Malcolm Turnbull calls Christian Porter's anonymous donation a ‘shocking affront to transparency'

Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP

Malcolm Turnbull says Christian Porter’s decision to accept money without knowing the source was an “extraordinary abrogation of responsibility”, after the former attorney general declared part of his legal fees were paid by unknown donors.

Porter, the industry and science minister, updated his register of interests on Monday, to include the Legal Services Trust, which made an unknown contribution to his legal fees for a discontinued defamation case against the ABC and journalist Louise Milligan.

Porter declared he had “no access to information about the conduct and funding of the trust”.

Speaking to ABC radio on Wednesday, Turnbull expressed concern about the accountability implications saying he was “staggered that Porter thought he could get away with” accepting donations without knowing the source.

“I will be even more staggered if the prime minister allows this to stand,” the former prime minister said.

“It is a shocking affront to transparency.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it.

Turnbull, who was prime minister from 2015 to 2018 during which time he promoted Porter to his previous attorney general portfolio, said it was “wrong” and he was “astonished” MPs could accept donations from unknown sources in a personal capacity, a practice which was banned for political parties.

“What Porter is saying is that it is OK for an Australian cabinet minister, a former attorney general, to take a large donation, a large gift to himself, without disclosing who the donor was and apparently without him knowing who the donor was,” Turnbull said.

Related: Christian Porter reveals part of legal fees paid by blind trust with funds from unknown source

The treasurer, Josh Frydenberg, defended Porter’s actions, saying he had disclosed the donation in a line with the rules and blamed the opposition for the criticism, which he labelled “vicious personal smears”.

“The point about Christian Porter’s legal defence is he did not use taxpayers’ money and that is very important,” Frydenberg said in an interview with Sky News.

“Labor will continue with their vicious personal smears and campaigns. I don’t think Australians have got time for it.”

Transparency International Australia was also highly critical of Porter’s acceptance of money from an unknown source.

Chief executive Serena Lillywhite told the Guardian it was “staggering” that Porter would take the money.

“The most basic due diligence would require knowing and disclosing who ultimately stumped up the money, who manages the Legal Services Trust, and when the Trust was established,” she said. “The hypocrisy is stark given the growing pressure on non-government organisations and charities to disclose, which they do, who their donors are.”

Lillywhite said the public and parliament had a “right to know” who was behind the money.

“If transparency and ‘abundant caution’ were the key drivers for the former attorney general, he should never have accepted money from an unknown source and for an undisclosed amount,” she said.

Porter launched defamation action against the public broadcaster in May over an online article that alleged an unidentified cabinet minister had been accused of rape in January 1988 in a dossier sent to Scott Morrison and three other parliamentarians.

Porter subsequently identified himself as the minister and strenuously denied the allegations.

In late May, Porter agreed to discontinue the defamation action, following mediation with the ABC. The broadcaster agreed to add an editor’s note to the original article which said it did not intend to suggest Porter had committed the alleged offence and that “both parties accept that some readers misinterpreted the article as an accusation of guilt against Mr Porter. That reading, which was not intended by the ABC, is regretted.”

The ABC agreed to pay Porter’s mediation costs, but no damages.

Porter would not say who was funding his case, despite repeated questions. His declaration was the first insight into where the funds had come from.

Overnight, Turnbull tweeted his concerns with Porter’s explanation, calling it “wrong” and that “it’s like saying “My legal fees were paid by a guy in a mask who dropped off a chaff bag full of cash.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it.This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it.

Labor’s Mark Dreyfus said the Australian people “deserved to know” who was donating funds to its politicians.

“The Australian people need to know who set this trust up, who funded it, how much they donated, and whether they expected to get anything in return for these donations,” he said.

”If Mr Porter genuinely doesn’t know who his donors are he shouldn’t accept their money. Did the money come from criminals? A foreign power? Apparently Mr Porter doesn’t care.”

Porter’s office has not responded to questions over whether the minister can rule out the money came from prohibited donors.

A spokesman said he had undertaken disclosure in accordance with the requirements of the register, but declined to say how much of Porter’s fees were covered.

“No taxpayers’ funds were used in meeting the costs of the minister’s actions against the ABC and Milligan, which have now concluded,” he said.

The prime minister’s office has not responded to questions on whether Porter’s declaration satisfies ministerial standards

News Related


M25 climate protest: Patel criticises ‘selfish' activists for ‘guerilla tactics'

© via REUTERS Members of Insulate Britain blocked parts of the M25 on Wednesday – the second such protest in a week – via REUTERS Priti Patel has criticised M25 ... Read more »

UK mula kempen dos penggalak vaksin Covid-19

© Provided by Sinar Harian LONDON- England melancarkan kempen vaksin Covid-19 dos penggalak pada Khamis. Menurut Perkhidmatan Kesihatan Nasional (NHS), ini susulan lampu hijau diberikan pada awal minggu. Vaksin dos ... Read more »

Singapore government announces $1 billion new fund to boost local stock market

Singapore’s government announced a series of initiatives to boost the domestic stock market. The government will co-invest with state investment firm Temasek in a new fund to support “promising high-growth” ... Read more »

Singapore courts equity listings with package including $1.1 billion fund

© Reuters/EDGAR SU FILE PHOTO: Youth fish at a largely empty Merlion Park in Singapore By Anshuman Daga SINGAPORE (Reuters) -Singapore moved to attract high-growth local and overseas companies to ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Now, pay street vendors with Paytm

© Provided by Hindustan Times Mayor Ravi Kant Sharma said that in order to mitigate the impact of Covid lockdown on the street vendors, the Union ministry of housing and ... Read more »

Govt invokes 3-way pact to recover power dues from 3 states

© Provided by The Financial Express The facility has been sparingly used so far, as such a move strains Centre-state relations. The Narendra Modi government is showing absolute resolve to ... Read more »

Horoscope for September 17 by Astro Sundeep Kochar: Follow the rules Taurians, don't lose temper Virgos

© Provided by Zee News It’s a new day, a new beginning. It’s all about starting life afresh. So as you begin a new journey, find out what the stars ... Read more »

Tech Wrap: Battlegrounds Mobile India, Realme C25Y, Realme Band 2 are the newsmakers today

Thursday was filled with launches and endless excitement in the world of technology. Even as we saw Battlegrounds Mobile India slapping a ban on as many as 1.42 lakh accounts ... Read more »

Financial Horoscope today, September 17, 2021: Aries will be successful in business; check which signs will get financially lucky today

How will your business turn out to be? Will you get financially lucky today? Check your daily financial horoscope here. Aries- You will keep your focus on profits. Work or ... Read more »

Rs 31,000-crore support for bad bank: Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman

© Provided by The Financial Express Some analysts have, however, raised the issue of moral hazard in such guarantees, arguing that it amounts to the government bailing out lenders for ... Read more »

Now, vigilance clearance must for J&K staff to obtain passport

© Provided by The Times of India SRINAGAR: Vigilance clearance will be mandatory for government employees to obtain a passport, the J&K government said in an order issued on Thursday. ... Read more »

Chandigarh: UP resident catches man trying to rob him

© Provided by Hindustan Times On September 15, one Pawan Kumar of Allahabad, UP, was on his way to the railway station when he was stopped by the accused who ... Read more »

Rains wreak havoc in Midnapore; claim seven lives, trigger flood

© Provided by The Statesman Rains wreak havoc in Midnapore; claim seven lives, trigger flood The deep depression that wreaked havoc in both East Midnapore and West Midnapore for the ... Read more »

Queensland records one new coronavirus case, Moderna rollout begins next week

Queensland has recorded one new local coronavirus case as a new vaccine is due to be rolled out from next week. The new infection announced this morning is linked to ... Read more »

BJP: Mamata flouted Covid norms during campaigning

© Provided by The Statesman BJP: Mamata flouted Covid norms during campaigning Just a day after the Election Commission sent notice to the BJP candidate Priyanka Tibrewal, acting on a ... Read more »

2021 monsoon in Delhi breaks one record after another; more in store

The monsoon this year has dumped a bounteous 1,170.7 mm of rainfall in Delhi till Thursday evening, the highest since 1964 and the third-highest since the India Meteorological Department (IMD) ... Read more »

Clarion cull: 24 new faces replace entire Gujarat cabinet

© Provided by The Times of India GANDHINAGAR: In a political purge seen as BJP’s most audacious experiment yet, PM Narendra Modi’s home state of Gujarat on Thursday lived up ... Read more »

Vishwakarma Puja 2021: Shubh Muhurat, Puja Vidhi, Significance and All You Need to Know

© Provided by News18 Vishwakarma Puja 2021: Shubh Muhurat, Puja Vidhi, Significance and All You Need to Know Vishwakarma Puja is an important festival of Hindus that is usually observed ... Read more »

Rapist Skaf to be released next month

Notorious Sydney gang rapist Mohammed Skaf will leave prison next month after being granted parole with strict conditions. © Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS Sydney gang rapist Mohammed Skaf will leave prison ... Read more »

Tradies stage smoko protests in Melbourne

Construction workers have blocked streets across Melbourne to protest the state government’s new coronavirus restrictions for the industry.  © Dan Himbrechts/AAP PHOTOS 13 per cent of Victoria’s active COVID-19 cases have ... Read more »

How breast cancer can affect your libido, and 8 other questions we've never really thought about.

Breast cancer is something you really may not want to know a lot about. © Getty Images How breast cancer can affect your libido, and 8 other questions we’ve never ... Read more »

Kendrick Perkins has Sixers star Joel Embiid winning the 2021 MVP award

Philadelphia 76ers big man Joel Embiid is one of the more talented players in the league as he is constantly in the conversations for the MVP award as well as ... Read more »

Two ex-Miami officers, who were ‘Bad Boys' fans, to begin prison sentences

Roderick Flowers and Keith Edwards are heading to prison after pleading guilty to conspiracy to distribute cocaine Two Miami-Dade police officers will be heading to prisons next week for their ... Read more »

What the papers say – September 17

A variety of stories are making headlines, ranging from the new AUKUS pact between the US, UK and Australia, to holidays abroad and climate campaigners. The Times leads with Prime ... Read more »

New Zealand says Australia's new nuclear submarines must stay out of its waters

FILE PHOTO: New Zealand Prime Minister Ardern participates in a debate in Auckland WELLINGTON (Reuters) – New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said on Thursday that Australia's new nuclear-powered submarines ... Read more »

Vaccinated Australians promised more freedom even as COVID-19 cases mount

British PM Johnson meets Australian counterpart Morrison in London SYDNEY (Reuters) – Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Friday pledged more freedom for vaccinated citizens, even as the country's second ... Read more »

T.I. and Tiny sexual assault case dismissed in Los Angeles

A Los Angeles judge declined to hear a case in which a woman accused rapper T.I. and his wife Tiny of sexually assaulting her in 2005, citing the expiration of ... Read more »

ITC surges 7% and opens the way for 15% more upside

Mumbai: Patience is a virtue — even when it comes to investing. And few stocks have tested the patience of investors as cigarettes-to-hotels conglomerate ITC has in recent years. For ... Read more »

Simone Biles, top US gymnasts excoriate FBI for ignoring Nassar sex abuse

Olympic gymnast Simone Biles held back tears on Wednesday, as she told lawmakers how the FBI and U.S. gymnastic and Olympic officials failed to stop the sexual abuse that she ... Read more »

TOM UTLEY: Aren't we ALL guilty of telling occasional whoppers?

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Did you chance to read yesterday’s story about the motorist who came up with a credulity-stretching excuse for speeding off after police had ... Read more »

PH will do its best to honour bargain in MoU, says Kit Siang

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Lim Kit Siang says there is a need for a ‘political ceasefire’ to fight the Covid-19 pandemic. PETALING JAYA: Pakatan Harapan, including DAP, will ... Read more »

The Best Matching Halloween Costumes for the Entire Family from Disney and More

© shopDisney Matching family Halloween costumes do double duty: They bring the whole clan together while offering the perfect Instagram photo op. Whether you convince everyone to go as The Incredibles or ... Read more »

'The Voice' Coaches Admit Ariana Grande Is a 'Formidable Opponent' in Season 21 (Exclusive)

© ET Ariana Grande is about to be a “formidable opponent” on season 21 of The Voice! The two-time GRAMMY winner joined fellow coaches Kelly Clarkson, John Legend and Blake Shelton for a ... Read more »

Fighting fire with fire to protect ancient sequoia trees

© Provided by Associated Press Fire-resistant wrap covers a historic welcome sign as the KNP Complex Fire burns in Sequoia National Park, Calif., on Wednesday, Sept. 15, 2021. The blaze ... Read more »

'Love Is Blind's Jessica Batten Is Engaged to Boyfriend Ben McGrath

© ET Congrats are in order for Jessica Batten! The Love Is Blind star is engaged to her boyfriend, Ben McGrath, she revealed on Thursday.  Batten shared the news on ... Read more »

USA: Sanktionen gegen Al-Kaida-Unterstützer in Türkei

© Keystone/AP/Evan Vucci Die US-Regierung hat Sanktionen gegen mehrere finanzielle Unterstützer der Terrororganisation Al-Kaida in der Türkei verhängt. Betroffen seien fünf Personen unterschiedlicher Nationalitäten, die finanzielle und logistische Hilfe für ... Read more »

#SayaDigital sedia kemahiran tingkat pendapatan perniagaan

© Provided by Harian Metro MAHADHIR Kuala Lumpur: Sejak beberapa tahun kebelakangan ini, Perbadanan Ekonomi Digital Malaysia (MDEC) melaksanakan pelbagai kempen dan inisiatif bertujuan membantu rakyat Malaysia mengenal pasti gangguan ... Read more »

#Showbiz: TV9 brings more happiness with new tagline

© Provided by New Straits Times TV9 rolls out a variety of exciting content with Datuk Rosyam Nor co-hosting a new daily talk show FANS of top actor Datuk Rosyam ... Read more »

Perang poster makin hangat

© Provided by Berita Harian Selain berkempen, ahli Sherrylicious Fan Club memastikan undian dilakukan konsisten. KUALA LUMPUR: Sebaik pusingan pertama undian Anugerah Bintang Popular BH (ABPBH) Ke-34 dibuka minggu ... Read more »

Germany arrests four over foiled synagogue attack

© ARD/EBU Police cordoned off the synagogue in Hagen after receiving a tip-off A 16-year-old Syrian boy and three other people have been arrested in Germany over a suspected Islamist ... Read more »