'Miss Universe boycott is unconstitutional,' says civil organisation as it heads to court

Asia's Tech News Daily

'Miss Universe boycott is unconstitutional,' says civil organisation as it heads to court
© Provided by Times Live

Citizens for Integrity cited a violation of several human rights and laws in its case against the government, the minister of justice and correctional services and the minister of sports, arts and culture.

Numerous protests and attempts to have Miss SA Lalela Mswane withdraw from the Miss Universe pageant have been unsuccessful.

“Miss SA pageant is a franchisee of the Miss Universe pageant and selects its winner via local and national competitions. The winner of the national pageant has the right to compete in the Miss Universe competition.

“The Miss SA franchise is wholly private and receives no state funding,” said the organisation in court papers.

There were also efforts to have Miss SA withdraw from the competition by minister Nathi Mthethwa, who said: “It has proven difficult to persuade the Miss SA pageant organisers to reconsider their decision to partake in the Miss Universe event scheduled to be held in Israel during the month of December 2021.

“What during initial consultations appeared like engaging, constructive and progressive discussions, was later met with an unpleasant demeanour that is intransigent and lacking appreciation of the potential negative effect of such a decision on the reputation and future of a young black woman.”

The Palestine Solidarity Alliance has accused recently crowned Mswane of not caring about the plight of Palestinians and being “worried about her own self gains”.

The alliance claimed “after weeks of trying to engage with Mswane, with regards to the plight of the Palestinian people, she has decided to block” both bodies.

Through their lawyers, ES Kgaka Attorneys, Citizens for Integrity argues that this push for Mswane to withdraw deprives citizens of their enjoyment of their freedom of expression and right of association.

“By publicly binding itself to this wrongful conduct, the government has placed itself firmly in the position of activity including and participating in an unlawful boycott and has rendered its citizens supporting Miss SA’s right to ply her trade open to infringement of their bodily integrity by violence, whether physical or by way of bullying by those supporting this unconstitutional decision,” said Citizens for Integrity.

It added that participating in the boycott activity and opened the way to potential international sanctions being imposed on SA and its trading entities.

Department of justice and correctional services spokesperson Crispin Phiri said they noted the application “and we will respond accordingly in the correct forum”.

Citizens for Integrity said the departments’ conduct constitutes an unconstitutional interference in a non-political, worldwide, cultural event that does not fall within the government’s legitimate objectives. Its actions further service to discriminate against its citizen’s freedom of choice.

“In terms of Section 18 of the constitution, Miss SA has the right to freedom of association. Her participation in a Miss Universe pageant in a country with which SA has diplomatic relations clearly falls within this category.

“Similarly, in terms of Section 22 of the constitution, the Miss SA pageant and Miss SA have the right to choose their occupation freely and in exercising this legitimate right to participate in beauty pageants worldwide has not been regulated,” said the organisation.

They say the following constitutional rights have also been violated:

  • In terms of section 9, the right to equal protection and enjoyment of rights and freedoms of the law and the right not to have the state unfairly discriminate against Miss SA pageant and Miss SA
  • In terms of section 10, the right to have dignity respected and protected
  • In terms of section 22 the right to freedom of occupation without undue interference
  • In terms of section 23 the right to fair labour practices
  • In terms of section 30 the right to participate in the choice of their culture 
  • And other rights have been violated.

“The mere fact that agents of the government approached Miss SA and attempted to coerce her to give up a legitimate and also the hugest event of her career is unconscionable, and disgraceful by all normal standards of governance.

“It constitutes a standard of undue administrative procedure where without regard to the rule of law the government has bullied its subjects and acted as judge and jury in the matter, imposing its own irrational decision upon them,” the organisation said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


FIFA 22 Ultimate Team: Leaks reveal Mohamed Salah excluded from FUT TOTY squad

Many in the gaming community are preparing for FIFA 22 Ultimate Team to release the Team Of The Year (TOTY) squad, but some may be sad to hear that leaks ... Read more »

Brighton promote David Weir to assistant technical director

© PA Archive David Weir joined the Seagulls in April 2018 (Andrew Milligan/PA) – PA Archive Brighton have promoted David Weir to the role of assistant technical director, working alongside ... Read more »

Slovakia imposes COVID restrictions to get ready for omicron

FILE – A teacher gives on-line lessons via webcam at the temporarily closed elementary school in the town of Trebisov, eastern Slovakia, Nov. 8, 2021. On Wednesday Jan. 19. 2022 ... Read more »

Paris unveils 'manifesto for beauty' to recapture lost charm after criticism

© Christophe Ena, AP Paris city authorities unveiled a “manifesto for beauty” on Tuesday containing plans to spruce up the City of Lights where an online campaign highlighting ugliness and ... Read more »

Barcelona facing €130m transfer battle with over key midfielder

Chelsea are ready to take advantage of Barcelona’s ongoing financial troubles and make a move for three of Xavi Hernandez’s players. Roman Abramovich is keen to help Thomas Tuchel strengthen ... Read more »

Rangnick 'believes Maguire, Shaw AND Wan-Bissaka are not good enough'

Ralf Rangnick has reportedly told the hierarchy at Manchester United that Harry Maguire, Luke Shaw and Aaron Wan-Bissaka are not good enough for the club. The German – who has ... Read more »

Texas synagogue hostage crisis: Scapegoating Jews will continue to lead to bloodshed

All the victims are safe, thank goodness. But downplaying antisemitism will lead to further tragedy. Jews in America might not be so lucky next time. Read more »

UAE reports 2,902 Covid-19 cases as tests top 500,000 for first time

© Provided by The National A nurse collects a sample at the Covid-19 drive-through testing station at NMC Hospital, Dubai Investments Park, Dubai. Chris Whiteoak / The National Live updates: ... Read more »

Luxury fashion house Gucci under fire for using real tigers in ad campaign ahead of Chinese New Year

© Provided by Business Insider Gucci has come under fire for using a real tiger in an ad campaign. Chukrut Budrul/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images. Animal rights groups have called out Gucci ... Read more »

Restrictions may lift ‘widely and quickly', says Eamon Ryan

© Brian Lawless Green Party leader Eamon Ryan (Brian Lawless/PA) Covid-19 restrictions may be lifted from the end of next week, a senior Irish Cabinet minister has said. Green Party ... Read more »

Dani Alves opens up on "strange" feeling at Barcelona and sends message to Lionel Messi

Dani Alves has called on Lionel Messi to return to Barcelona and finish his career at the Camp Nou. Things have not gone to plan for the Argentine since his ... Read more »

Marcos Jr., Sara eye Badjaos as sea patrollers

© Gerry Gorit Badjaos or sea gypsies scour the waters off Cagayan de Oro City on Thursday, December 19, for coins tossed by people on board ships. The number of ... Read more »

Palace wants additional labs for faster release of RT-PCR test results

© Ferdinandh Cabrera A locally stranded individual (LSI) from the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) who was among those rerouted to Cagayan de Oro City is subjected to ... Read more »

Winter Olympics athletes warned they will be under 'Orwellian surveillance' in Beijing

Athletes set to compete in the upcoming Winter Olympic Games in Beijing next month have been warned they will be exposed to ‘Orwellian’ surveillance by the Chinese state. The report ... Read more »

Burberry predicts 35% rise in annual profits backed by Asia sales

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Wallace Woon/EPA Burberry is forecasting that full-year profits will grow 35% compared with last year, as strong sales of its luxury clothing and bags ... Read more »

Kepa demands ‘frustrated' Chelsea step up in Tottenham derby clash: ‘We have to get back to winning ways'

Kepa Arrizabalaga has laid bare the fears inside Chelsea after their miserable slump continued at Brighton last night. A 1-1 draw at the Amex was a fourth Premier League game ... Read more »

Snapchat is making it harder for children to buy drugs on its app

© Getty Images iStock-1009995676.jpg Snap is making it harder for children to buy drugs on the app with a series of changes to its social media app. The company said ... Read more »

Indian couple to marry in metaverse with 'ghost' of bride's father

An Indian couple are set to marry in the virtual reality ‘metaverse’ in a Harry Potter-themed wedding – with the ‘ghost’ of the bride’s dead father in attendance. Dinesh Sivakumar ... Read more »

Auf 750 Exemplare limitiert - Porsche 911 Edition 50 Jahre Porsche Design

Der Design-Arm von Porsche wird 50 Jahre alt. Die Autoabteilung gratuliert mit einem 911 Targa 4 GTS-Sondermodell, von dem nur 750 Exemplare aufgelegt werden. © Porsche Ferdinand Alexander Porsche gestaltete ... Read more »

"Stop Pimping Uncle Waffles"- Nota Baloyi

South African rapper and music mogul Nota Baloyi, has reacted to the news that Uncle Waffles was apparently offered R500K in exchange for sex. This was revealed in the recent ... Read more »

Free things to do and see in Singapore in January and February

They say the best things in life are free, and it truly is with the fun activities happening in Singapore right now! Here’s a highlight of what you can do ... Read more »

You still here? One player per club we thought had left ages ago

Some teams have so few players these days they can’t even play football matches. And yet at every club – almost, anyway – there are still players knocking about you ... Read more »

Chelsea could ‘destroy' Barcelona by signing €130m trio

© PA Images Roman Abramovich smiles during a meeting with Russia’s prime minister Mikhail Mishustin Chelsea owner Roman Abramovich wants to sign Frenkie de Jong, Gavi and Sergino Dest from Barcelona, ... Read more »

Vaani Kapoor reveals best thing about acting, says 'want my journey in cinema to be filled with varied films'

© Provided by Pinkvilla Actress Vaani Kapoor, who recently essayed a trans woman in ‘Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui’, is consciously working on shaping up her filmography by choosing scripts and characters ... Read more »

Did Dhanush refuse to meet Rajinikanth for trying to make amends with Aishwaryaa?

© Provided by Pinkvilla It is now known fact that Dhanush has parted ways with his wife Aishwaryaa Rajinikanth after 18 years of marriage. The duo announced this shocking news ... Read more »

Duo base jump from a 3,280-foot Italian mountain into a foggy valley

This is the moment a pair of thrill-seeking base jumpers launched themselves from a 1,000-meter high cliff face into a cloudy abyss. Tom Newberry, 32, and Callum Coldwell-Story, filmed themselves ... Read more »

Aquarius to Libra: 4 Zodiac signs who are likely to suffer a heartbreak today

If you have started the day on a positive note and are all excited to complete your daily tasks and make your way into the good books of your boss, ... Read more »

A1 stars in bid for Eurovision 2022

A1 stars Ben Adams and Christian Ingebrigtsen are going head-to-head in a bid to represent Norway at the 2022 ‘Eurovision Song Contest’. © Bang Showbiz A1 stars put forward their bids ... Read more »

The abandoned London Underground station way out in the countryside that you probably never knew existed

Do you know about every hidden abandoned London Underground station there is? Even if you love exploring London’s lost tunnels and stations, we bet there’s a few hidden gems you ... Read more »

Bade Achhe Lagte Hain 2: Ram turns romantic as he shows Priya how to enjoy the rain; RaYa fans can't keep calm – view tweets

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Disha Parmar and Nakuul Mehta starrer Bade Achhe Lagte Hain 2 will see a lot of romantic twists coming up. In the upcoming episode of Bade ... Read more »

NEET UG Counselling 2021: MCC begins registrations process from today at mcc.nic.in

© Provided by Firstpost NEET UG Counselling 2021: MCC begins registrations process from today at mcc.nic.in The online registration process for National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) undergraduate (UG) counselling ... Read more »

Jay Z backs New York law change to stop rap lyrics being ‘weaponised' in court

Jay Z is supporting a proposed law that would block rap lyrics from being used as evidence of alleged crimes in court. According toRolling Stone, rappers Meek Mill, Big Sean, ... Read more »

Scottish fugitive Jamie Stevenson among UK's 12 most wanted men

One of Scotland’s most wanted men has been named in a new appeal to trace 12 UK fugitives believed to be hiding in Spain. The offenders are wanted for crimes ... Read more »

Reschedule Manipur Polls, Tough for Christians to Come to Vote on Sunday: Congress, BJP to EC

© Provided by News18 Reschedule Manipur Polls, Tough for Christians to Come to Vote on Sunday: Congress, BJP to EC After Punjab, political parties are now demanding rescheduling of elections ... Read more »

Delhi: Two arrested for fraudulently withdrawing over Rs 3 lakh from roommate's bank account

Delhi: Two arrested for fraudulently withdrawing over Rs 3 lakh from roommate’s bank account Delhi police claimed to have cracked a cheating case and arrested two persons for fraudulently withdrawing ... Read more »

2022 VCT Stage 1 - Challengers North America: How to Watch

The 2022 Valorant Champions Tour (VCT) Stage 1 – Challengers North America (NA) event is set to kick off the return of the region for the esport. Here’s a breakdown ... Read more »

Epic Esports to host Dota 2 Champions League Season 7 starting Jan. 24

© Provided by Dot Esports Epic Esports Events is capitalizing on the cancelation of Valve’s 2022 Dota Pro Circuit Winter Tour Major and hosting the Winline Dota 2 Champions League ... Read more »

Sony's valuation drops $20 billion in wake of Activision Blizzard acquisition

© Provided by GamePur It didn’t take long for the impact of Microsoft’s surprise acquisition of Activision Blizzard to be felt around the gaming world. When the news broke, it ... Read more »

Covid-19 Public Health Emergency May End If...': WHO's Dr Michael Ryan

© Provided by News18 Covid-19 Public Health Emergency May End If…’: WHO’s Dr Michael Ryan The World Health Organisation (WHO) has said that the public health emergency issued in 2020 ... Read more »

LIVE India vs South Africa 2022 Cricket Score Updates, 1st ODI: Skipper Temba Bavuma-Rassie Van der Dussen Stand Guides South Africa

© Provided by News18 LIVE India vs South Africa 2022 Cricket Score Updates, 1st ODI: Skipper Temba Bavuma-Rassie Van der Dussen Stand Guides South Africa Live Score India vs South ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic