Labour's rampant transphobia problem is only getting worse under Keir Starmer, trans members say

Labour is enabling institutionalised transphobia, say trans members who’ve been forced to resign high-profile roles or quit the party entirely – and it’s time for Keir Starmer to take action.

Calls for Keir Starmer to condemn and address transphobia within the Labour Party have been mounting for over a year.

The issue first came to mainstream attention when, in August 2020, Canterbury MP Rosie Duffield waded into an online row about who has a cervix.

Despite an initial apology, Duffield dug in her heels on her “gender critical” views, even liking a tweet from anti-trans campaigner Maya Forstater that branded the Law Society’s guidance on transition in professional settings as “celebrating cross dressers in the office”, prompting blistering backlash from LGBT+ Labour members.

She has consistently maintained that she is not transphobic and that she supports the LGBT+ community. However, two staffers have resigned from her office over the issue. LGBT+ Labour has called for “swift action” to be taken against the MP, Labour activists have demanded that she have the whip withdrawn, and campaigners have begged Keir Starmer to take a stand. But the silence from Labour Party leadership has been – and remains – deafening.

Two of Rosie Duffield’s team quit over the MP’s allegedly “transphobic” views. (Facebook/RosieDuffieldCanterbury)

Starmer insists he is a “proud ally”, and since July it has been reported that Duffield is “under investigation” by Labour Party officials.

But tangible action is yet to appear, and while Duffield may have become the poster child for the party’s so-called “culture war” over trans rights, it is clear that this is not a problem rooted in one individual’s views. The Labour Party is enabling institutional transphobia, say trans members both former and present – and it runs deep.

The Labour Party has no definition of transphobia, tying its own hands when it comes to weeding out discrimination

In October 2020, the Equality and Human Rights Commission investigation into antisemitism in the Labour Party found that there had been “unlawful acts of discrimination and harassment”.

It was required to produce an action plan on tackling antisemitism, in which the party also committed to tacking “any discrimination based on protected characteristics” under the Equality Act 2010.

While “gender reassignment” is a protected characteristic, to date the Labour Party has produced codes of conduct which provide clear definitions of various kinds of discrimination, including Islamophobia, antisemitism, sexual harassment and racism. However, it has not done so for transphobia.

Further, the party’s policy on bullying and harassment makes no mention of trans people, gender identity or transphobia.

Dr Heather Peto, who quit as the first-ever trans co-chair of LGBT+ Labour in January but remains a party member, told PinkNews that this provides a way for Labour members to “get away with” transphobia if they are “not harassing a specific person”.

She said: “For example, sharing something that we regard as transphobic, without a code of conduct definition of transphobia within the party, it’s quite difficult for the party to take action on that… Technically, they’re not breaking the rules.”

When the Labour Party Annual Conference begins on Saturday (25 September), the issue of an official definition of transphobia will likely not be raised.

That, Peto says, means “going through a whole year of transphobic people in the Labour Party ganging up on trans people and calling it ‘freedom of speech’” before it can be raised at next year’s conference, although there is no guarantee that this will happen.

Silence on transphobia could be a political tactic by the Labour Party

A lack of code of conduct and specific definition of transphobia is clearly tying the Labour Party’s hands when it comes to disciplining those who engage in it. But the question remains as to why nothing is being done to remedy this.

Many interpret the silence of Labour leadership on transphobia as fear of associating with a “woke” cause, and losing more socially conservative voters because of it.

Arthur Webber is a trans man who ran as a Labour candidate for city council in Paston and Walton last year. This month, he resigned his membership of the party.

In his resignation letter, Webber said that he had first found a “safe haven” in his university’s Labour students club, and was again met with “love and acceptance” when he first attended a constituency Labour Party meeting. He eventually ran for councillor as an openly trans man, and was pleasantly surprising by the welcoming response of the public.

He wrote: “I did, however, receive online abuse from members of the same party.

“The party that loves to remind me that it wrote and passed the Equality Act (2010), but allows members to advocate for this law to be broken to exclude and marginalise transgender people.

“The party of the NHS that says nothing as trans people die on waiting lists for treatment that seemingly never end.

“The Labour Party that said it was for people like me, until it wasn’t.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it.

Webber has spent significant time trying to educate the Labour members around him, as well as Labour politicians in power, about the impact of transphobia within the party.

Now, however, Webber has come to the conclusion that education is not enough.

The Labour Party, he wrote, knows “full well” that transphobia among its members is causing harm to trans folk, but “does not value us enough to protect us from harm”.

Webber told PinkNews that in order to regain his support, the Labour Party would need to undergo a complete culture shift.

“The way you win votes from the Red Wall is not to completely ignore the plight of minority groups and say they’re not worth your time,” he said.

Webber feels frustrated when he sees his peers, some of whom have also resigned their membership, saying they would rejoin if Rosie Duffield had the whip withdrawn.

“I think because it’s not a problem that’s concentrated in any particular faction, it’s making it much harder to deal with,” he explained.

“Everybody’s focusing on the more vocal ones who tend to be on the right of the party, we also very much have a problem on the left of the party… It’s very much not a factional issue, yet people try to make is a factional issue, which makes it impossible to deal with.”

He added: “Unfortunately, as with everything in the Labour Party, factionalism is clouding everybody’s judgement.”

Transphobia in Labour didn’t start with Keir Starmer, but he has a responsibility to end it

Transphobia in the Labour Party isn’t limited to Keir Starmer’s leadership, and certainly goes deeper and further back.

But following recent discussion on reforming the Gender Recognition Act and the huge increase in anti-trans public discourse, his lack of action and decisiveness is all the more jarring.

The problem with Labour leadership “equivocating” on tackling transphobia, Heather Peto said, is that “if a leader does that, all the people that are opposed to trans rights and trans equality come out of the woodwork, and they try to claim to talk for the leader, or they try to set the agenda”.

Arthur Webber added that there are those within the party that think “everything was hunky-dory and rosy” under Jeremy Corbyn, “and it just wasn’t”.

“Jeremy also ignored institutional issues in relation to transphobia,” he said.

“Yes, it wasn’t as blatant as it is now… but it wasn’t as bad as it is now.

“I think some of that does have to be assigned to Keir Starmer’s leadership, and the people he has working with him.”

Further, those people that Starmer has working with him in Labour’s upper echelons are entirely cisgender.

“We don’t have any representation at the table where they decide things,” said Peto.

Earlier this year, Peto was involved in the launch of a new group named Labour Trans Equality, which aims to work within the Labour Party to promote trans and non-binary equality.

Their aims are “clear and simple”: To increase trans representation in the party by training and encouraging potential trans Labour members and candidates, and to “be a strong and clear voice for trans and non-binary members and their allies”.

The group has even been consulting on a definition of transphobia which it tried to submit to the NEC, but was “ignored”.

Wolverhampton councillor Anwen Muston, who was the first trans Labour councillor elected after 2000 and co-sponsor of Labour Trans Equality, told PinkNews that the most vital thing is for those in power to actually talk to trans people.

“Our parliament is not fit for purpose because it’s not representative of all the communities it serves,” Muston said.

“We’re excluded from it, we’re excluded from the decision-making.

“They talk about us: ‘Shall we give them this, shall we give them that?’ And it’s without us, where we should be included.”

But it’s an uphill battle.

The Labour Party has no trans MPs, no trans members of its National Executive Committee (NEC), and the idea of a trans person in a senior leadership position seems like a near-impossible dream.

Trans people in the Labour Party have been disappointed by their cisgender allies, who on the whole seem to be avoiding the work required to tackle transphobia in the party.

Taking on the fight without cis allies by their side is an even more monumental task when trans folk are struggling to get a seat at the tables that matter most.

A Labour spokesperson said: “The Labour Party is absolutely committed to advancing trans rights and we continue to support updating the GRA to introduce self-declaration for trans people and upholding the Equality Act. We are also committed to improving the diversity of our elected representatives.

“Trans people are one of the most discriminated against groups in society. The Labour party will ensure every trans person can live with respect and dignity in an equal and inclusive society.

“We are committed to introducing a transphobia code of conduct as soon as possible and will be working with our stakeholders to prepare guidance that can be used in the interim.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Bigg Boss 15: Karan Kundrra tells Shamita Shetty why he broke-up with his ex, former girlfriend Anusha Dandekar drops cryptic post on 'loving someone'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The big daddy of reality TV, Bigg Boss 15 is currently running in full force with contestants making it an interesting watch. TV ... Read more »

India adds 16,156 new Covid-19 cases; highest single-day rise since October 23

© Provided by Hindustan Times Previously, the daily infection count crossed the 16,000-mark when 16,326 cases were reported last Saturday (October 23). (Praful Gangurde / HT Photo) India’s daily caseload ... Read more »

ASRB NET Result 2021 declared on, here's direct link to check

Agricultural Scientists Recruitment Board has declared ASRB NET Result 2021. Candidates who have appeared for National Eligibility Test (NET), Agricultural Research Service (ARS) & Senior Technical Officer (STO) (T-6) Examination 2021 ... Read more »

New films to watch in cinemas this week: Oct 28 to Nov 3

© Motivate Publishing movie guide Add a cinema visit to your plans this weekend… It’s Thursday and that means new movies have been released in the cinemas in UAE. There’s ... Read more »

Kenapa bina kemudahan lupus sisa Lynas dekat sumber air, soal Ahli Parlimen

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menurut Ahli Parlimen Kuantan Fuziah Salleh, tapak cadangan bagi PDF Lynas yang terletak berhampiran loji pengeluar nadir bumi di Gebeng, Pahang itu mempunyai air ... Read more »

Los Angeles will pay $1,000 'no-strings attached' monthly universal basic income to 3,000 families living below poverty line as part of largest guaranteed income program in the US

BIG:LEAP, or Basic Income Guaranteed: Los Angeles Economic Assistance Pilot, will be the largest guaranteed income program in the US Applications will open on Friday, October 29, and families will have until  November 7 to fill them outThose chosen in the lottery will receive the $1,000 monthly payments in January and all throughout 2022 Guaranteed income pilots have become increasingly popular as state governments struggle to address the needs of their residents during COVID-19   Also in California, a controversial program to give $500 monthly checks to families of color in Oakland was approved in the Spring During the summer, a program giving payments of $1,250 to 40 homeless people between 18 and 24 for two years  was announces in New York City  Read more »

Laos police seize record drugs haul in Golden Triangle

© Reuters/SOE ZEYA TUN FILE PHOTO: A view of the Mekong river bordering Thailand and Laos is seen from the Thai side in Nong Khai (Reuters) – Lao police have ... Read more »

Singapore witnesses 'unusual surge' in COVID-19 infections, records 10 new deaths

© Provided by Zee News SINGAPORE: Singapore`s health ministry said it is looking into an “unusual surge” in infections after the city-state reported 5,324 new cases of COVID-19 on Wednesday, ... Read more »

Hazard High School pics showing ‘students giving principal LAP DANCE' and cheerleaders ‘in Hooters outfits' spark fury

SHOCKING photos appearing to show high school students giving their principal a lap dance and cheerleaders in Hooters outfits has sparked outrage in a Kentucky town. An investigation has been ... Read more »

Kareena Kapoor goes for a run in the desert, shares post-workout selfie

Kareena Kapoor Khan shared her post-workout selfie from the desert. Kareena Kapoor Khan is currently enjoying her vacation in the desert with her husband, Saif Ali Khan, and her kids, ... Read more »

Opinion: Amit Shah's Kashmir Visit Had Two Messages—One for Kashmiris, the Other for Pakistan

© Provided by News18 Opinion: Amit Shah’s Kashmir Visit Had Two Messages—One for Kashmiris, the Other for Pakistan Amit Shah, Union Minister of Home Affairs (MHA), made his maiden visit ... Read more »

Raqesh Bapat shares mushy photo with Shamita Shetty, her sister Shilpa Shetty reacts!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Bigg Boss OTT contestant Raqesh Bapat is missing his fellow contestant and ladylove Shamita Shetty. The two grew fond of each other on ... Read more »

Three dead, two injured after truck rams into group of women farmers in Haryana

© Provided by Firstpost Three dead, two injured after truck rams into group of women farmers in Haryana Bahadurgarh: Three women farmers were killed and two others injured after a ... Read more »

4 Tips On How To Deal With Holiday Anxiety And Hold It Together

© Provided by MensXP In an ideal world, holidays would mean joy. They would mean eating good food, catching up with friends and relatives, going out, dressing up, enjoying days ... Read more »

U.S. Treasury's Yellen sets ambitious Europe agenda: taxes, pandemics, climate

FILE PHOTO: U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen answers questions during a Senate Appropriations Subcommittee hearing By David Lawder and Andrea Shalal WASHINGTON/ROME (Reuters) – U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen will ... Read more »

UK boat detained by France amid fishing rights row

A British trawler has been seized by France and another has been given a verbal warning, amid an escalating row over post-Brexit fishing rights. © Getty Images The row began ... Read more »

Fmr. ESPN reporter devested to lose job over vaccine mandate: 'There were a lot of tears shed'

Allison Williams says she had no choice but to leave her job after company’s mandate on ‘Tucker Carlson Tonight’ Read more »

When is Black Friday 2021 and when do the early deals start?

We’re bringing you all the latest information on the year’s biggest shopping bonanza (iStock/The Independent) The countdown to the Black Friday 2021 sales is on: while it might seem like ... Read more »

Republican senators pass bills to ban mask & vaccine mandates for Michigan students

The debate over mask and vaccine mandates for Michigan public schools is raging on. It’s an issue that has divided communities across the state, and now, the State Senate is ... Read more »

France detains British trawler during fishing rights row

© PA Media (file photo) – PA Media France has seized a British trawler fishing in its territorial waters without a licence and issued a verbal warning to a second ... Read more »

Volkswagen cuts deliveries outlook as chip crisis bites

© Reuters/ALY SONG FILE PHOTO: A Volkswagen logo is seen as it launches its ID.6 and ID.6 CROZZ SUV at a world premiere ahead of the Shanghai Auto Show, in ... Read more »

Vaccinations for minors to begin Nov 3 in NCR, Nov 5 rest of PH

THE rollout of coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) vaccinations for minors aged 12-17 will begin on November 3 in the National Capital Region (NCR), and on November 5, according to an ... Read more »

Chelsea, Liverpool become League Cup favorites after Manchester City's shock elimination

© Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images For the first time in five seasons, the League Cup will have a new winner, after Manchester City’s shock elimination last night at the ... Read more »

It's a boy! Melbourne Demons captain Max Gawn and his wife Jessica welcome their first child together

Melbourne Demons captain Max Gawn and his wife Jessica have announced the arrival of their first child together, a baby boy named George Oliver Gawn. The AFL star, 29, shared the ... Read more »

Bella Hadid calls herself a 'full time auntie' as she gushes over sister Gigi's daughter Khai, one, and says the baby has 'changed' their family 'for the better'

Her older sister Gigi Hadid gave birth to a daughter amid the COVID-19 pandemic last year. And Bella Hadid gushed over the ‘gift’ that is her one-year-old niece Khai while appearing ... Read more »

Dank Sonderfaktoren: Swisscom steigert Umsatz und Gewinn

Die Swisscom hat in den ersten neun Monaten mehr umgesetzt und verdient. Sonderfaktoren trieben den Gewinn unter dem Strich nach oben. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Die Swisscom hat von Januar ... Read more »

NRW: Razzia gegen Islamistenzelle aus dem Großraum Aachen

Sie sollen mit Äxten und Messern für Anschläge trainiert haben: Nach SPIEGEL-Informationen durchsuchen Ermittler in Nordrhein-Westfalen die Wohnungen mutmaßlicher Anhänger der Terrormiliz »Islamischer Staat«. © Kai Uwe Hagemann / picture alliance ... Read more »

Valerien Ismael drops West Brom transfer hint

© Provided by Football League World Championship – West Bromwich Albion v Birmingham City West Bromwich Albion boss Valerien Ismael has seemingly dropped a transfer hint to the Express & ... Read more »

Industrie drosselt Produktion, Preiserhöhungen unumgänglich: Ems-Chefin Martullo warnt vor Störungen in Lieferketten

Der Schweizer Zulieferer Ems ist weiter in Hochform. Der Umsatz in den ersten neun Monaten des Jahres ist kräftig gewachsen. Doch Sorgen bereiten die globalen Lieferengpässe. © Ems-Chefin Martullo ... Read more »

Astros will be Yankees' problem — even if they don't keep Carlos Correa

HOUSTON — The Astros should re-sign Carlos Correa. If they don’t, though, it’s hard to see that serving as a Get Out of (No World Series) Jail Free card for ... Read more »

Best wireless earbuds in Australia: the top Bluetooth buds for 2021

Bluetooth audio has come a long way in recent years, and the popularity of wireless headphones and true wireless earbuds has grown along with it. Improvements to audio quality, affordability, ... Read more »

Accident causes heavy congestion during morning rush hour in Dubai

© Antonie Robertson Traffic was slow along Umm Suqeim Road during the morning commute on Thursday. Antonie Robertson / The National A major Dubai road was heavily congested on Thursday ... Read more »

8 spook-tacular activities to experience in Dubai this Halloween

© Motivate Publishing Halima Halloween Dubai is all set to celebrate Halloween this year. From dinners to exclusive events, there are an array of options to choose from as the ... Read more »

Clariant hikes sales guidance after Q3 beats forecasts

ZURICH (Reuters) – Clariant raised its full-year sales outlook again on Thursday after the Swiss specialty chemicals maker reported better-than-expected third-quarter sales. © Reuters/Arnd Wiegmann FILE PHOTO: Logo of Swiss ... Read more »

Expo 2020 Dubai pavilions: Uzbekistan, US, Spain, Finland, UK, Oman, Sri Lanka, Brazil

© Motivate Publishing © Motivate Publishing Expo 2020 Dubai (1) Expo 2020 Dubai is the very first world expo where every participating country has its own pavilion. Each of the ... Read more »

SC orders filing of charges vs former BSP exec

THE Supreme Court has ordered the filing of criminal charges against a former officer of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas’ (BSP) Supervision and Examination Sector (SES) for obtaining a loan ... Read more »

Yet another UK police officer is being investigated over ‘racist, homophobic' texts

A Lancashire police officer is being investigated for allegedly sending “racist, homophobic” text messages. The officer is accused of using derogatory slurs against Asian people and homophobic terms for gay ... Read more »

Ghost hunter suffers 'paranormal hangover' after spirit 'whooshes' through him

A ghost hunter described his atrocious “paranormal hangover” caused by an angry spectre “whooshing” through him after it told him to “get out” and chased him down the corridor of ... Read more »

Emma Watson: Getting behind the camera has been the ‘most empowering thing'

Emma Watson has said getting behind the camera and learning how it works has been “the most empowering thing” she learned in lockdown. The actress, 31, revealed she previously thought ... Read more »

'AJ has got big decisions to make'

Anthony Joshua has “big decisions to make” but can regain his world titles with a “great coach” in Rob McCracken, says friend and sparring partner Frazer Clarke. Joshua has visited ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic