Landmark ruling over sacred site damage

The High Court has unanimously agreed the Commonwealth can be held criminally liable for damage done to sacred sites at Gunlom Falls, in a major win for traditional owners.

Following a two-day hearing last December, the High Court on Wednesday overturned a 2022 decision from the Northern Territory Supreme Court in a “critical” judgment that could change the way Commonwealth corporations and offices operate with respect to the country’s sacred sites acts.

The case centred around damage done in 2019 when the Director of National Parks authorised works within Kakadu National Park that allowed a walkway to be constructed too close to a sacred men’s site.

The waterfall, which featured in the film Crocodile Dundee, has been closed to visitors since the damage.

The Aboriginal Areas Protection Authority launched legal action against the Director of National Parks before the NT Supreme Court, where a decision was ultimately made that although the track works weren’t properly authorised, the Commonwealth could not be held legally responsible for the damage under territory laws.

The DNP had maintained it was a government body and held the privileges and immunities of the Commonwealth.

landmark ruling over sacred site damage

Landmark ruling over sacred site damage

The High Court on Wednesday ruled the DNP was established under the national Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act as a “body corporate” and therefore could be held criminally liable for breaching the Sacred Sites Act.

In its judgment on Wednesday, the High Court said the ultimate question was whether the DNP “can be criminally liable for breach of the prohibition of the (Sacred Sites Act) against carrying out work on a “sacred site”.

“The answer is that the DNP can be criminally liable for breach of the prohibition it imposes,” the judgment said.

The case will now return to the local court “where it all began”.

Celebrating the win, custodian Rachel Wilika said after such a long fight, she felt a “really good spirit” inside of herself.

“It’s good to see it all come together in the end,” she said.

landmark ruling over sacred site damage

Bernadette Calma, a member of one of another local clan groups, said while the fight was still not over she was hopeful the judgment would mean no other clans had to experience what they had been through.

“We hope that from this day on, hopefully this is the last time this happens,” she said.

“We know the Sacred Sites Act is strong and all Commonwealth body corporates … state and territory laws do apply to them.”

Acting chief executive of APRA, Shannon Tchir, said it was “disappointing and frustrating” it had taken so long, but Wednesday’s judgment was a significant win.

“This is a critical judgment. I think a successful High Court appeal makes it very clear that National Parks and other government body corporates can be held to account under the Sacred Sites Act for damaging sacred sites,” she said.

“Going forward, Commonwealth corporations and offices cannot assume territory criminal laws do not apply to them. I think it is pretty significant.”

OTHER NEWS

16 minutes ago

Video: Trevor Noah leads the stars at Anfield for Jurgen Klopp's final game in charge... as The Daily Show icon dons Liverpool shirt to hug outgoing boss

16 minutes ago

Video: Arsenal fans are sent into a wild frenzy after being tricked by rumours that West Ham had equalised against Manchester City - while Hammers were actually still trailing at the Etihad

16 minutes ago

Video: Jurgen Klopp fights back tears during emotional final You'll Never Walk Alone as Liverpool boss... ahead of his final match in charge against Wolves

16 minutes ago

Video: Jerry Seinfeld's stand-up show is interrupted by pro-Palestine heckler screaming 'free Gaza'

17 minutes ago

Jerry Seinfeld's stand-up show is interrupted by pro-Palestine heckler screaming 'free Gaza'

17 minutes ago

Arsenal vs Everton: Prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h results, odds today

17 minutes ago

Seriously injured FDNY firefighters sue NYC for $80M over ‘closure’ policy they claim endangered their lives

17 minutes ago

Transgender high school runner in Oregon booed after winning girls’ state title

17 minutes ago

Rep. Stefanik rallies for ‘total victory’ over Hamas during trip to Israel, blasts Biden

17 minutes ago

Marco Rubio won’t accept 2024 election results if they’re ‘unfair’

18 minutes ago

Tempers flare between Tigers and Diamondbacks' dugouts over pitching mound at Chase Field

19 minutes ago

Haaland’s self-sacrifice, Walker’s call to arms and Foden’s coming of age: How Man City won title

19 minutes ago

‘The Falling Sky' Review: The Yanomami People Deliver an Apocalyptic Warning in Scorching Resistance Doc

19 minutes ago

Mets Morning News for May 19, 2024

21 minutes ago

Disneyland characters and parade performers in California vote to join labor union

21 minutes ago

Sean Combs says behavior is 'inexcusable' in released 2016 hotel surveillance video

21 minutes ago

Georgia college student shot and killed on Kennesaw State University campus

23 minutes ago

New York Congressman Ritchie Torres says Bronx has 'no greater enemy than Donald Trump' after ex-president announces rally in borough

24 minutes ago

Markaz Report: GCC Fixed Income markets sees USD 37.7 billion in primary issuances during Q1 2024 representing a 33% increase from the same period last year.

24 minutes ago

Jadon Sancho could be forced to take huge pay cut as Man Utd set price for Dortmund target

24 minutes ago

Ditch Basic Closet Doors And Try This Genius Sliding IKEA BILLY Bookcase Hack

25 minutes ago

Salma Hayek is a Sequined Fantasy in Cannes

25 minutes ago

Dalot and Højlund seal late win for Manchester United at Brighton

25 minutes ago

Economic turning point could change course of Sunak's premiership

25 minutes ago

Tennis-Zverev wins sixth Masters title at Italian Open

25 minutes ago

Sterling sinks Bournemouth to clinch sixth place for fast-finishing Chelsea

25 minutes ago

When the beautiful game was a bit brutal

25 minutes ago

Disneyland's character actors and performers vote to unionize

25 minutes ago

Newcastle boss Eddie Howe ‘desperate to keep’ Bruno Guimaraes

25 minutes ago

‘Arne Slot!’ Jurgen Klopp chants successor’s name after final game as Liverpool manager

27 minutes ago

NBA MVP Winners By Nationality Per Decade

27 minutes ago

Demons 'nowhere near it' in humbling loss to Eagles

27 minutes ago

Man City seal historic Premier League four in-a-row as Phil Foden double sees off West Ham

27 minutes ago

Manchester City win fourth consecutive Premier League title, Spurs claim Europa place

27 minutes ago

Highly-Coveted Transfer Defensive Lineman Sets Visits To Two Big Ten Schools

27 minutes ago

Every Major Circular Saw Brand Ranked Worst To Best

28 minutes ago

Chelsea earn 2-1 win over Bournemouth to clinch European place

31 minutes ago

UK 'owes Caribbean nations £205bn in slavery reparations', says leading Cambridge academic - as he calls on Scotland to lead the way and start repaying its £20.5bn share of debt

31 minutes ago

Second-class post 'will be cut to just three days a week if billionaire Daniel Kretinsky completes £3.5bn takeover of Royal Mail'

31 minutes ago

Luton Town are RELEGATED from the Premier League after Nottingham Forest beat Burnley to avoid the drop and confirm the Hatters' fate

Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch