Los Angeles County trying to force Kobe Bryant's widow Vanessa to take psychiatric exam in lawsuit

Asia's Tech News Daily

The county of Los Angeles is trying to force the widow of Kobe Bryant and other surviving family members of a fatal helicopter crash last year to submit to psychiatric examinations that could help the county prove a critical point in their legal dispute:

Did Vanessa Bryant and the others suffer emotional distress because photos of their dead relatives were shared by county fire and sheriff’s department employees after the crash?

Or did their emotional distress stem only from the tragic crash itself?

The county contends it’s the latter and is seeking a court order to compel these medical examinations as part its effort to defend itself from a lawsuit filed by Bryant last year after the NBA legend and their daughter died in that crash with seven others. Vanessa Bryant is suing the county for invasion of privacy and negligence, claiming county employees improperly shared photos of human remains from the crash site.

In a court filing Friday, the county noted that Bryant and other surviving family plaintiffs are suing the county for “tens of millions of dollars based solely on their claimed ‘severe emotional distress.’ ” The county’s position is that their distress was not caused by county employees or any accident site photos it says “were never publicly disseminated.”

“Despite putting their mental condition front and center in this case, Plaintiffs refuse to submit to independent medical examinations (IMEs),” the county stated. “The County brings this motion to compel IMEs of the Plaintiffs, which are necessary to evaluate the existence, extent and nature of Plaintiffs’ alleged emotional injuries. Plaintiffs cannot claim that they are suffering from ongoing depression, anxiety and severe emotional distress and then balk at having to support their claims.”

Los Angeles County trying to force Kobe Bryant's widow Vanessa to take psychiatric exam in lawsuit

Attorneys for Bryant and other plaintiffs families ripped the county in response, noting that it would force involuntary psychiatric exams on a group of surviving family members that includes “four teenagers, a 10-year-old child, and a 5-year-old kindergartener.” They are fighting the county’s request for this, leaving it up to a judge to decide in coming weeks as the pretrial fight over discovery evidence has intensified.

“Unable to defend the indefensible conduct of its employees who took and shared horrific photographs of Plaintiffs’ deceased loved ones. … the County has resorted to scorched-earth discovery tactics designed to bully Plaintiffs into abandoning their pursuit of accountability,” the plaintiffs’ attorneys stated. “After seeking intrusive discovery into everything from Plaintiffs’ privileged therapist records and middle school report cards, the County now seeks to compel the victims of its employees’ misconduct … to undergo involuntary psychiatric examinations.”

The county said the photos were not posted on the internet and said the basis for Bryant’s claims is that county employees “showed accident site photos to other government personnel and to a bartender” after the crash. It also is fighting an attempt by Bryant to take the depositions of L.A. Sheriff Alex Villanueva and County Fire Department Chief Daryl Osby.

“Adding insult to injury, the County is making this demand while simultaneously refusing to make two of its key witnesses … available for a routine deposition,” the plaintiffs’ attorneys stated. “Apparently, in the County’s estimation, top officials should be shielded from providing any testimony, but the victims should not only withstand the emotional toll of a full-day deposition, but also submit to an eight-hour involuntary psychiatric examination simply because they had the audacity to demand accountability for Defendants’ disrespect of the dead and callous intrusion upon their private grief.”

Vanessa Bryant is seeking compensatory and punitive damages in her lawsuit. Earlier this year, she and other plaintiffs settled a separate wrongful death lawsuit they filed against the operator of the doomed helicopter and other defendants. That led the county to try to explore whether she was double-dipping by seeking to recover damages for the same harm of emotional distress in two separate lawsuits, including the one over crash scene photos.

The county said her lawsuit over the photos has no merit.

In the meantime, her attorney, Luis Li, is seeking the phone records of a retired fire department captain who took photos at the crash scene and later was rebuked and almost fired because of it after an investigation.

The case is scheduled for trial in February.

Follow reporter Brent Schrotenboer @Schrotenboer. E-mail bschrotenb@usatoday.com

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Newton lifts Evansville past Tennessee Tech 59-51

EVANSVILLE, Ind. (AP) — Jawaun Newton had 15 points and seven rebounds as Evansville defeated Tennessee Tech 59-51 on Saturday. Shamar Givance had 15 points and seven rebounds for the ... Read more »

Forbes scores 25 to lead Tulane past Alcorn St. 85-64

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Jaylen Forbes had 25 points as Tulane romped past Alcorn State 85-64 on Saturday. Kevin Cross had 16 points, 13 assists and seven rebounds for Tulane ... Read more »

No. 21 Auburn routs Yale; 5 Tigers score in double figures

AUBURN, Ala. (AP) — K.D. Johnson scored 19 points, freshman Jabari Smith added 17 points and seven rebounds and No. 21 Auburn blew past Yale 86-64 on Saturday. Johnson, who ... Read more »

Geron scores 15 to carry Rice over Jarvis Christian 100-62

HOUSTON (AP) — Jaden Geron posted 15 points as Rice rolled past Jarvis Christian 100-62 on Saturday. Max Fiedler had 12 points for the Owls (5-4). Mylyjael Poteat added 11 ... Read more »

Red Bull will not ‘hesitate' on Max gearbox change

Should there be any fear that Max Verstappen damaged his gearbox in qualifying for the Saudi Arabian Grand Prix, Red Bull will swap it out. © PA Images Max Verstappen ... Read more »

Campbell scores two touchdowns to lead Western to Vanier Cup win over Saskatchewan

QUEBEC — The Western Mustangs defeated the Saskatchewan Huskies 27-21 on Saturday to win the Vanier Cup. © Provided by The Canadian Press Griffin Campbell caught two touchdown passes for ... Read more »

Carius scores 26 to lift W. Illinois over UT Martin 81-64

MACOMB, Ill. (AP) — Will Carius had 26 points as Western Illinois topped UT Martin 81-64 on Saturday. Tamell Pearson had 17 points and seven rebounds for Western Illinois (7-2), ... Read more »

SE Missouri St. fends off feisty D-III member Webster 66-54

CAPE GIRARDEAU, Mo. (AP) — Eric Reed Jr. scored 26 points and Manny Patterson scored 14 with nine rebounds and Southeast Missouri State needed the second half to create safe ... Read more »

'I have never tried to be the best,' says Lionel Messi after seventh Ballon d'Or win

© Provided by WION Lionel Messi, the winner of this year’s Ballon d’Or, said he is glad to be considered one of the greatest players in the world, but he ... Read more »

Georginio Wijnaldum saves point for PSG in injury time

Kylian Mbappe passed the ball from the left, from a great distance, in front of the goal. Wijnaldum jumped higher than his opponents and headed the ball into the top ... Read more »

Ichiro surprising Daisuke Matsuzaka is heartwarming moment you need to see

© Provided by Fansided Ichiro Suzuki surprised Daisuke Matsuzaka in an emotional moment at his retirement ceremony in Japan. After over two decades of professional baseball, star pitcher Daisuke Matsuzaka ... Read more »

Leonardo Santos doesn't expect win over Clay Guida to change ‘gatekeeper' status in UFC

© Wagner Carmo, Inovafoto Leonardo Santos will look to rebound from his first UFC loss when he meets Clay Guida in Las Vegas. Leonardo Santos was eager for a chance ... Read more »

Cross makes clutch plays, lifts Louisville over NC State

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — Matt Cross blocked a 3-pointer and made a 3-pointer in the final minute, Louisville scored the game’s final nine points and the Cardinals defeated NC State ... Read more »

Alabama and Georgia face off to determine the 2021 SEC conference football champion

Georgia Bulldogs running back James Cook (4) carries the ball against the Alabama Crimson Tide during the first quarter in the SEC championship game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Image shot on ... Read more »

Verstappen rues ‘terrible' final corner qualifying crash

Max Verstappen admitted it was “terrible” to crash into the wall at the final corner in Jeddah, having been on for pole position. © PA Images Max Verstappen comes out ... Read more »

One moment is enough for Heerenveen to floor Heracles

little excitement After a cheerful initial phase, very little happened in the first half. Rami Kaib had the chance to put the visitors on 0-1 soon after the kick-off, but ... Read more »

White Is COVID Free: ‘Thank You, Dr. Joe Rogan'

UFC president Dana White is officially free of COVID-19 after taking the medical advice of long-time friend and UFC color commentator Joe Rogan. © Photo by Mike Stobe/Zuffa LLC White, ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand: Why Virat Kohli didn't enforce follow-on during Mumbai Test? Dinesh Karthik has answers

© Provided by WION Virat Kohli & Co. are in a commanding position after Day 2 of the second and final Test match against New Zealand, which is underway at ... Read more »

Davis Cup: Russian team beat Germany to set up final against Croatia

© Provided by WION The Russian Tennis Federation will play Croatia in the Davis Cup final after U.S. Open champion Daniil Medvedev comfortably beat Jan-Lennard Struff 6-4 6-4 to give ... Read more »

Wolff thought pole had ‘gone' until Max's crash

Toto Wolff admitted he thought pole position for Mercedes had “basically gone” until Max Verstappen crashed in Saudi Arabian Grand Prix qualifying. © PA Images Toto Wolff Mercedes boss smiling. ... Read more »

Motor racing-Hamilton takes Saudi pole, Verstappen hits the wall

By Alan Baldwin © Reuters/POOL Saudi Arabian Grand Prix (Reuters) -Lewis Hamilton boosted his bid for a record eighth Formula One title by taking pole position at the first Saudi ... Read more »

UFC Vegas 44 loses another fight

© Photo by Chris Unger/Zuffa LLC Jeremiah Wells poses on the scale during the UFC Fight Night weigh-in at UFC APEX on December 03, 2021 in Las Vegas, Nevada. UFC ... Read more »

Wake Forest trounces Virginia Tech in ACC opener, 80-61

BLACKSBURG, Va. (AP) — Daivien Williamson tossed in 19 points and Dallas Walton scored 17 as Wake Forest pulled away in the second half to beat Virginia Tech 80-61 in ... Read more »

Watch: Best pylon cam ever? Baylor stops Oklahoma State inches short of goal line to win Big 12 title

The Big 12 Championship Game on Saturday at AT&T Stadium in Texas came down to a goal-line stand. The Baylor defense stood tall and held off Oklahoma State, 21-16. Dezmon ... Read more »

ISL 2021-22: Angulo, Fall and Catatau Lead Mumbai City FC to Win over Bengaluru FC | IN PICS

A strong win for Mumbai City FC against Bengaluru FC takes them to the top of the table. (ISL Photo) Ygor Catatau sealed the match for Mumbai City FC with ... Read more »

INDvsNZ, 2nd Test: Aakash Chopra praises Indian pacer says, 'He did not allow us to miss anyone'

© Provided by WION Former Indian cricketer Aakash Chopra said that no one felt the absence of experienced pacers, such as Mohammed Shami and Jasprit Bumrah in the Indian squad ... Read more »

UFC Vegas 44: Rob Font vs. Jose Aldo live results and highlights

© Provided by Fansided UFC Vegas 44: Rob Font vs. Jose Aldo live results and highlights. The stacked UFC bantamweight division takes center stage as former featherweight champ Jose Aldo ... Read more »

McCoy scores 27 to lead Boston U. past Binghamton 68-63

BOSTON (AP) — Javante McCoy had a season-high 27 points as Boston University narrowly beat Binghamton 68-63 on Saturday. Sukhmail Mathon had 16 points and eight rebounds for Boston University ... Read more »

Mercedes team boss Toto Wolff: ‘Drivers not happy with the car at all'

“Max would certainly have been on pole without that mistake,” Wolff realized. “We were clearly not fast enough today. This is not what we expected and we will have to ... Read more »

Georges Niang, Sixers in awe by Matisse Thybulle's elite defensive play

© Provided by Sixers Wire The Philadelphia 76ers put on an impressive defensive performance in their 98-96 win over the Atlanta Hawks on Friday. They held an explosive Hawks team ... Read more »

LeBron James not happy with handling of his positive COVID-19 test: 'I thought it was handled very poorly'

© Provided by CBS Sports Los Angeles Lakers All-Star forward LeBron James wasn’t happy with the way that his recent positive COVID-19 test was handled by the NBA. James was ... Read more »

Luchi Gonzalez hired as US assistant, switching with Estévez

CHICAGO (AP) — Luchi Gonzalez was hired Saturday as Gregg Berhalter’s assistant coach with the U.S. men’s national soccer team, switching places with Nico Estévez. Gonzalez, 41, became coach of ... Read more »

Jude Bellingham questions integrity of referee after Der Klassiker defeat

Borussia Dortmund midfielder Jude Bellingham couldn’t hide his frustration with referee Felix Zwayer after his team’s narrow 3-2 defeat to Bayern Munich in Der Klassiker and even publicly questioned the ... Read more »

Bellator announces $1 million tournament, field of eight bantamweights

Last night—at Bellator 272—Sergio Pettis pulled off a stunning comeback and KO to beat Kyoji Horiguchi and defend his Bellator bantamweight title for the first time. The champion will have ... Read more »

Estrada scores 24 to lift Hofstra past Bucknell 88-69

HEMPSTEAD, N.Y. (AP) — Aaron Estrada had a career-high 24 points as Hofstra beat Bucknell 88-69 on Saturday. Zach Cooks had 19 points and six assists for Hofstra (5-4), which ... Read more »

Baylor holds on for Big 12 title, knocks Okla St out of CFP

ARLINGTON, Texas (AP) — Dezmon Jackson came up inches short on a desperate, fourth-down dive with 24 seconds and fifth-ranked Oklahoma State fell to ninth-ranked Baylor 21-16 in the Big ... Read more »

Jokic gets 32 points in just 27 minutes, Nuggets rout Knicks

NEW YORK (AP) — Nikola Jokic scored 32 points and had 11 rebounds in just 27 minutes, leading the Denver Nuggets over the New York Knicks 113-99 Saturday. © Provided ... Read more »

Krol after wear and tear: ‘I still don't see completely clear, I don't like this at all'

Wesly Dijs immediately set the tone in the opening stage by setting 1:42.38. Only three men hid under that time and Olympic champion Kjeld Nuis did not succeed. He finished ... Read more »

Young triggers Charlotte in 86-79 win over George Washington

CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — Jahmir Young scored 26 points and Clyde Trapp scored 19 with 12 rebounds and Charlotte ended a three-game losing streak beating George Washington 86-79 on Saturday. ... Read more »

MATCHDAY: Rangnick makes Man U debut; Hertha's new coach too

A look at what’s happening in European soccer on Sunday: ENGLAND Ralf Rangnick takes charge of Manchester United for the first time in a home game against Crystal Palace, hoping ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic