Liberal MPs need more than tepid climate signalling to overcome Joyce and Canavan's coal cosplay

Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP

At 7.31am on Tuesday morning, Scott Morrison’s backbench liaison staffer sent out a WhatsApp blast to Liberal MPs asking them not to front the media without first checking with the prime minister’s press office.

Obviously there is a lot happening. The prime minister was meant to fly straight to Washington, but has instead diverted to New York in an effort to quell the diplomatic storm from France and its European allies prompted by Australia’s decision to terminate the Naval Group’s $90bn submarine contract.

The times are delicate, and minding the message is part of what diligent prime minister’s offices do.

Related: Whether on Covid or climate, it seems our politicians really aren’t like you and me | Greg Jericho

But the other moving part of Tuesday morning was Australia’s acting prime minister. When we speak of Barnaby Joyce, perhaps the more apt description is moving bus rather than moving part. But in any case, with Morrison fully booked dealing with j’accuse on the sidelines of the United Nations general assembly, Joyce was minding the shop at home. As they say in the classics, what could possibly go wrong?

On Tuesday morning, at 7.23am, our moving bus accelerated through the Today show to address domestic issues of the day. One of the issues was ambition in climate policy.

With Cop26 in Glasgow now bearing down, the Liberal MP Dave Sharma was due on Tuesday to make a speech arguing the case for a new 2035 emissions reduction target of 40%-45% on 2005 levels. Sharma had dropped an advance copy to the Australian newspaper. Given the story was running prominently, Joyce was asked about Sharma, and naturally the acting prime minister thought Sharma was a “great bloke” but …

This script writes itself, doesn’t it?

At 7.27am, Karl Stefanovic noted not everyone was on the same page. Sharma wanted “40% by 2035 and, at the same time, Matt Canavan wants a new coal-fired power station in Queensland”.

Given Liberals like Sharma won’t cop coal plants, Stefanovic wanted to know who would win that battle internally?

Joyce did not disavow the coal plant.

“That’s the great thing about democracy,” the acting prime minister enthused. “They can both express their views.”

Stefanovic persisted. “You have firm views on this, though.” Joyce told his host Sharma was narrowcasting to Bellevue Hill and Vaucluse but the Nationals had to represent the people of Tamworth, Muswellbrook and Singleton. “We have to make sure that we keep them in a job,” he said.

All of two minutes later, backbenchers were told by Morrison’s office to zip it unless they had prior authorisation.

Perhaps a coincidence. But given metropolitan Liberals tend to front the rolling news channels in numbers when Nationals troll them about building new coal plants that their constituents oppose, that seems unlikely.

Presumably Morrison’s office is just trying to manage daily realities. The prime minister is dealing with an international incident in New York. He does not need to be dealing with a resumption of the internal climate wars at home. Serious ructions could blow up Morrison’s negotiations with Joyce ahead of the Cop26 in Glasgow. Officials also expect Australia will be pressed on our lack of ambition by Joe Biden and others this week.

So those are Morrison’s problems. But some Liberals are bone weary of climate policy transactions where the Nationals set the terms.

They aren’t interested in the fix articulated by Joyce on Tuesday morning – let Canavan talk about coal in regional Queensland, and Sharma talk about climate ambition in Sydney’s eastern suburbs. They want a firm commitment from Morrison on net zero by 2050 ahead of the Cop26 in November, and more if that’s possible.

Related: Former Liberal MP Julia Banks will join Climate 200 group to support independents

Conventional wisdom around the government is Morrison can probably land net zero ahead of the Cop (although there is also another dispiriting story doing the rounds that the government will set out a plan to achieve net zero by mid-century but decline to adopt the target).

You’d laugh at that if it was actually funny.

There has also been some speculation about what the government may or may not say about a medium-term target at Glasgow. There was a minor frisson among stakeholders a few weeks ago when Morrison appeared to leave open an adjustment to the 2030 target. But at the moment, internal expectations are low. People expect the government will try and sell projected “over-achievement” on the current 2030 commitment as banked achievement.

Sharma’s speech on Tuesday was an effort to keep ambition for the medium term in the frame, if not at Glasgow, then before the next federal election. Sharma said (entirely sensibly) on Tuesday: “I think there is a strong case to be made to update our 2030 target, particularly as we are likely to over-achieve it. Clearly, though, our next nationally determined contribution, with a post-2030 target, needs to be significantly higher in ambition. A 2035 target of 40%-45% below our 2005 levels is achievable on the technology and policy levers available today, and will put us on a managed transition to net zero by 2050.”

So what do all these moving parts tell us?

They tell us the moderates are mobilising, and the prime minister’s office knows it.

This mobilisation and coordination (which has been underway for several weeks) isn’t surprising, given a number of Liberals are currently wedged uncomfortably between Canavan’s coal cosplay and Climate 200 – the group coordinating climate-focused independents in city seats.

There is deep frustration at the perception (and reality) that the National party is defining the outer limits of any climate pivot Morrison can execute. One Liberal MP told me recently the group favouring more ambitious action does not want to start a civil war, but it needs to be visible enough to project as a bloc to be reckoned with.

But the most important bit of that sentence is reckoned with.

Reckoned with involves putting political capital on the line.

It is now well understood that MPs like Sharma want the government to do something rather than pretend to do something. None of that is news.

But attempts at political inoculation won’t cut it. It is not enough for well-meaning Liberals to engage in tepid signalling that they want change, and hope that signalling will save them if a credible independent turns up on their home turf between now and the next election.

Public life is supposed to be about purpose. Global heating, and the inexorable transition of Australia’s carbon intensive economy to manage that existential risk, is one of the most serious problems we face.

These MPs have power.

It’s well past time they used it.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Capex picture brightens

© Provided by The Financial Express Rising interest rates should not deter promoters from borrowing because the returns on investment are likely to be good, thanks to better infrastructure facilities ... Read more »

Inter Milan's Dzeko next to Drogba in Champions League ranks

At the age of 35 years and 216 days, Edin Dzeko is the second oldest player after Didier Drogba to score a goal and provide an assist in a Champions ... Read more »

Qlders promised plan on personal freedoms

Queenslanders will soon get another road map detailing plans to give greater social freedoms to people who’ve been vaccinated for COVID-19. © Albert Perez/AAP PHOTOS A new road map will ... Read more »

Colts promote Antwaun Woods to active roster

© Provided by NBC Sports The Colts elevated defensive tackle Antwaun Woods to the 53-player roster from the practice squad Tuesday, the team announced. Woods has spent time on Indianapolis’ ... Read more »

A 10-year-old Black girl was arrested at school in Hawaii after allegedly drawing a photo of her bully, ACLU says

© Google Maps Honowai Elementary School in Waipahu, Hawaii Google Maps A 10-year-old Black girl was arrested after drawing a picture that allegedly left a parent “very upset,” HawaiiNewsNow reported. ... Read more »

Democrats raise proposed IRS bank reporting threshold to $10,000 from $600

By David Lawder © Reuters/ANDREW KELLY FILE PHOTO: The word “taxes” is seen engraved at the headquarters of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in Washington, D.C. WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Senior Democrats ... Read more »

Trump Aide Steve Bannon Faces House Vote on Contempt Charges

Former White House Chief Strategist Steve Bannon will face a House vote on criminal contempt charges for refusing to comply with a subpoena in the investigation of the deadly Capitol ... Read more »

Dodgers vs. Braves: Walker Buehler's start unravels in after Gavin Lux misplay, missed strike-three call

The Dodgers, down 2-0 in the NLCS against the Braves, took an early lead in Game 3 (live updates here), and co-ace Walker Buehler had been cruising after getting out ... Read more »

Jan. 6 committee unanimously votes to hold Steve Bannon in contempt for defying subpoena

The Congressional committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol voted unanimously to hold right-wing firebrand Steve Bannon in contempt on Tuesday evening after the longtime ally of former ... Read more »

The January 6 panel unanimously voted to hold Steve Bannon in criminal contempt for refusing to comply with congressional subpoenas

Members of the House select committee investigating the events of January 6 unanimously approved on Tuesday to hold Donald Trump ally Steve Bannon in criminal contempt of Congress for refusing ... Read more »

Haiti kidnapping: Christian Aid Ministries faced close calls and threats before abduction

The danger was visible all around them, long before a group of Christian Aid Ministries missionaries and children were abducted from the road in Haiti. © CNN In one 2019 ... Read more »

Centre mulls amending law on drugs to make it stronger

The Centre is considering a proposal to strengthen the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985, by way of stricter enforcement provisions, especially to curb spread of illicit drugs ... Read more »

Flava Fav arrested for domestic battery after allegedly grabbing, throwing woman

The Public Enemy co-founder was booked on Oct. 5 by the Henderson PD in Nevada Rapper Flavor Flav was arrested earlier this month after a domestic violence incident in Nevada, ... Read more »

Who's the bearded man on the Timah label?

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today The award-winning local whiskey, Timah, has found itself under fire due to its name and label. (Facebook pic) PETALING JAYA: Another day, another controversy. ... Read more »

Declining birth rate not just linked to finances, say experts

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today The Federation of Reproductive Health Associations Malaysia says Malaysia’s fertility rate had been declining even before the national family planning programme was launched in ... Read more »

U.S. House committee backs contempt report on Trump aide Bannon

© Reuters/JAMES LAWLER DUGGAN FILE PHOTO: Former White House chief strategist Steve Bannon departs after testifying in the criminal trial of Roger Stone, former campaign advisor to U.S. President Donald ... Read more »

Trump aims to countersue sex assault accuser who sued him

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Dec. 5, 2017, file photo, Summer Zervos leaves Manhattan Supreme Court at the conclusion of a hearing in New York. Former ... Read more »

Set up new department to handle low-cost housing maintenance, govt told

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today The government must help upgrade the living conditions of families staying at low-cost housing projects, says Chang Kim Loong. PETALING JAYA: A house buyers’ ... Read more »

Boy Scout abuse survivor recounts horror for first time, says settlement is ‘massive step forward'

“Patrick” had wanted to join the Boy Scouts at a young age, but the abuse caused him to lose his faith and more. Ted S. Warren/AP A former Boy Scout ... Read more »

Only 30 schools in pilot run of in-person classes

AMID preparations to physically reopen schools for the conduct of limited face-to-face classes, only 30 schools have been determined by the Department of Education (DepEd) to implement a pilot implementation ... Read more »

PITC to return P2 billion unused funds this month

© STAR/File PITC to return P2 billion unused funds this month MANILA, Philippines — The state-run Philippine International Trading Corp. (PITC) has committed to return to the national treasury close ... Read more »

Private sector seeks accelerated vax rollout

© AFP / Ted Aljibe Private sector seeks accelerated vax rollout MANILA, Philippines — At a recent Task Force T3 meeting, recommendations were shared to accelerate vaccination rollout. Acceleration of ... Read more »

Two men dead after daylight Sydney shooting

Two members of the Hamze family have died after a public shooting in Sydney’s south-west this morning At around 8.55am, emergency services found two men in a ute on Osgood ... Read more »

Releasing in patch 1.0.3, New World server transfer feature is rolling out waves

Server transfers have finally arrived in New World in patch 1.0.3. Players in Amazon Games’ MMO have waited patiently for this feature to arrive since the game launched. However, most ... Read more »

No sentence reduction for man convicted in 2015 Texas attack

FILE – This undated file photo provided by the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Department shows Abdul Malik Abdul Kareem. A judge on Tuesday, Oct. 19, 2021, refused to reduce the 30-year ... Read more »

Bayfield County judge sets trial for man accused of Tri-County Corridor thefts

Oct. 19—A trial date has been set for mid-November for the man accused of stealing funds from the Tri-County Corridor Commission during his tenure as director. Scott A. Williams, 60, ... Read more »

Officers find body in bushes near a Miramar apartment while searching for missing teenager

Miramar police officers were searching an apartment complex Tuesday afternoon for a missing 18-year-old when they discovered a body in the bushes, according to police. Authorities did say whether the ... Read more »

As migrants leave Valley, officials say security up, situation getting better

© Provided by The Indian Express THE administration has stepped up police presence and security in areas inhabited by migrant labourers in Kashmir, though their sheer size and spread in ... Read more »

Chandigarh man caught with 280kg ganja awarded 20-year jail

© Provided by Hindustan Times The accused’s pleas of being the father of four children, sole breadwinner and first-time offender failed to get leniency from the court. (Getty Images/iStockphoto) Reiterating ... Read more »

Brian Cashman: Aaron Boone ‘part of the solution' for Yankees

After four straight postseason berths — and four more years without a World Series appearance — Yankees general manager Brian Cashman said Tuesday that Aaron Boone “is part of the ... Read more »

Sidhu gets back to work, leaves for Vaishno Devi

© Provided by The Indian Express AFTER ROUNDS of meetings with Congress top leaders, and an assurance that Punjab Advocate General, appointed last month, would be replaced, state party chief ... Read more »

Odisha teacher's belongings found; charred remains sent for DNA test

© Provided by The Indian Express Eleven days after a 24-year-old school teacher went missing, police recovered her ornaments and other belongings along with charred remains from an under-construction stadium ... Read more »

Centre assures fertiliser for Punjab within 3-4 days

© Provided by The Indian Express The Centre on Tuesday assured to supply 10 rakes of DAP (diammonium phosphate), five rakes of NPK (complex fertiliser) and two rakes of SSP ... Read more »

Biden's pick to lead CBP gets grilled during Senate confirmation hearing

President Biden’s nominee to head Customs and Border Protection wouldn’t call the surge of migrants at the border a “crisis” and came under intense questioning about his plans to take control of ... Read more »

Employers gear-up for NSW recovery

Job ads posted on the internet soared by 16.7 per cent for positions in NSW in September as employers prepared for the state’s reopening after a lengthy coronavirus lockdown. © ... Read more »

Vic hospitality fury over vax confusion

Melbourne pubs are “furious” about mixed messaging from the Victorian government on hospitality worker vaccinations, with many potentially staying closed when the city reopens, the Australian Hotels Association Victoria says.  © ... Read more »

10 Cult-Favorite Fall Perfumes to Enhance Your Autumn

© Vogue That zing of crisp air and those brilliantly colored leaves mean at long last, autumn is here—and with it come fall perfumes that, with a strategic spritz, will ... Read more »

Richmond health officials hopeful COVID-19 vaccine supply for kids 5-11 won't become an issue

RICHMOND, Va. (WWBT) – Richmond health leaders are working with The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, as well as the Virginia Department of Health, to get vaccine supply for ... Read more »

U.S. COVID-19 death toll tops 726,000 amid report FDA is set to allow mix-and-match vaccine booster shots

© robyn beck/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images CORONAVIRUS UPDATE The U.S. death toll from the coronavirus-borne illness COVID-19 rose above 726,000 on Tuesday, as a report indicated the Food and Drug Administration ... Read more »

FDA will reportedly allow mixing different COVID shots. What to know

Members of an advisory panel to the US Food and Drug Administration voted unanimously on Friday to recommend boosters for everyone who received Johnson & Johnson’s one-dose COVID-19 vaccine, one ... Read more »