Mouth bacteria may explain why some kids hate broccoli

When confronted with the tiniest forkful of cauliflower or broccoli, some kids can’t help but scrunch up their faces in disgust. But don’t blame them — a new study hints that specific enzymes in spit might make cruciferous vegetables taste particularly vile to some children.

© Provided by Live Science a young child sits at a table behind a plate of broccoli and looks grossed out

These enzymes, called cysteine lyases, are produced by different kinds of bacteria that live in the mouth. The same enzymes are also locked away in the cells of Brassica vegetables, such as cabbage, Brussels sprouts, broccoli and cauliflower. So when we chomp into a broccoli floret, these enzymes spill out of their storage containers in the veggie’s component cells while those in our spit kick into gear. 

These enzymes break down a compound called S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (SMCSO) in cruciferous vegetables, and this breakdown process transforms the compound into pungent odor molecules. Previous studies of adults suggest that the level of cysteine lyase activity in a person’s spit determines how much the SMCSO breaks down, and therefore, how many stinky molecules get produced in the process. This, in turn, influences how cruciferous veggies taste to adults.

Related: Tip of the tongue: The 7 (other) flavors humans may taste 

According to these past studies, when different adults consume, say, fresh cabbage, there can be up to a tenfold difference in how many sulfurous odors the food lets off as their saliva-borne enzymes break it to bits. But the study authors wondered whether the same variance can be seen in kids, who, compared with adults, are usually more sensitive to bitter and sour tastes anyway. They suspected that kids whose spit produced the most smelly, SMCSO-derived compounds would show the strongest dislike for Brassica vegetables compared with adults and their peers.     

And according to the team’s new study, published Sept. 22 in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, that’s just what they found. While both adults’ and kids’ spit produced smelly compounds when exposed to cauliflower, these odors did not sway whether adults liked or disliked the vegetable. On the other hand, kids whose spit produced high concentrations of these odors reported hating cauliflower the most out of all the study subjects.

In particular, kids seemed sensitive to a stinky compound called dimethyl trisulfide (DMTS), an odor that’s both a byproduct of SMCSO-breakdown and a scent that gets released by decomposing meat, first author Damian Frank, a food chemistry and sensory food scientist at the University of Sydney, told Live Science in an email.   

“DMTS is okay in small doses, but when dominant, it really has a rotten sulfur smell,” Frank said. And it turns out, when kids tuck into a serving of cauliflower, some might endure higher quantities of these super-smelly odors than others.

The new study included 98 pairs of parents and children ages 6 to 8. After taking samples of each participant’s saliva, the scientists stirred the spit into raw cauliflower powder that they’d concocted in the lab. They measured the SMCSO-derived odor compounds let off by the powdered vegetable, and as in previous studies, they found that each participant’s saliva generated a different quantity of stinky, sulfurous scents.  

In a separate analysis, the study authors found that broccoli lets off these same noxious smells, but cauliflower actually did so in slightly higher concentrations. 

Related: 5 ways gut bacteria affect your health 

Interestingly, the degree of putrid odor production was similar between parents’ spit and their children’s, the team found. This finding hints that parents and kids likely carry similar bacteria in their mouths, which would cause them to produce similar levels of cysteine lyase enzymes. “To be clear, we did not measure the microbiological composition of the saliva,” so the team couldn’t confirm exactly how closely parents and children matched each other, or which specific microbes were responsible for the stink, Frank said.

In a taste-test of raw cauliflower, the children whose saliva produced the largest quantities of sulfurous odors reported the strongest dislike of the vegetable. But the same pattern was not seen in adults whose spit also produced a plethora of putrid scents. This suggests that, over time, the adults came to tolerate the taste of cruciferous vegetables, the study authors suggested. 

These findings align with past studies of how our tastes change over time. According to Russell Keast, a sensory scientist at Deakin University in Australia, we can come to love foods that we despised as children through repeated exposure. In other words, our taste buds don’t necessarily change; we just slowly learn to enjoy a wider range of foods by eating them more and more. 

There may be an evolutionary advantage to kids’ insatiable desire for sugar and natural aversion to bitter broccoli: Sweetness usually signals that a food provides a lot of energy, while bitterness could mean that it’s toxic, Robin Dando, an assistant professor in the Department of Food Sciences in the Department of Agriculture and Life Sciences at Cornell University, told Bon Appétit magazine. And because our senses of taste and smell are strongest in youth, that may make kids even more sensitive to these differences in flavor. But eventually, as they try new foods, children can learn to overcome their aversion to smelly vegetables — regardless of what enzymes they carry on their tongues.

Originally published on Live Science. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Are you suffering from 'revenge' bedtime procrastination?

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Procrastinating before bed time despite being tired is usually a sign you are lacking sufficient ‘me time’ during the day, experts say. The ... Read more »

Victorian health department faces court

Victoria’s health department has faced court after it was charged over hotel quarantine failures that led to the state’s deadly second wave of COVID-19. © James Ross/AAP PHOTOS The health ... Read more »

Brumbies release Kata from Super contract

Solomone Kata has been granted a release from his Super Rugby contract with the Brumbies so he can remain in New Zealand for family reasons. © Jeremy Ward/AAP PHOTOS Solomone ... Read more »

Man charged with murder of pregnant Perth woman Janet Dweh

A man has been charged with the murder of heavily-pregnant aged care nurse Janet Dweh in Perth’s north-east Ms Dweh’s brother found the mother-of-three’s body inside her home in Dayton ... Read more »

Huge 5.9 magnitude earthquake strikes New Zealand

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo New Zealand has been hit by a huge 5.9 magnitude earthquake that was felt across the country – with buildings shaking on both ... Read more »

Young Thug reveals new song with Mac Miller was recorded a day before his death

Rapper Young Thug has revealed his song ‘Day Before’, a collaboration with Mac Miller that closes his new album Punk, was recorded just one day before MIller’s death in 2018. ... Read more »

Aldi is named the cheapest supermarket beating Coles and Woolworths

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Aldi has been crowned the cheapest supermarket in Australia for a basket of 29 essential grocery items costing just $80.75. The latest CHOICE grocery prices ... Read more »

Ozzy and Sharon Osbourne's love story getting a feature film at Sony Pictures

The lives and epic love story of rocker Ozzy Osbourne and manager and personality Sharon Osbourne will be the subject of an upcoming feature film. The untitled project comes from ... Read more »

Original Yellow Wiggle Greg Page meets new member Tsehay Hawkins

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Yellow Wiggle Emma Watkins announced earlier this week she was leaving the children’s band after 11 years. And The Wiggles have now released ... Read more »

Blake Lively calls out 'disturbing' Instagram post showing daughters' faces: 'You said you would stop'

Blake Lively has hit out at an Instagram account for posting photos of her three daughters with husband Ryan Reynolds. The Gossip Girl alum voiced her disapproval of the Instagram ... Read more »

All the ways to use your phone with one hand

This story has been updated. It was originally published on September 17, 2019. © Jae Park / Unsplash Are your thumbs having a hard time keeping up today’s ever-bigger phones? ... Read more »

Gabby Petito's Suspected Killer Brian Laundrie's Remains Are Found In Florida Park, FBI Confirms

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd No cause of death has been formally announced. Remains of missing person Brian Laundrie have been found in a Florida State Park, as ... Read more »

Did this woman go too far to catch her cheating boyfriend?

Earlier this week an internet goer took to Reddit to reveal the unusual test she set for her boyfriend. In the thread, the woman confesses that she put her boyfriend ... Read more »

The new 16-inch MacBook Pro offers a speed-enhancing 'High Power Mode'

The redesigned MacBook Pro might be more powerful than you think, provided you have the right configuration. Apple has confirmed to Engadget and MacRumors that the 16-inch MacBook Pro with ... Read more »

‘Unacceptable': NSW Premier seeks urgent advice as Obeid family keeps millions despite jail terms

NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet has vowed to take action against the Obeid family, who will keep $30 million in proceeds of crime despite family patriarch Eddie Obeid and his son ... Read more »

Scott Morrison says Singapore travel bubble could be established within next week

A quarantine-free travel bubble between Australia and Singapore could be established within the next week after Prime Minister Scott Morrison confirmed the two countries were in the final stages of ... Read more »

Olivia Newton-John gives stage 4 cancer update: 'I have my pains'

Olivia Newton-John says she has her good days and her bad days as she once again battles cancer. In an interview with Today US‘s Hoda Kotb which aired on Wednesday, ... Read more »

Brooke Shields Is ‘Obsessed' With This Potent Anti-Aging Serum

Us Weekly has affiliate partnerships so we may receive compensation for some links to products and services. © Andrew H. Walker/Shutterstock Brooke Shields in November 2019. Many celebrities who are ... Read more »

Brooke Blurton on rumours winner of The Bachelorette has been leaked

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Darvid Garayeli is the front-runner to win Brooke Blurton’s heart on The Bachelorette, according to all major bookmakers. And now Brooke has addressed ... Read more »

Task force to assess country bank closures

A government task force including the big four banks will assess the consequences of regional branch closures for country communities. © AAP Image/Kelly Barnes A task force will examine how bank ... Read more »

Joe Gorga reveals he CRIED over sister Teresa Giudice's engagement

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Joe Gorga is thrilled about his sister Teresa Giudice’s engagement to  Luis Ruelas, who proposed in Greece earlier this week after a year of ... Read more »

Inscryption, As Told By Steam Reviews

Sometimes there’s no better joy than drawing energy through the confused misery of others. That’s what it’s like reading the experiences of users on Steam trying to review Inscryption, the subversive ... Read more »

Joan Collins calls William Shatner a ‘fool' for going to space

Joan Collins calls William Shatner a ‘fool’ for going to space Dame Joan Collins has criticised William Shatner after he took a historic flight to space, describing him as a ... Read more »

Contrails: How tweaking flight plans can help the climate

Aircraft condensation trails can have a significant impact on the climate, say researchers Those wispy white lines that crisscross the skies after an aeroplane flies overhead, are far less benign ... Read more »

Cause of Death Revealed for Calif. Family Who Mysteriously Died on Hiking Trail

Authorities have revealed the cause of death for the California family mysteriously found dead with their dog along a hiking trail in the Sierra National Forest in August. In a ... Read more »

App to help people eat better and exercise more will launch next year

A new app helping people to eat better and exercise more will launch next year, the Government has announced. From January 2022, a pilot will see users wearing wrist-worn devices ... Read more »

Mom 'terrified' after spotting suspicious figure in baby monitor footage: 'Search every inch of your house'

A woman spotted something unusual that left her “terrified” while watching her baby monitor footage. TikTok user @honicanlaura shared a video of her young child lying down in her crib ... Read more »

Dame Joan Collins criticises William Shatner over historic space flight

Dame Joan Collins has criticised William Shatner following his historic space flight, describing him as a “fool”. The 90-year-old actor, famed for his Star Trek role as Captain James T ... Read more »

Number of poor Asian Americans in N.Y.C. area up 15 percent in 10 years, study says

The number of Asian Americans living in poverty in metropolitan New York City rose by 15 percent over the past decade, a new report found, including a pronounced increase in ... Read more »

Many double-vaccinated blood cancer patients vulnerable to Covid, study shows

More than half of double-vaccinated blood cancer patients are left without effective protection against coronavirus, new research has found. Data from a trial published in Cancer Cell shows 57% of ... Read more »

Cleo Smith search nears one-week mark, with WA missing girl investigation entering new phase

As the search for Cleo Smith nears the one-week mark, the investigation into the four-year-old’s disappearance in Western Australia is entering a new phase. Cleo’s family say they last saw her ... Read more »

Bec and Lleyton Hewitt gear up to move to Sydney

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo They are gearing up to move to Sydney with their three children – Mia, 15, Cruz, 12, and Ava, 10. And removalists arrived at Bec ... Read more »

Aboriginal groups call on NSW government to end cultural fishing prosecutions

The New South Wales government should cease prosecuting Aboriginal people for exercising their cultural fishing rights, says a coalition of legal, social justice and Aboriginal groups. © Provided by The ... Read more »

Victoria has recorded 2,189 new local COVID-19 cases and 16 deaths as Melbourne lockdown ends

Victoria has recorded 2,189 new local COVID-19 cases and 16 deaths as the state comes out of lockdown. There are now 23,230 active cases of the virus in Victoria, and ... Read more »

Aussies could travel to Bali by Christmas, Qantas CEO says

Qantas CEO Alan Joyce has said travel to Bali will return by early 2022 “at the latest”. Currently, vaccinated travellers to the Indonesian island have to spend seven days in ... Read more »

Canada will look to make more temporary migrants permanent, minister says

By Anna Mehler Paperny © Reuters/Chris Helgren FILE PHOTO: Migrants, refugees, undocumented workers and their supporters rally in Toronto TORONTO (Reuters) – Canada may extend the deadline of a program ... Read more »

Palace confirms the Queen spent a night in hospital after news she cancelled a royal trip over medical concerns

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd Buckingham Palace has confirmed that the Queen spent a night in hospital this week, after medical concerns forced her to cancel a trip ... Read more »

NSW takes aim at capital gains tax breaks for property investors in bid to help first-home buyers

© Provided by ABC NEWS The housing market is growing at its fastest pace since 1989. (ABC Pilbara: Verity Gorman) The New South Wales government has taken aim at controversial tax ... Read more »

NSW records 345 COVID cases, five deaths

COVID-19 cases in NSW have fallen slightly but the state is bracing for a potential spike in case numbers, almost two weeks after stay-at-home orders lifted. © Joel Carrett/AAP PHOTOS NSW ... Read more »

International Qantas flights are set to return months ahead of schedule, as Australia prepares to throw its border open

© Provided by Business Insider Australia Qantas will accelerate the return of popular international flights from Sydney, the airline has announced. The decision comes after New South Wales revealed COVID-19 ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic