Learning Loss Doesn’t Begin to Describe What Happened

learning loss doesn’t begin to describe what happened
© John J. Custer

On March 4, 2020, a week before the World Health Organization formally declared the coronavirus a global pandemic, Northshore School District, in Washington State, closed its doors, becoming the first in the country to announce a districtwide shift to online learning. Within three weeks, every public-school building in the United States had been closed and 50 million students had been sent home. Half of these students would not reenter their schools for more than a year. No other high-income country in the world relied to such a great extent on remote instruction. The coronavirus caused by far the biggest disruption in the history of American education. Neither the Great Depression nor even the two World Wars imposed anything close to as drastic a change in how America’s schoolchildren spent their days.

Adulthood is stasis: Any year in one’s 50s tends to be much like the next. But childhood is growth, and when schools closed, they shut children out of the place where much of this growth happens. Some of the lost growth was academic and social, as school closures cut children off from teachers and friends. These losses were compounded by children’s exclusion from an array of other goods and services. In the United States, almost all public services for school-age children in some way run through schools. Schools provide nutrition; dental care; nursing services; mental-health care; physical, occupational, and speech therapy; child care for teen parents; referrals to social workers and child-welfare agencies; and laundry facilities and clothing for homeless students. Even in an era of mass shootings and COVID outbreaks, schools are the safest place for children. Moreover, schools don’t just serve the children who attend them. They also provide child care for parents and create social, cultural, and political hubs for communities.

[Kelsey Ko: Classroom time isn’t the only thing students have lost]

Conventional accounts of the effect of school closures focus on the shift from in-person to online teaching and the academic losses that resulted. This familiar story isn’t false, but it’s only a part of the truth, and it understates both the disruption and the inequities that COVID wrought on students’ lives. When schools closed, all the goods that they provide became suddenly scarcer, and children and families who relied most on public provision of these goods suffered a cascade of harms that touched virtually every aspect of their lives. The disruption the coronavirus has caused to schoolchildren will ripple through the future of the COVID generation. Unfinished learning may turn out to be the easiest of these losses to cure.

A complete reckoning begins by explaining precisely how school closures affected children’s daily lives. For many students, physical school wasn’t replaced with Zoom school. Rather, physical school closures meant no school—literally none at all, for days and even weeks on end.

National surveys of teachers by the EdWeek Research Center, for example, reported that nearly a quarter of students ended the 2020 spring semester “essentially truant.” In Los Angeles, the situation was even more dire: Four in 10 students simply failed to participate regularly in remote-learning programs during the first pandemic spring.

[Read: The biggest problem for America’s schools]

Zoom school in many cases amounted to no school in the next year as well. According to our best estimate, by the time schools let out for summer in May or June 2021, the average American public-school student had experienced 65 school days without any contact whatsoever from their schools or teachers—no in-person classes, no Zoom classes, no video conferences, no telephone calls. That’s more than a third of a school year without schooling, full stop.

The losses, moreover, weren’t evenly distributed. Richer kids got more in-person schooling than poorer kids. And even when they were physically locked out of buildings, richer kids got more, and more effective, Zoom schooling than poorer kids. In public schools, students with household incomes below $25,000 experienced about 76 days, or nearly half a school year, without schooling at all. Students with household incomes above $200,000, in contrast, lost about 54 days—still considerable, but roughly a month less lost schooling than their lower-income peers.

Many elite private schools, meanwhile, avoided pandemic-related schooling loss almost entirely. Of the Forbes top 20 private schools, our research found that 14 met fully in person for the entire 2020–21 school year. Even when they closed their buildings, elite private schools had an easier time facilitating remote instruction thanks to low student-teacher ratios and access (for both students and teachers) to technology.

Overall, the overwhelmingly rich kids who attend private schools had both less and better remote schooling. And private-school parents surveyed in February 2021, unsurprisingly, were twice as likely as public-school parents to report that their children were developing very well. The rich also voted with their feet: Independent schools reported increased enrollment over the course of the pandemic.

Lost schooling shows up as “unfinished” academic learning, measured according to standardized test scores. Even in schools that closed only in spring 2020 and reopened more or less on time the following fall, students a full year later were about two months behind academically where they would have normally been. And when schools stayed closed longer, students fell even further behind, with the poorest students losing out the most. High-poverty schools faced the greatest obstacles to effective online education—including sometimes having trouble making any contact with students at all. Students in high-poverty schools that remained physically closed for the majority of the 2020–21 school year fell more than a full semester behind as measured by standardized tests administered nationwide.

Lost academic opportunities bleed into life beyond the classroom, including most immediately by influencing post-high-school plans. Once again, this harm was concentrated among low-income students: In national surveys, nearly half of low-income high-school graduates in the class of 2020 reported changed future education plans because of the pandemic, compared with about one-quarter of students who had never been eligible for free- or reduced-price meals. Changed plans lead to changed futures. Community colleges, which disproportionately serve low-income and first-generation college students, experienced a stunning 12 percent enrollment drop in the fall of 2020 compared with the year prior; community-college enrollment in California fell even further, with Black and Latino students suffering the worst declines. Historically Black, predominantly minority, and tribal colleges and universities all also experienced significant enrollment declines during the 2020–21 academic year. By contrast, in some cases, enrollment in predominantly white colleges and universities declined at far lower rates, and selective four-year colleges, which disproportionately serve wealthy students, saw enrollment rise.

[Thomas Kane: Kids are far, far behind in school]

Standardized test results and college-enrollment figures create visible measures of learning loss. But schooling loss during the height of the pandemic inevitably hurt children in other ways, too. Parents, teachers, doctors, and students themselves all see harms that can be hard to measure and resist a simple summing up, but they aren’t any less important.

Most immediately, a year of Zoom school unavoidably meant more screen time and less exercise. One study showed that increased screen time triggered a spike in childhood myopia diagnoses for kids ages 6 to 8. Because many low-income students depend on their schools to provide free- or reduced-price breakfast and lunch, they and their families experienced heightened food insecurity whenever schools closed during the pandemic (and non-school-based meal programs proved to be inadequate replacements). Some children—especially low-income, Black, and Latino students—went hungry, and for many more, empty calories replaced nutritious foods. Even just a few months into the pandemic, as children exercised less and ate worse, their risk of obesity increased. Once again, these harms fell hardest on children from marginalized families. In one study, public-school students were 1.5 times as likely to report decreased physical fitness as private-school students; in another study, kids whose schools had closed were two times more likely to spend less time outside and to get less exercise than kids whose schools stayed open.

Other aspects of children’s physical health also suffered. Schools form a bridge between families and the health-care system by, for instance, encouraging vaccinations against childhood communicable diseases. The CDC now assesses that among pandemic-era kindergartners, the rates of routine vaccinations for potentially fatal diseases such as measles and diphtheria have fallen below the threshold required for herd immunity (from 95 to 94 percent). Schools also normally provide dental-care access to an estimated 1 million Medicaid-enrolled children. Over the course of the pandemic, parents with Medicaid were almost four times as likely as parents with private insurance to report that they couldn’t get any dentist appointments for their children.

Shutting children out of schools (especially when Zoom school meant no school) put intense pressure on their emotional well-being. A CDC survey of high-school students from January to June 2021 found that nearly half had “felt persistently sad or hopeless” over the previous year—a 20 percent jump since 2019—and an astonishing one-fifth had “seriously considered attempting suicide,” representing a smaller but still concerning 5 percent increase over pre-pandemic levels. These average rates were even worse for girls, who also had higher rates of emergency-room visits and suicide attempts. Adolescents also reported skyrocketing rates of emotional and physical abuse at home during the pandemic. According to one study, teenagers’ self-reported rates of parental emotional abuse were four times higher during the pandemic than in 2013, and rates of parental physical abuse nearly doubled. Figures such as these have led the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, and the Children’s Hospital Association to declare a national emergency in child and adolescent mental health.

School guidance counselors also noticed a pronounced shift in students’ mental health. In a survey conducted by The New York Times, 94 percent reported increased signs of anxiety and depression, 88 percent reported observing increased difficulties with emotional self-regulation, and 73 percent reported that students had greater difficulties in solving conflicts with friends. One survey participant from a high school in Portland, Oregon, summed up the situation: “I’ve seen more physical fights this year than in my 15 years combined.” These impressions are bolstered by district data; in Denver public schools, for instance, fights were up 21 percent in the fall of 2021 over pre-pandemic levels. Strikingly, high schoolers who felt connected to somebody at their school—whether a peer or an adult such as a teacher or a guidance counselor—reported much lower rates of mental distress and suicidal thoughts. School closures, however, broke these protective connections and left the most vulnerable children most isolated.

The stresses of pandemic parenting are by now familiar, and the role that school closures play in producing them is dramatic. In one CDC survey, parents whose children’s schools had closed were nearly twice as likely to report concerns about job stability, child-care challenges, and difficulty sleeping as parents whose children’s schools remained fully open for in-person learning. The strains that school closures imposed on teachers were, if anything, greater still. The pandemic required teachers to work in unfamiliar and enormously stressful ways, without much training, adequate support, or even basic health safeguards (including personal protective equipment). Educators in many districts had to—and still have to—contend with chronic staffing shortages, leading to expanded class sizes and reduced or eliminated planning periods.

Parents’ and teachers’ interests were sometimes pitted against each other as communities and school boards navigated the tension between the educational needs of students, on the one hand, and workplace safety on the other. And they had to navigate this tension when the communal hub where teachers, students, and parents usually come together to talk things through—the school—was closed.

[Read: The pandemic broke a fundamental principle of teaching]

Many factors are no doubt driving the rise in aggression at school-board meetings over topics as diverse as mask mandates, race, gender, sexuality, history, civics, and even social-emotional learning. But school closures and all that they entailed surely haven’t helped. Nor are their effects likely to recede anytime soon. Parents remain stressed out and even enraged, while teachers are demoralized and burned out. Many educators fear a wave of teacher resignations. If the wave does come, pandemic school closures could continue long after the direct threat of COVID has receded.

One lesson of the pandemic is that, for all their inadequacies, schools do work, and for all their inequities, they provide a more equal setting than the worlds they draw children out of. Kids need to be in school—for their academic learning and for their health and safety. Parents need kids to be in school to do their jobs and keep their sanity. And communities need kids to be in school to sustain their solidarity.

Curing the many harms that school closures have imposed will take money—a lot of it. The $190 billion in federal pandemic-relief funds allocated to schools is barely enough to address the unfinished academic learning that dominates conventional narratives of pandemic schooling, let alone all the other challenges that students and teachers face.

A broad cure will also take a lot of imagination: to find new and better ways to deliver the many services that now run through physical presence specifically in schools. Effectively delivering these services will require flexibility and resilience, not least because school closures will likely continue. In just the past two years, and apart from COVID, schools have closed their doors because of wildfires, floods, violence or threats of violence, teacher and bus-driver shortages, strikes, and budget shortfalls.

Despite all the losses just rehearsed, the pandemic years also reveal some better approaches to post-pandemic schooling. They have driven states and districts to experiment with decoupling the delivery of family services from physical presence inside school buildings. In Mississippi, for example, State Superintendent of Education Carey Wright told us in an email that she collaborated “with the medical community over 18 months” to direct $17.6 million in federal funding to expand telehealth and teletherapy for students statewide, bringing new “on-site physical and mental health services to our students and communities, including those in rural areas.”

Another lesson of the pandemic is that it will pay to diversify the schools that kids are in. Different kids experience school in different ways, so although all kids need to be in school, not all kids need to be in school in exactly the same way. Every educator can tell stories of academic successes during Zoom school among students who are shy or have social anxiety, who suffer from illnesses or disabilities that make attending school difficult, who live in unstable circumstances, who have special talents, or who need on occasion to work or care for others during the school day.

Even Zoom school, for all its many challenges, has shown that children and families can be served in multiple ways, not all of which require attending school in person, five days a week, for six or seven hours a day. Although the experiment worked poorly for many students, it did work well for some.

The pandemic has amounted to a comprehensive assault on the American public school. It strained the ties—not just physical but also social and even psychological—that connect American families and children to the schools that are essential for delivering almost every support our welfare state provides. Kids missed out on all of it while schools were closed: not just academic learning but also nutrition, and exercise, and friendship networks, and stable relationships with caring adults, and health care, and access to social workers, and even the attention, at home, of parents unburdened by the need to provide child care during school hours.

School closures withdrew these services and supports in an era when Americans, and especially young Americans, were already losing faith in their institutions, and when community ties were already fraying. These abstractions have concrete consequences: Even as independent schools have increased enrollment, the nation’s public schools have lost more than 1 million students since 2020, and the districts that stayed remote the longest have suffered the biggest losses. In effect, millions of Americans are rejecting the central mechanism through which American society supports its children across all facets of their lives.

The disruption that the pandemic caused to American children’s lives has no historical precedent; the harms that this disruption has imposed on them, taken all together, are similarly large. Our response needs to be on a scale sufficient to meet the harms that students have already endured—and to create a more resilient system to meet future challenges, whether new variants of concern, climate-change-driven displacement, or other threats. We have barely begun.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Maxine Waters on SCOTUS abortion ruling: ‘The hell with the Supreme Court’

© Provided by The Hill Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) declared “the hell with the Supreme Court” after its justices ruled on Friday to eliminate federal-level abortion protections, overturning a 50-year ... Read more »

Aftershock in Afghanistan as Earthquake Toll Rises to 1,150 Dead

Overstretched aid agencies said the disaster underscored the need for the international community to rethink its financial cut-off of Afghanistan Read more »

Hannity: Supreme Court ruling sends abortion back to the states, where it belongs

Sean Hannity outlines the facts on the Supreme Court’s ruling on abortion and what this means for the states on “Hannity.” HANNITY: THEY HAD TO CREATE A SET OF INSTRUCTIONS ... Read more »

Wildfire Consumes Thousands of Acres, Prompts Evacuations in Palo Pinto County

Texas A&M Forest Service A wildfire in Palo Pinto County has consumed thousands of acres and prompted evacuations, authorities say. The fire, dubbed the Dempsey Fire, consumed 6,500 acres by ... Read more »

Turner homers, Dodgers stop Braves 4-1 in Freeman's return

ATLANTA (AP) — Trea Turner had three hits, including a home run, Freddie Freeman reached base three times in his emotional return to Atlanta and the Los Angeles Dodgers beat ... Read more »

Greinke, Olivares return, power Royals to 3-1 win over A's

KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) — Zach Greinke tossed six innings of one-run ball, Edward Olivares hit two solo homers and the Kansas City Royals beat the Oakland Athletics 3-1 on ... Read more »

Arroyo has three RBIs in return, Red Sox beat Guardians 6-3

CLEVELAND (AP) — Christian Arroyo hit a two-run homer in the seventh and had three RBIs in his return from the COVID-19 injured list, powering the red-hot Boston Red Sox ... Read more »

What is Lawrence v. Texas? The Supreme Court precedent Justice Clarence Thomas suggested reconsidering after overturning Roe v. Wade

1/21 SLIDES © Photo by Yasin Ozturk/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images Live updates: Here are the states where abortion is illegal, protected, or under threat after the Supreme Court overturned ... Read more »

How This Grandma Helped Cops Catch Her Accused Killer

© Provided by The Daily Beast Glendale Police/Facebook Arizona police have arrested a suspect in the shooting death of a 60-year-old food delivery driver—and they say the victim helped crack ... Read more »

Márquez earns 3rd straight win, Rockies shut out Twins 1-0

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Germán Márquez pitched 7 2/3 scoreless innings and the Colorado Rockies edged the Twins 1-0 Friday night in a rare trip to Minnesota. Charlie Blackmon’s run-scoring fielder’s ... Read more »

Rays' Ramirez delivers winning hit in 10th to beat Bucs 4-3

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) — Harold Ramirez scored Vidal Brujan with a game-ending pinch-single in the 10th inning, lifting the Tampa Bay Rays over the Pittsburgh Pirates 4-3 Friday night. ... Read more »

AlphaTauri Confirms Pierre Gasly Will Drive for the F1 Team in 2023

The news comes less than a week after team boss Franz Tost said in a press conference, “He has a valid contract. There’s nothing more to say.” © Provided by ... Read more »

Dodgers' Andrew Heaney placed on IL for second time this season

© Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Andrew Heaney. Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Andrew Heaney is headed back to the injured list for the second time ... Read more »

AOC to Biden: Open abortion clinics on federal lands 'right now'

© Provided by Washington Examiner Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) is leading the call for President Joe Biden to seek workarounds in states that are restricting abortion rights after the Supreme ... Read more »

P.G. Sittenfeld trial: FBI agent confirms political consultant pocketed $15K meant for Cranley campaign

© Provided by WXIX Cincinnati Former Cincinnati City Councilman P.G. Sittenfeld arrives at The Potter Stewart United States Courthouse for the fourth day of his federal public corruption trial Friday, ... Read more »

Verlander pitches Astros to 3-1 win, ends Yanks' home streak

NEW YORK — – Justin Verlander pitched four-hit ball over seven innings, Kyle Tucker hit a three-run homer and the Houston Astros beat the Yankees 3-1 Friday night to stop ... Read more »

Missouri AG Who Banned Abortions Says DOJ’s Response to Roe Protests Is ‘Third World’

© Provided by The Daily Beast via Twitter Hours after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, effectively ending the right for approximately 40 million women and girls nationwide to ... Read more »

Airlines Aim to Shift Blame for Flight Problems to FAA

The FAA shot back, with a reference to taxpayer money that airlines received after the pandemic devastated air travel Read more »

Lindor homers, knocks in 4 as Mets top Marlins 5-3

MIAMI (AP) — Francisco Lindor homered, doubled and drove in four runs to lead the New York Mets past the Miami Marlins 5-3 on Friday night. Mark Canha also went ... Read more »

Michael Bolton Suits Up & Hits High Notes for Daytime Emmy Awards ‘In Memoriam’ Performance

© Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP Michael Bolton Michael Bolton has had a long and successful musical career. The rocker will be performing singing his new song “Beautiful World” at the 2022 Daytime ... Read more »

Police find suspicious device with chemicals, BB pellets at Long Island school

MERRICK, Long Island (WABC) — There was a disturbing discovery at a school on Long Island where police found a suspicious device with chemicals and BB pellets in it. A ... Read more »

Xi to Attend Hong Kong Anniversary Event, Lee’s Swearing-In

© Bloomberg An exhibition marking the 25th anniversary of Hong Kong’s return to Chinese rule in Hong Kong, China, on Wednesday, June 22, 2022. The rising number of Covid cases ... Read more »

Merrick Garland's Mention of the FDA Hints at One Possible Way to Fight Restrictions on Abortion Pills

On the heels of the Supreme Court decision that struck down the national right to abortion, Attorney General Merrick Garland issued a statement proclaiming that the Justice Department disagrees with ... Read more »

Cubs Coach Chris Young Upbeat After ‘Scary' Episode in Pittsburgh

Cubs coach Young in good spirits after medical scare originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago ST. LOUIS — Cubs bullpen coach Chris Young still doesn’t have a diagnosis for the ... Read more »

Garland signals brewing battle with GOP-led states over access to abortion pills

© Provided by NBC News WASHINGTON — Attorney General Merrick Garland indicated Friday that the Justice Department would combat any Republican efforts to restrict access to abortion pills after the ... Read more »

Bruce Willis Spotted on Rare Public Outing With Wife Emma After Aphasia Diagnosis

Bruce Willis is still soaking in the sunshine. The 67-year-old actor was spotted running errands with his wife Emma Heming Willis on June 23 in Los Angeles. For the occasion, ... Read more »

You Can Save Hundreds on Stylish Patio Furniture Right Now at Amazon—Up to 64% Off

© Provided by Food & Wine Patio essentials available on Amazon If you’ve been waiting to upgrade your patio, backyard, or porch with stylish outdoor furniture, now’s the moment: You ... Read more »

US, four others launch initiative aimed at supporting priorities of the Pacific islands

© Provided by The Hill The United States and four other countries on Friday announced an initiative aimed at supporting the priorities of the Pacific Islands region. The initiative, called ... Read more »

Anderson Cooper Reveals How Richard Gere Helped Him Realize He's Gay: 'I Couldn't Speak'

© Provided by People getty (2) Anderson Cooper is opening up about his sexual awakening. The Anderson Cooper 360° host, 55, recounted how meeting a shirtless Richard Gere at age ... Read more »

‘A great loss but not a new one’: Lizzo pledges big bucks for abortion organizations

Lizzo’s putting her money where her mouth is. On Friday, the “Grrrls” singer said that she will donate $500,000 of proceeds from her upcoming fall tour to Planned Parenthood and ... Read more »

Brenner's goal lifts Cincinnati to 1-0 win over Orlando City

CINCINNATI (AP) — Brenner’s goal and Roman Celentano’s three saves led Cincinnati to a 1-0 victory over Orlando City on Friday. Brenner’s game-winner came in the 65th minute for Cincinnati ... Read more »

A Cool Mom’s Guide to What to Do With Kids When Visiting Los Angeles

© Provided by Fodor’s Ask any good traveler, and they’ll tell you that the best part of traveling is getting absorbed into a city’s culture. It’s one thing to go ... Read more »

Roe v. Wade Reversal Draws Protests Friday in North Texas Cities

Link video: http://nbclim-download.edgesuite.net/Prod/NBCU_LM_VMS/982/243/DIT_NAT_TOS_NEWS_NATIONAL_PROTESTS_ROE_V_WADE_20220624_FH__285896.mp4 NBCUniversal Media, LLC About 1,000 abortion rights advocates marched in the streets of downtown Dallas Friday night to protest the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade. ... Read more »

NYC Pride weekend celebration turns into rally cry following the overturn of Roe v Wade

LOWER MANHATTAN, Manhattan (WABC) — Friday’s ruling comes as New York City gets ready to celebrate Pride this weekend – with the Pride March and so many other events. However, ... Read more »

What is causing record floods and heatwaves in China?

© STR Parts of southern China have been hit by record floods Record floods in southern China this month displaced more than half a million people, while searing heat buckled roads ... Read more »

Health department sends inspectors to explore deplorable living conditions at Sterlingshire apartments complex

HOUSTON – The Houston Health Department is now involved in the quest for answers at the Sterlingshire Apartment Complex, and sent several inspectors to the property Friday. This comes as ... Read more »

How the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade impacts Texas

People leaving the state to receive abortion care is nothing new in Texas, ever since the state's Senate Bill 8 took effect in September 2021. Read more »

NBA draft night fashion: Paolo Banchero and the most memorable suits in recent years

The NBA draft is a moment many talented prospects dream of their entire lives, from preparing for team-focused workouts down to the attire they will don on the night of the ... Read more »

How you can easily use passive income to make more money

1/22 SLIDES © DepositPhotos.com Making money while you sleep has a beautiful ring to it I mean, who wouldn’t want to be making some extra money while playing with the ... Read more »

LEADING OFF: Cole leads Yanks against ex-Astros teamamtes

A look at what’s happening around baseball Saturday: ___ REMEMBER WHEN Yankees ace Gerrit Cole (6-1, 3.14 ERA) faces his former team when New York hosts the Houston Astros in ... Read more »