Manchester bomber's youngest victim Saffie-Rose Roussos, eight, would probably have survived if 'window of opportunity' to treat her at terror attack scene had not been missed, inquiry hears

Eight-year-old Saffie-Rose Roussos was the youngest Manchester terror victimShe was pronounced dead at 11.40pm on May 22, 2017 following the attack An inquest heard that earlier medical intervention could have saved her life 

The youngest victim of the Manchester Arena terror attack probably would have survived if a ‘window of opportunity’ was not missed to treat her at the scene, an inquiry has heard.

Eight-year-old Saffie-Rose Roussos arrived at Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital some 52 minutes after the explosion in the City Room foyer of the venue, at the end of an Ariana Grande concert on the evening of May 22 2017.

She went into cardiac arrest shortly after she entered the hospital’s resuscitation room and despite the efforts of medics she was pronounced dead at 11.40pm.

This week the public inquiry into the atrocity, which killed 22 people and injured hundreds of others, is focusing on whether Saffie-Rose, from Leyland, Lancashire, could have lived if she had received different or additional treatment.

A panel of blast wave experts has told the inquiry her multiple injuries were unsurvivable, but experts commissioned by lawyers for the youngster’s family disagree.

Eight-year-old Saffie-Rose Roussos arrived at Royal Manchester Children's Hospital some 52 minutes after the explosion in the City Room foyer of the venue, at the end of an Ariana Grande concert on the evening of May 22 2017

Eight-year-old Saffie-Rose Roussos arrived at Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital some 52 minutes after the explosion in the City Room foyer of the venue, at the end of an Ariana Grande concert on the evening of May 22 2017

This week the public inquiry into the atrocity, which killed 22 people and injured hundreds of others, is focusing on whether Saffie-Rose, from Leyland, Lancashire, could have lived if she had received different or additional treatment

This week the public inquiry into the atrocity, which killed 22 people and injured hundreds of others, is focusing on whether Saffie-Rose, from Leyland, Lancashire, could have lived if she had received different or additional treatment

The inquest is investigating whether victims could have been saved if they received earlier treatment

The inquest is investigating whether victims could have been saved if they received earlier treatment

On Friday, Dr Gareth Davies and Lt Col Claire Park said the injuries could not have been as serious as outlined by the blast wave panel, because Saffie-Rose was able to live so long without any meaningful intervention.

Dr Davies, a former medical director of London’s Air Ambulance, who has responded to numerous major incidents, including the July 7 2005 bombings, said she should have received crucial treatment in the City Room for her blood loss.

He said: ‘We believe the window of opportunity to provide therapy for Saffie actually begins in that room and it begins with the EMT (emergency medical technician) who tended Saffie.

‘They have the key skills and equipment to provide treatments that are important to Saffie, namely splintage, traction and tourniquets.’

The inquiry has heard that an Arena first-aider, trained to perform the role of EMT, assessed the youngster as she was lying on the floor, but moved on to assist other casualties as she thought she was not breathing and could not see signs of catastrophic bleeding.

Paul Greaney QC, counsel to the inquiry, asked Dr Davies: ‘Let’s assume those three measures had been taken, what is your view about the impact of those measures on Saffie’s survivability?

He replied: ‘The effects of those measures can be quite profound in terms of traction and splinting, and would have every expectation of improving the situation.’

Dr Davies added it was ‘more likely than not’ she would have survived.

Saffie-Rose asked for her mother as she lay on the floor following the blast, the inquiry has heard, and her condition deteriorated in time as a T-shirt seller, an off-duty nurse and two police officers were forced to carry her out of the City Room foyer of the venue on a bloodied advertising board.

She was five metres away from suicide bomber Salman Abedi as he detonated his device, packed with nuts and bolts, and received more than 100 injuries, an inquest into the atrocity heard

She was five metres away from suicide bomber Salman Abedi as he detonated his device, packed with nuts and bolts, and received more than 100 injuries, an inquest into the atrocity heard

One of the police officers had to flag down an ambulance outside and later Saffie-Rose asked a paramedic in the back of the vehicle: ‘Am I going to die?’

Dr Davies said a similar treatment intervention should have taken place in the ambulance before she was taken to hospital.

Mr Greaney asked: ‘If those measures had been taken in the ambulance would that have improved Saffie’s prospects of survival?’

Dr Davies replied: ‘Without a doubt. There is potentially a window of 20 minutes where those interventions could have been in place and acting before Saffie enters cardiac arrest.

‘If you are not taking those measures you are committing her (Saffie) to continuing haemorrhaging.

‘I would have expected paramedics and technicians to apply these techniques in this situation. I recognise that it’s very emotional and time pressured, that there is a need to get to hospital. You have to back a horse.

‘I think at this point we believe she probably would have still lived.’

Lt Col Park said she thought survival was ‘less likely’ at this point but still ‘possible’.

Dr Davies added: ‘Her chances have certainly degraded. I think the strategy for survival here is stop the bleeding as early as possible.’

The paramedic who treated Saffie-Rose previously told the inquiry she did not see any external bleeding and said she thought her only chance of survival was blood transfusion and surgery at hospital.

Both Dr Davies and Lt Col Park said an operation known as a resuscitative thoracotomy should have been performed on Saffie-Rose at the hospital, but accepted by this time the ‘chances of survival were stacked against her’.

They disagreed with the blast wave panel over the severity of the vascular and lung damage sustained by the youngster.

Saffie-Rose had earlier enjoyed the ‘night of her life’ with her mother, Lisa, and older sister, Ashlee, as she watched her idol Grande perform.

She was five metres away from suicide bomber Salman Abedi as he detonated his device, packed with nuts and bolts, and received more than 100 injuries.

News Related


Video: Prince Andrew's 41-point denial in full: Duke of York's responses to Virginia Roberts' catalogue of sex abuse allegations as he files legal papers with US court 

Read more »

The $100k job no Aussie wants: Shortage of workers means there's easy money to be made and NO experience is required - so could you hack it?

Aussie farms are offering school leavers lucrative jobs in sheep shearing shedsThe industry normally relies on 500 Kiwi workers to meet Spring demand surgeShearers with six months experience can make $1,500 a week shearing sheepSeasoned sheep shearing professionals can make more than $100,000 a year Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: 'I really hope he's The One!' The Apprentice star Navid Sole, 27, enjoyed 'magical' secret date with Capital XTRA's Will Njobvu... after revealing he's yet to lose his virginity

Having met the radio presenter during last week's installment of BBC Two's You're Fired, the pharmacist, 27, whisked his new crush off to Mayfair's swanky Bocconcino restaurant on WednesdayMailOnline can exclusively reveal that Navid told a friend: 'When we met each other backstage on You're Fired, it was really fun and smooth. Our jokes were amazing, it just felt like we'd known each other for years'When I saw him, we smiled at each other and I knew instantly we have this banter where we can understand each other. We exchanged numbers and agreed to meet up and see what happens'According to Navid's friend, Will - who presents The Masked Singer's Unmasked spin-off as well as Good Morning Britain - has agreed to a second date after having such a great timeWill's representative told MailOnline: 'They enjoyed a nice lunch as friends but that's it'  Read more »

Janet Jackson denies carrying a secret child with ex-husband James DeBarge... and blames the rumors on her weight gain from birth control

Jackson, 55, denied ever having a child with singer James DeBargeShe claimed the rumors started after she gained weight from birth controlThe singer was starring on season four of NBC's Fame at the timeJackson and DeBarged eloped in 1984 but got an annulment in 1985She said her weight was also ridiculed by her late brother Michael Jackson She makes the claims in her two-part Lifetime and A&E documentary  Read more »

'I thought she was bankrupt!' Katie Price's Mucky Mansion viewers question how she can afford lavish renovations in 'ill-timed' series after her arrest and OnlyFans launch

Katie Price’s Mucky Mansion sparked a flurry of reaction from viewers when it was finally broadcast on Channel 4 on Wednesday night. For many fans, it sparked questions around how ... Read more »

Menstrual changes from Covid jabs are only temporary and don't leave women infertile, top expert insists

Two studies of 10,000 women show changes to periods from vaccines are rareThey also showed changes are both minor and  quickly reverse after just 2 cyclesA British expert says the data should reassure women hesitant about a Covid jab Read more »

Man, 32, is arrested after admitting he sold semiautomatic Taurus G2C pistol to British terrorist who held rabbi and three others hostage in Texas synagogue

Maisal Faisal Akram traveled from Britain to Texas and on January 15 held four people hostage inside the Congregation Beth Israel in ColleyvilleThe four hostages escaped - one was released, and three fled when the rabbi threw a chair at AkramAkram was killed by police at the end of the 10-hour siege and questions have been asked about how he was let into the country and able to buy a gunOn Monday, Henry 'Michael' Williams was charged with being a felon in possession of a firearmWilliams admitted that he sold the weapon to a British man on January 13, at an intersection in south DallasWilliams told prosecutors that Akram said he wanted the gun to intimidate someone who owed an outstanding debt  Read more »

COVID-19: Restrictions eased today as England moves out of Plan B and back to Plan A

The Plan B restrictions introduced over the Christmas period due to the rise of the Omicron variant end today. Mask wearing and working from home advice are among those restrictions being removed. Read more »

Ander Herrera 'rules out a potential move to Tottenham' after Antonio Conte eyed a potential swap deal for Tanguy Ndombele... as the midfielder is 'happy at PSG and would only play for Manchester United if he returned to England'

Tottenham are hoping to sell Tanguy Ndombele before the January window shutsPSG were reportedly in talks to sign the out-of-favour midfielder on loanBut Spurs have since failed to include Ander Herrera in Ndombele's transferThe north London club wanted to bring Herrera back to England in a swap dealThe Spaniard would only rejoin Man United if he returned to the Premier League  Read more »

Two people are rushed to hospital after home is struck by LIGHTNING before catching fire

Two out of three residents of a Melbourne home were hospitalised following fireFire crews were called to the scene at 8am Thursday following reports of a fire Roughly 40 per cent of the home was lost in the blaze after residents evacuatedSpecialist investigators confirmed a lightning strike was the cause of the blaze Read more »

OnlyFans model hysterically cries to her boyfriend in confronting video after relentless trolling: 'This is why I don't leave the house'

OnlyFans model Mikaela Testa was seen crying hysterically in a confronting video on Thursday after becoming overwhelmed by years of online abuse. The footage was shared on TikTok by her boyfriend ... Read more »

Newcastle and Everton 'interested in stunning move for Bayern Munich legend Thomas Muller' with the German international approaching the final year of his contract at the club

Thomas Muller has just one year left on his deal after the end of this season The 33-year-old has spent his entire playing career at Bayern Munich Newcastle and Everton are reportedly interested in a move for the German  Read more »

'It's my country, what I love the most!': Mohamed Salah hungry for AFCON success with Egypt after coming up short in the 2017 final... as the Liverpool star insists leading his national team to glory would be the proudest moment of his career

Mohamed Salah's winning penalty earned Egypt victory against Ivory CoastThe Pharaohs are now set to face Morocco in Sunday's AFCON quarter-finalSalah is desperate to lead his country to the title after losing the 2017 finalThe Liverpool ace says doing so would be the achievement closest to his heart  Read more »

Brazen thieves are strolling out of stores in NYC's wealthy Upper East Side with bags full of looted goods and leaving shelves bare: One Rite Aid is being forced to close after being hit DAILY and small businesses fear they'll suffer the same fate

Brazen thieves have been hitting the same Upper East Side Rite Aid for months, forcing it to close Now, numerous small businesses in the upscale Manhattan neighborhood, where residents say they are on high alert because of rising crime, are worried they will soon suffer the same fate The Rite Aid store at 80th Street and 2nd Avenue will close on February 15  Sayed Imam, the store manager of nearby Wine Emporium, for 15 years said there is little to no support from the police - and even if they call 911, by the time the cops show up, the thieves are gone 'For us, every inventory counts,' he said. 'Since the beginning of the pandemic, these thefts just keep happening. And we don't have the support from police' Seeing thieves load up with goods is a common occurrence, and people refuse to intervene out of fear they'll be hurt or even killed On Tuesday, Michael Rapaport caught footage of a blatant shoplifting incident at a Upper East Side Rite Aid in New York CityThe actor and comedian said he was 'disgusted' by seeing a man fill two bags with stolen goods before nonchalantly strolling past security and leavingRapaport said he thinks Eric Adams could right the ship and that he hopes the new mayor 'lives up to our expectations'Rite Aid announced in December 2021 that 63 stores will close in order to save about $25 million per year but workers say that the thefts are part of the reason for the closures as inventory dwindles Read more »

Who'll find love on our blind date? This week it's Kai, 36, and David, 45, but will romance be on the cards?

Kai, 36, pictured, has been single for two years and has no children KAI, 36 Dating past? I haven’t had much luck. My last long-term relationship ended during lockdown 2020 ... Read more »

Lucy is a harassed mum of four with zero interest in investing. So when an email offered her the ‘opportunity of a lifetime', she didn't stop to think... BIG MISTAKE!

Lucy Cavendish had an email with 'Martin Lewis' written in the subject line After initially putting £250 on a Cryptocurrency scam, she lost a huge £23,500After a physically and emotionally draining divorce, she was in a vulnerable stateExperts say these scams are on the rise as they are 'rich pickings for scammers’ Read more »

How lockdown-lovers have turned my glorious, free New Zealand into a hermit kingdom: Families are forced to isolate for up to 24 days, borders are slammed shut for two years, and the streets are deserted, writes despairing Kiwi DAVID SEYMOUR

Yesterday morning I received a bleak text message. It was from the chairman of a local business association near my home in the Auckland suburb of Newmarket and contained a ... Read more »

A problem shared...GP and mother-of-four Clare Bailey gives her indispensable advice: Is my pregnant daughter gaining too much weight?

Soon-to-be-granny, from the UK, is worried about her daughter's weight gainHer daughter gets frustrated when she even mentions the subjectClare Bailey said she could be showing early signs of gestational diabetes  Read more »

What to wear this weekend: FEMAIL picks out the best patterned coats for a catwalk statement this season

Dinah Van Tulleken shares her advice for how to style a bright patterned coatShe says pairing them with a plain or boring outfit can bring it back to lifeAvoid looking childish by picking classic shapes like a double-breasted fit  Read more »

'Natural' caffeine-based supplements athletes take to boost performance can be harmful, cardiologists warn

Sport supplements  could pose 'a serious health risk' and break anti-doping rules Caffeine improves performance but can lead to fast heart rate and cardiac death And mixing substances can trigger heart attacks, heart failure and blood clots Read more »

Video: Isla Fisher reveals her VERY surprising career aspiration before becoming a Hollywood star

Read more »

JENNI MURRAY: Emma may be happy to strip at 62, but I'll never do it again

Dame Emma Thompson said she couldn't do nude performances when youngerUK columnist Jenni Murray says she's yet to meet a woman that confidentWhen interviewing famous women on Women's Hour, they pointed to their flaws  Read more »

Video: OnlyFans model hysterically cries to her boyfriend in confronting video after relentless online trolling: 'This is why I don't leave the house'

Read more »

Video: British troops are poised to deploy to Eastern Europe within DAYS to try and match Putin's build up of forces as Russia threatens to invade Ukraine

Read more »

Nick Kyrgios showers his glamorous new girlfriend Costeen Hatzi, 21, with more high-end designer gear as the couple go shopping for Dior

Nick Kyrgios may be winning on the doubles court, but it’s his glamorous girlfriend Costeen Hatzi who is really reaping the benefits. The former World No. 13 took his new squeeze to ... Read more »

Two men taken to hospital after double shooting near Wigan

Photograph: Peter Byrne/PA Two men have been taken to hospital after a double shooting near Wigan. Gunshots were fired at a property in Hawthorn Grove, Leigh at about 5.45pm on ... Read more »

Orf with her hair! German Waxwork model of The Queen is left BALD under her hat... to avoid museum splashing out too much money on real locks

German wax museum Panoptikum revealed figure of the Queen has a bald scalp Photographs of the Queen's wax figure with no wig on at all have been shared Dr Susanne Faerber lifted the headwear off model of the 95-year-old monarch  Read more »

Queensland's Covid cases dip with 11,600 new infections and 15 deaths - as hospitalisations in the Gold Coast drop

New cases of Covid-19 drop in Queensland but deaths increased to 15 peopleThere are now 829 people in hospital compared with 889 people yesterday  Read more »

Most Aboriginal Australians 'are saying don't change the date', expert claims – as thousands take to the streets

Indigenous professor says Aboriginal people have bigger issues to worry about Tens of thousands of people took part in 'Invasion Day' rallies across AustraliaSignificant fall in recent years in the number of people celebrating Australia Day  Read more »

Video: Tens of thousands gather in protest at German Covid rules as other European nations finally start dropping restrictions despite cases still going up - including Holland where bars will reopen after being shut for more than a MONTH

Read more »

Record number of Black and Asian students accepted at top UK universities

Photograph: Chris Ison/PA Black and Asian students won places at prestigious UK universities at record levels in 2021, alongside increasing numbers of students from all backgrounds, and the chief executive ... Read more »

Burnley continue talks with Wolfsburg for star striker Wout Weghorst as Sean Dyche looks to fill the void left by Chris Wood and bolster his attacking options in a bid to avoid relegation

Burnley saw striker Chris Wood leave for relegation rivals Newcastle this monthSean Dyche's side are short in attack and have made a new striker a priorityTalks are ongoing with German side Wolfsburg for attacker Wout Weghorst  Read more »

Adam Peaty reveals he could swim the 200m breaststroke in this summer's Commonwealth Games... which would see triple Olympic champion bid for FIVE golds at Birmingham 2022

Adam Peaty is the world record holder in both the 50m and 100m breaststrokeBut he is also going to give the more unfamiliar 200m a go at trials in AprilHis tally of events at Birmingham 2022 would go to five if trials are successful Read more »

West Indies beat England by 20 runs in high-scoring third T20 international with Rovman Powell hitting a terrific century in Barbados - as hosts take a 2-1 lead in best-of-five series

West Indies set a humungous target of 225 after a stellar batting innings Rovman Powell hit a sensational century while Nicholas Pooran scored 70 Tom Banton hit 73 for England but the tourists came up 20 runs short  West Indies are now 2-1 up in the best-of-five T20 series taking place in Barbados Read more »

'I haven't always been playing in the positions I want to play in': Christian Pulisic becomes the latest Chelsea star to complain about life under Thomas Tuchel after Romelu Lukaku's controversial interview

Christian Pulisic has opened up on his struggles at Chelsea this seasonThe American revealed he hasn't always played where he wants at the club He also admitted things aren't going how he would like them to at ChelseaHis comments follow Romelu Lukaku's controversial interview last month Pulisic though admitted it is a good quality to be versatile as a player  Read more »

Taking vitamin D and omega-3 fish oil supplements every day cuts your risk of developing arthritis by 22%, study suggests

Trial of 26,000 people found a 22% reduction in autoimmune disease in 5 yearsUS experts gave over-50s a mix of vitamin D, fish oil supplements and placebosPeople who got vitamin D had less chance of developing diseases like psoriasisExperts say this is first evidence of a way to prevent these conditions in people Read more »

Why are police refusing to prosecute two fantasists who falsely accused innocent VIPs of sex abuse? One was a convicted paedophile and the other a prolific liar with mental health issues... raising questions over why officers believed their claims

Four months since Dame Cressida Dick granted two-year extension to contractHer determination to carry on had received strong backing from Sadiq KhanMany people questioned extension because of number of blunders and scandals Read more »

Video: 'We're very emotional people!' Courteney Cox says she is just like pal Jennifer Aniston because they BOTH cried when guests on Ellen's last season

Read more »

Shoppers share their genius tricks for saving a FORTUNE at the supermarket - from stockpiling, never paying full price on cleaning products and going at a very specific time of day

Australian shoppers have shared their thrifty tips for saving on your weekly shopA post to Facebook drew in dozens people sharing their money-saving hacksMany said they buy their favourite grocery items in bulk when they go on specialAnother said to get to know the deal cycles when so you never pay full price Others suggested apps that show all the reductions at the major supermarkets  Read more »

No. 10 staff 'are paralysed' as ministers complain about slow decision-making while they wait for Sue Gray's report into Partygate

No 10 was said to be 'paralysed' as the wait for the Partygate report continuedThere were fears the report may not be given to Downing Street until next weekOne Whitehall source said it was growing difficult to get decisions out of No 10 Downing Street denied the crisis had led to a go-slow at the heart of government Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic