Moon's end of war proposal faces multitude of challenges

Asia's Tech News Daily

Moon’s end of war proposal faces multitude of challenges
President Moon Jae-in (Yonhap)President Moon Jae-in hopes to declare the end of the Korean War during his term, but such a declaration without corresponding denuclearization does not guarantee peace on the Korean Peninsula and time is too short to untangle complicated interests of all involved parties, experts say.

Moon revived the issue, which had remained dormant since the failed 2019 US-North Korea summit — at the United Nations in September. Since then, Seoul and Washington have discussed the issue, and are reportedly close to completing the declaration’s text.

However, the matter remains far from simple, as the North demands the US first end its “hostile policy against North Korea,” which the US is unlikely to accept.

When Moon first brought up the issue, Kim’s sister Kim Yo-jong agreed it would be a good idea, but said the hostile US policy against North Korea and unfair double standards must be withdrawn first — presumably relieving sanctions or suspending joint military training.

The proposal also faces opposition in the South, as well as the US.

Ban Ki-moon, former secretary-general of the United Nations, said Tuesday the declaration would weaken security posture on the Korean Peninsula and give Pyongyang an excuse to claim the dissolution of the United Nations Command and the withdrawal of US forces from Korea. He said denuclearization should come first.

“Real peace is more important than a formal declaration of war or a peace agreement,” said Shin Beom-chul, director of the Center for Diplomacy and Security at the Korea Research Institute for National Strategy.

In order to do that, North Korea should start the denuclearization process, conduct practical exchanges with the South and build trust. In the process, the North’s security concerns should be resolved step by step, he said.

“As these negotiations (for real peace) proceed, an end-of-war declaration is needed in the process. But there is no guarantee for such a peace process right now,” he said.

The US is also in a difficult position to participate in the discussion actively.

If the declaration is made, it will inevitably bring about changes in the current US armistice system and the status of the UN Command that supervises it.

Asked about the end-of-war declaration, White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan said in a press briefing on Oct. 27, “We (South Korea and the US) may have a somewhat different perspective on the exact order, timing and conditions of each action.”

The gap in Seoul and Washington’s view was apparent in the meeting between First Vice Foreign Minister Choi Jong-kun and US Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman in Washington on Oct. 16. While Korea’s Foreign Ministry said the peace process and communications on the Korean Peninsula, including the declaration of the end of the war, is being conducted thoroughly, the US counterpart did not mention the declaration. Instead, it said the two discussed a joint promise for the complete denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula.

“Biden is being criticized in the US for his foreign policy and is hitting the lowest approval ratings of his presidency in the low 40 percent range,” said Park Won-gon, a professor in the department of North Korean studies at Ewha Womans University.

He added that Kim Jong-un is “probably the most unpopular person in America,” and that it would not be easy for Biden to hold a meeting with Kim.

The China variable

China’s willingness to intervene is another variable.

China has been unhappy about being excluded in the discussion between the US and South Korea over the peace talks and it has expressed dissatisfaction to South Korea in various ways against the issue, Park said.

Chinese Ambassador to Korea Xing Haiming said in a local media interview last month, “China is a signatory to the armistice agreement. That’s why it’s right to discuss anything with China.”

Seoul’s national security adviser Suh Hoon, meanwhile, was set to meet with Beijing’s top diplomat Yang Jiechi on Thursday to talk about South Korea-China relations and Korean Peninsula issues. He could ask for China’s cooperation in drawing the North back to the negotiation table. They are expected to discuss ways to declare the end of the war in the wake of the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics. Ahead of Suh and Yang’s meeting, China and North Korea met to coordinate related issues.

China’s cooperation is needed to draw favorable responses from North Korea to the end-of-war declaration. However, as the US may seek to boycott the Beijing Olympics, Moon Jae-in’s calculation became more complicated.

Since Biden mentioned a potential “diplomatic boycott” of the Beijing Winter Olympics on Nov. 18, the UK and Australia have hinted at joining. European Union countries, Japan, Canada and New Zealand are also in the discussion.

The US is likely to openly demand the participation of allies in the cause of diplomatic boycotts, citing democracy and human rights.

Chung Wa Dae has not made an official statement about a boycott.

“When most Western countries boycott, it is hard for Korea not to follow it. Otherwise, there will be consequences that Korea should encounter,” Shin said.

Some experts, including Yang Moo-jin, a professor at the University of North Korean Studies in Seoul, however, believe the talks on the end-of-war declaration should proceed whether it occurs during Moon’s tenure or not.

“North Korea sympathizes with the push for an end-of-war declaration. And, the push for the declaration could catalyze denuclearization,” Yang said.

“The discussion is symbolic and if Moon’s administration fails to do it, the next government can push for it. It is meaningful that Korea leads the end of the war.”

Key presidential candidates are sharply divided in North Korea policy.

Lee Jae-myung, presidential candidate of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, said the declaration of the end of the war itself should not be prevented for any political reason. He said, “The state of war on the Korean Peninsula must be ended quickly for any reason.”

The main opposition People Power Party’s presidential candidate Yoon Seok-youl has opposed the declaration, saying if a political declaration with only the end of the war is made separate from denuclearization, the consequences would be severe.

“If the end of the war is declared first, the UNC is likely to be neutralized and the rear base of the UN office in Japan is also likely to be neutralized,” he said. “It is highly likely to give the international community the wrong signal.”

By Shin Ji-hye (shinjh@heraldcorp.com)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

HDC Hyundai Development chairman to resign over Gwangju apartment building collapse

Chung Mong-gyu, chairman of HDC Hyundai Development Co., leaves the press room at the company headquarters in Seoul, Jan. 17, after offering to resign over the partial collapse of its ... Read more »

N. Korean cargo train departs Chinese city of Dandong to return home: sources

This file photo shows a bridge over the Amnok River connecting Sinuiju in North Korea to the Chinese port city of Dandong. (Yonhap)A North Korean freight train that crossed a ... Read more »

Omicron set be dominant COVID-19 variant in Korea

A health worker wearing protective gear helps a visitor to receive coronavirus testing in the sub-zero temperatures at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, Jan. 14. AP-Yonhap ... Read more »

Yoon leads Lee 40.6% to 36.7%: poll

This compilation image shows (from L to R) presidential candidates Lee Jae-myung, Yoon Suk-yeol, Sim Sang-jeung and Ahn Cheol-soo. (Yonhap)Main opposition presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol is leading his ruling party ... Read more »

Talks between Moon, Abu Dhabi crown prince canceled due to 'unforeseen matter of state'

President Moon Jae-in speaks at a business forum on the hydrogen economy in Dubai on Sunday. (Yonhap)The scheduled talks between South Korean President Moon Jae-in and Abu Dhabi Crown Prince ... Read more »

Air Force to resume flights suspended in the wake of F-5E crash

Military officials check the wreckage of an F-5E fighter on a hill in Hwaseong, about 40 kilometers south of Seoul, where the plane belonging to the Air Force’s 10th Combat ... Read more »

[INTERVIEW] Han Hyo-joo stars as treasure-seeking hero in 'Pirates 2'

Actress Han Hyo-joo / Courtesy of BH Entertainment By Kwak Yeon-soo Actress Han Hyo-joo has taken on a new challenge by starring in the stunt-heavy, adventure fantasy film “The Pirates: ... Read more »

S. Korea and UAE to increase partnership in hydrogen economy

President Moon Jae-in, who is in Dubai for a three-day visit as part of his trip to the Middle East, speaks at a business forum held in Dubai, Sunday. (Yonhap)South ... Read more »

S. Korea, UAE to speed up cooperation in hydrogen ecosystem: Moon

President Moon Jae-in (C) is greeted by Suhail bin Mohammed Al Mazrouei, UAE Minister of Energy and Infrastructure, upon his arrival in Dubai last Saturday. (Yonhap)DUBAI — South Korea will ... Read more »

Opposition party's presidential candidate vows tough response to unauthorized labor rallies

Yoon Suk-yeol (C), the presidential nominee of the People Power Party, punches the air during the launch ceremony of his campaign’s Seoul committee held in the capital on Sunday. (Yonhap)Main ... Read more »

Scandal-hit Osstem facing delisting crossroads

Osstem Implant’s headquarters in Seoul / Courtesy of Osstem Implant Over 1,500 investors prepare to file class-action suit against dental implant maker By Yi Whan-woo Scandal-ridden dental implant maker Osstem ... Read more »

Contradicting court rulings over vaccine pass stoke confusion

Visitors scan smartphone QR codes for entry logs at a discount store in Seoul, Sunday. Yonhap 9 p.m. curfew extended through Feb. 6, private gathering limit raised to six By ... Read more »

India emerging as promising EV market

Workers are seen at a Hyundai Motor factory in Chennai, India. Courtesy of Hyundai Motor By Kim Bo-eun Carmakers are increasingly focusing on India’s market for electric vehicles (EV), given ... Read more »

Listed companies become more active in public disclosure

Getty Images By Anna J. Park Listed companies on the Korean stock market have become more engaging, as the number of the firms’ public disclosures increased by 16 percent. According ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution's IPO sucking up stock market liquidity like 'black hole'

LG Energy Solution’s headquarters located on Yeouido / Courtesy of LG Energy Solution By Anna J. Park Ahead of LG Energy Solution’s massive IPO slated later this month, the huge ... Read more »

Korean stock market could face foreign capital outflows on Fed's earlier rate hike

U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell, left, and Bank of Korea Governor Lee Ju-yeol / AFP-Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung The Korean stock market is feared to be facing risks of ... Read more »

HDC chief's leadership in crisis due to Gwangju accident

HDC Group Chairman Chung Mong-gyu issues an apology for the June 9 building collapse incident, at Gwangju City Hall on June 10, 2021. Courtesy of the Gwangju City Government By ... Read more »

Samsung's new Galaxy phones to see price hike due to chip shortages

Samsung Electronics’ Galaxy S21 FE 5G is displayed at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, Jan. 6. Courtesy of Samsung Electronics By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics is scheduled to ... Read more »

23rd Jeonju film festival to open in April, host offline screenings

The 23rd Jeonju International Film Festival logo / Courtesy of the Jeonju International Film Festival organizing committee By Kwak Yeon-soo This year’s Jeonju International Film Festival, scheduled from April 28 ... Read more »

Foreign chambers of commerce call for clarity in industrial accident law

New risk for CEOs feared to curb further investments By Kim Bo-eun Foreign firms share the view that industrial accidents need to be prevented, but concerns prevail over a strengthened ... Read more »

Justice Party presidential candidate resumes public activities after 'introspection'

Sim Sang-jeung (C), the presidential candidate of the minor progressive Justice Party, shakes hands with a rescue worker at the site of an apartment construction accident in the southwestern city ... Read more »

Yoon lays out pledges to ‘rebuild' Seoul, to relocate railroads underground

Presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol of the main opposition People Power Party announces his election pledges to “rebuild” Seoul at the party’s headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, Sunday. (Yonhap)Presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol ... Read more »

Pyongyang missiles hint at long-term standoff with US

North Korea test-fires a pair of short-range ballistic missiles from a rail-mobile launcher during firing drills on Jan. 14. (KCNA-Yonhap)Pyongyang’s recent missile launches serve a dual purpose, and may hint ... Read more »

40 percent of self-employed consider biz closure amid pandemic: survey

This Nov. 1, 2021 file photo shows people walking on the street of the shopping district of Myeongdong in Seoul. Korea Times file Four out of 10 self-employed people in ... Read more »

N. Korean cargo train arrives in Chinese city of Dandong: sources

Flags of China and North Korea (123rf)BEIJING/SHENYANG — A North Korean freight train crossed the the Yalu River railroad bridge into China on Sunday, multiple sources said. It was not ... Read more »

[INTERVIEW] 'PEFs adapt better to global disruptions'

Unison Capital Korea Representative Director Kim Soo-min speaks during an interview with The Korea Times at his office in Seoul, Dec. 30, 2021. Korea Times photo by Shim Hyun-chul Unison ... Read more »

Ruling party's presidential candidate vows to resume tourism to Mount Kumgang

Lee Jae-myung, the presidential nominee of the Democratic Party, greets citizens in Chuncheon, Gangwon Province, on Saturday. (Yonhap)Ruling party presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung said Sunday he will resume tourism to ... Read more »

NK fires two suspected ballistic missiles after US sanctions

This photo, released by North Korea`s official Korean Central News Agency on Wednesday, shows what the North claims to be a new hypersonic missile being launched the previous day. (KCNA-Yonhap)North ... Read more »

Korea expected to become world's biggest investor in fab equipment this year: report

gettyimagesbank Korea is expected to become the biggest investor in chip fabrication facilities this year, a global industry association said Thursday. According to SEMI, a global industry association representing the ... Read more »

Samsung demonstrates world's 1st MRAM-based in-memory computing

From left are Harvard University professor and Samsung Advanced Institute of Technology (SAIT) fellow Ham Don-hee, SAIT staff researcher Jung Seung-chul and SAIT Vice President of Technology Kim Sang-joon. Samsung ... Read more »

Louis Vuitton starts withdrawal from Korean duty free market

Louis Vuitton’s duty free shop at Incheon International Airport / Courtesy of Louis Vuitton Korea By Kim Jae-heunFrench luxury goods company Louis Vuitton has started pulling out its business from ... Read more »

Two orchestras hit sour note vying for official 'national' recognition

The Korean Symphony Orchestra (KSO) / Courtesy of the KSO KSO seeks to be national orchestra, while KBS believes it deserves that status By Park Ji-won One of Korea’s two ... Read more »

EU vetoes Korean shipbuilding merger between Hyundai and Daewoo

Hyundai Heavy Industries shipyard is seen in Ulsan Metropolitan City. Courtesy of Hyundai Heavy Industries The European Union antitrust regulator on Thursday vetoed Hyundai Heavy Industries Group’s proposed acquisition of ... Read more »

Bank of Korea chief leaves door open for additional rate hikes

Bank of Korea Governor Lee Ju-yeol speaks during a press conference in Seoul, Friday, after holding a monetary policy board meeting when the central bank decided to increase the key ... Read more »

Kep1er tops M Countdown just 11 days after debut

K-pop girl group Kep1er / Courtesy of Wake One Entertainment, Swing Entertainment By Dong Sun-hwa K-pop rookies Kep1er grabbed the No. 1 spot on a Korean music show for the ... Read more »

US scholar explains Confucianism as time-honored teachings for self-growth

Gettyimagesbank In upcoming book ‘Growing Moral,’ Stephen Angle untangles misunderstandings about Confucianism By Kang Hyun-kyung The 2015 census released by Statistics Korea presented interesting information about how Confucianism is viewed ... Read more »

Cho Hyun-min promoted to president of Hanjin

Cho Hyun-min / Courtesy of Hanjin Group By Kim Jae-heunCho Hyun-min, the youngest daughter of the late Hanjin Group Chairman Cho Yang-ho, has been appointed as the new president of ... Read more »

Korea to foster bio industry for innovation

Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Hong Nam-ki, left, speaks during a meeting at the Seoul Government Complex, Thursday. Yonhap By Lee Kyung-min Korea will invest 12.2 trillion won ($10.2 ... Read more »

Patients of rare diseases slam DPK candidate's health insurance coverage plan for hair loss treatment

Ruling Democratic Party of Korea presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung sweeps his hair up in a YouTube video posted Jan. 4, to collect public opinion about his pledge to include hair ... Read more »

'Those aged 30 and younger may not be able to receive state pension in 30 years'

Getty Images By Lee Kyung-min Those born in 1990 and after may not be able to receive monthly pensions from the National Pension Service (NPS) 30 years from now, unless ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic