Man charged over fatal Brisbane bashing alleged to be 'agitator' but did not throw punch, court told

A man charged over a violent brawl that resulted in another man’s death is alleged to have been the main agitator before the fatal fight unfolded, a court has been told.

Michael Trevor Royce Collins and his co-accused Harley James Raithby Hoodless are facing a range of charges, including unlawful striking causing death, following an altercation in November last year that led to Shannon Finemore being killed.

During Mr Collins’ bail application on Tuesday, Brisbane Supreme Court was told it was not alleged he threw the punch during the fatal incident.

On Tuesday Tom O’Brien, acting for the Director of Public Prosecutions, told the court Mr Hoodless was alleged to have struck Mr Finemore during the fight.

Man charged over fatal Brisbane bashing alleged to be ’agitator’ but did not throw punch, court told

Camera IconMichael Trevor Royce Collins leaves Brisbane watch house after appearing in the Magistrates Court. NCA NewsWire / Dan Peled Credit: News Corp Australia

Police allege Mr Finemore was critically injured after being struck in the head about 9pm in Fortitude Valley on November 3, 2020.

He died in hospital a week later.

Man charged over fatal Brisbane bashing alleged to be ’agitator’ but did not throw punch, court told

Camera IconShannon Finemore (pictured) died from injuries sustained during a fight in Fortitude Valley in November last year. Credit: Supplied

He said Mr Collins was the “principal agitator” as he took offence to an “exchange of words” with Mr Finemore and his friend.

“(He) made the decision to confront the deceased and his friend on the street,” Mr O’Brien said.

“There are many eyewitnesses who described both conjointly as being substantially more aggravated than the deceased victim and his friend.”

Mr O’Brien said Mr Collins armed himself with a crowbar from his garage before the fight, but it was not used.

The court was told Mr Collins was granted bail on previous charges in November last year, but he was remanded in custody when police upgraded the men’s charges upon Mr Finemore’s death.

The initial police response to an alleged brutal Fortitude Valley bashing has been captured on camera. FOOTAGE: Tristian Andre

In opposing bail, he said Mr Collins had a history of anti-social and violent behaviour while heavily intoxicated.

Mr O’Brien said it would be open to a jury to conclude whether the accused men had an intention to inflict violence during the fight.

Defence lawyer Cassandra Oswald said the “common purpose” was still in contention as it was not clear whether the pair wanted to fight or scare the two people on the street.

Ms Oswald said her client attempted to withdraw from the fight but it was not captured on the motion-activated CCTV footage.

She said some of Mr Collins’ bail conditions included a curfew and random testing.

But Justice Helen Bowskill refused bail, noting Mr Collins had not been compliant with past court orders.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Tornadoes not being ruled out as storms continue to lash Queensland

The wet season has well and truly arrived in Queensland, with more wild storms and possible tornadoes on the way this week. Residents across most of the state are being ... Read more »

Underdale: Man allegedly stabs roommate, sets fire to house

A man has allegedly stabbed his roommate in the neck and set their share house alight in a wild incident in Adelaide's west. Emergency services were called to the Underdale ... Read more »

John Barilaro fronts ICAC as corruption watchdog investigates Gladys Berejiklian and Daryl Maguire

Former NSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro will appear as a witness on Monday in a corruption hearing into the conduct of Gladys Berejiklian. Mr Barilaro quit politics earlier this month, ... Read more »

Man charged over alleged violent kidnapping of woman east of Melbourne

A man has been charged after a woman was allegedly violently kidnapped east of Melbourne. Police allege a 40-year-old man was speaking to a woman, also aged 40, in Moe ... Read more »

Dawn Award to recognise ground- breaking achievers in Australian sport

Australian sporting pioneer Dawn Fraser says her “lifetime dream” has been fulfilled in having an award that recognises ground-breaking qualities named after her. This year’s Sport Australia Hall of Fame ... Read more »

Man in 30s shot dead by police in southeast Perth

A man has been shot dead by police after a “disturbance” in southeast Perth. WA Police were called to reports of a disturbance in Fremantle Rd, Gosnells about 1am on ... Read more »

Major breakthrough in Guildford double shooting murder of Salim and Toufik Hamze

Police may have made a major breakthrough in the search to find those responsible for the double shooting murder in Sydney’s west last week. Salim Hamze, 18, and his father ... Read more »

Parcel delays expected as FedEx workers walk off job in industrial action

Thousands of workers at a major parcel delivery service have walked off the job across the country as talks for a workplace agreement broke down. Deliveries were almost certain to ... Read more »

Morrison government to beef up social media rules to protect teens

The Morrison government is set to usher in new social media laws aimed at protecting teen users and tightening privacy codes. Attorney-General Michaelia Cash on Monday revealed what she described ... Read more »

Nationals give key support to net zero emissions

The Nationals have given their conditional support to a policy for net zero emissions by 2050 in a move that has big ramifications before Prime Minister Scott Morrison flies to ... Read more »

Cleo Smith remains missing and police are convinced ‘someone knows something'

More than a week since Cleo Smith vanished from her family’s tent at a remote campsite in Western Australia, authorities are not ruling out the prospect of the four-year-old having ... Read more »

Police respond to two stabbings in Sunshine West, Tarneit in Melbourne's western suburbs

A person was left on the street with life threatening stab wounds as police responded to multiple stabbings in Melbourne’s western suburbs overnight. Police rushed to an address on Tatra ... Read more »

Two Qld border hoppers test positive after being kicked out of state

Queensland has recorded zero new Covid-19 cases on Sunday, however several outback towns have been put on alert due to two people who tested positive after being kicked out of ... Read more »

Media diversity inquiry: News Corp chief executive Robert Thomson raises concern about tech giants

News Corp’s chief executive Robert Thomson has raised concern about the potential for global online media platforms to move into Australian sport. Speaking to the Senate Environment and Communications References ... Read more »

NSW records 345 new virus numbers and five deaths

Another 345 new cases of Covid-19 have been recorded in NSW. There were also five deaths in the latest reporting period. The new figures came from more than 76,000 tests ... Read more »

Grisly find after skeleton discovered on dunes at Nora Creina in South Australia

Forensic investigators have descended on a remote beach in South Australia after a member of the public spotted a skeleton. The grisly find was made in the sand dunes at ... Read more »

NSW government considers poaching Melbourne's Formula One

The NSW government is reportedly considering a bold bid to poach the Formula One motor race from Melbourne amid a hefty cash splash on attracting major events. The glitzy race ... Read more »

Marissa Tofield: Court told woman's offer to provide drugs for alleged revenge plot just ‘bravado'

A woman’s offer to provide cable ties and GBL to a friend allegedly seeking revenge on an abusive boyfriend was just “bravado” and came during an amateur counselling session, her ... Read more »

Minister furiously rejects claim that Nationals should receive $250 billion for net zero agreement

Resource Minister Keith Pitt has slammed down suggestions that convincing the Nationals party to agree to net zero will require a hefty payout from the government. Earlier this month, Mr ... Read more »

Melbourne developer Barry Wang quizzed in court by ex-lover Jessie Qin over ‘broken promises'

Broken promises over trips to hot springs and whether a property developer ever loved his alleged “sugar baby” have been key questions raised in a defamation trial. Property developer Barry ... Read more »

Disgraced former ministers Eddie Obeid, Ian Macdonald to be jailed over mining tender plot

Disgraced ex-ministers Ian Macdonald and Eddie Obeid have been sentenced to prison for plotting to rig a lucrative mining tender. The two former NSW Labor MLCs and Obeid’s son, Moses, ... Read more »

Police seize large amount of Lego as part of $27m money laundering bust

Police have seized tens of thousands of dollars worth of Lego as part of a probe into an alleged $27m money laundering operation. Monash crime investigation unit detectives raided homes ... Read more »

Apology to Neil Pentland

An article published on in August 2020 reported that Mr Neil Pentland had been acquitted of the murder of Philip Carlyle following a trial. The headline published with the ... Read more »

Man, 21, viciously bashed by four men in retaliatory attack after Zillmere teen's murder: court

Four men launched a “cowardly attack” on an unarmed 21-year-old at a Brisbane soccer match in retaliation for a teenager’s fatal bashing, a court has been told. The shocking altercation ... Read more »

Outrage as government fails to release net zero modelling

The Morrison government has been accused of being ‘addicted to secrecy’ after it failed to publicly release Australia’s modelling on the impact of a net zero emissions target. The Coalition’s ... Read more »

ICAC: Former NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian showed ‘strong interest' in gun club

Former NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian had “strong interest” in a $5.5m project being pushed by a local MP she was in a secret relationship with, a corruption inquiry been told. ... Read more »

Lawyers for Malka Leifer consider fitness to stand trial report

Lawyers for the former principal of an Ultra Orthodox Jewish school in Melbourne will be exploring her fitness to stand trial, a court has been told. Malka Leifer, 55, previously ... Read more »

Mother who neglected dying baby didn't get help due to domestic violence, court told

A Port Pirie mother who allegedly left her four-month-old baby boy with untreated serious injuries for weeks was unable to protect her son because she was a victim of domestic ... Read more »

Woman allegedly followed, sexually assaulted in suburban Melbourne

A woman has allegedly been followed through a Melbourne suburb before being sexually assaulted along a track. Fawkner Sexual Offences and Child Abuse Investigation Team detectives are probing the alleged ... Read more »

Electric buses planned for Sydney in game-changing pilot program

A new bus fleet will arrive in Sydney next month, but they won't be Australia’s typical diesel-fuelled buses. The nation’s largest fleet of electric buses will be deployed onto the ... Read more »

Ultra Tune boss Sean Buckley charged over incident involving ex-girlfriend Jennifer Cruz Cole

Ultra Tune magnate Sean Buckley has been hit with criminal charges over allegedly installing a hidden camera in the apartment of his glamorous ex-girlfriend. The high-profile car repair boss, 61, ... Read more »

Victorian Coalition MPs erupt over gay conversion therapy

Victorian Coalition MPs have been involved in a heated private party room meeting and debate into gay conversion therapy mere weeks after one Liberal promised the party would not amend ... Read more »

‘Please come home': Cleo Smith's mum makes another public plea for information to help find her daughter

The heartbroken mother of Cleo Smith has again taken to social media to plead for information to help find the four-year-old girl as the desperate search enters a sixth day. ... Read more »

Malcolm Turnbull says Christian Porter ‘did not disclose properly' after government blocks bid to have him investigated

Former prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has accused Christian Porter of “gaslighting”, after the government denied referring the former attorney-general to the privileges committee for his use of a “blind trust” ... Read more »

Third person charged after teenage girl allegedly kidnapped and drugged in Sydney

A third person has been charged after a teenage girl was allegedly detained and assaulted in Sydney’s west. NSW Police announced on Thursday a 25-year-old woman had been arrested after ... Read more »

Children's book author Roy Askham charged with sexually abusing children

A children’s book author is facing charges of sexually abusing kids as young as 12. Police have charged Roy Askham, of the Ballarat region, with 20 offences, including 11 accusations ... Read more »

Inside the Hamzy family's bloody street war

When father and son Salim Hamze and Toufik Hamze were gunned down in broad daylight in western Sydney on Wednesday, they became the third and fourth members of the infamous ... Read more »

Jacqui Lambie slams Barnaby Joyce for ‘selling his support for cash' in Net Zero deal

Outspoken Senator Jacqui Lambie has come out guns blazing at Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce for dragging his feet on the Net Zero negotiations. Senator Lambie told the Today Show on ... Read more »

Brisbane teenager taken to hospital after suspected python bite at home

Health authorities are still trying to confirm the species of snake that bit a Brisbane teenager in his home early on Thursday morning, but all clues point towards a python. ... Read more »

Covid-19 Victoria: Hospitality sector caught off guard by double vax rules for Melbourne reopening

Melbourne hospitality industry claims it has been caught off guard by the requirement for staff to be fully vaccinated for the city’s opening on Friday. Hospitality staff must be double ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic