Manish Tewari moves bill to ‘regulate' intel snooping, seeks forum for complaints about RAW, IB

Manish Tewari moves bill to ‘regulate’ intel snooping, seeks forum for complaints about RAW, IB
© Provided by The Print

New Delhi: Congress MP Manish Tewari introduced a private member’s bill in the Lok Sabha Friday, which aims to regulate the way intelligence agencies function, especially concerning surveillance measures.

It also calls for setting up of tribunals and committees for better control and oversight of such agencies, and for redressal of surveillance-related complaints from individuals.

Tewari told the Lok Sabha that the bill is also to “regulate the manner of the functioning and exercise of the powers of intelligence agencies within and beyond the territory of India”.

The bill happened to be introduced in the Lower House on the same day the government told Parliament that it has “no proposal for banning any NSO Group”, and that it has no information on the United States blacklisting the Israeli firm that developed the military-grade Pegasus spyware.

The Pegasus spyware was at the centre of a raging controversy in July this year, after an international media consortium published reports that said phone numbers of several people — including Opposition leaders, journalists and others in India — were found on a list suggesting that their phones may have been targeted with snooping attempts.

The NSO Group says its products are used exclusively “by government intelligence and law enforcement agencies to fight crime and terror”.

The bill introduced by Tewari Friday essentially seeks to prevent officials of agencies such as Research and Analysis Wing (RAW), Intelligence Bureau (IB) and National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO) from entering into any property, or “interference with any form of communication”, without a warrant obtained from a designated officer not below the rank of secretary with the central government.

It highlights the need for a legal framework to regulate surveillance, and stresses on an “urgent need to balance the demands of security and privacy of individuals, by ensuring safeguards against the misuse of surveillance powers of intelligence agencies”. 

“Therefore, legislation is imperative to regulate the possible infringement of privacy of citizens, while giving credence to security concerns,” reads the bill.

Also Read: Only 15% Indians know about Pegasus. But once aware, their distrust of Modi govt grows

Oversight of intelligence agencies

The bill seeks to provide for the coordination, control and oversight of such agencies.

It also envisages a tribunal to provide citizens with a mechanism to lodge surveillance-related complaints against the agencies and a separate nine-member ‘National Intelligence and Security Oversight Committee’ — comprising the Prime Minister, Union home minister, Leader of Opposition in both Houses, the Lok Sabha Speaker, one MP from both Houses and the Cabinet Secretary — to examine the administration and compliance of policy laid down under the bill. 

The bill says the Centre should set up a three-member ‘National Intelligence Tribunal’, headed by a sitting or retired Supreme Court judge, for investigating complaints against RAW, IB and NTRO.

The tribunal, according to the bill, should be in a position to award compensations to complainants, destroy surveillance data, stop operations initiated by agencies, and also take administrative action against agencies, based on the merit of each case.

The bill was first introduced by Tewari in Parliament in 2011, when the Congress was in power at the Centre, but it lapsed when he became a Union minister in 2012. Private member bills can only be introduced in Parliament by MPs who are not ministers, and technically referred to as “private members” of the House concerned.

The Intelligence Services (Powers and Regulation) Bill was again introduced by him in the monsoon session of Parliament earlier this year but it did not materialise into a law.

(Edited by Arun Prashanth)

Also read: Pegasus committee must succeed, unlike other judge-led panels—black money to air pollution

News Related


Josh McDaniels emerges as Raiders head coaching candidate

A favorite might have arrived in the Raiders coaching search. Patriots offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels has emerged as a candidate and is expected to interview with the organization, according to ... Read more »

Arjun Kapoor talks about his upcoming projects, 'Can straddle both spectrums of films today'

© Provided by Zee News MUMBAI: Bollywood actor Arjun Kapoor recently opened up about his movie lineup for 2022, and it seems quite diverse and interesting. This year, along with ... Read more »

Former Zimbabwe Captain Brendan Taylor Banned By ICC For Delay in Reporting Spot-Fixing Approach

© Provided by News18 Former Zimbabwe Captain Brendan Taylor Banned By ICC For Delay in Reporting Spot-Fixing Approach Dubai: Former Zimbabwe captain Brendan Taylor was on Friday banned for three ... Read more »

Inside Homes Under the Hammer star Martin Roberts' stunning transformation of Welsh farmhouse

HOMES Under the Hammer star Martin Roberts has given fans a glimpse inside his stunning Welsh farmhouse transformation. The 58-year-old presenter completely overhauled the historic property that he purchased last ... Read more »

Eoin Morgan's endgame approaches as England prepare to do without him

© AFP/Getty Images Eoin Morgan’s runs have dried up in recent months © AFP/Getty Images Are we heading into the final stages of Eoin Morgan‘s England captaincy? Morgan was so ... Read more »

ISL 2021-22: Daniel Chima Chukwu on target as Jamshedpur FC down FC Goa 1-0

© Provided by Firstpost ISL 2021-22: Daniel Chima Chukwu on target as Jamshedpur FC down FC Goa 1-0 Jamshedpur FC inflicted a huge blow to FC Goa’s aspirations for a ... Read more »

Hearts' January window state of play: Incoming signings, player departures, transfer rumours

© Sporting director Joe Savage and head coach Robbie Neilson have brought in two players in the Januar… Confirmed arrivals Nathaniel Atkinson (Melbourne City), Ellis Simms (Everton, loan), Toby Sibbick ... Read more »

Watch Robert Irwin Jump Over a Land Cruiser on His Bike

© Jason Mendez/Getty Images Robert Irwin is showing off an impressive skill! The 18-year-old conservationist took to Instagram on Friday to share a video of himself jumping over a Land Cruiser ... Read more »

Black immigrants earn about $6,000 less than other immigrant groups, even though they have the same share of college graduates

© Provided by Business Insider The share of Black immigrants with at least a bachelor’s degree has risen faster than the share of other populations with a college degree. Chuck ... Read more »

Number of homeless drops for the first time in seven months

© Nick Ansell The December 2021 figures, released by the Department of Housing, show that 8,914 people were homeless (PA) The number of homeless people has dropped in the last ... Read more »

Frankie Bridge wows in slinky bodycon dress

Bringing her fashion A-game to Friday’s episode of Loose Women, Frankie Bridge kept all eyes on her as she stepped out in a neon green bodycon dress – and wow. ... Read more »

Ark Invest buys Tesla stock for the first time in 8 months after earnings report erases $109 billion in EV maker's market value

© Ark Invest, File (for Wood) and Hannibal Hanschke/Pool Photo via AP, File (for Musk). Cathie Wood is the founder, CEO, and CIO of ARK Investment Management. Elon Musk is ... Read more »

Count your luck and celebrate Chinese New Year at SM Supermalls

© Provided by The Manila Times SM Batangas City SM Batangas City © Provided by The Manila Times SM San Jose Del Monte, Bulacan SM San Jose Del Monte, Bulacan ... Read more »

Angel Lynn: ‘Lenient' sentence of kidnapper who bundled girlfriend into van to be reviewed

The prison sentence handed to a kidnapper who bundled his girlfriend into a van before she was found seriously injured will be reviewed to see if it was “unduly lenient”. ... Read more »

Autonomy founder plans appeal as Hewlett Packard wins fraud case against him

A British entrepreneur facing extradition to the United States over fraud allegations has signalled he intends to appeal against a High Court judge’s decision in a civil case brought by ... Read more »

Organizing a chest freezer – 10 ways to keep your cool when storing frozen food

© Provided by Homes & Gardens Freezer food Organizing a chest freezer is no mean feat. But if yours is full of forgotten leftovers and impromptu supermarket buys, now is ... Read more »

Stacey Dooley showcases spectacular home addition amid renovation chaos

Presenter Stacey Dooley lives with former Strictly star Kevin Clifton and their home is currently “turned upside down and back to front” amid major renovations. However, the star was eager ... Read more »

Irishman Mark McCall to take break from Saracens duties

© Billy Stickland INPHO McCall is taking a break for medical reasons. MARK MCCALL, THE Saracens director of rugby, and overseer of their ascension to the top of English and ... Read more »

Buckingham Palace braced for damage from Prince Andrew's ‘ultimate gamble' sex lawsuit defence

© AFP via Getty Images PRI218368593.jpeg Buckingham Palace fears irreparable damage as a result of Prince Andrew’s sex lawsuit defence demanding his case go to a jury trial, according to ... Read more »

Covid live: UK reports 89,176 new cases and 277 deaths; Hong Kong offers hamster reparations after ordering cull

LIVE – Updated at 17:05 UK cases and deaths fall day-on-day; Honk Kong government to compensate pet shops affected by culling of hamsters for Covid reasons.   17:05 Italy has ... Read more »

Workers spend one third less time on personal grooming when they clock in from home compared with when they commute to the office

© StefaNikolic/Getty Images Hiding money from your spouse is never a good idea, our columnist says. StefaNikolic/Getty Images Working remotely saves employees an average of 70 minutes per day, a ... Read more »

Scream: Original star Matthew Lillard has a problem with the first movie

© Getty Images Matthew Lillard may upset Scream fans with his recent comments Matthew Lillard (left) played Stu in the original Scream movie / Picture Credit: Dimension Films In comments ... Read more »

Staatssekretärin Leu spricht mit russischem Vertreter über Ukraine: Schweiz besorgt über russische Truppen

Staatssekretärin Livia Leu vom Aussendepartement hat mit dem russischen Vize-Aussenminister Wladimir Titow in Bern über die Spannungen an der Grenze zur Ukraine gesprochen. Dort soll der Kreml rund 100’000 Soldaten ... Read more »

Diese Promi-Kinder lernen gerade «Stemmbögele»

Humor, Geduld und Thermo-Unterwäsche sind gefragt: Derzeit tummeln sich ganz viele Stars mit ihren Familien im Schnee, denn der Promi-Nachwuchs lernt Skifahren! Das Wetter ist der Wahnsinn. Eiskalt aber sonnig. ... Read more »

Wochenhoroskop ab 31.1.: Diese 3 Sternzeichen müssen auf sich Acht geben!

© Peshkova/iStock Wochenhoroskop ab 31.1.: Diese 3 Sternzeichen müssen auf sich Acht geben! In der Woche vom 31. Januar bis zum 6. Februar stoßen drei Sternzeichen auf besonders viele Hürden. ... Read more »

Halb herrscht in Jerusalem Notstand, halb Magie

Der Wintereinbruch in der israelischen Hauptstadt schafft es, die ewigen Konflikte zu überdecken – zumindest für einen Moment. © Foto: Mahmoud Illean (AP) Der Winter bringt friedliche Stille: Palästinenser geniessen den ... Read more »

Kim kennt nur die Sprache der Raketen

Kim Jong-uns Regime blickt auf einen Monat voller Waffentests zurück und muss erkennen: Es hat damit vor allem seinen Feinden Argumente geliefert. © Foto: Korean Central News Agency (Keystone) Die ... Read more »

Cowboys owner Jerry Jones: Mike McCarthy's job is safe for 2022

© Danielle Parhizkaran / USA TODAY NETWORK Dallas Cowboys owner and general manager Jerry Jones Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy is not in danger of losing his job heading ... Read more »

Vikings interviewing Giants DC Pat Graham for head coach

© Provided by Vikings Wire You can add another name to the list of possible head coaching candidates for the Minnesota Vikings. The NY Daily News Sports’ Pat Leonard is ... Read more »

Who will Michigan hire to replace Mike Macdonald?

© Provided by Fansided The Michigan Wolverines have to replace their defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald, who is returning to the Baltimore Ravens to replace Don “Wink” Martindale. After only one year at ... Read more »

Report: Seahawks Have “No Interest” In Trading Russell Wilson

© Provided by The Spun Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson against the Giants. Russell Wilson’s future with the Seattle Seahawks has been in question for nearly a year. However, there’s ... Read more »

Skip Bayless Names The “Toughest” Player In 49ers-Rams Game

© Provided by The Spun Skip Bayless discussing ESPN’s all-time list. Guys like Aaron Donald, Trent Williams, Von Miller and Joey Bosa will go head-to-head in Sunday’s NFC Championship between ... Read more »

Hall of Famer Cris Carter puts Josh Allen, Patrick Mahomes on same level (video)

© Provided by Bills Wire Pro Football Hall of Famer Cris Carter joined NFL Network’s morning program “Good Morning Football” earlier this week and the Bills’ recent heartbreak against the ... Read more »

Top 2023 DL names Georgia football among final schools

© Provided by UGA (Georgia) Wire 2023 five-star defensive lineman Jayden Wayne has named Georgia football among his top-11 schools. BREAKING: 2023 DL Jayden Wayne has narrowed his list to ... Read more »

Von Miller wants to win a Super Bowl for his Rams teammates

© Provided by Rams Wire Von Miller already has a Super Bowl ring on his finger. He even won MVP of the big game six years ago. But even with ... Read more »

Jerry Jones Has Telling Comment About Kellen Moore

© Provided by The Spun dallas cowboys owner jerry jones walks onto the field Earlier this week, the Dallas Cowboys learned that defensive coordinator Dan Quinn would return for the ... Read more »

Georgia Bulldogs LB Nolan Smith arrested for driving on suspended license

© John Reed-USA TODAY Sports Third-team: Edge Nolan Smith MORE: Georgia DL signee Bear Alexander to miss spring football PFF: Georgia’s Jalen Carter is top returning DL in football Georgia ... Read more »

Patriots QB Mac Jones could reportedly earn a spot in the 2022 NFL Pro Bowl

© Provided by Patriots Wire Could Mac Jones be a Pro Bowler in his rookie season? The No. 15 pick wasn’t on the initial AFC roster, but he could potentially ... Read more »

Report: Raiders to meet with Patriots OC Josh McDaniels Saturday

© Paul Rutherford-USA TODAY Sports New England Patriots offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels The Las Vegas Raiders are reportedly looking at multiple candidates from the Bill Belichick tree to potentially be ... Read more »

Report: Ian Cunningham interviewing to be Bears' assistant GM

© Provided by Bears Wire The Bears have hired general manager Ryan Poles and head coach Matt Eberflus, which shifts the focus to assembling their respective staffs. Both Poles and ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic