My sci-fi novel about recreating an extinct species is becoming a reality - but even if we can, should we?

Last week I woke up to a string of notifications alerting me to the news a biotech company had secured US$15m (A$20.6m) to underwrite a scheme to recreate mammoths with a view to reintroducing them onto the Arctic tundra.

The reason for the flurry of emails and messages wasn’t that the story seemed like something out of a science fiction novel, it was that it was something out of a science fiction novel; specifically my novel, Ghost Species, which imagines the consequences of just such a scheme.

Related: Firm raises $15m to bring back woolly mammoth from extinction

My novel wasn’t supposed to be predictive in any narrow sense. Instead I wanted to use it to think through a series of questions about climate catastrophe and inevitability, extinction and de-extinction and perhaps most importantly, what it might be like to be the last – or the first – of one’s kind. Yet that doesn’t mean there isn’t something deeply disconcerting about witnessing one of its central conceits play out in real life, or seeing the questions it was trying to ask made explicit.

In Ghost Species it’s a tech billionaire who is behind the project, and indeed the even more ambitious project to recreate Neanderthals that lies at the book’s heart. Yet, like Colossal, the company behind the scheme announced last week, his ambitions are not confined to merely recreating mammoths. Instead the reintroduction of mammoths to the Arctic is part of a last ditch effort to slow down the melting of the permafrost, and the potentially catastrophic release of vast amounts of methane by recreating the ecosystem that existed in the region during the Pleistocene.

The idea isn’t entirely fanciful: as the tundra warms, trees and moss are replacing the grassland that once dominated the area; their darker foliage traps heat, while their roots break up the soil, creating a feedback loop that causes the region to warm faster. At least in theory mammoths could help slow this process by knocking down trees and leaving droppings that would fertilise grass.

Whether this could be done at scale, or in the timeframe needed seems unlikely. Some scientists estimate that 20,000 years ago there were as many as 200m mammoths roaming the tundra. Even if the artificial womb technology Colossal have suggested might be used to create them becomes a reality, that’s a lot of mammoths. Meanwhile the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change identifies the collapse of the permafrost as one of 12 crucial tipping points that have the potential to lead to abrupt climate change.

Nor is Colossal’s scheme quite what it seems. Despite the talk of de-extinction, and resurrected species, they’re not proposing cloning mammoths from frozen specimens Jurassic Park-style. Instead their plan involves taking the DNA of Asian elephants and splicing in genes that will produce woolly hair, increased fat deposits and presumably longer tusks. This will create a mammoth-like version of an Asian elephant capable of withstanding Arctic conditions.

There are obviously significant questions about the ethics of such a scheme. Do we have the right to create new species in this way? And even if we do, should we? But there are also other, deeper concerns we need to consider.

Animals are not simply biological machines or the sum of their genetic code. They exist within complex social and biological systems, webs of entanglement that bind them to communities of other species and their own. They have ways of being in the world, traditions, culture.

Related: Could bringing Neanderthals back to life save the environment? The idea is not quite science fiction | James Bradley

Nor is extinction really about the disappearance of the last member of a species – those uniquely grief-charged beings known as endlings – instead it takes place incrementally, and diminishes the world in unpredictable ways. As the philosopher Thom van Dooren has observed, “extinction is never a sharp, singular event – something that begins, rapidly takes place, and then is over and done with”; instead it is “a slow unravelling of intimately entangled ways of life that begins long before the death of the last individual and continues to ripple long afterwards”.

Seen like this it becomes clear that resurrecting a species is not simply about recreating the organism. Even assuming Colossal succeeds in creating an animal that looks like a mammoth, it will not be a mammoth. Instead it will be something new, a being – and perhaps eventually a species – that will have to learn new ways of being in the world if it is to survive.

For many this will be unthinkable, a symptom of the same thinking that got us into this mess in the first place. Yet as the planet is reshaped by global heating and other human impacts, species are disappearing at a terrifying rate. According to recent estimates, up to a million species face extinction due to human activity.

Most of these species will pass almost unnoticed, mourned only by a handful of scientists. Like the climate crisis, holding back this tide of extinction demands the transformation of human society and activity. But we will also be confronted with difficult choices about how far we are prepared to protect threatened species and restore damaged ecosystems.

And whether or not Colossal succeed in restoring mammoths to the tundra, it seems likely de-extinction technologies will play a part in that process.

• James Bradley is an Australian novelist and critic

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Still need a costume? Here are 7 easy DIY Halloween costumes

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. The countdown to Halloween is on—are you still undecided on what ... Read more »

TikTok, YouTube and Snapchat grilled on child safety by US lawmakers

US senators put executives from YouTube, TikTok and Snapchat on the defensive on Tuesday, questioning them about what they are doing to ensure young users’ safety on their platforms. Citing ... Read more »

Stripe and Klarna partner to offer businesses buy now, pay later

Stripe and Klarna have announced a new strategic partnership that will enable businesses using Stripe’s payment gateway to let their customers to buy now and pay later using Klarna. Buy ... Read more »

Best Saatva mattress sales and deals in 2021: up to $300 off ahead of Black Friday

The new Saatva mattress sale ahead of Black Friday contains a time-limited discount on the award-winning Saatva Classic hybrid. Until Thursday 28 October, you can save up to $300 on ... Read more »

Facebook's Q3 results had a 'pretty thick silver lining,' says analyst

Facebook (FB) shares took a hit Tuesday following news Monday that it’s seeing headwinds from Apple’s (AAPL) recent iOS privacy changes and waning interest among younger consumers. The news came ... Read more »

Chronicles of the epic mission to deliver Covid vaccines to the world

“A Shot in the Arm,” a new book from Professor Yossi Sheffi, reveals lessons about overcoming global threats. Read more »

Jason Momoa felt like he was 'the shittiest one in the whole room' working on 'Dune' with Javier Bardem and Josh Brolin

Jason Momoa at the London premiere of “Dune.” Karwai Tang/WireImage Jason Momoa felt like he was the “shittiest one in the whole room” during a group scene in “Dune.” Momoa ... Read more »

Facebook's algorithm 'promoted toxic and hateful content'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Facebook’s algorithm promoted ‘toxic and hateful’ content by giving five points to posts with emojis including ‘angry and sad’ and only one for ... Read more »

Social media giants try to distance themselves from Facebook

“We do not prioritize profits over safety,” one executive said at a congressional hearing in arguing that YouTube is not Facebook. Read more »

Corsair M65 RGB Ultra review: "a nice leap forward in Corsair's iconic line"

Corsair has given its M65 gaming mouse more than a spit polish for 2021. The new M65 RGB Ultra is the latest in the brand’s line of highly successful tunable ... Read more »

Kohl's shoppers can save an extra 20% off at this sale for a limited time

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re looking to skip the mad rush of Black Friday, ... Read more »

Samsung is making a cloud gaming service for its Tizen smart TVs

Samsung has announced its plans to create a cloud gaming service that will be available on its Tizen smart TVs, similar to Microsoft’s xCloud and Google’s Stadia. The announcement was ... Read more »

Open source cloud computing on the Akash Network

Akash Network co-founder and CEO joins Yahoo Finance to chat about his company’s decentralized cloud computer platform, Donald Trump‘s upcoming social media network, and more.. Read more »

Sophie Wessex's huge £1m family farmhouse she left to marry Prince Edward

Sophie Wessex married the Queen's son Prince Edward in 1999, and the couple moved to Bagshot Park in Surrey together, but prior to this, 34-year-old Sophie was living at her ... Read more »

Brandon Lee's fiancée Eliza Hutton speaks out about 'Rust' shooting: 'There's no such thing as a prop gun'

The fatal shooting on the set of Alec Baldwin's film Rust has motivated Eliza Hutton, fiancée of the late Brandon Lee, to speak out for the first time about his ... Read more »

Strictly's Johannes Radebe is 'careful what he wears' to avoi being stopped by police

Watch: Johannes Radebe says he tries to stay inconspicuous Strictly Come Dancing favourite Johannes Radebe has opened up about his fears of drawing attention of the police in the way ... Read more »

Radio host mocked for telling Insulate Britain activist you can grow concrete

Watch: Radio host tells Insulate Britain activist you can grow concrete A radio host has been mocked on social media after he told a climate change activist that you can ... Read more »

Millionaire hotel tycoon, 33, collapses and dies eight weeks after lavish wedding

Vivek Chadha was found dead on Sunday morning (supplied) A 33-year-old millionaire hotel tycoon mysteriously collapsed and died after partying in a Mayfair nightclub, it was reported. Vivek Chadha, who ... Read more »

On Her Majesty's Secret Server: how the spooks recruited Big Tech

When James Bond encounters Q in Skyfall, tousle-haired actor Ben Whishaw gives 007 a lesson in where the world of intelligence gathering is headed. © Provided by The Telegraph spies ... Read more »

HBO's hit 'Succession' renewed for fourth season

The first episode of Season 3 drew a series-high viewership of 1.4 million viewers across HBO's platforms that night. Read more »

US Federal Communications Commission revokes China Telecom America's operating licence, citing national security

The US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on Tuesday voted to order China Telecom Americas to stop providing telecommunication service in the United States, citing national security concerns. The move, announced ... Read more »

20 amazing gifts every Taylor Swift fan will love

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. It feels like Taylor Swift is the gift that keeps on ... Read more »

Is brushing your teeth for two minutes enough? Here's what the evidence says

The two minute rule has been recommended since the 70s. WAYHOME studio/ Shutterstock A lot of us are familiar with the advice that we should brush our teeth twice a ... Read more »

Verizon and Amazon are teaming up to boost rural broadband

Verizon and Amazon have announced a new strategic collaboration which will see the US telecom leverage the ecommerce giant’s Project Kuiper to deliver improved connectivity to rural and remote communities ... Read more »

'Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy' releases today—here's where to buy it

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Game developer Eidos-Montréal and publisher Square Enix bring us the latest ... Read more »

On Her Majesty's Secret Server: how the spooks got into bed with Big Tech

GCHQ – David Goddard/Getty Images When James Bond encounters Q in Skyfall, tousle-haired actor Ben Whishaw gives 007 a lesson in where the world of intelligence gathering is headed. “I’ll ... Read more »

5 things to consider when picking a smartwatch strap

When you’re buying a smartwatch for the first time, understandably your primary focus will be on what that smartwatch can do, whether it works with your phone setup and it’s ... Read more »

Chelsea vs Southampton live stream: how to watch 2021 Carabao Cup online from anywhere

Chelsea and Southampton played out an ill-tempered cracker a few weeks ago, the Blues snatching the points after the Saints went down to 10 men. And they meet again today ... Read more »

Adobe Max 2021: the 5 best new features coming to Lightroom

Adobe Max is the software giant’s equivalent of Apple’s WWDC, and some of the event’s most exciting announcements have been for its popular photo editing package Lightroom. Photoshop is likely ... Read more »

Here are the EE Pocket-lint Awards nominees for Best Speaker 2021 and how to vote

© Provided by Pocket-lint Here are the EE Pocket-lint Awards nominees for Best Speaker 2021 and how to vote photo 1 (Pocket-lint) – The EE Pocket-lint Awards celebrate 18 categories ranging from ... Read more »

RTX 3080 PC deals: Experience 4K gaming for less

RTX 3080 PC deals are the best way of beating the resellers and getting yourself not only one of the best graphics cards but one of the best gaming PCs ... Read more »

iOS 5.1: Apple finally releases delayed ‘SharePlay' feature alongside other new updates

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Apple China Removed Apps – Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Apple has finally introduced SharePlay, one of the ... Read more »

Amazon Kindle Paperwhite 2021 vs Kindle Paperwhite 2018

It’s been three years since the Amazon Kindle Paperwhite (2018) landed, but now finally we have a new model, in the Amazon Kindle Paperwhite (2021). Three years is a long ... Read more »

What could you do with Hertz's 100,000 Teslas? We did the math

Tesla’s deal with car-rental giant Hertz has generated some jaw-dropping numbers. The order of 100,000 Tesla Model 3s is potentially the largest ever purchase of electric vehicles. The announcement drove ... Read more »

Best laptops for graphic design 2021: top picks for graphic designers

If you’re in the market for one of the best laptops for graphic design, you’ll need a powerful machine. Without the necessary horsepower, it won’t keep up with the editing ... Read more »

Call of Duty: Vanguard PS5 Dualsense support is coming... but we have concerns

Activision’s Sledgehammer Games has outlined how the upcoming Call of Duty: Vanguard will use the adaptive triggers and haptic feedback of the PS5 DualSense controller. It’s exciting news for PS5 ... Read more »

Cyber Monday Xbox controller deals: what to expect this year

Buying a pad for your console is never a cheap business – that’s why the Cyber Monday Xbox One controller deals are so handy each year. Xbox controllers are actually ... Read more »

Black Friday arrived early for Blink cameras at Amazon, with prices from $24.99

While Black Friday is still over a month away, you can score epic deals right now on Amazon’s best-selling Blink security cameras. Amazon’s early Black Friday sale includes record-low prices ... Read more »

Loki season 2: everything we know

Spoilers for Loki season 1 follow. Loki season 2 is officially on the way and, surprisingly, it may arrive next year. That’s according to one of the show’s stars, who ... Read more »

Best laptops for photographers in 2021

The best laptops for photo editing need more than high-end internals like the fastest RAM, the best graphics card, and the best processor. A photographer has to make sure that ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic