Monday Musings: The many challenges facing Pune city's Metro project

Monday Musings: The many challenges facing Pune city’s Metro project
© Provided by Hindustan Times There have been inordinate delays in bringing the Metro project to Pune. While the major share of the blame does go to the Congress-NCP for failing to initiate the project earlier, local Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) politicians and environmentalists are also to be blamed for the deferrals. (HT FILE)

On December 24, 2016, three months before the Pune civic elections, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had said: “Had the (Pune Metro) project been sanctioned earlier by the Congress-Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) regime, the citizens of Pune wouldn’t have had to endure traffic snarls.” He was speaking at the Pune Metro Rail’s foundation stone laying ceremony, and was right, but only partially.

Five years have passed and citizens are now asking: Why is the project still not complete, even in parts?

There have already been inordinate delays in bringing the Metro project to Pune. While the major share of the blame does go to the Congress-NCP for failing to initiate the project much earlier, local Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) politicians and environmentalists are also to be blamed for the deferrals.

And now, there are some groups stalling the project because they are not happy with the height of the viaduct at Chhatrapati Sambhaji bridge, also known as Lakdi Pul, which is a crucial location in the entire project.


These groups, mostly Ganpati mandals feel the viaduct height poses a hindrance to immersion procession, something the project executing agency Maharashtra Metro Rail Corporation Limited (Maha-Metro) has denied. There have been meetings between PMC corporators, mayor, Maha-Metro officials and Ganesh mandal workers but stand-off continues.

For politicians, upsetting Ganesh mandals mean inviting the wrath of people who are also political activists when civic elections are just three to four months away. More so when these mandals are power centres, enjoying the power to sway voters from old city areas, largely the bastion of BJP.

A good 20 years ago when the Metro rail project proposal first came up, the then Congress MP, Suresh Kalmadi, first spoke about the Bus Rapid Transport System (BRTS) in 2001. For the next few years, nothing happened till everyone woke up to the fact that Pune’s traffic situation had deteriorated abysmally.

Well aware of the traffic problems, Kalmadi and senior NCP leader Ajit Pawar once again revived the Metro proposal in 2007, and again in 2012 when Pune was preparing for the civic polls. In the hope that promises made by the ruling parties would turn to reality, citizens once again elected the Congress-NCP to power in the civic body. On the ground, however, not much happened for the next five years till the BJP came to power at the Centre in 2014.

Just when things were looking up for the Metro in 2012, the entire issue was stalled over the question of whether it should be underground or elevated. While a section of politicians wanted it to be elevated, another section led by former MP, Anil Shirole and some environmentalists pushed for the underground route.

Over the last decade, the Metro has been presented as a panacea to the acute traffic problems of Pune. Traffic experts and citizen activists are cagey about the claim. While metro rail is certainly an affordable and speedy mode of urban mass transportation, experts say it can be successful only if the network is widespread, covering the most populous parts of the city. Currently work is underway only for three lines, two of which have reached an advanced stage and third – Hinjewadi to Shivajinagar still to gather momentum.

The two or three lines of the Metro may not be enough for a city like Pune where the population is over 50 lakhs. Also, the Metro and bus networks have to be well-synchronized to make them successful.

Lawless, chaotic traffic in the absence of a strong public transport system has been the bane of Pune and the guardians of the city have neglected this issue over the past decades. The citizens no longer trust the promises made by the politicians and therefore ask, “Will the Metro ever see the light of the day?”

As per the plan, two corridors are being developed by Maha-Metro, the state government company which will oversee Pune’s metro rail project. The rail network will cover a total distance of 31 kilometres (a 16-km stretch from Pimpri to Swargate and another from Vanaz to Ramwadi at an estimated cost of 11,420 crore. Recently, the Pune Metropolitan Regional Development Authority (PMRDA) proposed another route on the Metro map from Hinjewadi to Shivajinagar, which will be 23 kilometres in length, estimated to cost 7,947 crore.

Originally, all three lines were projected to become operational by 2021. However, as of now, only two priority stretches on two lines (each around 3km long) may start before elections. The current delay is not just increasing the cost of the project but also prolonging current woes being faced by citizens.

The conscientious citizens of Pune will now need to keep watch targets set by Maha-Metro for the completion of the various stages of the Pune Metro project. From here on, the citizenry needs to know whether the project is moving on time or will suffer more delays, as has happened in the past.

Those enjoying power, be it in the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC), state or Centre, need to be put under the watchful eyes of Punekars.

Yogesh Joshi can be contacted at

Sign on to read the HT ePaper

News Related


'I love Ryan as a character' - Praise for Irish international after match-winning display

© Alamy Stock Photo Ryan Manning r of Swansea City celebrates after scoring. SWANSEA HEAD coach Russell Martin hailed the character of match-winner Ryan Manning after the wing-back’s super strike ... Read more »

Ukrainisches Aussenministerium beruft deutsche Botschafterin ein

© Keystone/ZB/Bernd Wüstneck Vor dem Hintergrund des Ukraine-Konflikts hat ein führender deutscher Militär mit Aussagen zu Russland für Irritation gesorgt. Der Vizeadmiral und Chef der Deutschen Marine, Kay-Achim Schönbach, äusserte ... Read more »

How misidentifying an Asian man led to a false murder conviction and a movement

Nearly 50 years after a Korean immigrant was wrongfully convicted of a gangland murder in San Francisco’s Chinatown, longtime journalists Julie Ha and Eugene Yi have joined forces as co-directors ... Read more »

Video Shows Staff Pinning Teen Down for 30 Mins in Cell Before He Died

© Provided by The Daily Beast YouTube/Sedgwick County Communications Footage released late Friday by authorities in Sedgwick County, Kansas shows employees of a county juvenile center holding a 17-year-old boy ... Read more »

German navy chief Schönbach resigns over comments on Putin, Crimea

© Provided by DW Vice-admiral Kay-Achim Schönbach said the West could give Vladimir Putin respect Germany faced a diplomatic incident on Saturday following comments made by Navy chief Kay-Achim Schönbach ... Read more »

Mahatma's favourite hymn ‘Abide With Me' dropped from Beating Retreat

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Mahatma Gandhi’s favourite hymn ‘Abide with Me’ has been dropped from the Beating Retreat ceremony on January 29 this year, in ... Read more »

Flats for Punjab, Haryana officials: Chandigarh admn may shelve project

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Chandigarh Housing Board has already finalised the architectural plans for the project, which is to come up on 6.73 acres at IT Park. (HT FIle Photo) ... Read more »

The best baby gifts: From practical items to beautiful pieces that will be treasured forever

Whether you’re looking for a baby shower gift, a special something to celebrate bub’s arrival or perhaps an item for a Christening, if you’re stuck for a gift idea for ... Read more »

How we reconcile reality TV stars' alleged moral transgressions

© Provided by ABC NEWS Jerry Harris was a breakout star of Netflix’s docuseries Cheer, before being arrested by the FBI. (Getty images: Jim Spellman) The downfall of a protagonist is ... Read more »

Ana de Armas' Fans File Lawsuit After She Was Cut From 'Yesterday'

© Provided by US Weekly Ana de Armas’ Fans File Lawsuit After She Was Cut from ‘Yesterday’ After Appearing in Trailer Not pleased. After a pair of fans rented Yesterday, expecting ... Read more »

Punjab polls: 43% voters in Mohali below the age of 40

With the Punjab assembly elections scheduled on February 20, a look at the demographic profile of Mohali district, which comprises three assembly seats – Mohali, Kharar, and Dera Bassi, shows ... Read more »

Residents in a troubled group of Palmerston rental properties were warned to evacuate if a cyclone struck

© Provided by ABC Business Lori Montgomery moved into one of the properties in 2017. (ABC News: Michael Franchi) Families living in a group of troubled affordable rentals in Greater ... Read more »

Andy Cohen and Ralph Fiennes debate over a popular children's book

He is well-known for having extended conversations with various celebrities on his talk show, Watch What Happens Live! And on Friday, Andy Cohen showed that he was able to connect ... Read more »

‘Looting-While-Moving' Apex Legends Console Trick Explained

PC players in Apex Legends have long had the luxury of being able to loot death boxes while moving, whereas console players have a harder time performing such a technique. ... Read more »

Fnatic run down Misfits, join Rogue as only undefeated teams after 2022 LEC Spring Split Week 2

© Provided by Dot Esports Once more, Fnatic overcame a major obstacle in their start to the 2022 LEC Spring Split—and in doing so, become one of two teams to ... Read more »

Teck Resources announces new contract with union at British Columbia mine

(Reuters) – Canadian miner Teck Resources Ltd said on Saturday that members of a union representing 1,048 workers at its British Columbia mine have ratified a new five-year collective agreement. ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas 'want more kids'

© Bang Showbiz Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas want more children Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas hope to have “at least two children”. The 39-year-old actress recently announced the arrival ... Read more »

Ex-Yankee Sergio Mitre convicted of murdering child, sentenced to 50 years in prison

Sergio Mitre, who pitched in parts of eight major league seasons and won a World Series ring with the 2009 Yankees, likely will spend the rest of his life in ... Read more »

Look: Aaron Rodgers Shares Honest Admission Before Packers-49ers Game

© Provided by The Spun Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers. It’s no secret that before this season, Aaron Rodgers was always a bit more reserved. He never said too ... Read more »

Joe Burrow's speech before Bengals vs. Titans had team fired up and went viral

© Provided by Bengals Wire The Cincinnati Bengals have plenty of confidence going into the divisonal round against the Tennessee Titans. Joe Burrow and Co., after all, conquered a 31-year drought ... Read more »

Steven Gerrard told to complete Aston Villa transfer for Champions League midfielder

Aston Villa are reportedly interested in signing Juventus midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur. Steven Gerrard is keen to strengthen his squad before the January transfer window slams shut in nine days’ time. ... Read more »

Cincinnati Bengals inactive players vs. Tennessee Titans in playoffs

© File photo Jan 15, 2022; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals free safety Jessie Bates (30) celebrates during the fourth quarter in an AFC Wild Card playoff football game against ... Read more »

Pep Guardiola says Man City were excellent but title race is far from over

Pep Guardiola said that Manchester City’s draw at Southampton was a timely reminder that the Premier League title race is far from over. The Blues took a point on the ... Read more »

NFL picks, divisional round: Chiefs get a slight edge over Bills per the 'experts'

© Provided by Bills Wire The Buffalo Bills’ visit to Kansas City to face the Chiefs in the AFC divisional round is a tough one to pick. Even the so-called ... Read more »

Ireland's advertising watchdog aware of 'increasing concern' over misleading cryptocurrency ads

© Shutterstock Coyz0 IRELAND’S ADVERTISING STANDARDS watchdog says it is monitoring developments in other countries after British authorities unveiled new regulations aimed at curbing misleading advertising for cryptocurrencies this week. ... Read more »

Lily James revelled in the 'passion' of Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee

© Bang Showbiz Lily James shot intimate scenes for the drama series Lily James wanted to revel in the “passion” of Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee’s romance in ‘Pam & ... Read more »

Poodle 'identified' as Keane star on The Masked Singer by fans after Christmas clue

Poodle is singer Tom Chaplin, according to fans of ITV‘s The Masked Singer UK 2022. In the latest episode of series three, Poodle dropped a series of new clues and ... Read more »

Hawks seize drugs worth R1.2m in Beaufort West, suspect arrested

© Provided by SowetanLive Zinzi Hani, spokesperson for the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, said the consignment was destined for Cape Town. Hani said the bust was a joint operation ... Read more »

Where would the Texans' Davis Mills rank in re-draft of 2021 rookie quarterbacks?

© Provided by Texans Wire Where would Texans’ Davis Mills rank in re-draft of 2021 rookie QBs? Davis Mills provided some optimism for Houston Texans fans in the final five ... Read more »

‘Some bonds are eternal': Sussanne Khan meets ex-husband Hrithik Roshan on his sister Sunaina's birthday

Actor Hrithik Roshan’s sister Sunaina Roshan turned a year older on Sunday, January 23. On the special occasion, the Krrish actor’s ex-wife Sussanne Khan reunited with Hrithik to celebrate the ... Read more »

Goldie Hawn: I'm happy to stay in my lane

© Bang Showbiz Goldie Hawn won’t discuss politics in public Goldie Hawn is happy to “stay in [her] lane”. The 76-year-old actress has made a concerted effort to avoid speaking ... Read more »

Titans Will Be Without 5 Players vs. Bengals Today

© Provided by The Spun Tennessee Titans head coach Mike Vrabel. The Tennessee Titans may have gotten a huge piece back, but they’ll also be without a number of players ... Read more »

Hundreds detained in Kazakhstan in wake of violent unrest

© Pavel Mikheyev, Reuters Kazakhstan said Saturday it was holding more than 460 people on terrorism and disorder charges in the wake of mass unrest that saw Russian-led forces called ... Read more »

Arkansas righty Peyton Pallette, potential first-round pick in 2022 MLB draft, to undergo Tommy John surgery

© Provided by CBS Sports University of Arkansas right-hander Peyton Pallette will miss the 2022 college baseball season with an elbow ligament injury that will require Tommy John surgery, reports ... Read more »

Masked Singer fans baffled as they don't recognise the celebrity after Poodle is revealed

THE Masked Singer fans were shocked tonight as Poodle was revealed to be Tom Chaplin – the lead singer of Keane. The star managed to make it through the whole ... Read more »

Nick Saban, Alabama Staff Attend Arch Manning’s HS Basketball Game

© Provided by Sports Illustrated College football staffs have flocked to New Orleans to watch the five-star quarterback recruit, but not just to see his skills on the football field. ... Read more »

New Call of Duty: Warzone bug gives the shooter the look of an N64 game

© Provided by GamePur When it comes to Call of Duty: Warzone and bugs, there seems to be a never-ending connection, and unfortunately, today is no different. The latest offender ... Read more »

TrueGameData Reveals 'Secret OP' BAR and Type 100 Warzone Weapon Loadout

For those who aren’t the greatest fans of the Bren, Cooper Carbine, STG44, or the MP-40, but still want to use a top-tier weapon loadout in Warzone, look no further. ... Read more »

Morten Steenstrup elected as the new leader of the Oslo Conservatives

Former parliamentary representative Morten Steenstrup has been elected as the leader of the Oslo Conservatives, the newspaper Avisa Oslo reports. Merete Agerbak-Jensen was chosen as the deputy leader. Steenstrup was ... Read more »

US embassy families to evacuate Ukraine as Russia tensions rise: report

The State Department is planning to order families of US embassy personnel in Ukraine to evacuate the country. REUTERS/Gleb Garanich Families of US embassy personnel in Ukraine will be ordered ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic