Merrily We Roll Along review – Sondheim's ‘flop' is a musical delight

Asia's Tech News Daily

It was only a matter of time before Hayes Theatre Co – the impossibly small Sydney space dedicated to making musicals matter – staged Merrily We Roll Along.

Merrily, a famous flop, boasts one of Stephen Sondheim’s most gorgeous scores – more straightforward and pop-influenced, full of ease without sacrificing intelligence – and since it has been extensively rewritten from its original disastrous run in 1981 (it closed after just 16 performances), the story contains more much-needed clarity.

Related: ‘Sydney, we’re back’: Hamilton makes jubilant return to the Australian stage

But it’s still extraordinarily difficult to pull off. The show doesn’t work if we don’t care about its characters – it’s critical that we believe in them and find their journey credible.

That’s because this story – the story of Franklin (Andrew Coshan), Charley (Ainsley Melham) and Mary (Elise McCann) – moves backwards through time. The trio are close friends – or at least they used to be. We meet them in their 40s, when Franklin – a Broadway composer turned Hollywood success – is rich and famous, and ultimately unhappy. His best friend Mary is drunk and caustic; their third musketeer and Franklin’s one-time musical collaborator, Charley, is nowhere to be seen – the friendship clearly over. Franklin’s life is falling apart as the positive reviews roll in. It’s lonely at the top.

It’s well-known by now that Merrily, after that first scene, just starts rolling back the clock. We see the moment Charley’s frustrations with Franklin boiled over and ended the friendship; we learn why Mary is so unhappy; we watch the friends lose their loving bond and with it their youthful optimism. We end, heartbreakingly, when the friends are in their 20s, on the brink of their adult life. They see nothing but blue skies. We’ve just lived the wreckage.

How do actors de-age in front of your eyes and feel consistently real? How does a director ensure that we always understand the progression of time, and keep the characters on a steady journey that doesn’t feel overblown and overplayed? Both of these questions are even more critical at the Hayes, which only seats 110; there’s nowhere to hide.

Enter director Dean Bryant, an artist who never chooses the easy laughs and spectacle-first approach to staging musicals. He probes restlessly at character and story to find the emotional truth of the scene, and it’s that focus on the complications of friendship, fame and creative work – the tension of love affairs and the shattering depth of lost friendships – that makes the show feel like a success.

He transitions his cast back in time with the necessary support (wigs, costume changes), but it’s the subtle embodied shifts that make us believe it. (The choreographer, Andrew Hallsworth, is critical here: he finds a movement language for these characters that evolves in reverse; they open up and move more freely as they get younger.) The musical director, Andrew Worboys, makes a band of five feel like an orchestra, giving the show a driving, constant source of life.

The set, by Jeremy Allen, provides plenty of dimension for the actors to work within, but an additional (sometimes live) video element, with screens mounted at the back of the stage, designed by David Bergman, pulls focus from the production more often than it adds to it. This is a theatrical character study that doesn’t need to be augmented or padded out; the screens make a tough narrative sell even more difficult, and reminds us how much we’re relying on imagination.

Still, Merrily is a product of its time. We end at the dawn of the 1960s, so critical scenes rely on political and cultural references that are fading out of the collective consciousness, and George Furth’s book doesn’t hold up as well as Sondheim’s music and lyrics.

But the bigger problem is Merrily’s treatment of its women. Mary, Franklin’s second wife Gussie (Georgina Hopson), ingenue Meg (Vidya Makan) and Franklin’s first wife Beth (Tiarne Sue Yek) are only ever in service to the men of the story, their own perspectives either downplayed by the book and lyrics or worse, ignored outright. The show is cruellest to Mary, making her the butt of every joke.

Bryant, to his credit, works hard to offset this in direction, offering Beth, Gussie, Meg and especially Mary moments of dignity, complexity and strength. Yek gives Beth the anger she needs (although the character is still painfully undeveloped), and Makan’s supporting roles elevate the entire company. Hopson is glorious as Gussie, a camp portrait of a diva being made and unmade that comes close to, but deliciously never becomes, caricature.

But it’s McCann who goes the furthest towards solving the problem of Mary. Resisting the acting shortcut of performing simple anger, she laces her caustic comments with vulnerability and an aching openness. McCann has always had a gift with a lyric, and Sondheim’s wordy lines sound natural, necessary in her mouth. Her voice is beautiful, malleable; if you listen closely, you hear it get younger as the characters do.

Still, Merrily cares the most about Franklin and Charley, and Bryant coaxes the entire show into something of a platonic love story. Melham, a new leading man on the biggest musical theatre stages (Pippin, Aladdin) in Australia, gets better and better every time, and he’s remarkable here. He has the showiest, flashiest number of the evening – the patter song Franklin Shepard, Inc – and Melham delights in every second of it, droll and dashing and deft. Coshan’s Franklin is the heart of the show and his steady performance props up the action, but he’s at his best when he’s with Melham – the notes are held a little longer, the lyrics trip easier off the tongue. He and Coshan light each other up, making the tragedy of their severed bond even more deeply felt.

Merrily only works if we care. This production makes sure we do.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Chinese property firm Kaisa suspends share trading

© JADE GAO Kaisa is China’s 27th-largest real estate firm — but one of its most indebted Chinese property firm Kaisa suspended share trading in Hong Kong on Wednesday as ... Read more »

Woman says Maxwell abused her at age 14

NEW YORK (AP) — One of Ghislaine Maxwell’s accusers testified Tuesday that she was just 14 years old when the British socialite had her undress, fondled her and told her ... Read more »

Suspect in killing of Saudi journalist arrested in France

The Associated PressFILE – Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi speaks during a press conference in Manama, Bahrain on Dec. 15, 2014. A suspect in the 2018 killing of Saudi journalist Jamal ... Read more »

Michigan attorney general will review Oxford school shooting

The Associated PressThis booking photo released by the Oakland County, Mich., Sheriff’s Office shows Ethan Crumbley, 15, who is charged as an adult with murder and terrorism for a shooting ... Read more »

Risiko dipenjara kekal, Najib dijangka hadiri prosiding keputusan rayuan dari pejabat peguam

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Najib Razak mungkin dapat mengelak dari drama kamar mahkamah seperti mana dilalui Presiden PKR Anwar Ibrahim dalam perbicaraan kes liwat kira-kira tujuh lalu, berikutan bekas perdana ... Read more »

‘I am officially on the run': Daughter testifies against Keith Smith in case of hoax panhandler killers

BALTIMORE — Trying to outrun murder charges in Baltimore, Valeria Smith and her father barreled toward Mexico, stopping only to change clothes, grab a bite or buy a diary so ... Read more »

Shashi Tharoor explains who a 'bhakt' is after being trolled for pic at wedding

© Provided by Hindustan Times Shashi Tharoor was trolled on Twitter for his photo at a wedding event.  (PTI) A photo of Congress MP Shashi Tharoor along with a bridegroom ... Read more »

Aer Lingus pilot battles Barra winds in wild conditions at Dublin Airport

© Provided by A pilot landing a plane in Dublin Airport on Tuesday was faced with a tricky landing thanks to Storm Barra. Storm Barra, which is only halfway ... Read more »

Pengurusan jenazah Covid-19 makin menurun

© Provided by Sinar Harian RANTAU PANJANG – Pengurusan jenazah Covid-19 yang dikendalikan oleh Jabatan Bomba dan Penyelamat Malaysia (JBPM) Kelantan menunjukkan penurunan. Pengarah JBPM Kelantan, Zainal Madasin berkata, penurunan ... Read more »

Covid-19: VTL testing now 48 hours prior to travel, digital tracker during quarantine for those from countries with Omicron cases, says Khairy

© Provided by Malay Mail An explainer released categorised those who would be affected by the new regulations into six main categories; those travelling under the land and air Vaccinated ... Read more »

Unvaccinated? As World 'Bans' Those Without Jabs, You Have More to Lose Than Just Covid Antibodies

© Provided by News18 Unvaccinated? As World ‘Bans’ Those Without Jabs, You Have More to Lose Than Just Covid Antibodies As governments and scientists around the world champion vaccination as ... Read more »

Weibo shares slip 6% below issue price in Hong Kong trading debut

HONG KONG (Reuters) – Shares in Chinese social media giant Weibo Corp opened 6.1% below their issue price in the debut of its secondary listing on the Hong Kong Stock ... Read more »

Biden, Putin square off as tension grows on Ukraine border

WASHINGTON (AP) — Face to face for over two hours, President Joe Biden and Russia’s Vladimir Putin squared off in a secure video call Tuesday as the U.S. president put ... Read more »

RTE star Marty Morrissey's mum killed in horror car crash

© Provided by RTE star Marty Morrissey’s mother, Peggy, has died tragically after a car crash. Peggy Morrissey (nee Twomey) was involved in a single-car road traffic collision in Co Clare ... Read more »

Some schools to remain closed as Storm Barra ‘only halfway through'

© Provided by Some schools are to remain closed on Wednesday December 8 as it has been revealed that Storm Barra is only ‘halfway through’ and the strongest winds ... Read more »

'Emmerdale' killer Meena FINALLY exposed this Christmas as she plots to kill Manpreet?

© Provided by WhatToWatch Emmerdale Meena Jutla and Manpreet Sharma It looks like Emmerdale fans may finally get the moment they have been waiting for this Christmas as the walls ... Read more »

Schools in Dublin to close again tomorrow as Met Éireann issues new Status Orange wind warning

Met Éireann has updated its weather warning for the greater Dublin area to an Orange alert which will be in place from 1am to 7am tomorrow morning. The Status Orange ... Read more »

Gardai make appeal for witnesses after shots fired at house in Dundalk

Gardai have appealed for any witnesses to come forward after a shocking incident over the weekend saw shots fired at a house in Dundalk. Officials responded at around 8.30pm on ... Read more »

Board of Elections replaces top official amid pledge for reform

Deputy executive director Dawn Sandow will be departing the Board of Elections after 11 years. C-SPAN The embattled city Board of Elections bounced its powerful No. 2 official amid a ... Read more »

Terkuburkah karier politik Bossku?

© Provided by Sinar Harian SEPERTI diketahui, hari ini menjadi detik cukup getir bagi bekas Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak kerana keputusan rayuan untuk mengetepikan sabitan dan hukuman ... Read more »

Little Mix share the worst looks of their career: ‘Shall I get the catalogue out?'

Little Mix have reflected on the “worst looks” of their career to date in a new YouTube documentary aired ahead of their forthcoming hiatus. The pop group announced last week ... Read more »

United Arab Emirates makes the weekend match the West to woo investors

General view of the Burj Khalifa and the downtown skyline in Dubai, United Arab Emirates The United Arab Emirates is moving its weekend to Saturday and Sunday as it seeks ... Read more »

Peter Foster: Serial Australian conman linked to the Blairs found after six months on the run

Serial Australian conman Peter Foster was arrested by Australian police in Melbourne on Tuesday. © TORSTEN BLACKWOOD/AFP/Getty Images Peter Foster has previously been charged for high-profile scams, including Britain’s ‘Cherigate’ ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal-Katrina Kaif`s wedding: Groove to the Punjabi beats

© Provided by Mid-Day What’s a Bollywood wedding without naach-gaana? On Tuesday, Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif’s pre-wedding celebrations began with an elaborate sangeet night at the Six Senses Fort ... Read more »

Horoscope Today, December 8, 2021: Aries to win praise, Leo, Pisces & other zodiac signs know your prediction

Scorpio, Capricorn and Pisces ascendant sign people will enjoy a quiet evening today in the com[any of their family members. Read your daily predictions to know the possibilities for your ... Read more »

Model Gisele Bundchen saves turtle tangled in fishing net

© Provided by Mid-Day NFL superstar Tom Brady’s wife, Gisele Bundchen recently rescued a turtle caught in a fishing net and encouraged others to do their part to protect animals.  ... Read more »

CTET December 2021: Admit card to be released soon at, check how to download

© Provided by Zee News CTET December 2021: The 15th edition of the Central Teacher Eligibility Test (CTET) is scheduled to be conducted by the Central Board of Secondary Education ... Read more »

Singer/Songwriter Dhruv announces signing to RCA Records releases new track ‘Stable Life'

Today, RCA Records announces the signing of 22-year-old singer/songwriter dhruv. In celebration of the announcement dhruv releases a new track “stable life” (listen here). “stable life” was written by dhruv ... Read more »

Discord will give creators VIP features with new premium membership

© Provided by Dot Esports Discord announced in a blog post today that a variety of content creators will be invited to a new, premium beta. Though Discord has recently ... Read more »

Gov't eyes 2nd vaccine dose for 7M Filipinos for Dec. 15-17 vax drive — Duque

© Danny Pata Over 500K vaccinated on first day of national vax drive The Philippines seeks to fully vaccinate seven million individuals against COVID-19 for the second round of the mass ... Read more »

How to catch Vibrava during Dragonspiral Descent in Pokémon Go

© Provided by GamePur Vibrava is a small dragonfly that evolves from Trapinch and evolves into Flygon and is in high demand during the Dragonspiral Descent Collection Challenge in Pokémon ... Read more »

3 skincare products that can help you look younger without Botox, according to experts

© PhotoAlto/Frederic Cirou/Getty Images PhotoAlto/Frederic Cirou/Getty Images While certain signs of aging are best treated with cosmetic procedures, some products can help. There are skincare products that can reduce wrinkles ... Read more »

Is foam rolling effective for muscle pain and flexibility? The science isn't so sure

© Provided by BusinessWorld By Ken Nosaka Many physically active people get muscle pain after exercise, known as “delayed onset muscle soreness” or DOMS. Foam rolling has emerged as a ... Read more »

Where to find Starhorse and Xûr in Destiny 2

© Provided by Dot Esports Whether you’re looking for Xûr bounties or just want to pet Starhorse, you’ll need to know where they are. These two are located in a ... Read more »

How to earn and use Treasure Keys in Destiny 2

If you’ve run through Destiny 2‘s Dares of Eternity activity, odds are you’ve stumbled upon a few Treasure Keys of your own. They can open loot-filled chests from Xûr or, ... Read more »

Genshin Impact: Where is Inazuma's souvenir shop in Genshin Impact?

© Provided by GamePur Every region in Genshin Impact has a souvenir shop where you can spend Elemental Sigils you find throughout your journey. Elemental Sigils drop from chests and ... Read more »

Duterte accepts Biden's invite to Democracy Summit

MANILA, Philippines — President Duterte is set to join the US-organized Summit for Democracy to be held this week, Malacañang announced yesterday. “President Duterte has accepted United States President Joseph ... Read more »

What the papers say – December 8

Rule-breaking, Omicron, vaccine passports and other pandemic developments are splashed across the national papers. The Daily Mail calls the situation a “sick joke”, while those responsible are branded “No 10 ... Read more »

Kerja pembersihan kawasan tanah runtuh selesai minggu ini

© Provided by Sinar Harian SUNGAI SIPUT – Kerja-kerja pembersihan kawasan tanah runtuh di Laluan FT 185, KM27.1 Jalan Simpang Pulai-Blue Valley, Simpang Pulai dijangka selesai minggu ini. Exco Infrastruktur ... Read more »

Military, suspected communist rebels clash in Cagayan; 3 firearms recovered

© Nolcom Firearms recovered at site after clash with suspected NPA rebels in Gattaran, Cagayan, December 7, 2021. Photo from Nolcom The Northern Luzon Command (NOLCOM) on Tuesday said an ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic