MN's virtual court hearings aren't going away. Review finds advantages -- and drawbacks.

Asia's Tech News Daily

Oct. 24—Using video technology to conduct hearings“>court hearings has its drawbacks. Participants can sometimes show up shirtless, smoking, driving and with children screaming in the background.

Some talk back to the judge or swear, out of reach of a bailiff's rebuke. Judges waste time waiting for technical issues to be worked out, and victims sometimes feel cheated out of facing an offender in person.

“I think we need to be careful about what happens to the rules of decorum,” Judge Stoney Hiljus, of the Minnesota 10th Judicial District, said in a recent judicial council meeting. “Because, quite frankly, I deal with more issues of decorum on Zoom. At what point, especially in a criminal context, if I decide that a defendant is so unruly that I'm going to remove them or mute them in a Zoom hearing — when does that have constitutional ramifications?”

Since the pandemic prompted Minnesota courts to find ways to conduct proceedings without meeting in person, judicial officials have gained experience with using video conferencing. Now, the state is beginning to work out a framework of what court hearings might look like when all pandemic restrictions are gone.

ZOOM IS HERE TO STAY

The findings show that virtual hearings — generally conducted using the Zoom app — have their place and will not be going away entirely.

In September, the Minnesota Judicial Council Committee, composed of 25 members, many of them judges, voted to phase in a structure that would decide when a court could meet in person and when it could meet remotely.

The vote was based on the findings of a work group dubbed “The Other Side” that compiled feedback from all areas of the court in a six-month period.

For non-criminal cases, the council voted that hearings where evidence is being presented or testimony is taken must be held in person.

For non-criminal cases that don't involve evidentiary hearings, those may be held remotely.

WHAT ABOUT A JUDGE'S DISCRETION?

The ruling allows for case-by-case exceptions under extenuating circumstances — and that has been the sticking point. What exactly constitutes an extenuating circumstance?

Some judges want the choice to be up to them.

“This was raised by multiple judges in our district,” said state Supreme Court Associate Justice G. Barry Anderson. “We want to retain that discretion with the judge.”

That motion was overruled because the council felt there would be no reason to provide guidance if judges were left to their own discretion, and that this freedom might create a “nightmare” in terms of implementation.

WHEN IT WORKS AND WHEN IT DOESN'T

The work group found that holding hearings remotely worked well in family court because attendance was more reliable. Parents didn't need to get baby-sitters or rearrange their lives to be at the courthouse. They simply had to pick up their phones.

Sometimes Zoom worked better for order-for-protection hearings because the victim felt safer, not having to worry about seeing their abuser in court.

Other times, however, in-person worked better because of the contentious nature of the hearings. Everyone could be in the same room and could air their differences with a judge and bailiff present instead of talking over each other online or miring the process with multiple text messages to representatives.

Any kind of trial that required showing evidence or hearing testimony did not work well remotely, the group found.

CRIMINAL HEARINGS ARE A DIFFERENT BREED

Jeanette Boelter, mother of 21-year-old Anthony Boelter, this month attended two sentencings for the men who shot and killed her son. The first one was in person and the second was remote.

For her, confronting her son's killer was overwhelming emotionally. She sobbed through her victim impact statement and tried not to look at the defendant. The sentencing for the second man was somewhat easier for her.

“I felt more secure,” she said. “I got to have my dog on my lap. Also, I liked being able to turn the camera on and off.”

Family members who lost a pregnant relative were more angry than sad at Clinton Roosevelt Delaney's murder sentencing in September. They objected to Delaney appearing remotely on a screen in the courtroom, and said they felt cheated out of being able to face him in person.

Although most hearings are public, when testimony is shared, unless it's a high-profile case, most of the people in the courtroom are known to the parties. On Zoom, some have expressed the awkwardness of talking about private anxieties knowing multiple other people not related to the case are listening in as they wait for their time with the judge.

A recent rape victim in Ramsey County District Court peered into the camera wondering who all those other people were as she stammered out an excruciatingly difficult victim impact statement.

THE UPSIDE, WITH A CAVEAT

For judges covering multiple counties, Zoom hearings have been a blessing. No more wasting an entire day driving from courthouse to courthouse. Multiple cases can be seen in one day, a perk now with courts digging out from pandemic backlogs.

Last week, the council met again, but made no further decisions on how hearings will be held post-pandemic, planning instead to adjust its framework on a month-by-month basis depending on the level of virus cases in the state.

This hesitation concerns some who think the council is rushing to make future decisions in an uncertain present.

“It's real important that this not be a permanent change to the functioning of the trial courts,” said 10th District Chief Judge John Hoffman. “All this exists because of COVID. I think we're doing this under a public health emergency and until that public health emergency has resolved itself, then, I think we should make permanent decisions about how the trial courts function.”

The council's vice-chair, 7th District Judge Michelle Lawson, disagreed, saying now is the time to prepare for post-pandemic proceedings.

“What's being recommended is the framework for getting there … with an eye toward not doing this because of a public emergency,” Lawson said. “We're doing this because it serves our public, it works well with our court operations, and it's really valuable lessons that we learned during the pandemic.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Atrangi Re song Chaka Chak: Don't miss Sara Ali Khan's dance moves to A.R Rahman's catchy tune! - Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Anand L Rai’s Atrangi Re’s first song ‘Chaka Chak’ is finally out on YouTube and is already winning the hearts of fans. Sung ... Read more »

Kanye West dedicates Sunday Service to late friend Virgil Abloh

© Bang Showbiz Kanye West dedicates Sunday Service to Virgil Abloh Kanye West dedicated his Sunday Service to his late friend and longtime collaborator, Virgil Abloh. The influential fashion designer ... Read more »

BTS concert: Jin turns up in a Squid Game doll inspired ponytail; ARMY has a swell time playing 'red light green light' with him – view tweets

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com And just like that the Day 2 of Permission To Dance on Stage has come to an end. Today Megan Thee Stallion performed at the concert ... Read more »

Weekly Tarot Card Readings: Horoscope from November 29 to December 5, 2021

© Provided by Zee News Aries It appears that things are not going perfect in your love life at the moment. Insecurities, lack of trust or deceit might affect your ... Read more »

Lady Gaga hails Tony Bennett's wife Susan 'remarkable'

© Bang Showbiz Lady Gaga hails Tony Bennett’s wife ‘remarkable’ Lady Gaga has heaped praise on Tony Bennett’s “remarkable wife” Susan for “the love” she has for her husband. The ... Read more »

Anil Bishnoi to debut in Bollywood with Abbas-Mustan thriller based on 'Money Heist'

© IANS Anil Bishnoi. Mumbai, Nov 29 (IANS) TV actor Anil Bishnoi is excited to join upcoming Bollywood movie ‘Three Monkeys’ directed by Abbas-Mustan which is based on the hit ... Read more »

Greenpeace: half a century on the frontline of environmental photo activism

Fifty years ago, on 15 September 1971, a ship named the Greenpeace set out to confront and stop US nuclear weapons testing at Amchitka, one of the Aleutian Islands in ... Read more »

Mob attacks Pakistan police, fail to grab blasphemy suspect

PESHAWAR, Pakistan — A Muslim mob burned a police station and four police posts overnight in northwest Pakistan after officers refused to hand over a mentally unstable man accused of ... Read more »

Food, gas prices pinch families as inflation surges globally

The Associated PressFILE – A Black Friday shopper wearing a face mask leaves a Walmart store with a TV in Pic Rivera Calif., Friday, Nov. 26, 2021. From appliance stores ... Read more »

British pubgoers trapped in bar with Oasis cover band amid blizzard

British fans of an Oasis tribute band spent the weekend confined to a remote Yorkshire pub with the group when a mountain of snow trapped them all in the bar. ... Read more »

'Pressure is a privilege' for Ireland's US-born striker and Danish club's captain

© Laszlo Geczo INPHO Kyra Carusa was a second-half substitute against Slovakia on Thursday night. WITH THE HUNT on for a winner down the home straight of the Republic of ... Read more »

Japan to bar foreign visitors after Omicron threat

© Provided by Al Jazeera Japan’s borders have been almost entirely shut to new overseas visitors for most of the pandemic [File: Issei Kato/Reuters] Japan announced it will reinstate tough ... Read more »

Macrotech plummets 10% after realty firm unveils plans to enter Bengaluru market

NEW DELHI: Shares of Macrotech Developers plunged close to 10 per cent in early trade as investors were not enthused with the company’s plan to enter the Bengaluru market and ... Read more »

IndusInd Bank gains 4% as RBI's new pvt lender norms pave way for Hindujas to up stake

NEW DELHI: Shares of IndusInd Bank rose 4 per cent in early trade on Monday as investors welcomed the Reserve Bank of India’s recent decision to permit promoter holding of ... Read more »

Ties that bind: Missouri Senate candidate hopes Trump notices neckwear

Photograph: Nathan Papes/AP Congressman Billy Long seeks Trump’s endorsement for ‘the guy that was with you from day one. I mean, look at this tie’ Senate candidates endorsed by Donald ... Read more »

What Trying To ‘Look Expensive' On TikTok Says About Us

“Okay I’m gonna tell you why your basic outfit is super boring and it’s not working for you,” says Maddison Collinge, a 25-year-old influencer from Michigan. She’s speaking on a ... Read more »

Commemoration Day: Sacrifices of the martyrs will remain indelible in conscience of our nation, says UAE President

© Provided by Khaleej Times UAE President His Highness Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan On the occasion of the Commemoration Day, President His Highness Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al ... Read more »

Abu Dhabi event of global Muslim council postponed as precaution due to Omicron strain

© VB Abu Dhabi is adopting strong measures to curb the spread of coronavirus. Victor Besa / The National The World Muslim Communities Council conference, which was due to be ... Read more »

Abu Dhabi acquires new antibody treatment to fight Covid-19

© Victor O. Besa Dr Jamal Al Kaabi, undersecretary of the Department of Health – Abu Dhabi, said the new drug would further equip the emirate to protect its population. ... Read more »

'Saya mahu beri kejutan kepada ibu dan nenek'

© Provided by Sinar Harian JOHOR BAHRU – Selepas hampir setahun berada di Singapura, seorang pengurus operasi gembira kerana dapat pulang bertemu keluarganya di Nusajaya menerusi Laluan Perjalanan Lengkap Vaksin-Laluan ... Read more »

Best Cyber Monday deals on DSLR cameras include Nikon D5600, Canon EOS 4000D

Black Friday may be over but deals on your favourite gadgets and electronics have not stopped pouring in. That is because it is Cyber Monday and there is a wide ... Read more »

Delhi Air Pollution: SC raps NCR govts over rising AQI amid COVID-19, questions Centre over Central Vista project

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: The Supreme Court on Monday once again slammed the Centre and Delhi-NCR governments over the rising pollution levels in ... Read more »

Bailable warrant cancelled against Param Bir Singh, asked to deposit r₹r15k in CM relief fund

© Provided by Hindustan Times File photo of former Mumbai police commissioner Param Bir Singh. (HT_PRINT) The commission investigating corruption allegations against former Maharashtra home minister Anil Deshmukh on Monday ... Read more »

‘Visionary' designer Virgil Abloh dies at 41, two days before Louis Vuitton fashion show

© Provided by Lifestyle Asia Virgil Abloh, founder of streetwear label Off-White and designer of menswear at Louis Vuitton, has died. He was 41. The news was announced through a ... Read more »

News18 Afternoon Digest: Singapore, Malaysia Ease Covid Curbs At Busy Border Crossing & Other Top Stories

© Provided by News18 News18 Afternoon Digest: Singapore, Malaysia Ease Covid Curbs At Busy Border Crossing & Other Top Stories Singapore, Malaysia Ease Covid Curbs At Busy Border Crossing Singapore ... Read more »

You Can Now Rent Lake Como Villa From ‘House of Gucci' on Airbnb

© Provided by News18 You Can Now Rent Lake Como Villa From ‘House of Gucci’ on Airbnb If you have watched Ridley Scott’s latest film House of Gucci, you may ... Read more »

Delhi on alert as Sikh for Justice threatens to gherao Parliament, hoist Khalistani flag

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: An alert has been issued in the national capital after an intelligence input stating that the banned terrorist organization Sikh ... Read more »

Royal Family: Prince Charles denies making comment about skin tone of Meghan Markle's baby

Prince Charles has denied speculation about the skin tone of Meghan Markle’s baby following allegations in a new book. A “well-placed source” claimed Charles made the comments in a conversation ... Read more »

Nurdles: the worst toxic waste you've probably never heard of

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Chamila Karunarathne/EPA When the X-Press Pearl container ship caught fire and sank in the Indian Ocean in May, Sri Lanka was terrified that the ... Read more »

Solomon Islands province 'not happy' at Australian police presence - political aide

© Reuters/JONE TUIIPELEHAKI Protests turn violent in Solomon Islands By Kirsty Needham SYDNEY (Reuters) – The Solomon Islands most populous province, the source of anti-government protestors who converged on the ... Read more »

DOH: All regions at low, minimal risk case classification for COVID-19

DOH Building All regions in the Philippines are now at low and minimal risk case classification for COVID-19, the Department of Health (DOH) announced Monday. At a media briefing, Health ... Read more »

Fishmongers' Hall victims continue to inspire two years on, says Sadiq Khan

© PA Media Incident on London Bridge People continue to draw inspiration and hope from Jack Merritt and Saskia Jones two years after they were killed in a terror attack, ... Read more »

French economic growth is solid, says finance minister despite new COVID wave

© Reuters/GONZALO FUENTES FILE PHOTO: French Economy and Finance Minister Le Maire presents government 2022 budget in Paris PARIS (Reuters) – French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire sees no risk ... Read more »

Omicron Variant: What Is It And How It Can Affect Children And The Elderly

© Provided by The Asian Parent Singapore may have to “take a few steps back” with its reopening plans according to Prime Minister Hsien Loong. This news has come after ... Read more »

The fashion world pays tribute to Virgil Abloh: 'A once in a generation creative mind'

© Charles Platiau Louis Vuitton and Off-White designer Designer Virgil Abloh. Photo: Reuters The world of fashion lost a great this week, following the death of Louis Vuitton and Off-White ... Read more »

Ranveer Singh shares what Kapil Dev's mom always told him, announces 83 trailer update

Ranveer Singh (R) plays the role of Kapil Dev (L) in 83. Ranveer Singh shared an exciting new update about his upcoming film, 83. Sharing a new poster of the ... Read more »

Shop Selena Gomez's Rainbow Knives From 'Selena + Chef' at Amazon's Cyber Monday Sale

© HBO Max Each product has been independently selected by our editorial team. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability ... Read more »

Satyameva Jayate 2 lags behind Antim after first weekend. Box Office Collection Update

Satyameva Jayate sees a decline at the box office. The last weekend saw two huge releases in Bollywood. John Abraham-starrer Satyamave Jayate 2 and Salman Khan’s Antim: The Final Truth ... Read more »

Dollar Seshadri, Senior Priest and Officer on Special Duty at Tirupati Temple, Dies of Cardiac Arrest at 74

© Provided by News18 Dollar Seshadri, Senior Priest and Officer on Special Duty at Tirupati Temple, Dies of Cardiac Arrest at 74 Pala Seshadri, popularly known as Dollar Seshadri, who ... Read more »

'A heavy burden on lives': WHO criticises travel bans over Omicron variant

© Provided by Hindustan Times Since the discovery of the Omicron variant, several countries have imposed travel bans on the affected region in southern Africa. (Reuters Photo) The World Health ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic