Mike Yardley: Who is to blame for the Christchurch Indoor Stadium shambles?

Mike Yardley: Who is to blame for the Christchurch Indoor Stadium shambles?


If I can be so immodest, New Zealand’s second-largest city is the sporting powerhouse of the nation and Christchurch is still bereft of a half-decent stadium.

That godforsaken piecemeal set up in Addington is the stadium equivalent of a freedom camp. It was only meant to be short-lived but is now a manky, rag-tag overstayer. Positively third world for the sporting capital of New Zealand.

Ten years on from the killer quake, it’s embarrassing that the Christchurch Council is still faffing around with the concept design, arguing the toss over the seating capacity.

$473 million is the capped budget for the new Arena. It’s long been agreed it will be a 30,000-seater venue, of which 5000 seats are movable and temporary. Roll them out, on-demand.

And of course, just like Dunedin’s Forsyth Barr, the Christchurch facility will be enclosed, a tub-thumping cauldron for live sport and entertainment.

But now it transpires, there’s been a last-minute cost blowout. They’re blaming the rocketing costs on materials and shipping. And the budget will only stretch to 25,000 seats. So today, the council convenes to thrash it out.

They should not settle for a substandard seating capacity. It will jeopardise the chance of securing regular tier-one All Blacks Tests – without shovelling out monstrous incentive fees to NZ Rugby.

Who’s to blame for this shambles? Many of those city councillors should look in the mirror.

Many of them despise this stadium – and rugby. They’d far prefer to plough this cash into wider and longer cycleways. The tragedy is the capital costs for this project have continued to grow and fester, while the council dithered.

Eight years ago, Lianne Dalziel and friends sabotaged the project by kicking it into touch for 10 years. They could have got this anchor project built years ago, at half the cost.

This whole saga is amateur hour on a grand scale. Frankly, the surrounding district councils in greater Christchurch should now chip in to boost the capital budget.

This project’s integrity is on the line, without decent seating capacity. Don’t betray the hopes and dreams of Christchurch. Don’t downgrade the stadium.

News Related


Search steps up for missing Clyde teen

More than 72 hours after her disappearance, police last night were no closer to locating missing Central Otago teen Caitlin Blanch. That led to police issuing a second appeal to ... Read more »

'Reign of terror': Man continued to assault girlfriend outside police station

A Dunedin man responsible for a 16-month reign of terror over his girlfriend viciously assaulted her outside a police station, a court has heard. Scott James Wreford Kelly, 38, appeared ... Read more »

Christchurch mum of four dead - police probing final hours, appeal to public for information

The woman who died after suffering severe injuries at a Christchurch property was mother-of-four Heather Foote. Foote, 56, was found with critical injuries at her Port Hills Rd home in ... Read more »

Dunedin footprints mystery solved after police investigation

Police offered support and assistance to a young woman who called emergency services early on Thursday morning over a suspicious pair of footprints, which turned out to be her own. ... Read more »

Operation Hannah: Police targeting vehicles at ski fields after death of Hannah Francis

A new police operation is targeting passenger vehicles in and around ski fields after the tragic death of 11-year-old Hannah Francis in 2018. Hannah was killed when a bus carrying ... Read more »

Fire in roof of house in Woolston, Christchurch

Crews have worked to contain a fire in the roof of a house in Woolston. A Fire and Emergency NZ spokesman said they were called to the blaze on Kotuku ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Five new MIQ cases; WHO patient's mercy dash from Fiji

There are five new Covid cases to report in managed isolation today. Two of the cases tested positive on day 13 of their stay. The pair arrived in the country ... Read more »

Luxury Queenstown wine tour voted best in the world by Tripadvisor

A Queenstown tourism operator has taken out a global award for its winetasting tour – bringing celebration to a region struggling with the lack of international tourists. Altitude Tours’ Queenstown ... Read more »

Missing teen Caitlin Blanch 'possibly travelled outside Alexandra'

Police and Land Search and Rescue volunteers are still searching for a teenage girl from Clyde who hasn’t been seen in more than 48 hours. Caitlin Blanch, 17, left her ... Read more »

Cave mystery and a shipwreck: Ship drawing, names, cannon found at Chalky Inlet

A scientific expedition from Christchurch has found a cave in a remote part of Fiordland where survivors of a shipwreck may have sheltered. The team from Willowbank Wildlife Reserve was ... Read more »

'Extremely lucky to survive': Company fined $275k for poisoning employee

A Rolleston-based pest bait manufacturing organisation has been fined $275,000 after an employee was poisoned and nearly lost his life. Pest Control Research Limited Partnership (PCR) appeared for sentencing in ... Read more »

Teen girl still missing from Alexandra

Police have concerns regarding the whereabouts of an Alexandra teen missing since Tuesday morning. Caitlin, 17, was last reported to be seen getting off her school bus at about 8am. ... Read more »

Tractor tragedy: Family shares precious memories of daughter, grandson

In the wake of the report on the death of Dunback farmer Nadine Thomlinson and her son Angus, the Otago Daily Times’ Alice Scott talks to Nadine’s mother, Ann Restieaux. ... Read more »

Driver in Otago crash that killed 28-year-old Kirsty Moffett avoids jail

The sentence handed to a 49-year-old woman will seem “hopelessly inadequate” to the family of a Northern Irish woman killed in a crash in Central Otago. That was according to ... Read more »

Tokyo Olympics 2020: Wonderful but exhausting journey for Erika Fairweather

Erika Fairweather started her Olympic campaign in lane eight and swam her way into a final with a stunning performance. A day later, she swam in a blusteringly quick semifinal. ... Read more »

Building consents rise 12 per cent in Christchurch, house listings still low

Christchurch is seeing a rapid rise in new house builds. Building consents have been issued for nearly 2800 new dwellings over the past year – up 12 per cent on ... Read more »

Christchurch-based Coupland's Bakeries' mince and cheese pie ranked among NZ's best

Christchurch-based Coupland’s Bakeries’ mince and cheese pie took out a top award at the Bakels NZ Supreme Pie Awards last night. Bakers across the country celebrated at the Hilton Hotel ... Read more »

Otago lead contamination: Do not drink notice lifted after six months

The Dunedin City Council has lifted the “do not drink” notice for water supplies to communities north of the city. The notice was put in place in February following intermittent ... Read more »

Weather: The wettest and sunniest places in NZ for July revealed

Westport was more than likely the wettest place in the country this month but forecasters can’t say for sure because the rain gauge broke during the recent flooding event. MetService ... Read more »

Average 35-day wait in Canterbury for face-to-face youth mental health support

The 35-day average wait time for face-face contact under the Child and Youth Mental Health services in Canterbury has been labelled ”not good enough.” Data released to the Herald under ... Read more »

Eating disorder breakthrough: Govt starts 'work' on desperately needed treatment, service plan

The Government is finally planning “a way forward” for eating disorder services – and while advocates welcome the breakthrough, after begging for years for action, they say if a strategy ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Mum stuck in NSW until September - 'I just want to come home to my babies'

An Otago woman stuck in New South Wales is upset at the lack of communication and her inability to get home to her family. Primary school teacher and mother-of-two Kim ... Read more »

About 80 high-security prisoners to be sent to Otago

A significant number of high security prisoners will be moved to Otago Corrections Facility after the closure of two Christchurch units that are no longer fit for purpose. About 80 ... Read more »

Waitaki Tourism staff subjected to racist online abuse

The Waitaki district tourism board was left with a sour taste after staff appearing in the Sweet Spot marketing campaign were targeted by online abuse. Tourism Waitaki said that staff ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Christchurch vaccine clinics staying open to 10pm as CDHB ramps up roll-out

The ramping up of the Covid-19 vaccine rollout is seeing clinics extend their hours to 10pm in Christchurch. The Canterbury District Health Board estimates vaccinations will increase to 37,000 a ... Read more »

Weather: Some highways still disrupted, thunderstorms possible in south

Heavy rain and strong winds continue to cause disruption on South Island highways this morning. Due to flooding, NZTA is advising motorists to use caution when driving along SH6 Belgrove, ... Read more »

Dunedin man pleads not guilty to rape charges

A Dunedin 21-year-old allegedly raped two women at the same Orientation Week party, a court has heard. Samuel Leigh Ebdell is on trial before the High Court at Dunedin after ... Read more »

Weather: Wild weather batters New Zealand, flood-hit areas in the firing line again

Bursts of thunder and flashes of lightning are keeping the skies over parts of the North Island busy this afternoon – as thunderstorms rattling parts of the South Island track ... Read more »

Reginald Robert Ozanne who killed miniature horse Star to be released early from prison

A man who killed a miniature horse, stabbing it 41 times, will be released from prison four months early. Reginald Robert Ozanne, 51, was jailed for two and a-half years ... Read more »

Dead pigs spotted at Queenstown Airport carpark causes online stir

A hunter who parked in a busy airport car park with his ute stacked with the fresh wild pig carcasses has inadvertently created a stir online. The pig hunter’s freshly-killed ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Two positive cases on container ship in quarantine in Bluff

Two crew members on a container ship in the South Island have tested positive for Covid-19. The Marshall-islands flagged ship Mattina is the third vessel in New Zealand to have ... Read more »

Hang glider crashes near Taylors Mistake, Christchurch

TOKYO – One minute, he’s doing the splits alongside a gymnast from Belgium. The next he’s chatting it up with Brazilian volleyball players, eating with a Mexican weightlifter and doling ... Read more »

Holidaymakers in Marlborough rescued by mud-covered fire chief after night of landslides around them

Tougher restrictions will soon come into effect in South Australia as the state races to stop the spread of three locally acquired coronavirus cases uncovered on Monday. An 81-year-old man, ... Read more »

More rain on way for Westport as 'lengthy' clean-up effort begins

Nashville Predators prospect Luke Prokop announced on Monday he’s gay, becoming the first player under an NHL contract to publicly come out. Before Prokop’s announcement, no NHL player – active ... Read more »

South Island ski fields snowed under by school holiday traffic

School holidays, low temperatures and some fresh snow has led to busy South Island ski fields overflowing, with some forced to turn holidaymakers away. Mt Dobson Ski Field was full ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Nine mariners test positive on container ship in Bluff

More crew members on board a container ship struck by Covid-19 have tested positive for the virus. A total of nine crew members on the Marshall Islands-flagged vessel, the Mattina, ... Read more »

Former military man George Tweedy admits armed attack

A woman made her attacker a cup of tea in an attempt to calm him down after she woke to the former army major pointing a military-style rifle at her. ... Read more »

'It's not ideal': Westport man reeling after waist-high water destroys home of 60 years

Trevor Fox was born and raised in his Westport home and has never lived anywhere else. But after the weekend’s record-breaking flood he may never be able to live there ... Read more »

Possibly explosive material found at Founders Heritage Park in Nelson

The public is being asked to avoid the Founders Heritage Park in Nelson as items in the facility are checked for an explosive material. A police spokesperson said the NZ ... Read more »

Samuel Samson's mother on trial for allegedly helping to dispose of murder evidence

The mother of the murderer of Azalia Wilson was woken in the middle of the night of the crime with a request to babysit his daughter — and she did ... Read more »