read more »

Daily Voice | Be prepared for corrections, despite positive factors, says Srinivas Rao Ravuri of PGIM India MF

At a time when a euphoria of sorts has gripped the equity market with the benchmark indices scaling record highs, one voice raises a note of caution. Meet Srinivas Rao Ravuri, CIO – ... Read more »

Over 2,500 workers hired, Tuas port storage space tapped as S'pore ports help to tackle global supply crisis

The not yet operational Tuas port has opened up 2,000 TEUs (20-foot equivalent units) in yard capacity. SINGAPORE – The not-yet-operational Tuas port is already being used to store containers, ... Read more »

Buzzing Stocks: Asian Paints, PNB Housing, Mindtree and other stocks in news today

Results on October 21: Asian Paints, JSW Steel, Biocon, 63 Moons Technologies, Agro Tech Foods, Borosil Renewables, Can Fin Homes, CG Power and Industrial Solutions, Container Corporation of India, ICICI ... Read more »

Hot Stocks | Here is why you should buy Indoco Remedies, Jindal Steel and Apollo Pipes for the short term

In the previous week, Nifty50 witnessed three gap-up openings in three consecutive trading sessions and formed a continuation gap on the daily chart. Benchmark index, on October 19, engulfed its ... Read more »

Monsoon set to withdraw by October 26

India’s southwest monsoon rains are likely to finish withdrawing from the country by October 26, according to the weather office, marking one of the most delayed retreats of the vital ... Read more »

Evergrande crisis: developer Modern Land (China) cancels US$250 million bond repayment plan on liquidity issues

China’s property market has taken another turn for the worse as developer Modern Land (China) has cancelled its plan to repay a portion of a US$250 million junk bond and ... Read more »

Business Hub: Dan Huggins

Bank of New Zealand CEO Dan Huggins talks his return to NZ and taking on the role amid the Covid-19 pandemic. Video / NZ Herald Read more »

India all set to cross the milestone of 1 billion jabs today

India is set to cross the milestone of administering one billion Covid-19 vaccine doses today, just over nine months after the government initiated the mammoth immunisation drive in the second ... Read more »

Retail giants Lotte, Shinsegae make major changes to cope with shopping trends

Lotte has made its staff younger by hiring new workers and dismissing longtime employees.  South Korea's retail giants Lotte and Shinsegae are implementing measures to cope with the challenges brought ... Read more »

How stable is such a ‘stablecoin' actually?

It is a golden find, the stablecoin: a crypto currency with all the associated advantages of security, privacy and tradability. But then fully covered by ‘real’ money. So for every ... Read more »

Easing of social distancing measures raises hopes for liquor businesses

Soju sales soar by 15 to 20 percent between November and December as South Koreans prefer it over a beer in winter. South Korea’s brewery companies and liquor traders are ... Read more »

Tesla shifting to cheaper batteries tried in China as material prices soar

Tesla has been using LFP batteries in China supplied by Contemporary Amperex Technology (CATL). DETROIT (BLOOMBERG) – Tesla said it’s shifting to cheaper lithium-iron-phosphate (LFP) batteries globally, a move away ... Read more »

Sure, Americans like stuff in Dems' spending bill — but paying for it? Not so much

While Sen. Bernie Sanders insists Americans “have little understanding of what their government is,” they absolutely know what not to spend their taxes on. Tom Williams/Congressional Quarterly via ZUMA Press ... Read more »

Supalai to launch condo projects soon New supply worth 5.74 billion baht

Mr Tritecha (left) is confident that the condo market recovery will start in this quarter. SET-listed developer Supalai Plc will launch four new condo projects worth a combined 5.74 billion ... Read more »

FPT redevelopment efforts to create Silom Edge Former Silom Center building to become a new sandbox community in the capital's central business district

A digital rendition of Silom Edge on the corner of Rama IV Road and Silom Road. With an investment of 1.8 billion baht, Silom Edge aims to change Silom Road ... Read more »

TSTH eyes post-flood recovery

SET Listed Tata Steel Thailand Plc (TSTH), a unit of India's largest steel maker, expects steel consumption in Thailand will recover after the flood crisis which affected steel sales. Up ... Read more »

Xi Faces Resistance to Property Tax Planned to Combat Bubble After negative feedback from within the party, an initial proposal to test a property tax in some 30 cities has been significantly scaled down

High-rise apartment buildings in Taicang, Jiangsu province, are being built by China Evergrande Group. Bloomberg Chinese President Xi Jinping has made no secret of his desire to deflate property bubble. But ... Read more »

Qantas sees return to 100% of pre-pandemic domestic capacity by January

Qantas will resume international passenger flights from Sydney to London and Los Angeles on Nov 1, 2021. SYDNEY (REUTERS) – Qantas Airways expects to get back to flying 100 per ... Read more »

Thailand Post starts drone deliveries

A drone carries medicine and medical supplies to far away recipients under the ‘Delivers Wellness’ project, the country’s first medicine delivery service using drones to fly from hospitals to homes. ... Read more »

B29bn budget to cap diesel

The Energy Policy Administration Committee has approved a budget worth around 29 billion baht to put a cap on the diesel price at below 30 baht per litre in line ... Read more »

PIN to sell 290m shares through IPO by year-end

Six factory units located at Pinthong Industrial Park’s Pinthong Industrial Estate 5 in Chon Buri. Industrial estate developer Pinthong Industrial Park Plc (PIN) will sell 290 million shares, representing 25% ... Read more »

DTAC owner Telenor vows to remain in Thailand

Mr Brekke reiterated that Asia is very quickly catching up with digital development. Telenor Group, the major shareholder in Total Access Communication Plc (DTAC), has expressed its commitment to long-term ... Read more »

True, partners launch 'Telehealth Together'

From left Mr Viriya, Mr Natwut and Dr Watchara (on screen) at the launch of ‘Telehealth Together’ project. SET-listed telecom operator True Corporation has worked with partners to launch “Telehealth ... Read more »

Cramer would rather buy reopening stock United Airlines than Zoom, which has been cut in half

CNBC's Jim Cramer said Wednesday he sees more upside ahead for economic reopening play United Airlines, while expressing a cautious outlook on stay-at-home winner Zoom Video Communications. “For now, I'd ... Read more »

Bitcoin surges on back of crypto ETF Fund started trading on NYSE on Tuesday

The Bitcoin price had fallen to around $40,000 earlier this year, but the ETF launch appears to have revived investors’ interest in the asset. (Reuters photo) The price of Bitcoin ... Read more »

AAV approves restructuring plan Plan to raise capital, issue bonds gets nod

The board of Asia Aviation (AAV), the largest shareholder of budget carrier Thai AirAsia (TAA), has given the nod to the company's restructuring plan, including increasing its registered capital and ... Read more »

Rising coal, natural gas prices to fuel inflation across the globe and hasten transition to renewable energy, CME says

CME Group, the world’s largest futures exchange operator, said rising coal and natural gas prices are expected to have a profound impact on consumers, as higher energy bills and manufacturing ... Read more »

Buy Netflix after the streaming giant's post-earnings slide, says Jim Cramer

CNBC's Jim Cramer on Wednesday advised investors to buy shares of Netflix, arguing the stock's post-earnings decline is creating an attractive purchase point. “When you see Netflix pulling back after ... Read more »

Cramer's lightning round: Celanese Corp. is a winner

Figs Inc.: “I think it's kind of interesting, to tell you the truth. I think it's just kind of an interesting idea. It's a little quirky, but so is Crocs. ... Read more »

Foreign speculators pressure baht

Foreign investors have been heavily speculating on the baht as Thailand's twin deficits this year have pressured the local currency to weaken. Offshore investors, especially from the US, have been ... Read more »

Netflix walkout is latest example of workers taking stand on social issues

“There’s a sense that these aren’t business issues and that companies shouldn’t get involved, but there’s a clear business case for it,” said one industry expert. Read more »

Tesla will change the type of battery cells it uses in all its standard-range cars

Close up of Tesla logo on a charger at a Supercharger rapid battery charging station for the electric vehicle company Tesla Motors, in the Silicon Valley town of Mountain View, ... Read more »

Tesla Q3 profit more than quadruples on record deliveries despite chip crunch

Tesla also delivered a record 241,391 vehicles during the period, with sales significantly ramping up in North America and China. NEW YORK (AFP) – Tesla’s third-quarter profit more than quadrupled ... Read more »

NZX gets its third cannabis listing with Greenfern debut

The NZX has gained its third cannabis company with the listing of Taranaki-based Greenfern. The company – a cannabis, therapeutics and wellness company incorporated in 2018 – aims to be ... Read more »

Bitcoin jumps to record-high above US$66,000 in crypto's 'validating moment'

NEW YORK (BLOOMBERG) – Bitcoin rallied to a record, topping US$66,000 for the first time on Wednesday (Oct 20) as optimism surged for greater mainstream acceptance in the wake of ... Read more »

Jim Cramer blasts 'bearish billionaires,' says it's time to stop taking their investment advice

CNBC's Jim Cramer on Wednesday blasted “bearish billionaires,” saying everyday investors ought to stop listening to their stock market calls. “It's time the end this ridiculous charade of bearish billionaires ... Read more »