Krystle Wittevrongel: Let's be smarter on carbon capture — we won't get to net-zero without it

Asia's Tech News Daily

Next week COP26 in Glasgow is likely to call for even more ambitious GHG emission reduction targets than the ones that have been consistently missed by virtually all countries. Canada’s existing target of reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 is daunting enough as is.

Krystle Wittevrongel: Let's be smarter on carbon capture — we won't get to net-zero without it
© Provided by Financial Post Canada’s existing target of reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 is daunting enough as is.

Strangely, much of the focus of carbon policy has been on reducing the amount of carbon generated, with little attention paid to carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS). Yet CCUS technologies have the potential, not only to reduce, but to actually reverse rising atmospheric GHG. In fact, we simply cannot achieve carbon neutrality without them. Barrelling ahead without recognizing and acting on that fact would have very harmful effects on our economic growth and standard of living.

For one thing, some heavy industries, such as cement production, emit GHGs in essential processes that would be very hard to replace. They therefore need other strategies in order to achieve emissions reductions of the magnitude required to reach net-zero. Cement manufacturing alone currently produces eight per cent of CO2 emissions. But it does so in a very concentrated way, as the cement is cooked in giant kilns, that lends itself to carbon capture. There is a real opportunity to reduce GHG emissions through decarbonization, and not only in the cement industry.

CCUS could also work for energy. Most CCUS technologies can absorb 85 to 95 per cent of the CO2 produced by a power plant — though obviously at a cost. Worldwide, coal-fired power plants generated about 30 per cent of total CO2 emissions in 2018, so capturing most of that carbon would make a big dent in total emissions.

Ottawa has recognized CCUS technologies as being important in the move to net-zero, but challenges remain. In particular, high front-end and operating costs can discourage the uptake and large-scale deployment of these technologies. In order to enable and encourage commercial CCUS, government mechanisms need to provide incentives for entrepreneurs to do what they do best: innovate.

That does not mean picking winners and losers or favouring particular industry players. But, unlike many measures in Canada’s climate change strategy that involve uncertainties, competitive disadvantages, and job losses for manufacturing and other sectors, well-designed measures to encourage the capture and utilization or storage of carbon emissions could be less costly overall, while still helping to achieve Canada’s climate goals.

For instance, although an investment tax credit for capital invested in CCUS projects is in the works for 2022, its implementation needs to minimize market distortions. At the moment, “enhanced oil recovery” (EOR) projects, which capture and permanently store carbon, would be ineligible for the credit simply because they involve extraction. This exception should be eliminated. If oil extraction can be made less carbon-intensive, there is no reason, except pure ideology, to try to suppress it.

Because non-refundable tax credits tend to favour incumbent firms that have established revenues, the tax credit should be refundable. This would level the playing field for start-ups and others with negative or fluctuating tax liability.

  • Terence Corcoran: Two climate activists take charge of Canada’s resource economy. What could go wrong?
  • Joe Oliver: Our energy self-delusion continues
  • Terence Corcoran: Report on environmental groups targeting Alberta oil exposes disastrous charitable system

What about a tax credit based on performance? A potential model is the U.S.’s performance-based “Section 45Q Tax Credit,” which offers eligible facilities and projects (including EOR projects) a tax credit for each metric tonne of carbon captured, provided a number of conditions are met. A Canadian performance-based tax credit could be wedded to the existing federal carbon tax and based on net emissions. With appropriate incentives in place, entrepreneurs would innovate to find new ways to capture and store or use more emissions.

Projects need to thrive or not based, not on policy-makers’ arbitrary decisions, but on how the market judges them. That said, it is more important than ever to recognize the immense potential of CCUS technologies and to foster a robust, self-sustaining market for them. This will help Ottawa meet its environmental goals while favouring economic growth and preserving a high standard of living for Canadians.

Krystle Wittevrongel is a public policy analyst at the Montreal Economic Institute.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Cabinet minister Jacob Rees-Mogg and Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross investigated by sleaze watchdog

Britain’s Leader of the House of Commons Jacob Rees-Mogg arrives in Downing Street for a cabinet meeting in central London on November 30, 2021. (Photo by Daniel LEAL / AFP) ... Read more »

Erdogan defends 'risky but correct' economic policy

© Ozan KOSE The Turkish lira has lost over 43 percent in value against the dollar since the start of 2021 Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan defended Wednesday his “risky ... Read more »

Possession lost 20x: £40k-p/w NUFC dud who won 25% duels was run ragged vs Norwich - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast newcastle-manquillo-howe-norwich-premier-league Newcastle United’s winless start to the Premier League season continued as they were held to a 1-1 draw by Norwich on Tuesday night. The Magpies ... Read more »

Barry Bennell ‘stole or borrowed Manchester City kit for youth teams'

Paedophile former football coach Barry Bennell has told a High Court trial that he stole or borrowed Manchester City kit for his youth teams to wear during the 1980s. Bennell, ... Read more »

SL vs WI: Lasith Embuldeniya's magic delivery that cleaned up Kraigg Brathwaite - WATCH

© Provided by Zee News Sri Lanka spinner Lasith Embuldeniya is popular for weaving magic with the ball and Day 3 of the second Test against West Indies saw yet ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Craig Revel Horwood wants FIVE Strictly judges next year

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Craig Revel Horwood has revealed he’s got his sights set on Strictly Come Dancing returning next year with a five-piece judging panel for ... Read more »

New features and items, achievements revamp, and more listed in FFXIV Endwalker 6.0 preliminary patch notes

© Provided by Dot Esports Final Fantasy XIV‘s Endwalker is just around the corner, bringing the biggest content patch in over two years. Fans’ anticipation has reached its peak, and ... Read more »

UK energy supplier Zog Energy ceasing to trade regulator says

LONDON (Reuters) -Small British energy supplier Zog Energy is ceasing to trade, regulator Ofgem said on Wednesday, becoming the latest casualty of soaring wholesale energy costs. More than 20 energy ... Read more »

The best boutique hotels in the Lake District

When it comes to being almost irresponsibly good looking, the Lake District has easy-on-the-eye down to a fine art. Bursting with bucolic mountain tarns and rugged windswept fells, these picture-perfect ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Mahima Makwana on rejections: I was a typecast, can't describe the feeling when Antim happened

© Provided by Pinkvilla Antim: The Final Truth starring Salman Khan and Aayush Sharma has been released and has won the audience’s hearts. Helmed by Mahesh Manjrekar, it is an ... Read more »

Why now? The key points behind the changes at Inditex, including the appointment of Marta Ortega as chair

Inditex, the largest company in Spain’s blue-chip Ibex 35, with a market value of €87 billion, announced sweeping changes to its leadership team on Tuesday. Starting April 1, Marta Ortega ... Read more »

International Flights Won't Resume on Dec 15, India Rejigs Order Amid Omicron Threat

© Provided by News18 International Flights Won’t Resume on Dec 15, India Rejigs Order Amid Omicron Threat The Centre on Wednesday decided to postpone the resumption of scheduled international flights ... Read more »

Five of the England striker's best goals as she breaks Lionesses' all-time record

Ellen White became the Lionesses’ all-time record goalscorer as England beat Latvia 20-0 last night. © GiveMeSport Ellen White breaks Kelly Smith’s record The ever-present striker now has 48 goals ... Read more »

Top 10 novels about novelists

Writers writing about writers: the fact that there’s a lot of it about should perhaps come as no surprise. From the likes of Jack Torrance in The Shining to Paul ... Read more »

Marvel's Benedict Cumberbatch is an unsettling terror in Netflix's The Power of the Dog

The Power of the Dog is a Trojan horse. The movie, out now on Netflix, stars bonafide stars Benedict Cumberbatch, Kirsten Dunst and Jesse Plemmons in what appears at first ... Read more »

Covid deaths fell by 7% last week with 952 victims, figures show

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The number of people dying with Covid in England and Wales fell seven per cent last week, official data revealed today as flu ... Read more »

FIFA 22 FUT Champions Premium Upgrade SBC: Here's how to Complete, Cost and More

The FUT Champions Premium Upgrade SBC has officially been added to the FIFA 22 Ultimate Team system, but how can it be completed? © GiveMeSport Here’s how to complete the ... Read more »

Everything changing on railways from next weekend as London Underground expected to receive bailout

As is the case each December, a new National Rail timetable is set to be introduced meaning changes to journeys by rail across the capital. This year the changes take ... Read more »

Sutradhara's tales: When Shaniwarwada screamed “Uncle save me”

© Provided by Hindustan Times Chief Justice of Maratha Empire Ramshastri Prabhune ordered the death sentence on Raghobadada for Narayanrao’s murder. Narayanrao was killed in Shaniwarwada by Sumer Singh who ... Read more »

CHED: Only Fully Vaccinated Students Can Join Face-to-Face Classes

© Provided by PHOTO BY Facebook/CHED © Provided by PHOTO BY Facebook/CHED ( Only fully vaccinated tertiary students can join face-to-face classes, emphasized Commission on Higher Education Executive Director ... Read more »

Kashmir, Ladakh reel under bone-chilling winter, temperature hits record low

© Provided by Zee News Srinagar: Bone-chilling winter seemed to freeze Jammu and Kashmir as Srinagar recorded the season’s coldest night at minus 2.5 degrees Celsius, while Pahalgam town remained ... Read more »

FDA Issues Warning Against 10 Face Mask Brands, Plus Complete List Of Approved Masks

Even as new cases of COVID-19 continue to decline in the country daily, another threat looms. Omicron, a new variant of the coronavirus, has been detected in different South African ... Read more »

On Chinese Village near Arunachal, CDS Rawat and MEA Did Not Contradict Each Other

© Provided by News18 On Chinese Village near Arunachal, CDS Rawat and MEA Did Not Contradict Each Other The Indian media recently accused the government of contradicting itself; this was ... Read more »

Billie Eilish urges people to get vaccinated: ‘It's not just for you, you selfish b****'

© Vanity Fair/YouTube Screenshot 2021-12-01 at 11.26.49 2.png Billie Eilish has called on people to stop being “selfish” and get vaccinated against Covid-19. The 19-year-old singer made her plea in ... Read more »

Manchester United co-owner's company buys UAE T20 League franchise

© Provided by Zee News Lancer Capital, headed by top English football club Manchester United’s co-chairman Avram Glazer, has made its first foray into cricket by acquiring a franchise in ... Read more »

Jaya Bachchan complains about Amitabh Bachchan, Shweta Bachchan reacts

© Provided by Mid-Day Amitabh Bachchan has been associated with the game show Kaun Banega Crorepati for the last 2 decades. It all began for the Superstar in the year ... Read more »

200 e-Emergency X-visas issued to Afghans till Nov 24: Govt informs Parliament

© Provided by Hindustan Times A Taliban fighter stands guard in Kabul, Afghanistan.  (Reuters File Photo) The Union home ministry on Wednesday informed Parliament that 200 e-Emergency X-miscellaneous visas have ... Read more »

Victoria Beckham jets to Paris in the most extra outfit ever

© Provided by Hello! victoria-beckham-makeup On Tuesday evening, the gorgeous Victoria Beckham took to Instagram to share a video of herself on the way to Paris, rocking an extremely chic ... Read more »

Spider-Man: No Way Home star Tom Holland looks back at ‘amazing advice' he received from Elizabeth Olsen

© Provided by Pinkvilla Spider-Man: No Way Home star Tom Holland recently opened up about getting some useful advice from his Marvel co-star Elizabeth Olsen. Talking to GQ for a ... Read more »

Blue are 'always' working on new music

Blue are “always recording” and could show off some new material in 2022. © Bang Showbiz Blue could play some new material on tour The ‘One Love’ hitmakers – whose ... Read more »

Marcus Rashford to publish children's novel The Breakfast Club Adventures

Fresh from receiving an MBE for his campaigning to lift children out of poverty, Marcus Rashford is now warming up for a new challenge: the England footballer is writing a ... Read more »

Five accused in 2013 Muzaffarnagar riot case acquitted

© Provided by Zee News Muzaffarnagar: A court here has acquitted five 2013 Muzaffarnagar riot accused due to the paucity of evidence against them. Additional Sessions Judge Babu Ram acquitted ... Read more »

Technology firm Blue Prism agrees new £1.2bn takeover bid from SS&C Technologies

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Software developer Blue Prism has accepted a £1.2billion takeover approach by American fintech giant SS&C Technologies. Under the new proposal, Blue Prism ... Read more »

With Omicron Variant Lurking Globally, Is India Battle Ready for a Third Wave?

© Provided by News18 With Omicron Variant Lurking Globally, Is India Battle Ready for a Third Wave? The new Covid-19 variant, Omicron, first detected in southern Africa, has sparked concerns ... Read more »

Tourism chief brushes off impact of tighter entry rules for fully vaxxed travelers

Tourism Sec. Bernadette Romulo-Puyat at Senate hearing Sept. 23, 2021 Tourism Secretary Bernadette Romulo-Puyat brushed off the impact on the tourism industry of the suspension of a resolution allowing the ... Read more »

Tom Morello wants shock factor in guitar playing

Tom Morello wants as many “what the f***” factors in his music as possible. © Bang Showbiz Tom Morello wants to innovate The Rage Against The Machine guitarist – who ... Read more »

Forget Neves: Lage must unleash Wolves' "magnificent" rarely-seen 19 y/o tonight - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Wolves, Premier League, Bruno Lage, Jeff Shi, Molineux, Ruben Neves, Luke Cundle, Wolverhampton Wanderers’ start to the 2021/22 campaign was far from ideal. Bruno Lage ... Read more »

Tyson Fury's coach shares 'never before seen' image of Gypsy King when he weighed 28 stone

The coach that trained Tyson Fury has shared a first time image of the WBC heavyweight champion at 28 stone. © GiveMeSport p1flqu78pj79mhits7t4eh1c41h.jpg The Gypsy King has been on the ... Read more »

Horoskop: Deine geheime Schicksalszahl verrät dein Zukunft!

© Dzhulbee / iStock Horoskop: Deine Lebenszahl verrät dein Schicksal! Du möchtest mehr über dich selbst herausfinden? Checke jetzt ab, was deine geheime Schicksalszahl über dich, deine Zukunft und dein ... Read more »

EU unveils 300 billion euro answer to China's Belt and Road

By Jan Strupczewski © Reuters/YVES HERMAN EU flags flutter outside the European Commission headquarters in Brussels BRUSSELS (Reuters) -The European Commission unveiled on Wednesday a plan to invest 300 billion ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic