Men over 45 who identify as having 'excellent investment experience' are more likely to panic sell during a market downturn, MIT study finds

© Andrew Kelly/Reuters A trader works on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, U.S., March 5, 2020. Andrew Kelly/Reuters

  • While the S&P 500 has generated an annualized return of 7.5% over the past two decades, the average investor has only seen a return of 2.9%, according to JPMorgan.
  • Now a study from MIT helps reveal which investors are panic selling at the worst possible time.
  • According to MIT, men over the age of 45 who identify as having “excellent investing experience” are more likely to panic sell than other cohorts.
  • Sign up here for our daily newsletter, 10 Things Before the Opening Bell.

Panic selling during stock market corrections can be detrimental to the long-term returns of an individual investor, as both the best days and worst days in the market tend to happen in clusters that are extremely difficult to time.

That’s why over the past two decades, while the S&P 500 generated an annualized return of 7.5%, the average investor only saw a gain of 2.9%, according to data from JPMorgan.

Now, a study from MIT has identified the cohort of people that are most likely to panic sell at the worst possible time: men over the age of 45 who are either married or identify as having “excellent investing experience.” Cohorts with more dependents or an account size of less than $20,000 are also more likely to “freak out” and panic sell.

The MIT paper analyzed the trading behavior of more than 600,000 brokerage accounts attached to more than 200,000 households to identify who is selling and potentially be able to predict when they might sell in the future.

And while an individual investors’ initial panic sale can prevent future losses in the ensuing days and weeks, the study found that the biggest detriment to portfolio performance is the reluctance of the individual to buy back into the stock market when the fundamental outlook may still look challenging.

“We measure the opportunity of cost of panic sales and find that, while freaking out does protect investors during a crisis, such investors often wait too long to reinvest, causing them to miss out on significant profits when markets rebound,” wrote Daniel Elkind, Kathryn Kaminski, Andrew Lo, and colleagues.

The study defined a panic sale as a 90% decline in a household’s stock portfolio over a one-month period, of which 50% of the decline can be attributed to trades.

While the study does not define the “why” behind the panic selling trades, any human who has ever put money into a stock or ETF likely knows the gut punch feeling of a 20%, 30%, or even 50% decline in their portfolio value, and the resulting temptation to cut losses and get out.

Those human emotions have not changed in centuries of investing and stock market speculation, and they’re likely to continue as a constant wave of uncertainty clouds markets.

“Panic selling and freaking out are distinct behavioral patterns in finance that differ from other previously studied patterns” like over trading, the study concluded.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

#Showbiz: 'I have to talk loudly due to the voices in my head' - Janna Nick

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Award-winning actress Janna Nick who suffers from bipolar disorder, constantly hears voices in her head, which consequently cause her speak loudly. The ... Read more »

Ahmadinejad: ‘No War in the Region Will Have Any Winners'

US has helped install Taliban in Afghanistan which will lead to a resurgence of Al Qaeda, only to clash with Iran, but this plan will be foiled soon, Iran’s former ... Read more »

Dos penggalak untuk 'frontliners' Pulau Pinang bermula Isnin

© Provided by Sinar Harian GEORGETOWN – Program Imunisasi Covid-19 Kebangsaan (PICK) bagi dos penggalak untuk petugas barisan hadapan peringkat Pulau Pinang bermula pada Isnin. Ketua Menteri, Chow Kon Yeow ... Read more »

PH Melaka bawa isu pembuburan DUN ke mahkamah

© Provided by Sinar Harian MELAKA – Pakatan Harapan (PH) Melaka akan meneruskan langkah membawa isu pembubaran Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Melaka ke-14 ke mahkamah dalam minggu ini. Pengerusinya, Adly ... Read more »

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar unveils 'Bhoodan Grove' plaque at Jerusalem Forest in Israel

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Monday unveiled the “Bhoodan Grove” plaque at the Jerusalem Forest, bringing out lesser-known aspects of Indo-Israel relations before the establishment of full-fledged diplomatic ties ... Read more »

Tata Power zooms 15 per cent on renewable energy unit IPO buzz

New Delhi: Shares of Tata Power zoomed as much as 15 per cent on Monday as the company is eyeing to raise funds for the initial public offering (IPO) of ... Read more »

Hindustan Copper rallies 12% amidst divestment buzz

New Delhi: Shares of Hindustan Copper advanced 12 per cent during the trading session on Monday following a buzz over divestment. ET Now reported that the divestment process of the ... Read more »

HDFC Bank shares hit record high as brokerages raise target prices after Q2 results

Mumbai: Shares of HDFC Bank hit a record high today as the bank reported a 17% year-on-year growth in the September quarter profit to Rs 8,834 crore and brokerages raised ... Read more »

UK must pound the table for the return of imperial measures in Northern Ireland

A demonstration outside the High Court in London during an appeal against the convictions of the ‘metric martyrs‘ The Northern Ireland Protocol must allow pounds and ounces to be used ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing 2021 LIVE: Fans' SHOCK as Adam Peaty ‘almost kisses' Katya Jones as Greg & Karen voted off

STRICTLY Come Dancing's Greg Wise and Karen Hauer have been voted OUT as Adam Peaty reacted to 'almost kissing' Katya Jones. Greg, 55, was kicked out after a losing in ... Read more »

The Duchess Of Cambridge Dazzles In Decade-Old Dress From Alexander McQueen

© Credits: Getty Prince William and Kate Middleton Kate Middleton seems to have a mandate to dazzle us this autumn. First came the premiere for No Time To Die, where ... Read more »

Food at Expo 2020: German chef Thomas Buhner brings award-winning dishes to Dubai

© Provided by The National A Touch of Autumn by chef Thomas Buhner. Photo: Flavel Monteiro / WG With five Michelin stars under his hat, Thomas Buhner is one of ... Read more »

Singapore Airlines offers the world's shortest A380 flight between KUL and SIN

Singapore Airlines will be operating the world’s shortest Airbus A380 flight starting next month for its Kuala Lumpur and Singapore route. The announcement comes as more countries are gradually lifting ... Read more »

Over 12k COVID-19 vaccine doses discarded —DOH

DOH Usec. Ma. Rosario Vergeire during virtual briefing on June 25, 2020. Screencap: PCOO A total of 12,970 doses of COVID-19 vaccine have been discarded due to issues with temperature, ... Read more »

Complaint filed vs QC's Belmonte, others over allegedly overpriced food packs

Quezon City Hall thumbnail A graft complaint was filed against Quezon City Mayor Joy Belmonte and other local officials on Monday over allegedly overpriced food packs procured by the local ... Read more »

Trillanes on running with Binay, Gordon under Robredo's slate: The mission is to make Leni win presidency

Trillanes, Gordon, Binay Former Senator Antonio Trillanes IV said Monday he is okay with the inclusion of former Vice President Jejomar Binay and Senator Richard Gordon in the Senate slate ... Read more »

Carousell Has a Thriving Black Magic Market — Is This Ok?

Top Image: Screengrabs from Carousell Scrolling through popular online marketplace Carousell, I stumble upon a listing that catches my eye. A small bottle filled with blood-red oil, in which a ... Read more »

MPs tell of death threats as they pay tribute to Sir David Amess

MPs have shared fresh experiences of receiving death threats as they prepare to pay tribute to Sir David Amess in the wake of the Conservative backbencher’s murder. Labour’s Chris Bryant ... Read more »

The Duchess of Cambridge brings back her lilac Alexander McQueen gown for the Earthshot Prize Awards

Photo credit: Samir Hussein – Getty Images The Duchess of Cambridge has gone back into her style archives for the Earthshot Prize Awards. Kate chose to re-wear one of her ... Read more »

Thailand to cease Sinovac vaccine use when stocks end this month

FILE PHOTO: A health worker holds a syringe and a vial of the Sinovac coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine at a market in Bangkok BANGKOK (Reuters) – Thailand will stop using ... Read more »

Man, 76, arrested after death threat sent to Labour MP

Chris Bryant, Labour MP for Rhondda – Geoff Pugh for The Telegraph A 76-year-old man has been arrested after a Labour MP received death threats in response to a call ... Read more »

David Amess latest updates – Ali Harbi Ali ‘radicalised watching Anjem Choudary on YouTube' as MP's wife pays tribute

DAVID Amess murder suspect Ali Harbi Ali was radicalised by YouTube videos of hate preacher Anjem Choudary, ex pals have claimed. As a first photo of the alleged knifeman emerged, ... Read more »

Blankety Blank contestant raises eyebrows as he flashes VERY cheeky picture to Bradley Walsh

BLANKETY Blank suffered a momentous TV blunder over the weekend after presenter Karim Zeroual appeared to draw a phallic-shaped symbol on-air.  The iconic BBC programme often contains a number of ... Read more »

Myanmar junta chief says military government committed to restoring peace

Coup leader Min Aung Hlaing responds to the Association of Southeast Asian Nations' decision to sideline him from an upcoming leaders' summit due to the lack of progress in a peace roadmap. Read more »

ADUN Kukusan nafi keluar Warisan

© Provided by Sinar Harian KOTA KINABALU – Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Kukusan, Rina Jainal menafikan keluar daripada Parti Warisan Sabah (Warisan) seperti yang dilaporkan sebuah portal. Rina yang ... Read more »

Fire erupts at Kuwait oil refinery, injuries reported

© Provided by Al Jazeera The fire at the Mina al-Ahmadi oil refinery was quickly brought under control in 2008 [File: Yasser Al-Zayyat/AFP] A fire has erupted at Kuwait’s largest ... Read more »

French ambassador ordered out of Belarus

© Provided by Al Jazeera France, like other EU countries, has not recognised Lukashenko’s claim to a sixth presidential term in disputed elections in August last year [File: Vasily Fedosenko/Reuters] ... Read more »

Jail chiefs STOPPED treating Brit drug smuggling gran Susan Clarke & only let husband see her through glass before death

PRISON chiefs stopped treating a British drug-smuggling gran suffering from cancer and only let her husband see her through glass before she died. Susan Clarke, 72, died of breast cancer ... Read more »

Dollar Up, China's Economic Growth Slows Down While New Zealand Inflation Picks Up

By Gina Lee Investing.com – The dollar was up on Monday morning in Asia. Inflation data from New Zealand was higher than expected while data from China showed slower-than-expected economic ... Read more »

Dollar holds firm as inflation tugs yields higher

FILE PHOTO: U.S. dollar banknote is seen in this picture illustration By Tom Westbrook SINGAPORE (Reuters) – The U.S. dollar found a footing on Monday as soft economic data in ... Read more »

THG founder Moulding gives up golden share in governance overhaul

THG founder Matthew Moulding has confirmed plans to give up his “golden share” after the online retail giant’s shares plunged amid fierce scrutiny over its corporate governance. The company, which ... Read more »

Arrest over death threat sent to Labour MP Chris Bryant

© Yui Mok Labour MP Chris Bryant (Yui Mok/PA) Police have arrested a man on suspicion of sending a death threat to Labour MP Chris Bryant in the latest sign ... Read more »

‘Miracle': Australian pair survive days without water in the remote outback

© NT Police australianoutbacksurvivors1810v2.jpg A man and a teen have been rescued from the remote Australian outback after surviving days without water. Mahesh Patrick, 14, and Shaun Emitja, 21, had ... Read more »

Tributes paid to man killed in house collapse

© Credits: Lancashire Police Carl Whalley The family of a man who died in a house fire in Clayton le Woods have paid tribute to him. Emergency services were called ... Read more »

Dorset MP calls for 'pause' in face-to-face meetings

© gov.uk It follows the fatal stabbing of Conservative MP Sir David Amess which has been declared as a terrorist incident by police. Sir David, who represented Southend West in ... Read more »

Cop26 sponsors complain of ‘mismanaged' climate summit run by ‘inexperienced' staff

© Getty Images Members of the public cross the Clyde Arc road bridge by the Scottish Events Centre which will be hosting the Cop26 UN Climate Summit – Getty Images ... Read more »

Explainer-China joins heated race for new missiles, vies with U.S., Russia

© Reuters/ALY SONG Airshow China in Zhuhai By Hyonhee Shin SEOUL (Reuters) – China reportedly tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic glide vehicle https://www.reuters.com/world/china-surprises-us-with-hypersonic-missile-test-ft-reports-2021-10-17 from an near-orbital trajectory in August, amid an ... Read more »

1300 Armeeangehörige werden aus dem Militär entlassen

Wie in den Vorjahren werden im Kanton Bern die betroffenen Männer und Frauen zeitlich gestaffelt und in Zivil zur Abgabe ihrer persönlichen Ausrüstung aufgeboten. © Symbolbild: Keystone/Steffen Schmidt Nach der ... Read more »

Facebook sucht 10'000 Mitarbeiter in der EU für das «Metaversum»

© picture alliance / AA | Sefa Karacan Der US-Techkonzern braucht viele neue Angestellte für seine Online-Welt. Facebook will für den Ausbau des Internets der Zukunft seine Standorte in Europa ... Read more »

Skan kommt am 28. Oktober an die Schweizer Börse

© KEYSTONE/GEORGIOS KEFALAS Die Skan Group macht ihre Pläne für den geplanten Börsengang jetzt konkret. Bereits nächste Woche wagt das Baselbieter Unternehmen den Gang aufs Börsenparkett der SIX. Das damit ... Read more »