Lakhbir Singh's lynching is the ‘irrational religiosity' that Gandhi warned against in 1925

Asia's Tech News Daily

Lakhbir Singh’s lynching is the ‘irrational religiosity’ that Gandhi warned against in 1925
© Provided by The Print

The brutal killing of Lakhbir Singh, a Dalit who was lynched by a few Nihang Sikhs in Delhi for allegedly desecrating the Sikh holy book, is a firm reminder that we do not have any principled position on religious fanaticism.

Although this event was overwhelmingly criticised, the manner in which the ‘sacredness’ of religious scriptures is invoked by our political class is highly problematic.

A strong impression is created that religious symbols — cow, holy books, places of worship — are as important as human life. Hence, they should be protected by the State as rights-bearing citizens. The calculated response of major political parties, especially in Punjab, in the Lakhbir Singh episode, underlines this emerging political consensus.

Three key questions associated with this case are important. Is it possible to compare the life and liberty of an individual citizen with any religious book? Do holy books and religious relics, which are supposed to be guarded by the ‘Almighty God’ (or Gods), really need human protection? If yes, what is to be done with irrational and outdated religious practices propagated by holy books?

Also Read: Communal violence in the time of Modi has a distinct shade. Here’s why

Holy books vs unholy citizens

I do not want to invoke the typical ‘freedom of expression’ argument. Instead, we must trace the processes that contribute to pro-religion politics.

In 2018, the Punjab Legislative Assembly passed the Indian Penal Code (Punjab Amendment) Bill. The law amends Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code by introducing a new sub-section 295AA, that is applicable only in the state of Punjab.

According to this new sub-section, “whoever causes injury, damage or sacrilege to Sri Guru Granth Sahib, Srimad Bhagavad Gita, the Holy Quran and the Holy Bible with the intention to hurt the religious feelings of the people shall be punished with imprisonment for life.”

There are two crucial aspects of this new law: the act of ‘sacrilege’ and the ‘intention’ of a person. These are highly subjective matters, which are subject to official/judicial interpretations. There cannot be a universally applicable parameter to determine the exact meaning of these terms.

In any case, this legal fluidity gives immense powers to the police as well as the religious elite. Any deviation from the standard religious practices/customs defined by the dominant religious establishment as reverential or sacred could become ‘desecration’ or ‘disrespect’.

This legal framework, however, seems to offer a privileged status to religious scriptures. The provision of life imprisonment in such cases clearly indicates that the protection of a holy religious book is comparable with the right to life given to a citizen.

The statement made by Akal Takht jathedar Giani Harpreet Singh seems to reiterate this point. He does not make any comment on the brutality of this event. Instead, a narrative of Sikh victimhood is presented as an argument to justify the legally protected status of the Sikh holy book.

He says, “there is a background to what happened at Singhu as more than 400 incidents of sacrilege have been reported in the last five to six years…there is nothing above the Guru Granth Sahib for Sikhs. But how sacrilege incidents are being reported and accused are often termed mentally ill to avoid the unfolding of conspiracy have hurt the confidence of Sikhs in the law and justice system.”

Also Read: Stop looking for scientific discoveries in holy books, be it the Vedas or the Quran

Spiritual vs religious

Giani Harpreet Singh’s emphasis on Sikh sentiments reminds us of the late 1980s controversy on Salman Rushdie’s novel Satanic Verses when Muslim clergy also used the same set of arguments to justify their status as the protectors of faith.

Such politically motivated religious assertions, we must note, highlight the fragility of religious scriptures, symbols and personalities. The religious icons are presented in the image of humans as if their survival depends entirely on the mercy of the concerned religious group and its recognised clerics.

All-India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB), for instance, gives an interesting description of ulema class. It strongly argues that ‘…Allah entrusted the responsibility of explanation of divine laws to fuqha (learned).’ (Maulana Syed Shah Minnatul Rehmani, Qanoon-e-Shariat ke Masadir aur naye masael ka hal, (Urdu) Delhi, AIMPLB, 2012, p. 12). Does it mean that a layperson cannot draw their own meanings of the Quran?

This instrumentalist description of the religious scriptures as complex, rigid and stagnant texts, actually goes against the spiritual/philosophical foundations of religious doctrines. Religious scriptures are called ‘holy books’ precisely because of their ability to produce complex philosophical arguments in a simple, straightforward and commonsensical manner.

These sacred books make universal claims and recognise the entire humanity as their intended/interested readers. The religious elite, on the other hand, always undermines this universalism to claim ownership of religious texts and relics. That is why the Bhagavad Gita becomes Hindu and the Quran becomes Muslim.

Also Read: Nihang tradition is rich. Don’t just view them through Singhu killing lens

Holy books and inhuman practices

In any case, it would be wrong to believe that religious scriptures contain the ‘final truth’. These texts are product of a particular historical moment and they are full of inconsistencies and contradictions. Therefore, imagining religious texts as ‘context-free’ is a critical mistake.

Many organised religious establishments in India (such as Vishva Hindu Parishad-supported Dharam Sansad, Akal Takht, AIMPLB, and various Christian organisations) use religious texts to justify inegalitarian practices and customs. The debates on cow vigilantism, ‘triple talaq’ and alleged desecration of the Granth Sahib are good examples of this trajectory.

Gandhi, perhaps, is the only public figure in India, who offers us a religious critique of this irrational religiosity. In 1925, when two Ahmadiyya Muslims were lynched and stoned to death by a section of Muslims in Afghanistan, Gandhi wrote, “I understand that the stoning method is enjoined in the Koran…But as a human being living in the fear of God, I should question the morality of the method under any circumstance whatsoever…this particular form of penalty cannot be defended on the mere ground of its mention in the Koran. Every formula of every religion has in this age of reason, to submit to the acid test of reason and universal justice if it is to ask for universal assent. Error can claim no exemption even if it can be supported by the scriptures of the world.”

Gandhi’s courage and conviction underline a principled critique of irrational and unspiritual religiosity that we experience today. He does not give up what he calls the ‘fear of God’ and makes it difficult for the religious elite to appropriate religion.

Bapu, you are right. We must feel sorry for Lakhbir Singh’s death in the name of God!

Hilal Ahmed is a scholar of political Islam and associate professor at Centre for the Study of Developing Societies. Views are personal.

(Edited by Srinjoy Dey)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


A man was found in an American Airlines landing gear compartment after the flight landed in Miami

© William Perugini/Shutterstock American Airlines Boeing 767 William Perugini/Shutterstock A man was taken to the hospital for evaluation after he was found a plane’s landing gear compartment. CBP officers apprehended ... Read more »

Thomas Wells death: Former X Factor and The Voice USA contestant dies in tragic workplace accident, aged 46

Thomas Wells death: Former X Factor and The Voice USA contestant dies in tragic workplace accident, aged 46 Thomas Wells, a former X Factor USA contestant, has died, aged 46. ... Read more »

Tripura civic polls: BJP sweeps 8 municipal bodies, leading in 6; TMC finishes second in Agartala Municipal Corporation

© Provided by Hindustan Times The counting of votes began at 8am on the day amid tight security measures provided by the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) and the state ... Read more »

Bangladesh police bust Pakistan-run fake Indian currency racket, Rs 73.5 million seized

© Provided by WION Acting on a tip-off, Dhaka Metropolitan Police (DMP) recovered fake Indian currency notes (FICN) valued at Rs 73.5 million from a house in Dhaka on Saturday. ... Read more »

News updates from HT: PM Modi pays tribute to armed forces on Mann Ki Baat and all the latest news

© Provided by Hindustan Times Prime Minister Narendra Modi. (File Photo) Here are today-’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from ... Read more »

23 arrested in connection with UPTET 2021 paper leak: Report

© Provided by Hindustan Times UPTET 2021 will be conducted again within a month, UP basic education minister Satish Chandra Dwivedi said.  (HT Photo) At least 23 people have been ... Read more »

Lockdown-like restrictions in Maharashtra? CM Uddhav Thackeray to take BIG decision as Omicron fears increase

© Provided by DNA Amid rising concerns over new COVID-19 variant ‘Omicron’, Maharashtra Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray is set to hold a COVID-19 review meeting with all Divisional Commissioners and ... Read more »

18 Killed, 5 Injured as Vehicle Hits Truck in Bengal's Nadia District; CM Banerjee, Governor Offers Condolences

© Priyanka | News Desk The people were on their way to the Nabadeep crematorium to cremate someone from Bagda of North 24 Parganas. I offer my deepest condolences ... Read more »

Golf-Chan's par putt clinches win in first Asian Tour event of 2021

(Reuters) – Taiwan’s Chan Shih-chang rolled in a four-foot par putt on the final hole to win the $1 million Blue Canyon Phuket Championship on Sunday as the Asian Tour ... Read more »

Three players Ralf Rangnick could bring with him to Manchester United

Since it was announced that Ralf Rangnick would be taking over at Manchester United, there’s been a big focus on what he’ll do to improve the team. At the time ... Read more »

Behind Enemy Lines: Sevilla FC

© Photo by Angel Martinez/Getty Images Sevilla’s deeper squad The third season of Julen Lopetegui’s is going as strong as ever. They have finished comfortably in fourth place for two ... Read more »

The rise of international players in the NBA

© Provided by Mid-Day The NBA has shown its appeal as a truly global league, enticing fans and players from different corners of the world to be united by the ... Read more »

India tour of South Africa cancelled? BCCI says THIS as new COVID-19 variant fears spike

After the completion of the New Zealand series at home, Team India would be travelling to South Africa for their upcoming tour which is scheduled to begin on December 17. However, ... Read more »

Passengers from 'at risk' countries will have to undergo RT-PCR test on arrival in Delhi

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: In wake of Omicron variant, Delhi’s IGI Airport has from Sunday morning started conducting RT-PCR tests on all arrivals from the ... Read more »

Wisconsin's senators - a Democrat and a Republican - issue joint statement warning against politicizing the Waukesha tragedy

Community members mourn during a candle light vigil in Cutler Park after a car plowed through a holiday parade in Waukesha, Wisconsin, U.S., November 22, 2021.Cheney Orr/Reuters A man drove ... Read more »

Sens. Johnson, Baldwin condemn outside groups for trying to 'exploit' Waukesha tragedy

Wisconsin’s Democrat and Republican senators issued a joint statement Saturday warning of outside individuals or groups exploiting the Waukesha Christmas Parade attack for political gain and urged them not to ... Read more »

Ex-Trump adviser Steve Cortes is out of right-wing channel Newsmax for refusing to take vaccine, report says

Steve Cortes, the Newsmax host, is leaving the right-wing network after the organisation mandated Covid-19 vaccines for employees (Screengrab/YouTube/Fox Business) Donald Trump’s former campaign adviser Steve Cortes is reportedly leaving ... Read more »

Ravneet Gill's recipe for a Christmas baked alaska

A baked alaska feels really extravagant and full of effort. Truth is, though, it doesn’t have to be. A baked alaska is really adaptable to what you like, and can ... Read more »

Wisconsin senators ask outsiders not to exploit parade attack 'for their own political purposes'

Both senators from Wisconsin issued a joint statement on Saturday urging those considering exploiting the past weekend's deadly parade attack “for their own political purposes” to “cease and desist.” “It ... Read more »

Dasvi to OMG – Oh My God! 2, Yami has a promising line-up for films in 2022

© Provided by Mid-Day Yami Gautam, who tied the knot with Uri: The Surgical Strike director Aditya Dhar earlier this year, celebrates her 33rd birthday today. Unlike 2021, the coming ... Read more »

Alia Bhatt, Soni Razdan's birthday posts for Shaheen will make you go aww. See here

As Alia Bhatt’s sister Shaheen Bhatt turned a year older, the actress showered love upon her in a sweet birthday note. Mother Soni Razdan, on the other hand, penned a ... Read more »

Prabhas and Pooja Hegde`s first look from Love Anthem out

© Provided by Mid-Day Prabhas` pan-India magnum opus today unveiled yet another stunning poster and announced the teaser launch of their first Hindi song tomorrow. Having created a lot of ... Read more »

Comedian Munawar Faruqui on shows getting cancelled repeatedly: I'm done, I think this is the end

© Provided by Pinkvilla Comedian Munawar Faruqui has made headlines ever since he was arrested by the Indore police in January 2021 for jokes that “he was going to crack” ... Read more »

Baby elephant's cute peekaboo will make your Sunday brighter. Viral video

Videos showcasing any baby animals are a treat for one’s eyes. Many times, after a tiresome day, you probably find yourself scrolling through your social media accounts, looking for a ... Read more »

Laverne Cox confirms she's got a boyfriend who she 'met on Tinder'

© IANS laverne cox. Los Angeles, Nov 28 (IANS) ‘Orange is the New Black’ star Laverne Cox has confirmed she has a boyfriend whom she “met on Tinder”, as she ... Read more »

GM Survey Asking Corvette C8 Owners About Electric Sports Car

Interesting? Yes. Sacrilege for purists? Absolutely. Like the Porsche 911, the Chevrolet Corvette crowd is a rabidly loyal, and purist, bunch. Something as trivial as changing the headlights are enough ... Read more »

French government 'ready' to discuss autonomy for aggrieved Guadeloupe

France is willing to discuss autonomy for the French Caribbean territory of Guadeloupe if it is in the interests of the people who live there, government minister Sebastien Lecornu has ... Read more »

Tory anger grows over Priti Patel's failure to start resettling stranded Afghans

Photograph: Bülent Kılıç/AFP/Getty Images MPs said to have confronted home secretary over ‘moral obligation’ to deliver refugee programme announced in August Priti Patel is facing growing criticism from Tory MPs ... Read more »

Natasha Faces Mzansi's Wrath Over R1 Million

It has been said before that going on MacG’s podcast never ends well for celebrities. Blood And Water actress Natasha Thahane is the latest ZAleb to prove this fact right. Remember ... Read more »

The trailblazing Irish athlete who's just become a world champion

Amy Wall recently became a world champion. SHE MAY not be a household name, but Amy Wall is one of the most successful Irish athletes competing on the international stage ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu message sent ahead of London return - 'We mustn't panic'

Emma Raducanu was like a “caged animal let loose” when she won the US Open after lockdown. But Annabel Croft claims the teenager must now be given time to learn ... Read more »

Kyrgyzstan's parliamentary election to boost president's clout

© Vladimir Voronin Kyrgyzstan’s President Sadyr Zhaparov prepares to cast his ballot at a polling station in Bishkek during the parliamentary elections (Vladimir Voronin/AP) Voters in Kyrgyzstan were casting their ... Read more »

IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st Test Match, Day 4: Iyer, Saha Lead India's Fightback After Ashwin's Departure

© Provided by News18 IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st Test Match, Day 4: Iyer, Saha Lead India’s Fightback After Ashwin’s Departure IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st Test Match, ... Read more »

More than 1.53 lakh skip 2nd dose in Burdwan (E)

© Provided by The Statesman More than 1.53 lakh skip 2nd dose in Burdwan (E) As many as 1.53 lakh people in Burdwan East have skipped their Covid-19 second dose ... Read more »

Prayagraj Dalit Family Murder Case: Opposition Mounts Attack on Yogi Govt; 8 Accused Arrested, 2 Cops Suspended | Key Points

© Sharmita Kar | News Desk UP Police (File Image) Prayagraj: The brutal murder of four members of a Dalit family in Gohri village of Prayagraj district has triggered ... Read more »

Headless body falls out of cannibal's car after crash

Yegor Komarov and two other men were arrested after police discovered a decapitated body at the scene of a car crash they were involved in. Twitter A purported Russian cannibal ... Read more »

West Bengal Road Accident: 18 killed, 5 injured in car-truck collision in Nadia; CM Banerjee offers condolences

© Provided by Jagran English Kolkata | Jagran News Desk: At least 18 people lost their lives while five others were injured after a matador car collided with a truck ... Read more »

Mann ki Baat: PM Narendra Modi says he wants to serve India, hails Indian startups

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday (November 28) hailed Indian startups saying we are leading the world in this field with more than ... Read more »

Ind vs NZ, 1st Test Live Cricket Score: Jamieson removes Ashwin as India lose sixth wicket

© Provided by Firstpost Ind vs NZ, 1st Test Live Cricket Score: Jamieson removes Ashwin as India lose sixth wicket 13:19 (IST) After 48 overs,India 120/6 ( Shreyas Iyer 35 ... Read more »

Kerry Katona slams Kourtney Kardashian and says PDAs are "cringe"

Kerry Katona has said that public displays of affection are “cringe.” © Bang Showbiz Kerry takes a swipe at Kourtney for her excessive PDAs with Travis Barker The 41-year-old television ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic