Mano a mano: We must learn to talk to one another

Face-to-face engagement with a problem should be encouraged. It is good for human harmony and development, and costs nothing but decency.

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

First published in the Daily Maverick 168 weekly newspaper.

Rather than resolve often minor conflicts mano a mano – hand to hand as the Spanish say – many who find themselves living in former colonies have unconsciously internalised the one-step-removed method of resolving everyday conflict: calling in faceless “authorities”.

It is a lazy, ingrained and habitual response to conflict and difference that seeks to remove human contact and gentle friction, both vital in the pursuit of a more harmonious and respectful existence.

Let’s begin with Djo BaNkuna, the man hailed as the “Cabbage Bandit” and who has gone viral for daring, in a global pandemic in crushing economic circumstances, to grow food on a verge outside his residence, instead of grass.

Lawns, or grass, too have their roots in the taming of “alien” nature, but that is a chicken to tickle on another day. Suffice to say, in many of SA’s more affluent suburbs, grass settles the troubled soul seeking order.

Especially so if lawns are kept neat and nobody sits on them.

BaNkuna, as Maverick Citizen reported, is a resident of Theresa Park in Pretoria North who was threatened with arrest by Tshwane Metro Police after neighbours behind twitching curtains complained about his cabbages.

For three years BaNkuna has rotated his crops from pumpkin to sweet potatoes and cabbages on the verge outside his home. Maybe it was just the cabbages – the vegetable known as “the poor man’s friend” – that tripped the last residual colonial lightbulb in the mind of the person who complained.

BaNkuna is now a potential criminal, until the soldiers of social media stepped in when the constant gardener posted his experiences with “the authorities” on Facebook. He soon became People’s Hero No 1. Now, hundreds of South Africans have pledged to support BaNkuna and plant vegetables everywhere, hopefully running what passes for “law enforcement” off their tired feet.

There are cultures, and it must be mentioned that in this author’s experience they tend not to be Anglo-Saxon, where face-to-face engagement with a problem in a society or community is encouraged. It is good for human harmony and development, and costs nothing but decency.

My mother was Portuguese and I learned, through the lively discussions that took place in our kitchen and that sounded like “shouting”, that an issue of great importance was being “sorted out”. After the shouting followed laughter.

In South Africa there are many communities and cultures that have established gentle and constructive internal checks and balances when inevitable misunderstanding or turbulence comes a visiting.

It is the experience of the person on the other end of the remote-control law enforcement brigade who suffers alone the rage and pain, the sad indifference to “talking it out”.

A recent experience with a dog owner who was perceived to be “abusing” his dog and who had been visited previously by the SPCA found himself a target again this week.

The dog in question is a happy and loved dog. It is clear from his wagging tail and friendly hello to all who pass by. There are many other dogs in my neighbourhood who are left alone or who are seldom taken out for walks. He is not the only one.

When a second SPCA notice was stapled to the gate of his house, I queried if someone in the group had decided to contact them and perhaps it might have been better to approach the owner directly with any concerns.


Long story short. The family in question are not white or of Anglo-Saxon origin. In his broken mother tongue, X explained that the SPCA had previously cut the lock on his gate and taken and neutered his beloved dog without his permission.

Where he grew up – in a village trapped between Russia and China – there were animals all around him, he explained to me, searching for the right words in a language that does not roll easily off his tongue.

“I love my dog,” he said.

The disrespect, pain, hurt and rage caused by an unwillingness to engage with our neighbour in a manner that did not automatically assume abuse or transgression was palpable. It is the pain all “outsiders” feel in a community that seeks to remain homogeneous, isolated, hermetic, and which views anything or anyone outside of a personal understanding of the world as “suspicious”.

Each of us, if you think about it long enough, contains multitudes, and to live decently we need to open ourselves to each other’s real presence. Those who fear “conflict” or a violent escalation can always call in elders or experts who should be able to navigate a path to understanding and solidarity.

If not, then call in someone who understands the weight of the authority they carry on behalf of society as a whole and who will exercise it with compassion.

So, next time you want to rat on someone, do it yourself at least. Pick up your spine, walk out the door, shake their hand, and learn to talk. DM168

Marianne Thamm is Daily Maverick assistant editor.

This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper which is available for R25 at Pick n Pay, Exclusive Books and airport bookstores. For your nearest stockist, please click here.

© Provided by Daily Maverick

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


It's time for Vera Pauw's talented Ireland squad to make the step forward

© Provided by Just as one of our national senior soccer sides has finally shown tangible signs of progress, the other begins their World Cup qualification campaign in Tallaght ... Read more »

Finishing off rivals through central agencies new policy: Sanjay Raut attacks Centre

© Provided by Hindustan Times Sanjay Raut alleged that Central investigating agencies are working at the behest of the ruling party to finish off political rivals in Maharashtra. (PTI) Shiv ... Read more »

Uttarakhand to Receive Heavy Rain Across State, Schools to Stay Shut, Cities on Alert | 10 Points

© Provided by News18 Uttarakhand to Receive Heavy Rain Across State, Schools to Stay Shut, Cities on Alert | 10 Points The India Meteorological Department (IMD) on Sunday issued a ... Read more »

Cloudburst may have led to latest Kerala disaster, say experts

© Provided by Hindustan Times Flood-hit areas of Kottayam and Pathnamthitta in Kerala on Sunday. (HT PHOTO.) For the last four years Kerala has been witnessing a series of natural disasters. ... Read more »

Security forces blast house with 2 militants inside in J K's Pampore | Watch

Security forces blew up a building in which two militants were hiding in Pampore on Saturday. (Photo: Screengrab) During an encounter in Jammu and Kashmir’s Pampore on Saturday, security forces ... Read more »

Eleven legal rights in India that you must know as an Indian Citizen

© Provided by The Statesman Eleven legal rights in India that you must know as an Indian Citizen Have you ever been in a situation where you’ve been victimized, discriminated ... Read more »

Merck COVID-19 pill sparks calls for access for lower income countries

FILE PHOTO: A handout photo of an experimental COVID-19 treatment pill, called molnupiravir and being developed by Merck & Co Inc and Ridgeback Biotherapeutics LP By Francesco Guarascio and Michael ... Read more »

How super Jack is rapidly becoming super John as McGinn delights in his new-found Aston Villa freedom

John McGinn is looking back to his best this season. He looks fitter, stronger and more determined than ever, and all of this is shining through in every performance he ... Read more »

Sir Gerry Robinson, brilliant but ruthless Irish-born businessman who became a reality TV presenter – obituary

Sir Gerry Robinson, who has died aged 72, was an Irish-born business leader who specialised in making weak organisations work better. © Crispin Rodwell/Shutterstock Gerry Robinson at home in Co ... Read more »

Zu viele Köche verderben den Brei: Deshalb steckt der ZSC in der Krise

© Deshalb steckt der ZSC in der Krise Drei Pleiten in Folge. Nach den Blamagen gegen die SCL Tigers und die SCRJ Lakers setzen die ZSC Lions ihren Fans ... Read more »

It's official: Biden's performance is hurting Democrats' electoral prospects

The recent drop in support for President Biden and his administration has imperiled Democratic gubernatorial candidates in Virginia and New Jersey, according to recent polling conducted by our firm, Schoen-Cooperman ... Read more »

Donald Trump being subpoenaed by the January 6 committee is not 'far-fetched', says Rep. Stacey Plaskett

© Getty Images (L), Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call (R) Former President Donald Trump (L), Rep. Stacey Plaskett (R). Getty Images (L), Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call (R) Rep. Stacey Plaskett said ... Read more »

This Home Storage Organizing System Also Fits in Your Car's Trunk

Scouting Report: This storage organizing unit goes from the house to your trunk. © Provided by The Daily Beast Photo: GOAT Boxco. I’ll admit it, I have way too much ... Read more »

‘Mr. Smith Goes to Washington': THR's 1939 Review

James Stewart in Mr Smith Goes to Washington On Oct. 17, 1939, Frank Capra’s drama Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, starring James Stewart, premiered in the nation’s capital. The film ... Read more »

Laneige introduces Perfect Renew Youth Retinol Eye Cream For Face

© Provided by New Straits Times The combination of blue light and sun exposure is like the starter pack for skin ageing but it’s quite impossible to hide from the ... Read more »

Conor McGregor accused of ‘punching DJ in the face leaving him with bloody lip & nose in front of horrified wife'

CONOR McGregor has been accused of punching a well-known Italian DJ in the face leaving him with a bloody lip and nose in front of his horrified wife. Police were ... Read more »

There's a 'Southport rap' with thousands of views on Youtube

Did you know there is a rap song dedicated to Southport? As previously reported, former Southport College student Phil Bridge composed the song about his experiences growing up in the ... Read more »

Heavy rain and landslides leave 18 dead in southern India

© R S Iyer Hindu devotees walk back after performing rituals, past an inundated Shiva temple on the banks of the Periyar River following heavy rains in Kochi, Kerala state, ... Read more »

Alabama teen playing on iPad in his room fatally shot in ‘senseless murder'

Tuscaloosa Police Chief Brent Blankley labeled the shooting “a senseless murder.” Tuscaloosa Police Department A teenager in Alabama was fatally shot in his room on Friday, and was likely an ... Read more »

David Amess: Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle says ‘quality of political discourse must change' to end hate

© UK Parliament/AFP via Getty Images Conservation MP Sir David Amess died after being stabbed during a constituency surgery in Leigh-on-Sea, Essex – UK Parliament/AFP via Getty Images The quality ... Read more »

Arrests after 18 people killed by drinking contaminated alcohol in Russia

© via REUTERS Members of the Russian Investigative Committee investigate deaths related to the consumption of contaminated alcohol – via REUTERS Two people have been arrested after 18 people died ... Read more »

Soldier who died in training exercise on Salisbury Plain is named

© The Yorkshire Regiment jethro.jpg A soldier who died during an Army training exercise on Salisbury Plain has been named. Pte Jethro Watson-Pickering, 23, of the 1st Yorks Regiment, was ... Read more »

Macron's condemnation of 1961 massacre in Paris ‘not enough', historians say

© Rafael Yaghobzadeh, Pool/AFP Historians and activists in France have expressed disappointment that President Emmanuel Macron did not go further in his condemnation of the deadly crackdown in 1961 by ... Read more »

‘The empire strikes back': lauded Australian show begins European tour

On one level, it is a vivid treat for the eye, astonishing bursts of reds, oranges, yellows that are bound to warm up visitors during the bleak British winter months ... Read more »

Tory MP Mark Francois breaks down in tears as he lays wreath at Sir David Amess murder scene

Tory MP Mark Francois broke down in tears as he laid flowers where his “best friend in politics” Sir David Amess was murdered. Long-serving MP Sir David died after he ... Read more »

Disgraced Matt Hancock's UN Africa job offer withdrawn

Former health secretary Matt Hancock has seen a United Nations job offer withdrawn. Mr Hancock this week announced he had been appointed a special representative to the UN in an ... Read more »

Four people shot as gunman opens fire at college football game in Alabama

Four people shot as gunman opens fire at college football game in Alabama A shooting at an Alabama high school sports event left four injured, two of whom were juveniles, ... Read more »

Warm regards from Ironbridge Gorge ... ‘the birthplace of climate change'

Museums in Ironbridge Gorge want to teach visitors about Britain’s role in global warming and showcase the district as an example for transitioning to clean manufacturing Ironbridge Gorge is best ... Read more »

Lucid's Answer to Tesla's Autopilot Is Called DreamDrive

© Lucid Motors Maker of the Lucid Air EV will offer an advanced driver-assist system to rival Tesla’s Autopilot and Full Self-Driving, but there will be some limitations. Lucid reveals ... Read more »

Illinois Democrats agonize over how much to gerrymander

Illinois Democrats unveiled a draft congressional map Friday that would bury the GOP: The proposed lines could give them control of 14 of the state’s 17 House seats. © Charles ... Read more »

The quiet war being waged against 'foreign agents' in Russia

MOSCOW — Russia is in the midst of the largest crackdown on the free press and political dissent since the Soviet era.  The trends driving it are numerous, and have ... Read more »

How long is Russell Wilson out? Injury timeline, return date, latest updates on Seahawks QB

It might take a little getting used to, but there’ll be a new look at quarterback in Seattle for the first time in nearly a decade. Dating back to Sept. ... Read more »

Steve Bruce the ‘fall guy' and shown ‘lack of respect' at Newcastle

© PA Images Steve Bruce reacts during Premier League match between Newcastle United and Southampton Newcastle boss Steve Bruce has been made the “fall guy” at St James’Park and shown ... Read more »

Should Daniel Craig be hanging out at gay bars? LGBTQ people weigh in

Actor Daniel Craig, best known for playing the dashing and decidedly heterosexual James Bond, made headwinds this week when he revealed that he is a big fan of gay bars. ... Read more »

Soldier who died in training accident named

A soldier who died during an Army training exercise on Salisbury Plain has been named. Private Jethro Watson-Pickering, 23, of the 1st Yorks Regiment, was part of a crew operating ... Read more »

Murder probe after schoolboy killed in ‘shocking act of violence'

A murder investigation has been launched into the death of a 14-year-old boy who was fatally injured at a railway station. Justin McLaughlin was found seriously hurt at High Street ... Read more »

Lexus unveils 2022 version of flagship LX

© Provided by The National Getting ready for the rough stuff. Lexus has unveiled the new LX, the second model in what the manufacturer is calling its “next-generation” line-up. This ... Read more »

Lexus unveils new flagship LX600 in Dubai

© Motivate Publishing LEXUS LX600 Lexus recently held the world premiere of its new flagship LX in Saudi Arabia and Dubai within the UAE. The LX which first debuted back ... Read more »

Harsh winter expected to bite Kingdom this year

© Provided by Ajel News The National Center of Meteorology (NCM) expects that Saudi Arabia is likely to witness harsh winter with temperatures reaching below zero degrees Celsius in the ... Read more »

Muslims perform Fajr prayer at Grand Mosque amid new atmosphere after lifting social distancing

© Provided by Ajel News Muslims performed Al-Fajr prayer Sunday at the Grand Mosque amid atmosphere full of faith. The mosque received large numbers of worshipers and Umrah performers after ... Read more »