Laugh at the US if you will, but Australia narrowly escaped a debt ceiling

contingency plan, Moody’s, A$500 billion, Peter Martin, did just that, end the weekend, endorse the switch

Shutterstock

The United States government is scheduled to hit its “debt ceiling” of US$28.4 billion on or around October 18.

The US debt ceiling isn’t like the limit on a credit card, which is imposed by the lender worried about the borrower’s ability to make payments.

Instead, it’s a form of self-delusion: a limit imposed by the borrower itself — the US government in the form of the Congress — in order to limit borrowing largely necessitated by decisions of the Congress.

This statement endorsed by a panel of leading US economists surveyed by the Chicago Booth school in 2013 sums up the absurdity of the requirement

because all federal spending and taxes must be approved by both houses of Congress and the executive branch, a separate debt ceiling that has to be increased periodically creates unneeded uncertainty and can potentially lead to worse fiscal outcomes

No-one knows what would happen if the Congress didn’t approve the regular increases in the debt ceiling made necessary by the programs it legislates. What does happen is that each increase gets approved at the last moment in a largely symbolic high stakes game of chicken.

If each increase wasn’t approved, the US might be unable to borrow to meet the payments on its debt and would default.

Or, and this was the basis of a contingency plan drawn up in 2011, it would delay payments for other things, such as contractors, staff, social security recipients and Medicare providers, in order to meet free up enough cash to ensure it continued to make payments on debts.

Either would scare the heck out of financial markets, as does the fact that both are evoked each time Congress goes through the charade of deciding whether or not to do what it has so far always done.

In an episode of Aaron Sorkin’s brilliant TV show The West Wing, staffer Annabeth Schott asks: “so this debt ceiling thing is routine, or the end of the world?”

White House press secretary Toby Ziegler replies: “Both.”

What would happen if the US breached the debt ceiling? Credit ratings agency Moody’s says if the government defaulted GDP could fall by close to 4%, six million jobs could be lost, mortgage and business interest rates would spike, and US$15 trillion would be wiped off the value of assets markets.

Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen described the sequence as “catastrophic”.

Will the US end up raising the debt ceiling once again? Almost certainly. But even a small probability of a catastrophe is an unnecessary risk.

The politics of the matter are that the Republicans seem to want Democrats to raise the debt ceiling without Republican votes, preserving it as a campaign issue.

Since Democrats only have 50 of the 60 votes in the Senate required to force a vote, it requires a workaround. It’ll probably happen, but it’s a dangerous game.

Down under, Australia flirted with this stupidity, then escaped it.

Australia’s brief debt ceiling

During the financial crisis of 2008-09, Labor introduced a debt ceiling as a way of signalling its seriousness about economic management.

I would have thought its success in saving Australia from a recession did the trick, but I’m just an economist.

In its wisdom Labor set the ceiling at A$75 billion.

Since deficits kept happening and flirting with a debt ceiling was bad news, Labor increased the ceiling to A$200 billion, then to A$250 billion, then A$300 billion.

And, just like the reckless Republicans in the United States, an opportunistic Coalition in Australia opposed each increase.

Then, shortly after the Coalition took office in 2013, newly minted Treasurer Joe Hockey proposed a really big increase, from A$300 billion to A$500 billion, to end the recurring charade.

Labor took the high road, said it wouldn’t oppose the sort of thing it would also have to do in government, and refused to play politics. The debt ceiling was abolished, and everyone lived happily ever after.

Actually, no. I made that up.

What Labor did was start making noises about opposing the increase. “I don’t believe he’s come anywhere near yet justifying that extraordinary increase to the debt limit,” said Labor’s (otherwise generally sensible) treasury spokesman Chris Bowen.

It was a journalist’s rather bold suggestion that provided the cut through. Peter Martin suggested Hockey bypass Labor and do a deal with the Greens to abolish the ceiling altogether.

A fortnight later, Hockey did just that.

Labor, realising its mistake, said it supported the deal and promised to treat sovereign default in the same bipartisan way that the two major parties deal with national security issues.

“Politics must stop at the door of sovereign default” the opposition leader said.

Actually, no. That didn’t happen either. Labor described the deal as “bizarre”.

The broader lesson

One takeaway is that Australia was right to remove a silly constraint that risked blowing up the economy for no good reason. We should say no to debt ceilings.

But there’s a broader lesson. Politicians in this country should stop playing politics with issues on which they agree.

Labor should stop complaining about “debt and deficits”, given that if it had been in government it would have done much the same.

And the Coalition should knock off the hypocrisy on a range of issues including climate change where it is likely to end up endorsing the sort of policies it ridiculed when they came from Labor.

Electric cars were never going to end the weekend. The targets Australia puts forward at the Glasgow climate talks are likely to implicitly endorse the switch.

Our politics can be better, but only if our politicians are.

contingency plan, Moody’s, A$500 billion, Peter Martin, did just that, end the weekend, endorse the switch

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Shipments in Novorossiysk suspended due to storm — Transneft

It was also reported that the weather is expected to worsen during the weekend and a typhoon is possible Read more »

Norway, Russia agreed fishing quotas for Barents Sea in 2022

According to the Norway’s Ministry of Trade, Industry and Fisheries, this is the most important and the large-scale bilateral agreement in the fisheries sphere for the country Read more »

Russia, Venezuela developing secured messenger — Rostec

The parties are also considering implementation of information solutions for power system management with Corpoelec electrical company and digitalization of production processes for Conviasa airline Read more »

Russia's non-resource non-energy exports may set a record with $180 bln in 2021

According to Head of the Russian Export Center Veronika Nikishina, Russia's non-resource non-energy exports will surpass $141 bln - the figure for the entire 2020 already this month Read more »

Russia, Germany discuss new transit contract with Ukraine — Deputy PM

The agreement on the supply and transit of gas, which Russia and Ukraine signed in 2019, expires in 2024 Read more »

Russian Arctic zone may grow into new energy generation center — senator

The Arctic regions may develop into centers to produce and export hydrogen energy and new types of fuel, Konstantin Dolgov said Read more »

Analysts list Arctic cities liable for state support

According to the expert, absolute leaders in terms of functions are Arkhangelsk, Murmansk, Nadym, Naryan-Mar, Norilsk, Noyabrsk, Novy Urengoi and Tarko-Sale Read more »

Aluminum up over $3,200/tonne on London Metal Exchange first time since July 2008

According to analysts, the rise in the cost of aluminum is caused by a shortage of thermal coal in China and a general increase in energy prices Read more »

Amazon seeks to invest in SK Telecom spun-off unit, SK Square

Amazon is in negotiations with South Korea's SK Telecom Co. to invest in the mobile carrier's non-telecom operations unit SK Square, a to be hived off next month. Amazon, the ... Read more »

Russian official does not exclude spot sales restart by Gazprom in November-December

The company is now selling gas on its platform only with delivery in the third quarter of 2022 and in 2023 Read more »

Russian crude production to total 9.8 mln barrels per day in October, Novak specifies

Russian Deputy Prime Minister said earlier that Russia might produce more than 522 mln tonnes of oil and gas condensate in 2021 Read more »

China's first smart oil platform starts operations — TV

The platform is located in the Bohai Sea and fitted with a smart safety system using artificial intelligence technology Read more »

Brent oil price on the ICE exchange up over $ 85/barrel

The cost of a WTI crude oil futures also rose to $ 81.36 per barrel Read more »

(2nd LD) BOK continues to normalize monetary policy to ease 'financial imbalances'

(ATTN: UPDATES with more remarks in paras 12-15; ADDS photo) SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — The Bank of Korea will continue adjusting its accommodative monetary policy and determine the timing ... Read more »

Daewoo Shipbuilding wins 640.8 bln won order for 4 container carriers

By Nam Kwang-sik SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering Co. (DSME) said Friday that it has signed a 640.8 billion won (US$542 million) deal to build ... Read more »

From Markets to Maharaja: Indian Economy Finally Takes Off After Pandemic Turbulence

© Provided by News18 From Markets to Maharaja: Indian Economy Finally Takes Off After Pandemic Turbulence After 18 months of pandemic-caused turbulence, the Indian economy is showing signs of bouncing ... Read more »

India has faced COVID-19 crisis with resilience and fortitude: Nirmala Sitharaman

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitaraman. India has not only faced the COVID-19 crisis with great resilience and fortitude but has also played a major role and “walked the talk” on the ... Read more »

Israeli companies getting increasingly interested in Russian market — Lavrov

Despite the aftermath of the coronavirus pandemic, trade between Russia and Israel declined by a modest 3.9% in 2020, while in January-July of this year it grew by 51.8% year-on-year, the minister stressed Read more »

Korea faces continued economic uncertainty: finance ministry

This Oct. 8 file photo shows closed stores in the shopping district of Myeongdong in downtown Seoul amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Yonhap The South Korean economy is facing continued uncertainty ... Read more »

Metals head for record, zinc spikes as energy crisis hits supply

LONDON (BLOOMBERG) – Base metals soared, led by zinc’s surge to its highest price since 2007 after European smelters became the latest casualties in a global energy crisis that’s knocking ... Read more »

'Unleash American shale' to end energy crisis, gas driller says

NEW YORK (BLOOMBERG) – The largest U.S. natural gas driller is using the global energy crisis to renew its call for more investment in domestic infrastructure such as pipelines, which ... Read more »

From Markets to Maharaja: Indian Economy Finally Takes Off After The Pandemic Turbulence

© Provided by News18 From Markets to Maharaja: Indian Economy Finally Takes Off After The Pandemic Turbulence After 18 months of pandemic-caused turbulence, the Indian economy is showing signs of ... Read more »

Aluminum makers sould alarm about US magnesium shortage

NEW YORK (BLOOMBERG) – There’s a widening scarcity of essential raw materials for aluminum used to make automobiles and building supplies that threatens to worsen a supply squeeze that already ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel prices on October 15: Fuel rates at record highs after fresh hike

Representative Image Petrol, diesel prices were hiked for the second straight day across metros on October 15, according to a price notification of state-owned fuel retailers. With the latest hike, ... Read more »

(LEAD) BOK continues to normalize monetary policy to ease 'financial imbalances'

(ATTN: ADDS more comments in paras 9-11; REPLACES photo) SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — The Bank of Korea will continue adjusting its accommodative monetary policy and determine the timing of ... Read more »

(LEAD) S. Korea faces continued economic uncertainty: finance ministry

(ATTN: UPDATES with more details in paras 2, 13-16; ADDS photo)By Kim Soo-yeon SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — The South Korean economy is facing continued uncertainty as slumps in person-to-person ... Read more »

S. Korea's finance chief voices concerns over U.S. info-sharing request for chipmakers

WASHINGTON, Oct. 14 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s finance minister on Thursday voiced concerns about the U.S.’s request for Korean chipmakers to share information on their supply chains. Finance Minister Hong ... Read more »

NH All One REIT pushing for stock market listing in Nov.

SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — The real estate investment trust (REIT) unit of major bank holding firm NH Financial Group Inc. said Friday it is seeking to get listed on ... Read more »

BOK continues to normalize monetary policy to ease 'financial imbalances'

SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — The Bank of Korea will continue adjusting its accommodative monetary policy and determine the timing of another rate hike in a way that could ease ... Read more »

(Yonhap Feature) Craft beer market sees big growth potential in S. Korea

By Choi Kyong-ae SEOUL, Oct. 15 (Yonhap) — Beer has long been a key ingredient of mixed drinks in South Korea, but changing appetites and the extended coronavirus pandemic have ... Read more »

United Aircraft Corporation ready to build Be-200 squadron to put of fires world over

According to the corporation, it expands the batch production with a glance to the current and future orders Read more »

User reports indicate problems with Instagram in some countries

Most complaints come from the US, Germany, the UK and the Netherlands Read more »

Oil market volatility remains low - Russian deputy prime minister

This volatility that we are witnessing in the gas market is not possible in the oil market, Alexander Novak said Read more »

Russia to overfulfill contractual obligations for gas transit through Ukraine in 2021

The contract includes the transit of 65 bln cubic meters of gas in 2020 and 40 bln cubic meters annually from 2021 to 2024 Read more »

Asia grabbing more European fuel oil to ease energy crisis

LONDON (BLOOMBERG) – Asia is taking more fuel oil from Europe to help deal with the energy crisis, according to a company that manages hundreds of ocean-going tankers. There’s been ... Read more »

Starbucks Korea sets restrictions on the number of purchases for Halloween goods

Many consumers began purchasing the Halloween specials early in the morning, causing items with buying restrictions to run out rapidly. Starbucks Korea stores have set restrictions on how many of ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia proposes Russia to consider gas market cooperation — Novak

Saudi Arabian Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman Al Saud and the Russian Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak discussed this issue at the bilateral meeting Read more »

Hungary in talks with Russia on technology transfer to produce Sputnik V vaccine

"Today we are discussing what preparations are needed and what timetable is possible for our National Vaccine Plant, which is currently under construction, to receive the technology required for the production of Sputnik," Hungarian Foreign Minister Peter Szijjarto noted Read more »

Russia needs to restructure all industries to reach carbon neutrality — envoy

According to Anatoly Chubais, the climate sphere should be completely excluded from any restrictions Read more »

Transition to carbon neutrality will allow Russia to master other industries — envoy

"We have an absolutely unique opportunity to offer the world, the global investment community, the business community, completely new types of projects that will be implemented in Russia much more efficiently than anywhere else," Anatoly Chubais pointed out Read more »