Lack of Glove Changes at COVID-19 Testing Centers Led to Major Cross-Contamination

Lack of Glove Changes at COVID-19 Testing Centers Led to Major Cross-Contamination

Lack of glove changes at COVID-19 testing centers in Belgium led to major cross-contamination of samples and a high rate of false positive results.

A lack of glove changes at COVID-19 testing centers in Belgium led to major cross-contamination of samples and a high rate of false positive results. This was the finding of research that was presented at this year’s European Congress of Clinical Microbiology & Infectious Diseases (ECCMID) in Lisbon, Portugal.

The introduction of large-scale PCR testing for COVID-19 presented a number of logistical challenges. A major one was a scarcity of personnel adequately trained to do nasopharyngeal swabbing.

Research from a government-funded lab in Belgium identified inadequate personal protective equipment (PPE) management in testing centers as a source of major cross-contamination.

Scientists at the COVID-19 Federal Platform, Department of Laboratory Medicine UZ Leuven, Leuven, Belgium were alerted to the problem in September 2021 after they noticed that 70% of samples that were taken that day at a testing center in Flemish Brabant, Flanders, had tested positive for COVID-19. The average positivity rate at the time was around 5-10%.

90% of the positive samples had a very low viral load. This hinted that they had been contaminated with the SARS-CoV-2 virus, rather than being true positives.

The patients’ results were immediately withheld and a root-cause analysis (an investigation into the cause of the spike in positive samples) was carried out.

Lead researcher Bram Slechten says: “After excluding lab contamination we arranged the results from that day in chronological order by time of sample collection.

“We saw that no one had tested negative after a sample was collected from a patient with a very high viral load and immediately contacted the test center.

“This led to lack of glove-changing, in combination with high-paced sample collection by a new swabber and the breaking of a swab in the tube, being identified as the likely source of the contamination.

“Protocols at this test center were sharpened overnight and all the patients whose results were withheld were recalled for a new sample the next day. 100% of them were negative.”

To assess the scale of the problem, Mr. Slechten and colleagues then retrospectively checked four months of results (June-Sept 2021) of PCR tests from 11 testing centers for false positives.

A suspected series of contaminated samples was defined as a minimum of three weak positive samples (low viral load, <104 copies RNA/mL) after one positive sample with a high viral load (>106 copies RNA/mL).

They also visited the sites to assess the personnel.

The analysis identified potential cross-contamination events in 73% (8 out of 11) of the test centers. The percentage of samples suspected of being wrongly reported as positive widely varied per day and per center. The four-month average ranged from 0% to 3.4% per testing center.

The highest number of false positives at one testing center on a single day was 77 (out of 382 tests) — 20% of people tested that day. (All of these patients were given the opportunity to retest.)

Site visits identified the lack of glove changes between patients as being the source of cross-contamination.

“If the staff didn’t change gloves between each patient, it was almost certain that contamination would occur,” says Mr. Slechten. “We identified four reasons why changing of gloves didn’t happen: it was simply not in the protocol; correct protocol was in place but it was not followed due to lack of training of new members of staff; not having the right size of glove available; work pressure, some swabbers had to sample one patient every two minutes.”

In response to the study’s results, more rigorous PPE policies were put in place at all 11 testing centers at the end of October 2021.

This included managers being tasked with telling every staff member who swabbed patients about the importance of glove changing and test centers being contacted if there was a spike in their false positive rate.

Follow-up of one test center revealed the impact. Before the intervention, it had a daily positivity rate of 11% and an average false positivity rate of 3.4%. But occasionally, the false positive rate rose to 20%. After the intervention, the false positive rate fell to almost zero.

The team at UZ-Leuven is continuing to monitor rates of false positives, to detect any isolated cross-contamination events.

In addition, Sciensano (the Belgian scientific institute for public health) alerted all labs in Belgium to the issue in October 2021.

The researchers say that most of the cases of cross-contamination were detected in time to withhold the results and recall the patients, meaning the erroneous results weren’t given out. Some cases, however, went undetected, meaning that on some days, a lot of patients received a wrong result.

Mr. Slechten says: “Nasopharyngeal sampling involves close contact between the hand of the health professional, the patient and sample tube. Therefore, it is essential to change gloves between each patient.

“In the context of high-throughput sampling, insufficiently trained staff had to sample high numbers of patients in a limited time. This situation led to a high level of cross-contamination which had gone largely unrecognized, resulting in false positives and people self-isolating and taking time off work unnecessarily.

“Furthermore, each false positive generates high-risk contacts who may also need to be tested, increasing the burden for labs, testing centers, and contact tracing.”

He believes the false positives artificially inflated the COVID-19 case numbers for Belgium. He says: “It is hard to put a number on, however, because we saw a lot of differences between the test centers we studied. In addition, we only looked at test centers in one part of Belgium, making it hard to get the whole picture.

“It is very probable that this also occurred in other countries.

“While I don’t have detailed knowledge of the protocols in testing centers in other countries, the focus is generally on potential events within the lab environment. However, our research provides a perfect example of the importance of looking beyond the lab and keeping an eye on the entire testing chain.”

News Related


Max Tegmark

Max Tegmark left his native Sweden in 1990 after receiving his B.Sc. in Physics from the Royal Institute of Technology (he’d earned a B.A. in Economics the previous year at ... Read more »

This shell is not just a symbol, but also a map

A lone pilgrim walking the last (and most popular) part of the Camino in Spain. (Credit: Romy Arroyo Fernandez/NurPhoto via Getty Images) An epiphany, but not of the religious kind. ... Read more »

20 Food Subscription Boxes You'll Want to Sign Up for ASAP

Our top picks: Blue Apron Green Chef Fresh N Lean Butcher Box Omaha Steaks Murray’s Cheese The Blend Box Thrive Market Misfits Market Candy Club Wine Access Club Hive Brands ... Read more »

17 Types Of Popular Grains And How To Use Them

Brown Rice Cornmeal (Grits And Polenta) Wheat Berries White Rice Wild Rice Different types of grains Grains can be found on nearly every corner of the globe. Cuisines from around ... Read more »

Struggling to make friends as an adult? Why you should try looking to older generations

Credit: fizkes / Shutterstock While loneliness can strike at many points throughout our lives, there are times when it is especially acute. Big transitions like leaving university, changing jobs or ... Read more »

Chickensplash! Exploring the health concerns of washing raw chicken

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Health experts recommend against washing chicken before cooking it because that can spread harmful bacteria. But if you’re among the nearly 70% of people who do, ... Read more »

Ancient footprints on UK beach record demise of biodiversity hotspot

Holocene stratigraphy, radiocarbon dates and footprint record at Wicks Path B. This is the only site without human footprints. Credit: Nature Ecology & Evolution (2022). DOI: 10.1038/s41559-022-01856-2 A team of ... Read more »

Featured video: Building a roller coaster

Every year during Residence Exploration Week at MIT, the East Campus community invites first-year students to help build a working roller coaster. Read more »

8 Salmon Stir-Fry Recipes for a Quick, High-Protein Meal

1. Salmon Stir Fry With Homemade Sauce 2. Teriyaki Salmon Stir Fry 3. 25-Minute Salmon Stir Fry 4. Spicy Stir Fry Salmon 5. Teriyaki Salmon Stir Fry 6. Honey Garlic ... Read more »

Layering, not liquid: Astronomers explain Mars' watery reflections

This image from NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter shows the edge of the Martian South Pole Layered Deposit. The stack of fine layering is highlighted by the rays of the polar ... Read more »

Scientists find decreased summer rainfall over Tibetan Plateau after large tropical volcanic eruptions

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Tropical volcanic eruptions inject sulfur gases high into the atmosphere, which then convert to sulfate aerosols, spread globally and block the incoming sunlight like a parasol. ... Read more »

Southwest Detroit Restaurant Week Returns After Hiatus

The mole verde, a special dish prepared for Southwest Detroit Restaurant Week, from El Palenque at 5426 Vernor Highway. Following a two-year pandemic hiatus, Southwest Detroit Restaurant Week returns Friday, ... Read more »

Whole Foods Creamy Caesar Dressing Recalled Nationwide Due to Undeclared Allergens

If you’re allergic to soy or wheat, toss this dressing. Westend61/Getty Images If you buy Caesar dressing at Whole Foods, you might want to check your refrigerator and pantry. According ... Read more »

Would You Buy A Pumpkin Spice Latte Engagement Ring?

The stunning ring costs over $11,000 and comes in a pumpkin spice-scented package. When PSL season blows through each year, it brings with it an ample supply of pumpkin spice ... Read more »

NASA makes the call to protect its Artemis I mission from Hurricane Ian

"The decision allows time for employees to address the needs of their families." Read more »

Keeping current with landslide prediction tools

Florian Schäfli (left) and Adrian Wicki (right) install soil moisture sensors to help verify electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) measurements. This requires digging a trench which filled in again after the ... Read more »

New mapping tool to support the search for high-quality nature-based carbon credits

NUS Professor Koh Lian Pin (right) and his research team collaborated with ST Engineering Geo-Insights to develop the Carbon Prospecting Dashboard. The dashboard pictured in the screens helps policymakers and ... Read more »

Manmade wetlands: A barrier to the spread of microplastics

Credit: Griffith University Constructed wetlands, built to treat wastewater and stormwater runoff, act as a barrier preventing the spread of microplastics through the environment, a Griffith-led study has found. Published ... Read more »

Life can thrive around even the smallest stars, study claims

A starlight simulator (left) and when illuminated (right). Credit: La Rocca, et al Photosynthesis is probably the most important chemical reaction for life on Earth. It is the process plants ... Read more »

Study shows how turtles have fared a decade after oil spill

Josh Otten, who graduated in May from UToledo with a Ph.D. in biology, holds a turtle while downloading data to his computer on the Kalamazoo River. Otten is lead author ... Read more »

Why wandering albatrosses get divorced: New research

Wandering albatross pair performing a courtship dance. Credit: Samantha Patrick, Author provided Monogamy is widespread among birds and it is well known that many seabird species mate for life. Famous ... Read more »

Asteroid apocalypse: How big must a space rock be to end human civilization?

The damage caused by an asteroid impact depends on its size. But how big a space rock must be to cause an apocalypse? Read more »

The Unusual Cereal Topping That's Gained A Cult Following

Corn flake cereal with strawberries Cereal is one of the easiest breakfasts to make. As long as you have the muscle strength to open a jug of milk and the ... Read more »

The Most Nutritious Way To Cook Mushrooms

Mushrooms and herbs While mushrooms might not be everyone’s favorite, to many, mushrooms are a complex delicacy worth enjoying in every form. At times, entire restaurants have been dedicated to ... Read more »

I’m a nutritionist and here’s 4 foods that will STOP you overeating

IT'S so easy to overeat – whether that be out of hunger, boredom or for comfort. However, overeating may well just be one of the biggest risks to our health ... Read more »

PTSD and Comorbid Substance Abuse Are Associated With a Cellular Marker for Early Death

Summary: Trauma-exposed veterans with PTSD and comorbid externalizing psychiatric disorders, such as substance abuse or antisocial personality disorder are at greater risk for early death. Source: Boston University Psychiatric symptoms ... Read more »

New Therapeutic Target Could Check the Progress of Alzheimer’s Disease

Summary: Researchers have devised a new, non-invasive method for tracking the progression of Alzheimer’s disease. The study also proposes removing excess toxic Alzheimer’s proteins from the blood could improve clinical ... Read more »

Life Expectancy Tool May Improve Quality of Life for Patients With Dementia

Summary: A new mortality prediction model for older patients with Alzheimer’s disease can help medical professionals and families determine the best course of action for end-of-life care. Source: UCSF A ... Read more »

AI Worse at Recognizing Images Than Humans

Summary: Most AI models are unable to represent features of human vision, making them worse at recognizing images. Source: HSE Researchers from HSE University and Moscow Polytechnic University have discovered ... Read more »

ESA’s Deep Space Network Tracks DART Asteroid Impact

NASA’s Double Asteroid Redirection Test (DART) will impact its target asteroid Dimorphos on September 26 at 7:14 p.m. EDT (4:14 p.m. PDT). Credit: NASA Today, all eyes will be looking ... Read more »

Key phases of human evolution coincide with flickers in eastern Africa's climate

Chew Bahir coring site, extracting a liner full of recovered sediment material from the 280-m-long core: the day shift trying to pull the liner out with combined forces. Credit: Frank ... Read more »

Study reveals a master regulator controlling fungal infection of wheat

The pathogenic fungus Zymoseptoria tritici. A novel molecular tool allows microscopic detection of non-pathogenic spores (red) and the invasive hyphae (green). Credit: Professor Gero Steinberg & Professor Sarah Gurr The ... Read more »

How money and technology are militarizing the fight against the illegal wildlife trade

Rangers in Kruger Park, South Africa. Credit: WildSnap/Shutterstock Thousands of animals and plants are bought and sold each year globally as food, medicine, clothing and furniture—even in the form of ... Read more »

Researchers study sugar uptake mechanism of industrial microorganism

Model of cellulosome regulation and sugar transporters in Clostridium thermocellum. Credit: Feng Yingang With the help of genetic manipulation and advanced biophysical tools, an international research team has gained unexpected ... Read more »

Five xenophobic myths about immigrants in South Africa debunked by researchers

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain In South Africa, immigrants are often scapegoated as the root of socio-economic problems. In the post-apartheid landscape, Black African immigrants, mainly, from other African countries have ... Read more »

Clickbait extremism, mass shootings, and the assault on democracy: Time for a rethink of social media?

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Credit: Anthony Quintano/Wikimedia Commons Social media companies have done well out of the United States congressional hearings on the January 6 insurrection. They profited from livestreamed ... Read more »

Nigeria is producing less and less oil. Here's why

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Nigeria’s oil output was at the lowest since 1990 as its crude oil production fell below 1 million barrels per day (bpd) in August 2022. And ... Read more »

How do we deal with the polarization around climate change?

A diagram showing standard world view differences between the political left and right. Credit: Photo: David President Biden recently scored a big win in the fight against climate change with ... Read more »

New theory concludes that the origin of life on Earth-like planets is likely

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Does the existence of life on Earth tell us anything about the probability of abiogenesis—the origin of life from inorganic substances—arising elsewhere? That’s a question that ... Read more »

Toward a more localized, impact-based alert system for extreme weather to mitigate heat waves

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain England’s extreme weather warning system could be further refined to help mitigate the public health effects of heat waves, according to a new study from the ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network