[Law Talk] Trademark issues in the world of the metaverse

Asia's Tech News Daily

[Law Talk] Trademark issues in the world of the metaverse
Lee Keun-woo (left) and Helen H. HwangThe word “metaverse,” a portmanteau of the prefix “meta” (meaning beyond) and “universe,” is typically used to refer to a communal and interactive cyberspace where content, commerce and networking exist with increasing permeability with the real world. With new technical capability and accelerated cultural shift to online due to the COVID-19 crisis, the metaverse is creating innovation that transcends time and space in all areas of industry and society. In particular, gaming, fashion and luxury brand companies are partnering with metaverse platforms to expand their market bases to the virtual world.

In the world of the metaverse, you can easily create a virtual person and a virtual brand, but would it be okay to create anything you want in the world of the metaverse, even items which contain trademarks of others? Imagine that a company intends to create a virtual character to be active on metaverse platform and use items bearing another person’s trademarks for the virtual character. The company may face a range of legal issues.

First, there is a risk of trademark infringement. As a general rule, you may infringe another person’s trademark when you use a mark identical or similar to the trademark on goods identical or similar to the designated goods, and thereby causing consumer confusion. In the context of the metaverse, trademark infringement may occur if (i) items used in the metaverse are “goods” for purposes of the Trademark Act, and (ii) the act of using the trademark registered in the real world on similar or identical items in the metaverse can lead consumers to confusion.

The act of using another person’s trademark in the metaverse may meet those two prongs. For purposes of the Trademark Act, the term “goods” is interpreted to mean “articles which have exchange value” and traded in commerce (Supreme Court Decision 98Hu58). In light of such interpretation, items used in the metaverse may be construed as “goods” as long as they are traded with economic value. Given that various brands such as Gucci, Nike and Puma have recently launched their products in the metaverse by concluding contracts with metaverse platform providers, the act of using a trademark registered for the real world products in a corresponding product in the metaverse may lead consumers to confusion that the product is sold by the trademark owner itself.

If a trademark possesses creativity, it can be eligible for copyright protection in addition to protection as a trademark. The Supreme Court has hold that figures used as trademarks can be protected under the Copyright Act (Supreme Court Decision 2012Da76829). Accordingly, the use of a trademark protected as a copyrighted work on items used for a virtual character in the metaverse may also lead to the risk of copyright infringement.

In addition to the potential risk of trademark infringement and copyright infringement, the unauthorized use of another person’s brand in the metaverse may constitute an act of unfair competition under the Unfair Competition Prevention and Trade Secret Protection Act. If you sell items displaying another person’s brand in the metaverse, it may lead consumers to confusion that the items are licensed or sold by the brand owner itself. As such, it may be considered as “an act of causing confusion with another person’s goods” which is prohibited as an act of unfair competition under Article 2(1)(a) of the Act. It may also constitute an act of infringing on the economic interests of others by using outcomes achieved through substantial investment of efforts without permission in a manner contrary to fair commercial practices” as prohibited under Article 2(1)(k) of the Act, given that (a) a well-known brand generally falls within the scope of such achievement; (b) the use of the brand on items may directly or indirectly increase the awareness of the virtual character using such items; and (c) several brands have already entered into formal contracts to launch their products on metaverse platforms.

In sum, the reach of laws related to the use of trademarks in the real world can extend even to the world of the metaverse. In this context, the world of the metaverse is not completely cut off from the real world, but can be considered as an extension of it.

Lee Keun-woo and Helen H. Hwang

Lee Keun-woo is a partner at Korean law firm Yoon &Yang, with an expertise in intellectual property protection, privacy protection, trade secrets protection, including e-commerce and other technology, media and telecommunication laws. Helen H. Hwang is a US-qualified attorney at Yoon & Yang, with an expertise in the areas of intellectual property, technology, media and telecommunications and corporate laws. — Ed.

By Korea Herald (khnews@heraldcorp.com)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Match Group (MTCH) Outpaces Stock Market Gains: What You Should Know

Match Group (MTCH) closed the most recent trading day at $135.60, moving +0.86% from the previous trading session. The stock outpaced the S&P 500’s daily gain of 0.31%. Elsewhere, the ... Read more »

3 Stocks to Buy and Hold for Retirement

Buy and Hold Investing Can Set You Up For a Nice Retirement It’s safe to say that stocks play a valuable role in investing for retirement, regardless of how close ... Read more »

Logitech (LOGI) Outpaces Stock Market Gains: What You Should Know

Logitech (LOGI) closed at $82.43 in the latest trading session, marking a +1.18% move from the prior day. The stock outpaced the S&P 500’s daily gain of 0.31%. Elsewhere, the ... Read more »

Abbott (ABT) Stock Sinks As Market Gains: What You Should Know

Abbott (ABT) closed at $132.37 in the latest trading session, marking a -0.04% move from the prior day. This change lagged the S&P 500’s daily gain of 0.31%. Meanwhile, the ... Read more »

Less than 2% of companies get A grade on climate crisis disclosures

(Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Archive) The number of companies considered leaders on climate crisis action and transparency has fallen sharply this year, according to a global study of more more than ... Read more »

FTSE 100 Live: Sterling pressure continues ahead of Plan B curbs, Rolls-Royce posts update

(ESI) Pressure on sterling in the wake of Boris Johnson's Plan B restrictions has continued after the pound fell to a 2021 low yesterday. Sterling remained close to 1.32 versus ... Read more »

Frasers forecasts full-year profit leap despite supply chain and pandemic woes

Mike Ashley’s Frasers Group has reported surging half-year profits and forecast a jump in annual earnings despite revealing a hit from supply chain costs and pandemic uncertainty. The parent company ... Read more »

Mirae Asset-led consortium wins legal battle with Chinese insurer over hotel purchase deal

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — A consortium led by South Korea’s leading asset management firm Mirae Asset Global Investments said Thursday it has won a legal battle with China’s Anbang ... Read more »

Demand still strong for India-made AstraZeneca vaccine doses - COVAX's GAVI

FILE PHOTO: A man displays a vial AstraZeneca’s COVISHIELD vaccine as the country receives its first batch of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccines under COVAX scheme, in Accra By Krishna N. ... Read more »

UK's FirstGroup flags uncertainty in recovery pace amid new restrictions

FILE PHOTO: First Student school buses parked in San Francisco (Reuters) – British transport company FirstGroup warned on Thursday of uncertainty in its recovery pace because of new restrictions imposed ... Read more »

Go-Ahead admits to ‘serious errors' over running of Southeastern trains

Train operator Go-Ahead Group has admitted to serious errors and failures in the way it ran the Southeastern rail franchise prior to it being taken over by the Government in ... Read more »

Moonpig's first-half revenue falls as COVID boost fades

LONDON (Reuters) – British online greetings card company Moonpig reported a 8.5% drop in first-half revenue after the reopening of high street rivals that were forced to close in the ... Read more »

Harbour Energy sets $200 million annual dividend policy

LONDON (Reuters) –Harbour Energy has introduced a $200 million annual dividend policy, equating to 16 pence per share, it said on Thursday on the company's first post-merger capital markets day. ... Read more »

Axis AMC's Growth Avenues AIF achieves final close, hits Rs 1,000-crore target

Axis Asset Management Company, an arm of private sector lender Axis Bank, has raised over Rs 1,000 crore through the final close of Axis Growth Avenues AIF – I, aiming ... Read more »

HSBC suddenly closed account for our charity helping people in Kenya

Photograph: Neil Cooper/Alamy I am treasurer of a smallish charity, Akamba Aid Fund, which has supported impoverished communities in Kenya for the last 21 years. We’ve built wells, dams, health ... Read more »

Analysis-Superbonus! Italy's green growth gambit lines homes and pockets

A view of scaffoldings of a building in Rome By Gavin Jones and Giuseppe Fonte ROME (Reuters) – When Briton Candida Arvanitakis decided to make her 18th century Italian holiday ... Read more »

Plan B: Retail and property chiefs react on the hit firms face from new rules

New Covid restrictions could impact West End footfall (REUTERS) A move to Plan B Covid-19 restrictions has been announced by the Prime Minister Boris Johnson, leaving business leaders in certain ... Read more »

Trucks catch up in the self-driving vehicle race

Trucks catch up in the self-driving vehicle race By Nick Carey and Paul Lienert OXFORD, England (Reuters) – We'd all be whizzing round in robotaxis by now if Elon Musk ... Read more »

Saga to introduce paid leave for birth of a grandchild

Photograph: lolostock/Alamy The birth of a grandchild may be considered a priceless gift in itself, but for some grandparents it now comes with a new perk – an extra week ... Read more »

State-run deposit insurer completes sale of 9.33 stake in Woori Financial

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s state-run deposit insurer said Thursday that it has completed the sale of a 9.33 percent stake in Woori Financial Holdings Co. In a ... Read more »

Foreigners turn net buyers of local stocks in November

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Foreign investors purchased a net of about US$2.52 billion worth of shares on South Korea’s stock market in November as they picked up chips and ... Read more »

Bond issuance in S. Korea edges down in Nov.

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Bond issuance in South Korea inched down in November from the previous month amid rising interest rates, data showed Thursday. The value of bonds sold ... Read more »

[Interactive] Internet banking users reach record high in H1

South Korea’s internet banking services continued to grow in the first half of the year, with the number of users and daily transactions rising to new highs, central bank data ... Read more »

Trafigura plans $540 million hydrogen plant at its Australian lead smelter

FILE PHOTO: Trafigura logo is pictured in the company entrance in Geneva SYDNEY (Reuters) – Commodity trading firm Trafigura said on Thursday it planned to build a A$750 million ($540 ... Read more »

Scramble for staff in UK pushes starting pay up by record - REC

FILE PHOTO: Workers travel through London Bridge rail and underground station during the morning rush hour in London LONDON (Reuters) – British employers' hunt for staff pushed pay for new ... Read more »

Bank of England now expected to raise rates in Q1, but Dec a close call- Reuters Poll

FILE PHOTO: General view of the Bank of England in London, Britain By Jonathan Cable LONDON (Reuters) – The Bank of England will wait until early next year before raising ... Read more »

Tax revenue down W6.2tr in October

(Yonhap)South Korea’s tax revenue fell 6.2 trillion won ($5.3 billion) in October from a year earlier as the government delayed the payment of some taxes by small merchants and firms ... Read more »

Lack of homes for sale in UK keeps up pressure on prices - RICS

Houses are seen in London By David Milliken LONDON (Reuters) – The number of people in Britain putting their home up for sale fell for an eighth month in a ... Read more »

Britain's energy market needs quick reforms, says regulator

FILE PHOTO: The sun rises behind electricity pylons near Chester LONDON (Reuters) – Britain's energy market needs quick reforms, regulator Ofgem said on Thursday, flagging it plans to announce changes ... Read more »

Christmas jingle to warn customers over loan fraud

Selfridges’ Christmas decorations on Oxford Street in London, England. Photo: Reuters The UK’s financial watchdog has launched an official anti-fraud jingle in the hopes it will protect customers from loan ... Read more »

Workplace trends: predictions for 2022

Employees will be empowered to demand more from their employers in 2022. Photo: Getty The UK job market and the way people work have undergone unprecedented change during the last ... Read more »

UK law firms earn £29bn as legal services retain global appeal

London is seen as the world’s preferred centre for arbitration, according to TheCityUK. Photo: Getty Images The legal services sector contributed £29.6bn ($39bn) to the UK in 2019, and posted ... Read more »

UK's £3tn property windfall 'unequal, unearned and untaxed'

Those aged 60 and over have seen the biggest windfalls. Photo: Getty Images Soaring house price growth in the past two decades has delivered huge capital gains on the homes ... Read more »

Stock futures are flat after major averages post third straight day of gains

U.S. stock index futures were little changed during overnight trading on Wednesday, after the major averages posted a third straight day of gains as traders bet that the omicron variant's ... Read more »

Best reward and cashback credit cards

(Pexels) A rewards credit card gives you the opportunity to earn something back as you spend. This can be airmiles, loyalty points or – in the case of cashback credit ... Read more »

More than 200 firms named for breaching minimum wage rules

House of Fraser, Schuh and Waterstones are among more than 200 employers across the UK who broke minimum wage laws when paying staff, according to the Government. The businesses were ... Read more »

Is Waterstone Financial (WSBF) Stock Undervalued Right Now?

Here at Zacks, our focus is on the proven Zacks Rank system, which emphasizes earnings estimates and estimate revisions to find great stocks. Nevertheless, we are always paying attention to ... Read more »

3 Reasons Why Builders FirstSource (BLDR) Is a Great Growth Stock

Growth investors focus on stocks that are seeing above-average financial growth, as this feature helps these securities garner the market’s attention and deliver solid returns. But finding a growth stock ... Read more »

4 Reddit Penny Stocks To Buy For Under $5 As Trump Stocks Jump

Trump Penny Stocks To Watch Right Now The debut of former President Donald Trump’s Truth Social media platform has caused a stir in the stock market today. Once again, news ... Read more »

Here Comes Santa Claus - 3 Strong Buy Stocks to Boost Your Portfolio

After a tumultuous last two weeks, the bulls have made a stand this week as the major indexes are back in the green for December. This month normally gives investors ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic