Lessons from the Virus and doing development differently

Whilst there was more than one reason for China in late March 2020 to abandon setting a target for GDP growth-the most familiar indicator of development- for the first time in decades, it did foreground the role and importance of development in debates and sense making around Covid-19.

VOV, VOVworld, lessons, from the Virus, doing development, differently, lessons, from the Virus, doing development, differently Dr Michael Spann

School of Political Science and International Studies, University of Queensland

With the effects of the pandemic continuing to resonate, socially, politically and economically the current pandemic can be seen as an opportunity to hit the ‘reset button’ on development and engage in critical insight around what is needed to build more inclusive institutions and communities and ‘do development differently’. In short, Covid-19 may be a catalyst to question the climb up the ‘development ladder’ towards an ‘ideal type’ of modernisation at the expense of social and ecological relations. If the pandemic is considered as a highly visible warning shot across humanity’s bow due to prioritising economic growth premised on a narrow conception of development, it is indeed time for actionable conversations about development between policy makers, donors, the private sector, scholars and communities.

This is especially because ‘planetary health’ experts consider the continuing negative changes to the structure and function of the Earth’s natural systems to be a growing and recurring threat to human health (Whitmee et al 2015). Moreover, one major challenge identified by eminent ‘planetary health’ scholars is a conceptual one. That is, the over reliance on GDP as a measure of progress and development leading to externalising environmental harms and current and future health for present day economic gains. Whilst this is not a new finding, the integration of human health, environmental sustainability and development has been brought to the forefront by the Covid-19 pandemic, especially in regard to the emergence of the virus.

The New Normal?

Beyond the finger pointing, blaming and conspiracy theories around Covid-19, examining the emergence of Covid-19 through the lens of development and political economy uncovers two things. Firstly, the connection between health and environmental sustainability and secondly, why pandemics like Covid-19 could become the ‘new normal’. This ‘new normal’ is because the virus did not emerge in a vacuum but can be seen as a consequence of the deepening of market centred growth and globalisation expanding into new frontiers. Thus, the analysis and focus on the culture of the Chinese eating ‘wild animals’ (which also happens around the world) makes the political-economic drivers of the emergence of the virus invisible.

These political-economic drivers help to illustrate China’s ‘second leap’ in its march towards modernisation in the 1990’s led towards a rapid expansion of agricultural production. Part of this was the ‘livestock revolution’ where China’s livestock population almost tripled. Following a well-worn path of development, industrial food conglomerates emerged as did investment opportunities for both domestic and foreign capital as pork and poultry was packed into ‘factory farms’. As has happened in ‘factory farms’ in ‘developed countries, pandemic potential due to a lack of genetic diversity in industrially farmed livestock increased (e.g. forms of avian flu) but the agricultural expansion also had some far reaching social and economic impacts that underpin the current pandemic (Wallace 2016).

As had been the case in other countries as they climbed the development ladder, independent smallholders-especially in the pork and poultry sectors- were forced out of the market due to the liberalisation of the economy, government subsidies and lax environmental regulations. Quite simply, their traditional crop and livestock production system became economically unviable (Bai et al 2018). Apart from those who chose to become contract farmers to one of industrial food conglomerates, other farmers found the only way to make a living was to raise local breeds and wild species to sell (Fearnley 2018). Increasing shortages of land near the expanded farms also meant more people were pushed to live closer to forests and use them to make a living. This increased contact between humans and wildlife and land clearing compounded by changed livelihood strategies involving wild animals increased the risk of the emergence of zoonotic diseases-ones that jump from animals to humans.

It is also important to note that 3 out of every 4 new or emerging infectious diseases in people come from animals. In other words, the political and economic drivers of the increased risk of pandemics, that is, people seeking new livelihood strategies are extremely important to consider as they are found globally. In short, economic and political factors connected to development are some of the reasons people turn to activities like poaching, animal trafficking and illegal mining to make a living. This is course leads to more degradation of ecosystems and chances for virus spillover events. Worryingly, reports from many countries indicate such illegal activities and resulting deforestation has been on the increase since the onset of Covid-19 due to a lack of government presence, economic pressure and increased urban-rural migration as people seek refuge in isolated places that can still provide the opportunity to make a living.

Ironically, many people returning to rural areas from cities had previously been pushed out of rural areas by the effects of development activities like the expansion of industrial agriculture. Even if it is accepted that ecological changes, clearing of habitat and creating pathways for virus spillover events between species have led to increased rates of emerging diseases, development strategies like the industrial expansion of agriculture and their associated environmental and social dislocations are still seen as viable to help people on the pathway out of poverty and for countries to climb the ‘development ladder’.

As such, more ‘Disease X’s’-the name given to unknown pathogens by the WHO that can cause serious international harm- might indeed become the ‘new normal’ unless we heed this wake-up call and consider other conceptions of development and ways of living that consider the well-being of individuals, communities and nature.

Well-being and taking a pause

Even as the above might suggest all doom and gloom, this is not the whole story. Amidst the continued economic, social and political shocks of the pandemic, many people have taken the opportunity to pause, to live a little slower than normal, and rediscover and reconsider. When images of people marvelling at Himalayan peaks not seen for decades because of pollution made headlines around the world this created ‘discursive space’ around the quality of life that comes from a healthier environment and how to achieve this whilst also having an economy to benefit from in various ways- not just economically as a passive participant.

Whilst such images might just be considered clickbait they can also transfer into individuals and communities asking for more input around policy decisions on projects that affect natural ecosystems – such as major energy or transport infrastructure projects and industrial-scale farming.

In the UK, a large number of people worried by disruptions to global supply chains turned to gardening which has led to more social cohesion, a feeling of community and not just being consumers. Some people for the first time as well considered the inequalities and dependency on global supply chains which, as has been shown, can be greatly disrupted by workers getting sick at distribution and food processing centres; at borders and ports where new protocols have been imposed, and at airports where grounded flights are no longer available to carry fresh produce.

Even in Solomon Islands (where there have been no cases) a group I work with-The Bushmen Farming Network- took the opportunity presented by Covid-19 to highlight people’s growing dependence on imported food like rice and instant noodles and initiated projects around rediscovering local food and sustainable cultivation techniques. This will have long term development impact as people will be informed by values, social relations and practices that were being forgotten in the relentless need to bolster GDP. Ironically, the global economic and social shocks of Covid-19 might be a catalyst to harness a wider range of values and practices to build a more inclusive and equitable future.

Resources used

Bai et al. (2018), China’s livestock transition: Driving forces, impacts, and consequences. Science Advances: 1-11.

Fearnley, L. (2018), After the livestock revolution: Free-grazing ducks and influenza uncertainties in South China. Medicine Anthropology Theory 5 (3): 72–98

Wallace, R. (2016), Big Farms Make Big Flu: Dispatches on Infectious Disease, Agribusiness, and the Nature of Science. NYU Press.

Whitmee et al. (2015), Safeguarding human health in the Anthropocene epoch: report of The Rockefeller Foundation–Lancet Commission on planetary health. The Lancet 386 (10007) 1973-2028

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Brazilian film week to take place in Hanoi

Brazilian film week to take place in Hanoi The event will be held by the Brazilian Embassy in Vietnam. The movies include Nise: The Heart of Madness, Jules and Dolores, Trinta, Rio 2096:… Read more »

First Vietnam International Photography Festival to take place in Ninh Binh

First Vietnam International Photography Festival (Source: VNA) The Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism has decided to hold the first ever Vietnam International Photography Festival. The event comprises a competition to select a… Read more »

Bac Ninh organizes exhibition on Vietnam’s National Assembly

Visitors at the exhibition (Photo: bacninh.gov.vn) The exhibition displayed more than 500 photos and artifacts, which are divided into 3 main parts: the first general election to elect the National Assembly (NA) of… Read more »

More pre-1975 villas in Ho Chi Minh City added to preservation list

The old Phuong Nam villa, one of the city’s most well-known buildings of its type, is on the list of ancient villas that need preservation. (Photo: sggp.org.vn) The buildings, which have historical, cultural… Read more »

Young Vietnamese man infatuated with Origami

By choosing traditional Vietnamese paper to complete his new Origami models, Nguyen Nam Son has put Vietnam on the global map. Like other people who have a passion for Origami, which is the Japanese… Read more »

Fighting rings once popular public events in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta

Before 1975, when Vietnam was reunified, Go Cong – nowadays Tien Giang Province in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta – was a hub for well-attended martial arts exhibitions, which appealed to highly-skilled fighters from famed… Read more »

Empty streets of Hoi An after COVID-19 new cases detected

No one can be spotted on the pedestrian zone in Hoi An Town. The town that had been bustling with tourists during freshly-concluded break for public holidays fell silent following the municipal government’s… Read more »

Woman collects garbage in 39 out of Vietnam's 63 provinces

At the age of 33, Giang Thi Kim Cuc could have bought an apartment already if she had not spent so much money on courses in environmental protection and human resources management. The… Read more »

International community criticize China's acts of destabilizing East Sea

China’s continued deployment of ships in the East Sea has been criticized by the international community (Photo: AFP) The Philippines has sent two more diplomatic protests to China, saying that the continued swarming… Read more »

International community criticize China's new moves in East Sea

China’s continued deployment of ships in the East Sea has been criticized by the international community (Photo: AFP) The Philippines has sent two more diplomatic protests to China, saying that the continued swarming… Read more »

Over 20-year-old pho cuon eatery

Located in Ngu Xa area Ba Dinh district, Chinh Thang restaurant has been famous for pho cuon. It is known as the first place in the city to offer the food, also a… Read more »

Vietnamese woman works to involve ethnic minority farmers in clean agriculture

After several years of trial and error, Huynh Thi Quoc Tri has successfully equipped rural farmers, including ethnic minority households in central Vietnam, with the skills they need for a transition to clean farming. Tri,… Read more »

Vietnamese theatre to perform famous Greek tragedy at online Asian festival

Set in a mythical era, Prince Oedipus defies the fate of “killing his father and marrying his mother” and becomes King, only to face the most horrible test he could ever imagine. Photo… Read more »

Close-up look at Dien Bien Phu Campaign panorama painting

The section that describes citizens going to the battle. (Photo: VNA) The Frech Army’s attack. (Photo: VNA) The scene shows Vietnamese soldiers pulling the cannon into the battlefield, demonstrated by both painting and… Read more »

Vietnam Children’s Fine Arts Awards 2021 to be organized

Entries should reflect love for the nation, daily life of the children and their love for Uncle Ho, grandparents, parents and families, among others. Photo for illustration It aims to encourage and facilitate… Read more »

Recipe: Watermelon ice-cream for a cool and fresh summer - Video

Watermelon ice-cream is easy to make. The ingredients do not include milk and dairy products, so it is suitable for those who want to stay in good shape. Watermelon is rich in vitamin… Read more »

Rescue soldiers save suicidal girl from jumping off 18th floor, with video

(Video: VTV) At around 11 a.m. on May 2, residents at Duc Khai apartment building in Ho Chi Minh City’s District 7 noticed what looked like a potentially suicidal woman sitting on the… Read more »

Woman makes unique 'Vietnamese style' bento boxes

Despite living in Japan for over two decades, Yamamoto Chihiro (Phuong in Vietnamese) has never been able to forget the delicate, fragrant flavors of the Vietnam of her youth. It is with this… Read more »

“True Italian Taste” 2021 promotes Italian cuisine in Vietnam

Over the years, “True Italian Taste” events have been held in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City with diverse activities, including workshops and seminars, incoming business and training activities, master classes, and events… Read more »

Bien Ho, a freshwater lake 800 meters above sea level

Sea Lake is a natural freshwater lake located seven kilometres northwest of Pleiku city center and 800 meters above sea level. It actually encompasses two connected lakes in the middle of a pine… Read more »

Late-night eating: a pleasure of Hanoians

Wandering around Hanoi at night, you will stray into another world of the capital city. It is not as busy as during the day time but still lively with restaurants opening late.  The… Read more »

Grilled pork in bamboo tube, a specialty of the Central Highlands

A: Hello! Welcome to this week’s edition of VOV 24/7’s“Food delight”. We’re A and B, very happy to be on the air with you. B: Hello, guys and gals. Did you know that… Read more »

Bolo de Rolo of Brazil

Roll cake ”. This is a typical Brazilian dessert, from the State of Pernambuco. The cake dough is made with flour, eggs, butter and sugar (Photo: https: //blogs.transparent.com/portuguese/brazilian-recipe-bolo-de-rolo/) Phuong Khanh: Hello, guys and… Read more »

Boro de Rolo of Brazil

Roll cake ”. This is a typical Brazilian dessert, from the State of Pernambuco. The cake dough is made with flour, eggs, butter and sugar (Photo: https: //blogs.transparent.com/portuguese/brazilian-recipe-bolo-de-rolo/) Phuong Khanh: Hello, guys and… Read more »

Quang Binh caves get surreally real under photographic light

Early last month, HCMC-based Trung joined a group on a two-day tour to explore the two caves that are part of the cave system in the Phong Nha – Ke Bang National Park.… Read more »

Khuc Pie: A gift from Hanoi’s rural area

At the end of the 19th century, Hanoi was already famed for its cuisine, but then, as today, the best-known dishes were not found in large restaurants or at fancy feasts, street stalls… Read more »

Duck braised with dracontomelon

Chi: Welcome to VOV24/7’s Food Delight with recipes and cooking tips. I’m Kim Chi, your host. Today, let’s join a class at EZCooking, a well-known cooking center in Hanoi to learn how to… Read more »

Sidewalk iced tea - an indispensable part of Hanoians' life

Modest shops of sidewalk iced tea and groups of people enjoying their glass of the drink are an ordinary part of the capital city but memorable to many people.  A simple beverage Perhaps… Read more »

The project of “Map of Vietnam’s culinary tourism” launched

The Vietnam Restaurant Association in cooperation with Vietnam Cuisine Culture Association and World Food Travel Association will undertake the project entitled “Map of Vietnam’s Culinary Tourism”. The project launching ceremony took place on… Read more »

Four Vietnamese restaurants listed among “Asia’s 50 best restaurants 2021”

The renown global website www.theworlds50best.com has just released its annual “Asia’s 50 best restaurants 2021” list called “Essence of Asia” collection.  Four restaurants from Vietnam are on the list, including Pho Bat Dan… Read more »

Vietnamese exquisite herbs and spices

Vietnamese cuisine is a happy blend of influences and a variety of different styles. The country was ruled for differing periods by China and France, and local dining borrowed some of the best… Read more »

Arousing the taste buds

When you are ravenously hungry, what dish do you yearn for most? The French salivate about a bowl of onion soup, the Chinese about chicken soup and the Japanese would probably go for… Read more »

The main rituals in the Lunar New Year Festival

Farewell to Kitchen God Land Genie and the Kitchen God ride carps to Heaven to deliver an annual report on the household’s activities to the Jade Emperor. Photo: Tet feast to farewell Kitchen God… Read more »

New unique Banh Chung attracts diners

Amid socio-economic development, traditional food is still kept and enjoyed. In addition, there has been renovation and creativity based on the tradition for new delicious dishes that are welcome. Banh Chung (traditional rice… Read more »

‘Pho’ - a Hanoian's exquisite cuisine

A simple pleasure The weather turns harsh, the chill of winter penetrates, and it is to soups and stews and comforting ritual meal we turn with gratitude. And it’s the time for Hanoi… Read more »

Vietnamese specialties: Someone’s loves, other’s horrors

According to travel’s expert Fabienne Fong Yan, some Vietnamese typical dishes such as Trung vit lon (fertilized duck egg), Chan ga (chicken feet) or Tiet canh (blood soup) might make foreign travellers feel… Read more »

Trang Cat Village of Dong Leaf bustling at the end of the year

Visiting Trang Cat village, Kim An commune (Thanh Oai district, Hanoi) these days, everywhere is covered with the green color of Dong (Phrynium placentarium) leaves, typical wrapper for Banh Chung (traditional sticky rice… Read more »

Anyone has tasted all the street food of Hanoi?

When people from all over the country settled down in Thang Long – Hanoi, they brought the best food from their homeland. As the nation’s capital and a trading hub, Hanoi is also… Read more »

Quang Nam incense village prepares for Tet rush

Du Van Nhan, whose family has been making incense sticks in the village for three generations, dries raw materials in front of his home. Nearly a month before the Lunar New Year holiday,… Read more »

Tuong: Vietnamese fermented soybean jam

A: Welcome to this week’s “Food delight” with a recipe to help you diversify your menu. We’re A and B, and we’re always happy to be here to share some recipes with you.… Read more »

A memorization of time

Whatever it serves, a funky and relaxing place to restore physical and mental function after hard working day in the bustling capital will always be popular.  “Mon bung pho co” or “Hanoi old… Read more »

Dien Pomelo – the meaningful valuable gift for Tet holiday

A precious gift from nature A 30-year-old tree of Dien Pomelo in Phu Dien ward, Bac Tu Liem district, Hanoi/ Photo: Thoi Nguyen Dien Pomelo or the pomelo planted in Dien village of… Read more »

What makes “Banh mi” different from worldwide sandwich?

You could find Banh mi wherever you go and every seller would somehow use different ingredients from others. The mixed flavor between continents, regions In Vietnam you see carts on the side of the… Read more »

An ancient house a modern mystery in Vietnam’s northern highlands

Less than 3 km from the Sa Phin junction in Dong Van District, this ancient house keeps to itself in Ha Sung Village, Lung Tao Commune. It has an appearance that is quite… Read more »

Hanoi specialty: Tasty dishes prepared from snails

As the windy cold winter arrives, it’s the best time for one of the Hanoi specialties – the snail.  The popular food of hard-shell mollusk, which lives in muddy areas like ponds or… Read more »

Soldiers protect fishermen at sea

An officer of Naval Region 1 Command gives the national flag and a gift to fishermen (Photo: VOV) During the rough maritime season at the year’s end, the fishermen of Thuy Nguyen district,… Read more »

A menu with soft-shell turtles

(Photo: Vi Xua restaurant) A: Welcome to VOV24/7’s “Food Delight”, the show that shares cooking tips and recipes from great chefs. B: On today’s show we meet again chef Nguyen Van Hoang from… Read more »

Banh cuon Cao Bang, a must-try dish in Hanoi

Originally from Cao Bang province in the mountainous northeast of Vietnam, the specialty of this group of Tay ethnic minorities has gradually cemented its position on the Hanoi cuisine map. Different with other… Read more »

Autumn must-try foods for visitors to Hanoi

Snacks are not only the typical taste of Hanoi’s autumn but they are also an indispensable part of the capital’s charm. Let’s explore the list of foods that visitors to the capital should… Read more »

Metropole Hanoi unveils new mooncake flavors

(Photo: The Sofitel Legend Metropole Hanoi) Reporter: We are glad to have here Mr. Anthony Slewka, Director of Sales & Marketing for the Metropole, who will tell us more about the new mooncakes.… Read more »