Meghan Markle: Mail on Sunday loses appeal in privacy case – the judgment explained

Meghan Markle: Mail on Sunday loses appeal in privacy case – the judgment explained

This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Associated Newspapers Limited (ANL) the publisher of the Daily Mail, the Mail on Sunday and MailOnline, has lost an appeal in its three-year legal battle against Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex, over the Mail on Sunday’s publication of extracts from a letter written by the duchess to her father, Thomas Markle, in August 2018.

The duchess sued for copyright infringement and breach of privacy, arguing that the letter to her father had been “private and personal”. High Court judge Mr Justice Warby issued a summary judgment in favour of the duchess in February 2021 which upheld her claim of breach of privacy and copyright infringement.

A summary judgment means that in this case the judge ruled there was no need to go to trial in order to reach a determination. This is because ANL’s defence had no real prospect of success.

ANL was given permission to appeal and brought fresh evidence to support its argument that the case should go to trial. But the Court of Appeal has stated that, even in light of the new evidence, Warby had been correct in granting the summary judgment, and therefore that the Mail on Sunday was liable for copyright infringement and breach of privacy.

Copyright infringement

Copyright protects things such as writings – including, as in this case, a letter. The copyright in the contents of the letter belongs to the person who wrote the letter – not the recipient. To use someone’s copyright-protected letter without their permission is copyright infringement, unless an exception applies.

ANL argued that its use of the letter fell within a copyright exception, known as “fair dealing” for the purposes of reporting current events. But for this exception to apply, certain criteria have to be met – including that the purpose of the use is for reporting current events and the amount taken was fair.

The summary judgment found that the Mail on Sunday’s printing of the letter had been for the purpose of reporting its contents – which was not a current event. Warby also ruled that the amount of material from the letter published by the newspaper had been too great to be fair and was irrelevant and disproportionate to any legitimate reporting purpose.

Appealing his decision, ANL argued that Meghan’s father, Thomas Markle, wanted to publish the letter because he felt an article published in the US by People Magazine, featuring interviews with friends of the duchess portraying her as a “caring daughter” who had intended the letter as an “olive branch”, had been inaccurate. But the court ruled that the contents of the letter did not support this point, as it mostly reinforced the points made against him in the People article.

The court also disagreed with ANL’s submission that the use of material from the letter was in the public interest. The public interest defence can be used to stop copyright enforcement in the name of free speech – but it only applies in special circumstances. It is very rare for this defence to justify copyright infringement, particularly where a fair dealing defence also fails. So, it is unsurprising that the Mail on Sunday also failed on this defence.

So the Court of Appeal ruled that none of these defences applied and upheld Warby’s judgment that the Mail on Sunday had infringed Meghan Markle’s copyright in the contents of the letter when they published it.

Privacy

The duchess also sued ANL for misuse of private information. To make this claim, a claimant must demonstrate “a reasonable expectation of privacy”. ANL argued that Meghan thought the letter might be leaked and therefore did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the contents of the letter.

To support this contention, it presented evidence from Jason Knauf, former communications secretary to the Sussexes, who claimed in a witness statement that the letter had been written with the expectation it might become public.

But Court of Appeal judges Sir Geoffrey Vos, Dame Victoria Sharp and Lord Justice Bean upheld Warby’s decision to grant summary judgment, and ruled that the duchess had a “reasonable expectation of privacy” in the contents of the letter. “Those contents were personal, private and not matters of legitimate public interest,” Vos, the Master of the Rolls, said in a statement read aloud in court.

ANL also argued in its appeal that the duchess had shared the letter with Omid Scobie and Caroline Durand, authors of a book about the duke and duchess called Finding Freedom. To make this point, ANL also relied on Knauf’s evidence, which disclosed that he had provided some information to the authors of the book with Meghan’s knowledge. This, the publisher argued, destroyed her reasonable expectation of privacy by putting the letter into the public domain.

But the court found that even if Meghan had shared a quote from the letter with the authors of the book, she still had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the detailed contents of the letter, so the Mail on Sunday had breached Meghan’s privacy rights by publishing its contents.

Having lost the case on appeal, the Mail on Sunday will have to do four things:
1) publish a correction and apology
2) pay damages (likely in the form of account of profits)
3) destroy copies of the letter in their possession
4) be subject to an injunction that stops them from infringing Meghan’s copyright and privacy rights in the future.

It is not yet known whether ANL will pursue a further appeal to the UK Supreme Court. In order to do this, they would need to seek permission from the Court of Appeal.

Meghan Markle: Mail on Sunday loses appeal in privacy case – the judgment explained

The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Human remains found in search for missing man

By RNZ Human remains have been found in the bush in Pipiwai, near where Northland man Kukama Waa was missing. While the remains have not been formally identified, police said ... Read more »

Ute catches fire on Waikato Expressway in Bombay

A ute fire on the Waikato Expressway in Bombay sent plumes of thick black smoke into the air this afternoon. Fire and Emergency NZ said the vehicle was “well involved ... Read more »

How the shift to red light level impacts New Zealand sport

Sports minister Grant Robertson has eased fears that the move to a red light alert level could impact the women’s ODI Cricket World Cup later in the year. New Zealand ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron: Nelson Mayor calls for government to help cover event changes

Omicron has hit the South Island and the mayor in the region with nine new cases is calling for more Government support to help it weather the red traffic light ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: 'Irresponsible and dangerous' - Pauline Hanson cops fiery blast

Right-wing Australian politician Pauline Hanson has been slammed for making “irresponsible and dangerous” views about Covid-19 and demanding a royal commission into the country’s pandemic response. Queensland Health Minister Yvette ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Whanganui leaders react to New Zealand's move to red traffic light setting

Whanganui has joined the rest of the country in the red traffic light Covid-19 setting as communities prepare for a potential Omicron outbreak. Nine Covid cases in Motueka were confirmed ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: National's Chris Luxon says Government dozed in summer as Omicron set its sights on NZ

National Party leader Chris Luxon says rest homes, retirement villages and at-risk communities must be flooded with boosters if New Zealand is to withstand Omicron. Jacinda Ardern confirmed the country ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Booster urgency, free face mask calls as political rivals digest red light move

Ventilation standards must be improved at workplaces and N95 masks or similar face coverings should be distributed for free, the Green Party says. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern confirmed the country ... Read more »

Air New Zealand stands down 15 aircrew identified as close contacts of Omicron-positive case

Following the Government’s announcement that the country will move to the red traffic light at midnight tonight, Air New Zealand say they will continue to operate domestic services and have ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Two new Napier locations of interest, country to go to red levle

Booster shots and mask wearing are key to manage the spread of Omicron, as the country moves into red traffic light setting,says the Prime Minister. Jacinda Ardern announced this morning ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: New locations of interest include Auckland rest home

New locations of interest linked to the Omicron outbreak have been revealed by the Ministry of Health – including Auckland Airport’s domestic terminal. Rest home Summerset by the Park Flat ... Read more »

Wildfire along California's Big Sur forces evacuations

Strong winds pushed a wildfire that broke out in the rugged mountains above Big Sur to the sea, forcing hundreds of residents on this precarious stretch of the California coast ... Read more »

Jobs available: Wattie's on mission to recruit more than 150 people

Wattie’s is set to begin its biggest harvest of the year and is on a mission to recruit more than 150 people before the end of January. Due to border ... Read more »

Covid-19: PM urges NZ's 213,000 unvaxxed to 'please reconsider'

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has made an 11th hour appeal to New Zealand’s 213,000-odd unvaccinated teens and adults: “please reconsider”. According to the Herald’s Vaccine Tracker, around 5.1 per cent ... Read more »

Ukraine crisis: UK says Russia seeking to replace Ukraine government

The British government has accused Russia of seeking to replace Ukraine’s government with a pro-Moscow administration, and said former Ukrainian lawmaker Yevheniy Murayev is being considered as a potential candidate. ... Read more »

Herald afternoon quiz: January 23

Test your brains with the Herald’s afternoon quiz. Be sure to check back on nzherald.co.nz for the morning quiz tomorrow. To challenge yourself with more quizzes, CLICK HERE. Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron outbreak: Splore, The Others Way music festival cancelled as NZ moves to red light setting

An already under-pressure live events sector is grappling with the shift to the red light system – and a festival has already announced it will not go ahead. Prime Minister ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron: Chris Luxon says Govt dozed off in summer as Omicron set its sights on NZ

National Party leader Chris Luxon says rest homes, retirement villages and at-risk communities must be flooded with boosters if New Zealand is to withstand Omicron. Jacinda Ardern confirmed the country ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron outbreak: The Others Way music festival cancelled as NZ moves to red light setting

An already under-pressure live events sector is grappling with the shift to the red light system – and a festival has already announced it will not go ahead. Prime Minister ... Read more »

Tennis: Craig Tiley responds to $6 million Novak Djokovic rumour

Tennis Australia boss Craig Tiley has again addressed the Novak Djokovic saga in media interviews on Sunday morning, denying the Serbian is suing TA and claiming he will be back ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Sore throat most common symptom that could be warning you're infected

One Covid symptom could be warning you that you’re infected with the virus before a positive rapid antigen test. As Omicron surges around the world, experts are warning of the ... Read more »

Police say vehicle theft in Hawke's Bay has increased over last few months

Hawke’s Bay people are being warned to lock their car doors as vehicle theft in Hawke’s Bay has increased over the last few months, according to Eastern District police. Police ... Read more »

Auckland Marathon: Daniel Jones makes it back-to-back wins

Daniel Jones made it back-to-back wins at the Auckland Marathon today with an accomplished run, finishing just three minutes behind the course record to claim the title in 2:20:22. The ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Why Siouxsie Wiles won't be going to bars or restaurants

Associate Professor Siouxsie Wiles says New Zealand’s shift to red isn’t going far enough to meet the threat that is Omicron – and her family won’t be entering indoor bars ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: 24 cases of virus in community as new variant begins to spread

There are 24 new community cases of Covid-19, the Ministry of Health says. As announced this morning, the nine Covid-19 cases reported yesterday in the Nelson/Tasman region have now been ... Read more »

Photos: Fun at the Extravaganza Fair

Sunny summer weather drew the crowds to the Extravaganza Fair over the weekend at William Fraser Park in Whangārei. Photographer Michael Cunningham was there to catch the action. Tyler Osborne, ... Read more »

Insider's guide to Wellington: Beth Brash from Wellington on a Plate

Beth Brash is Head of Programming and Event Delivery for Visa Wellington On a Plate. She lives, breathes and consumes Wellington’s food scene. Beth Brash is Head of Programming and ... Read more »

Zoi Sadowski-Synnott claims second X Games gold medal in as many days with big air triumph

Zoi Sadowski-Synnott is peaking at the perfect time. With the Winter Olympic Games fast approaching, the 20-year-old snowboarder has added another X Games gold medal to her collection, taking out ... Read more »

Julia Fox hits back at claims she is dating Kanye West for fame

Julia Fox has hit back at claims she is dating Kanye West for “attention”. The 31-year-old actress insisted that their relationship is real and denied accusations that she is with ... Read more »

Napier fire: Fire burns on side of hill, property threatened, at Poraiti Hill, Napier

A 100 metre by 100 metre fire travelling upward threatened a property at Poraiti Hill, but both the property and the owners are safe. Fire and Emergency services were alerted ... Read more »

The Hague Rock Band Di-Rectwint Popprijs 2021

De Haagse rock band Di-Rect is dewinnaar van de Popprijs 2021. Dat is the zaterdagavondbekendgemaakt tijdens de digitale editie van muziekfestival Noorderslag vanuit de Oosterpoort in Groningen. Met het toekennen ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: PM Jacinda Ardern cancels wedding as country moves to red

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has cancelled her wedding to partner Clarke Gayford, as the country prepares to move to the red traffic light setting at 11.59pm tonight. The Prime Minister ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Ministry of Health to release latest case numbers

The Ministry of Health is due to update the latest Covid case numbers at 1pm. It comes two hours after Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Dr Ashley Bloomfield confirmed there ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Kiwis flock to supermarkets as red traffic light move announced

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern had not even finished her press conference announcing a move to the red traffic light setting before long queues at some Auckland supermarkets began. Queues formed ... Read more »

Focus Live: PM Jacinda Ardern and Clarke Gayford cancel wedding

PM Jacinda Ardern has cancelled her wedding to partner Clarke Gayford, as the country prepares to move to red traffic light setting at 11:59pm tonight. Read more »

Man found dead in Tauranga Harbour: Police seek help identifying him

Police are needing help to identify the person who was found dead in the water at Tauranga Harbour this morning. Emergency services were notified at 7.50am about a body that ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: NZ moves to red light tonight, PM Jacinda Ardern confirms nine cases with variant

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has confirmed New Zealand will move to the red traffic light setting at midnight tonight. Nine Covid cases in Motueka are confirmed to have the Omicron ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron variant: Jacinda Ardern cancels wedding as country moves to red

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has cancelled her wedding to partner Clarke Gayford, as the country prepares to move to red traffic light setting at 11:59pm tonight. The Prime Minister announced ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Two new Napier locations of interest, country to go into level red

Booster shots and mask wearing is key to manage the spread of Omicron, as the country moves into red traffic light setting,says the PM. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced the ... Read more »

Focus Live: NZ moves to red traffic light setting

January 23 2022 PM Jacinda Ardern has confirmed New Zealand will move to the red traffic light setting at midnight tonight. Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic