MP at the centre of expense scandal, Terry Stephens, to ask Supreme Court to keep his address secret

The senior Liberal MP at the centre of South Australia’s parliamentary expense scandal is seeking a court order to keep secret the address where he nominated for the 2018 state election.

Terry Stephens is arguing release of the address would invade his privacy and security.

That is despite a tribunal accepting it is likely he does not live there now, did not live there at the election and was using a different address to claim tens of thousands of dollars in Country Members Accommodation Allowance.

The ABC sought access to Mr Stephens’s electoral nomination form under Freedom of Information, applying to the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) for access to the document after being denied by the state Ombudsman.

Lawyers representing Mr Stephens told the tribunal releasing the address would invade he and his family’s privacy.

But SACAT rejected those arguments, accepting the ABC’s “powerful” evidence that Mr Stephens was not living in the property declared on the form at the time he nominated and that there was a requirement under electoral law to declare the address publicly.

SACAT Senior Member Kathleen McEvoy ruled that while the address did constitute his personal affairs, it should be released.

“There is no substantive information before the Tribunal to suggest that Mr Stephens’s or his wife’s privacy and security are threatened,” Senior Member McEvoy wrote.

“It (the address) is already in the public domain (put there by Mr Stephens), and its disclosure will not threaten his or his wife’s privacy or security.”

The address remains suppressed while the MP seeks leave to mount his latest legal appeal.

Mr Stephens declined to answer questions for this story.

Terry Stephens was one of several MPs who became the subject of investigation by the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption, after an ABC investigation raised questions about their entitlements to claim the $234-a-night payment available to regional MPs required to be in the city overnight for work.

The ABC investigation last year uncovered the then-President of the Upper House was claiming the allowance while spending lots of time at his Norwood property in suburban Adelaide, while publicly claiming to live in Victor Harbor.

The apartment he owned in the seaside town had been leased as a short-term holiday rental since early 2017.

Under scrutiny over his living arrangements, he told Parliament he lived in Victor Harbor:

“From 2010 to 2017, I lived in an apartment that I owned and from 2017 to the current day, I live in an apartment in the same complex which I lease.”

In seeking to test this statement, the ABC sought access to Mr Stephens’s nomination form held by the Electoral Commission of South Australia (ECSA) in the expectation it would show his home address in 2018.

Mr Stephens has always denied any wrongdoing since questions over his use of the allowance were first raised last year.

The legal battles

Mr Stephens’s nomination form was approved for release to the ABC by ECSA under Freedom of Information laws in December, 2020.

At Mr Stephens request, that decision was reviewed by the Ombudsman who subsequently overturned the call to release it, on the grounds it would amount to an unreasonable disclosure of his personal affairs.

The ABC disagreed with that ruling and sought a review in the South Australian Administrative and Civil Tribunal (SACAT).

The ABC’s barrister, Michelle Hamlyn, submitted that there was significant public interest in releasing the information.

The tribunal heard that a letter from Mr Stephens’s lawyer to the Ombudsman indicated the nomination address put forward by Mr Stephens in February 2018, was the same Victor Harbor apartment the MP had told Parliament he had moved out of almost a year earlier.

The ABC submitted that if that was the case, the address on the nomination form sat at odds with the address Mr Stephens had used to submit monthly claims for Country Members Accommodation Allowance from May 2017 onwards.

Ms Hamlyn submitted there could be no issue of unreasonable disclosure given he stopped living at the property more than four years ago and it is owned by someone else.

Naomi Kereru, for Mr Stephens, did not directly address the issue of ownership or use of the Victor Harbor property by her client, but said the ABC was “making assumptions” concerning the address contained in the nomination form.

Terry Stephens’s lawyers also argued the address should stay secret because he had applied for silent elector status in February 2021 — after the ABC’s FOI request was lodged.

But Senior Member McEvoy dismissed the argument.

“There was no suppression of his name prior to the 2018 election, and suppression of his address in February 2021 cannot change that fact,” she said.

The Supreme Court will hear arguments on whether Mr Stephens can appeal against the tribunal’s ruling next month.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

'Robbery every game', 'Having a stinker' - Many Leeds fans slam 'absolute nightmare' vs Wolves

Lots of Leeds fans have taken to Twitter to slam Jack Harrison’s  display against Wolves in the Premier League. © Provided by This is Futbol Jack Harrison Trailing at half-time, ... Read more »

Norris reacts to being voted the ladies' favourite driver

Lando Norris is happy to have been the ladies’ choice in F1’s biggest ever fans’ survey – especially if he can help them towards a career in the sport. © ... Read more »

'Absolutely sums up Angeball', 'Just what we wanted to see' - Many Celtic fans hail 'great' news

Plenty of Celtic fans were quick to offer their thoughts on social media as they flooded Twitter in the wake of the first half of the Bhoys’ Premiership game against ... Read more »

'Is it possible to sack a stand in manager?' - Many Newcastle fans react to 'horrible' news

Plenty of Newcastle fans were quick to offer their thoughts ion social media as they flooded Twitter in the wake of the first half of Newcastle’s game against Crystal Palace. ... Read more »

Minnesota politician backs fundraiser for alleged Capitol attackers

A Minnesota politician has promoted a fundraiser for several constituents who are charged with participation in the deadly 6 January attack on the US Capitol, saying they come from a ... Read more »

Erdogan orders removal of 10 ambassadors, including US envoy

ISTANBUL (AP) — Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Saturday that he had ordered 10 foreign ambassadors who called for the release of a jailed philanthropist to be declared persona ... Read more »

Russia, China hold first joint patrol in the western Pacific, Russian defense ministry says

© Russian Defense Ministry/Reuters A group of naval vessels from Russia and China conduct a joint maritime military patrol in the waters of the Pacific Ocean, in this still image ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Temba Bavuma rues 'a day that didn't go to plan' as South Africa lose Super 12 opener vs Australia

South African captain Temba Bavuma was disappointed with his team’s batting performance after their 5-wicket defeat in the opening game of the ICC T20 World Cup Super 12s which got ... Read more »

T20 World Cup 2021: India look to make winning statement against arch-rivals Pakistan

© Provided by Firstpost T20 World Cup 2021: India look to make winning statement against arch-rivals Pakistan Virat Kohli will step down as India captain in the shortest format of ... Read more »

England vs West Indies Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021, Today's Match at Dubai: Windies in Tatters After Losing Nicholas Pooran

© Provided by News18 England vs West Indies Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021, Today’s Match at Dubai: Windies in Tatters After Losing Nicholas Pooran England vs West Indies, Live ... Read more »

Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in Poll-Bound UP: CM Yogi Adityanath

© Provided by News18 Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in Poll-Bound UP: CM Yogi Adityanath Months ahead of the 2022 Assembly elections, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath ... Read more »

Tennis icon Billie Jean King explains why she admires Ons Jabeur and why she wants the Tunisian to succeed

© PA Images Ons Jabeur delighted Ons Jabeur continues to make history on the WTA Tour and few are happier about the Tunisian’s success than tennis great Billie Jean King. ... Read more »

Chelsea 7-0 Norwich: Mount hat-trick as Blues thump dismal Canaries

© PA Images Chelsea v Norwich Chelsea thumped Norwich by seven goals to nil as Mason Mount bagged himself a hat-trick as the Blues’ homegrown talent came to the fore. ... Read more »

'Fake an injury', 'Has no business near this team' - Many EFC fans slam 'putrid' man vs Watford

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Salomon Rondon Everton Many Everton fans have been slamming the display of Salomon Rondon in the first half of their game at home to Watford ... Read more »

A great read: Meet the GP selling books to raise money for sick children

© Provided by Evoke.ie ‘I learned most of my life by becoming a parent I think. When I was working in a maternity hospital as a pediatric doctor, I would ... Read more »

McCarthy on brink after Cardiff suffer eighth straight loss

© Getty Martin Payero celebrates after making it 2-0 Middlesbrough cranked up the pressure on under-fire Cardiff boss Mick McCarthy as they inflicted a club record eighth straight defeat on ... Read more »

American Film Institute remembers Halyna Hutchins with memorial scholarship fund for women cinematographers

The American Film Institute is honoring the memory of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins with a scholarship for female filmmakers following her tragic death on the set of the movie, “Rust.” © ... Read more »

Klimaaktivisten: Reiche Länder wie Deutschland haben Bringschuld

© Keystone/Fridays for Future/- Vor der UN-Klimakonferenz fordern junge Klimaschützer aus ärmeren Weltregionen reiche Länder wie Deutschland zum entschlosseneren Einsatz gegen die Klimakrise auf. Wohlhabende Industrienationen wie die USA, Grossbritannien ... Read more »

Stunning outdoor TVs up to $500 off at Amazon ahead of Black Friday

© Provided by BGR Best Outdoor TV Deals If you’re looking for the best outdoor TV deals around ahead of Black Friday, look no further than Amazon. You’ve undoubtedly done ... Read more »

Where to find the secret in the Pazuzu chapter of House of Ashes

There are many secrets to discover in The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes. Scattered throughout each chapter of this tale, you can find objects that paint a larger picture ... Read more »

NATO not ready for equal dialogue with Moscow - Russian defence chief

© Reuters/SPUTNIK FILE PHOTO: Russian Defence Minister Shoigu attends the opening ceremony of the International military-technical forum “Army-2021” in Moscow Region MOSCOW (Reuters) – Russia’s defence minister accused NATO on ... Read more »

Four arrested after man, 23, dies in Hampshire stabbing

© PA Archive Police have arrested four people after a man was stabbed to death in Hampshire (Peter Byrne/PA) – PA Archive A man has died and two other people ... Read more »

Covid news - live: UK ‘must do more than booster jabs' to avert threat of Christmas lockdown, advisers warn

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. Virus Outbreak Vaccine Supply LIVE – Updated at 15:13 A government adviser has said it was “quite questionable” for chancellor Rishi ... Read more »

Cop26 Glasgow - news: Reaching global deal will be tougher than Paris agreement, says Sharma

© AFP via Getty Images PRI205473977.jpg LIVE – Updated at 15:41 Securing a global climate deal in Glasgow will be “really tough”, Cop26 president Alok Sharma has warned. He said ... Read more »

Wanita meninggal dunia dalam kluster pengebumian ‘bukan mangsa Covid-19'

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Jurucakap Covid-19 Sabah, Masidi Manjun kesal dengan kesilapan menaip dalam kenyataan semalam. (Gambar Bernama) KOTA KINABALU: Seorang wanita yang upacara pengebumiannya dikatakan mecetuskan kluster ... Read more »

Nancy bantu wanita Batang Sadong dengan sumbangan peralatan dapur

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Nancy Shukri (kiri) menghadiri majlis penyerahan peralatan membuat kuih dan kek kepada usahawan wanita di kawasan Parlimennya, Batang Sadong. BATANG SADONG: Menteri Pelancongan, Seni ... Read more »

Elijah Wood, James Gunn Among Stars Paying Tribute To Cinematographer Halyna Hutchins Following Tragic ‘Rust' Shooting

Stars have been paying tribute to cinematographer Halyna Hutchins following Thursday’s tragic shooting on the set of “Rust”. © Shutterstock Halyna Hutchins. Hutchins died after actor Alec Baldwin accidentally shot ... Read more »

CJI inaugurates new building of Bombay HC, Rijiju reiterates Centre's commitment to judicial infrastructure

Chief Justice of India NV Ramana inaugurated the new annexe building of the Bombay High Court’s Aurangabad Bench on Saturday. He also expressed concerns about the country’s judicial infrastructure in ... Read more »

Dhruv, Mithila say ending 'Little Things' is like leaving school

© IANS Little Things Mumbai, Oct 23 (IANS) When the first episode of the rom-com series ‘Little Things’ released in 2016, actors Dhruv Sehgal and Mithila Palkar did not know ... Read more »

Kurup: Dulquer Salmaan announces the release date of his first pan-India biggie with an emotional note; says, 'The film almost feels like my second child'

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com As we saw the makers announcing the release dates of their pending films post government allowing the reopening of cinema halls, Dulquer Salmaan has dropped the ... Read more »

China has been breaching Nepal-China border rules in Humla: Report

© Provided by WION A recent study conducted by the Ministry of Home Affairs of Nepal has found several issues along the Nepal-China border in Humla district. Local media houses ... Read more »

Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin in November End in Poll-Bound UP: CM Yogi Adityanath

© Provided by News18 Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin in November End in Poll-Bound UP: CM Yogi Adityanath Months ahead of the 2022 Assembly elections, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi ... Read more »

Navjot Kaur Sidhu slams Amarinder Singh's links to Pak journalist, says he gave her ‘gifts'

Punjab Congress president Navjot Singh Sidhu’s wife and former MLA Navjot Kaur Sidhu on Saturday launched an offensive against former chief minister Capt Amarinder Singh over his ties to Pakistani ... Read more »

Mick McCarthy sacked by Cardiff City minutes after eighth successive defeat

Cardiff City have sacked manager Mick McCarthy after a disastrous run which culminated in eight defeats on the bounce. The shocking run of results has seen Cardiff plummet down the ... Read more »

Bodybuilder Chris Bumstead Shared His Epic Cheat Meal After Winning ‘Mr. Olympia'

Chris Bumstead is in celebration mode after being named the winner of the Classic Physique category of the Mr. Olympia bodybuilding competition for the third year in a row. And ... Read more »

Irish celebs throw support behind mum-of-four with aggressive cancer

© Provided by Evoke.ie Irish celebrities Kathryn Thomas and Aoife Walsh have offered their support to brave mum-of-four Jamie Phelan who is currently fighting aggressive brain cancer. Jamie’s friend Niamh ... Read more »

Spain's Sabadell rejects offer from Co-op bank for its British unit TSB

© Reuters/ALBERT GEA Sabadell bank’s logo is seen at an ATM machine outside an office in Barcelona By Jesús Aguado MADRID (Reuters) – Spain’s Sabadell said on Saturday its board ... Read more »

Crewe one-punch killer faces jail after being found guilty of attack

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A man who killed a father-of-two in a one-punch attack as he was celebrating his 45th birthday faces years in prison after he ... Read more »

Nurses and shop staff in UK face tide of abuse since end of lockdowns

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Paul Dennis/Rex People in public-facing jobs are facing rising hostility and verbal abuse since the end of the Covid lockdowns, according to organisations which ... Read more »

Coronavirus: 2,427 new cases of Covid-19 confirmed in Ireland

© Alamy Stock Photo Chief Medical Officer Dr Tony Holohan PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS have confirmed 2,427 new cases of Covid-19 in Ireland. As of 8am this morning, there were 449 ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic