Barrage of cheap shots unleashed on Lord Botham at DCMS hearing a disgrace

barrage of cheap shots unleashed on lord botham at dcms hearing a disgrace

Botham made comments about the ICEC on a podcast – Getty Images/Daniel Pockett

“Is that the last gasp of an old dinosaur?” These were the words uttered by John Nicolson of the Scottish National Party on hearing that Lord Botham, not content with describing last year’s report on discrimination in English cricket as “nonsense”, had claimed to have thrown the document on the floor. It seemed, whether or not you agreed with Botham, an impertinent label to attach to one of England’s greatest-ever players. It also begged the question of why the 68-year-old, these days happier developing his vast southern-hemisphere wine collection, was being dragged into the debate in the first place.

Botham, for his part, says he was never asked to recount his own experiences as part of the Independent Commission for Equity in Cricket’s inquiry. This is rejected by Cindy Butts, the commission’s chair, who insists he was invited to give evidence. Their conflicting recollections escalated at a select committee hearing into almost a character assassination of Botham, with Nicolson painting the country’s finest all-rounder as irredeemably out of touch and Butts castigating the England and Wales Cricket Board for lacking the “moral backbone” to call him out as such.

A more grating display of grandstanding you would struggle to find. While Nicolson praised Butts for her “powerful testimony”, he neglected to challenge her on her highly selective quotation of Botham’s remarks. In the same podcast where he hit out at the ICEC’s “nonsense”, Botham had also talked of sharing his Somerset dressing room with Sunil Gavaskar, Hallam Moseley, Joel Garner and Viv Richards, declaring: “I stand here now, and I tell you, ‘Find someone who says I’m a racist’. There isn’t one.” He mentioned being tapped on the shoulder by Nelson Mandela and being told, “You’re my hero”, for the part he had played in England’s boycott of apartheid South Africa.

barrage of cheap shots unleashed on lord botham at dcms hearing a disgrace

Sir Viv Richards and Both played together for Somerset – Getty Images/ Gareth Copley

This, then, is the man being denigrated as an “old dinosaur” by the MP for Ochil and South Perthshire. It is an apt moment to explore what, if anything, entitles Nicolson, the SNP’s spokesperson on culture, media and sport since 2020, to cast such aspersions on Botham’s views. Not much in his recent political career, that is for sure. Last March, Nicolson courted controversy when he argued that politicians applying their own make-up for television appearances look “overly brown” and “tandoori themselves”. He later apologised for using racially insensitive language.

You would think, against this backdrop, that he might go easy on the moralising where Botham and cricket are concerned. Instead, Nicolson donned the cloak of parliamentary privilege to excoriate a sporting icon who was not even in the room to defend himself. When Butts solemnly informed him of the ECB’s argument that Botham was entitled to his opinions “in a democracy”, he launched into an irrelevant little lecture about hereditary privilege and the House of Lords, with the cricketer having been made a life peer four years ago.

If this is the calibre of politician seeking to impugn Botham’s reputation, you cannot help but wonder whether there are other motives at play here. Was Nicolson’s intervention based on a deep understanding of the inner workings of English cricket? Or was it simply a case of him amplifying Butts’ message because it corresponded with his own world-view?

It is a feature of so many discussions on this subject that they take place in an echo chamber. Even figures such as Nicolson, who should know better, instinctively gravitate towards those who reinforce their preconceptions. Thus is Butts cast as the voice of reason and Botham as the antediluvian agitator. But can the equation truly be so binary?

While Botham could arguably have been more thoughtful than to say he threw the ICEC’s findings on the floor, his reaction arose from pure exasperation, from a sense that everybody in the game was being tarred with the same brush. It is, inescapably, a problem in the report: the fact that so many testimonies are anonymous, and that dressing rooms are depicted as places of rancid prejudice. If English cricket is ever to emerge from its long night of the soul over racism, there surely needs to be a more nuanced conversation than this. And it can start by resisting a portrayal of Lord Botham, of all people, as a dinosaur.

%n

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Disrupt Burrup protesters searched and phones seized

Disrupt Burrup Hub group say police have issued move-on notices prohibiting access to the WA site. A group of climate activists and filmmakers say their phones have been seized during ... Read more »

The generation driving a ‘megatrend’ of poor mental health in Australia

As individuals, we have unique experiences that affect our mental health and wellbeing, but what about the collective experiences that influence each generation? The mental health of Australians has been ... Read more »

Geraldton meatworks set to reopen after five years in bid to meet chilled meat demand from Asia, Middle East

Syed Ghazaly wants to see the Geraldton abattoir reopen early next year to process 1,000 sheep a day. (ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Chris Lewis) The new owners of a mothballed ... Read more »

Blues seek ‘growth’ as pre-season begins; new Hawk aims to be AFL’s serial pest

Carlton coach Michael Voss says he and his players understand there are heightened expectations on them, but insists the Blues are ready to develop individually and in their game plan. ... Read more »

Bulldogs continue signing frenzy with swap deal

The Bulldogs’ off-season signing frenzy is set to continue with the club reportedly set to land Cronnor Tracey in a swap deal. The Sydney Morning Herald reports Tracey is expected ... Read more »

Customers to weigh in as Optus disruption comes under microscope

Consumers and impacted businesses are being urged to have their say on the Optus outage, with the federal government laying out the terms of reference for its review into the ... Read more »

Released detainee unable to be contacted by authorities

It has been revealed a released immigration detainee is unable to be contacted by authorities. Border Force has referred the matter to the Federal Police as authorities are attempting to ... Read more »
Top List in the World