Kerala HC refuses to interfere with Karnataka govt travel restrictions on people coming from the southern state

#coronavirus, #Current Affairs, #India, #Karnataka, #Kerala HC

Kerala High Court (File image: PTI)

The Kerala High Court on Tuesday dismissed two pleas challenging Karnataka government’s decision to restrict entry from Kerala at borders of Kasaragod and Mangalore only to those having a negative RT-PCR report, saying the neighbouring state was well within its powers to issue such directions.

The high court said it was an admitted fact there was no blockade of the roads from Kerala to Karnataka and the restrictions, like a negative RT-PCR certificate, were imposed within that state in view of the unprecedented surge of COVID-19 pandemic prevalent in Kerala.

“Therefore, going by the guidelines issued by the central government, it is clear that under any such circumstances, the states are given the power and responsibility to impose reasonable restrictions, so as to combat the disease.

“Therefore, state of Karnataka was well within its powers to issue circulars, orders or guidelines under the provisions of the Disaster Management Act, 2005, in consonance with various guidelines issued by the central government,” a bench of Chief Justice S Manikumar and Justice Shaji P Chaly said and dismissed the two PILs, one by A K M Ashraf, the IUML MLA from Manjeshwar and the other by Jayananda K R, the Secretary of Rastrakavi Manjeshwara Govinda Pai Smaraka Samithi.

The bench further said that the Karnataka government has the necessary leverage to issue circulars, taking into account the situations prevailing in the neighbouring states of Kerala and Maharashtra.

“Viewed from that angle, it can never be said that a part of cause of action for the writ petitions has arisen within the state of Kerala. This is more so when there is no absolute prohibition for the citizens of Kerala to travel to Karnataka by any means, but we can only view it as restrictions imposed by the state of Karnataka.

“Whether the restrictions imposed within the State of Karnataka are reasonable or not, is a matter to be considered and decided by the jurisdictional High Court,” the bench said in its 100-page judgement.

It further said that a “wholesome appreciation of the facts and circumstances” would show that no part of the cause of action, as regards the circulars issued by Karnataka government or its officials, would arise in Kerala.

“Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the petitioners have failed to establish territorial jurisdiction of this court in interfering with the circulars issued by the state of Karnataka dated July 31 and accordingly, we decline the reliefs sought for by the petitioners in the background of the circulars so issued. In the result, the writ petitions are dismissed for want of territorial jurisdiction,” the bench said.

The petitioners had contended that the travel restrictions had resulted in people from Kerala being unable to enter Karnataka for any emergent situations and therefore, it was totally illegal and violative of the fundamental rights of citizens.

The blockade was also causing disruption in trade, supply of food and other essential items and interfering with the rights of the citizens to move freely throughout the territory of India, the two PILs — one of them filed by advocate P V Anoop — had claimed.

The pleas had also claimed that people of Manjeshwar rely entirely upon the medical facilities at Dakshin Kannada district/Mangalore city and its adjacent areas, since it is the nearest medical hub available.

The Karnataka government had opposed the two pleas on the ground that the entire cause of action arises within that state, and the petitioners should challenge the circulars before the High Court of Karnataka.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

COVID effect: When the weakest quarter becomes the strongest for airlines

Representational image. Traditionally, Indian aviation has been divided into two ‘good’ and two ‘not good’ quarters. More often than not, this is also reflected in airline results. The April-May-June quarter ... Read more »

100-cr milestone achieved through made-in-India vaccines: COVID Task Force chief

As the total COVID-19 vaccine doses administered in India crossed the 100-crore milestone, COVID Task Force chief V K Paul said on Thursday said this is a remarkable feat and ... Read more »

India shows exemplary capabilities to ensure people's welfare: Niti Aayog VC on vaccine milestone

Niti Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday said India once again shows exemplary capabilities to deliver the solutions for ensuring people’s welfare as the total COVID-19 vaccine doses administered ... Read more »

India crosses 100-crore-vaccination mark | The Everest is yet to be conquered

Despite the hostile terrain, the northern state of Himachal Pradesh, where Malana is located, earlier this month became the first in India to administer at least one COVID-19 vaccine dose ... Read more »

Zahl der Menschen mit einfachem Impfschutz in Deutschland steigt auf rund 57,4 Millionen

Düsseldorf. Die Impfungen gegen das Coronavirus laufen. Bislang wurden in Deutschland rund 110 Millionen Dosen verimpft, im Vergleich zur letzten Meldung stieg die Zahl um 191.737 weitere Impfungen. Hier finden ... Read more »

Housing prices across cities largely stable in third quarter, may inch up as demand outgrows supply

An accelerating COVID-19 vaccination drive, robust hiring in the financial services, information technology (IT) and IT-enabled services (ITes) sectors, coupled with record-low home loan interest rates, helped housing sales double ... Read more »

Delhi Police to SC: Need four more months for probe into case against Shivinder Singh

Delhi Police on Thursday told the Supreme Court it needed four more months to complete the probe in a case in which former Fortis Healthcare promoter Shivinder Mohan Singh is ... Read more »

India now as a 'protective' shield' of 100 crore vaccine doses: PM Modi

India now has a strong “protective shield” of 100 crore vaccine doses to combat Covid-19, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Thursday, as the country passed this important milestone in ... Read more »

Farmers have right to protest but they can't block roads indefinitely, says SC

The Supreme Court on Thursday said farmers protesting at Delhi borders against the three farms laws have the right to agitate but they cannot block roads indefinitely. A bench headed ... Read more »

As India administers 100 cr COVID-19 vaccine doses, experts urge caution, say pandemic not yet over

Even as India reached the landmark of 100 crore COVID-19 vaccinations on Thursday, experts urged caution and said that the pandemic is far from over. Former Director-General of Indian Council ... Read more »

Zahl der vollständig Geimpften in Deutschland steigt um 77.278 auf 66 Prozent

Düsseldorf. Die Impfungen gegen das Coronavirus laufen. Bislang wurden in Deutschland rund 110 Millionen Dosen verimpft, im Vergleich zur letzten Meldung stieg die Zahl um 191.737 weitere Impfungen. Hier finden ... Read more »

NCB in Bollywood: Ananya Pandey summoned for questioning

Image: Twitter/Ananya Pandey The Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) has issued a summons to Bollywood actor Ananya Pandey’s. The NCB is yet to confirm if the summon is related to Aryan ... Read more »

Varroc Engineering up 8% as HDFC AMC ups shareholding

NEW DELHI: Shares of Varroc Engineering jumped almost 8 per cent on Thursday as HDFC Asset Management Company took a 0.58 per cent stake in the company through open market ... Read more »

Shoppers Stop rallies 20% after upbeat Q2 results

New Delhi: Shares of Shoppers Stop zoomed as much as 20 per cent on Thursday after the company reported a strong set of numbers in September 2021 quarter. The retail ... Read more »

UK borrowing halves in first half of tax year as Rishi Sunak readies budget

British public borrowing fell by around half in the first six months of the current financial year compared with a year earlier, when the economy faced the full force of ... Read more »

Green hydrogen to account for 20% of European power demand by 2050: Statkraft

Hydrogen produced from renewable energy sources will account for 20% of Europe’s power consumption in 2050, and for 10% globally, a report published by Norwegian power company Statkraft on Thursday ... Read more »

100 heritage monuments to be lit in colours of Indian flag to mark 100 crore COVID vaccination feat

The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) will light up 100 of its heritage monuments in colours of the national flag to mark 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses being administered in ... Read more »

Over 103 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses provided to States, UTs: Centre

The government has provided more than 103.5 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses to States and union territories (UTs), said the Union Health Ministry on Thursday. A total of 1,03,53,51,045 vaccine doses ... Read more »

Gauri Lankesh murder: SC sets aside HC order quashing charge sheet against accused for KCOCA offences

The Supreme Court on Thursday set aside the Karnataka High Court order quashing the charge sheet against an accused in the murder of journalist Gauri Lankesh for purported offences under ... Read more »

Shah Rukh Khan meets Aryan Khan at Arthur Road jail

Actor Shah Rukh Khan paid a visit to his son Aryan who is lodged in Mumbai’s Arthur Road jail in a drugs haul case, on October 21. The the 23-year-old was arrested after ... Read more »

100 crore vaccination milestone: 61% Indian citizens willing to take third dose, finds survey

Source: AP As India achieved the 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses milestone, at least 61 percent of citizens have expressed willingness to take the third dose of COVID-19 vaccine, if ... Read more »

Havells slumps 7% on disappointing Q2 results

NEW DELHI: Shares of Havells India slumped more than 7 per cent in early trading Mumbai on Thursday as the consumer electrical goods maker posted a 7.34 per cent fall ... Read more »

Why Indian Doctors Are Taking Booster Shots Of COVID-19 Vaccine

Ever since the pandemic first struck, doctors and healthcare workers have emerged as our first line of defence against infection. Their contributions have been widely reported and lauded. Some of ... Read more »

MG Motor India sells out first batch of SUV Astor within 20 minutes of opening bookings

MG Motor India – the British brand owned by China’s SAIC – has sold out the first batch of SUV Astor within 20 mins of opening booking Thursday. Deliveries for ... Read more »

Ministers ‘wilfully negligent' by not reimposing Covid restrictions, says doctors union

© REUTERS London Underground passengers, some wearing masks, travel amidst the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in London Doctors have accused ministers of being “wilfully negligent” after the ... Read more »

Uttarakhand flash floods and landslides: Death toll mounts to 54, five missing

Flash floods and landslides caused by heavy rains in Uttarakhand have claimed the lives of 54 people in the last few days. A total of 19 people have sustained injuries ... Read more »

Achieved 100 crore COVID-19 vaccinations through collective effort, says Bhupender Yadav

Union Minister for Environment, Forest and Climate Change Bhupender Yadav on Thursday said the landmark of 100 crore COVID-19 vaccinations has been achieved through collective effort. “Today we’ve achieved 100 ... Read more »

The hydra-headed monster that wants to gatecrash your retirement party

Fixed deposits or FDs, the play-safe savings investment bet for many Indians, now fetch a negative return due to high inflation. That is, the interest you earn on your FD ... Read more »

L&T Finance Holdings sheds almost 5% after dip in Q2 profit

NEW DELHI: Shares of L&T Finance Holdings dropped almost 5 per cent in early Mumbai trading Thursday as the non-banking financial company reported a fall of 10 per cent in ... Read more »

India administró 1.000 millones de vacunas contra COVID-19

© AP ASI-GEN CORONAVIRUS-VACUNAS INDIA India ha administrado 1.000 millones de dosis de vacunas contra el COVID-19, dijeron las autoridades el jueves, un hito para un país donde la variante ... Read more »

Uttarakhand: At least 46 killed in floods in northern India

India Floods (ASSOCIATED PRESS) At least 46 people have died and several are missing after floods triggered by heavy rains hit the northern Indian state of Uttarakhand officials said Wednesday. ... Read more »

Cruise drugs case: Bombay HC to hear Aryan Khan's bail plea on October 26

The Bombay High Court on Thursday said it would hear on October 26 the bail plea filed by Aryan Khan, son of superstar Shah Rukh Khan, in connection with a ... Read more »

Jhunjhunwalas hike stake in Titan for first time since Dec 2019

NEW DELHI: The jhunjhunwala duo, Rakesh and his better half Rekha, bought Titan Company shares in September quarter on a net basis for the first time since December quarter of ... Read more »

India's vaccination drive outpaces most countries as it breaches 100 crore inoculation mark

With an uptick in the world’s largest vaccination drive against COVID-19, India on Thursday crossed inoculation of 100 crore vaccine doses, according to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. ... Read more »

Online abuse: Banning anonymous social media accounts is not the answer

In the wake of the tragic death of the member of parliament for Southend West, David Amess, fellow MPs have been talking about how to best protect both politicians and ... Read more »

China: Crunch time for Evergrande as unit sale collapses

The collapse of China Evergrande’s planned $2.5 billion sale of a property services unit has left the troubled company closer than ever to its end, ramping up fears it will ... Read more »

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker: India achieves 100-crore-vaccinations milestone on October 21

Representative image. India has achieved the milestone of 100 crore (one billion) vaccinations on October 21. India accounts for about 15 percent of the total vaccine doses administered worldwide as ... Read more »

'India scripts history,' PM Modi says, as nation reaches 100-crore COVID jab milestone

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. As India reached an extraordinary milestone of giving away 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses on October 21, Prime Minister Narendra Modi congratulated the nation and expressed gratitude to ... Read more »

India sees over 18,000 new COVID-19 cases, 160 deaths

A single-day rise of 18,454 fresh cases pushed India’s COVID-19 tally to 3,41,27,450, while the number of active infections rose to 1,78,831, according to the Union Health Ministry data updated ... Read more »

Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya congratulates nation as COVID-19 vaccinations cross 100 cr mark

Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya on Thursday congratulated the citizens of India on crossing 100 crore COVID-19 vaccination coverage and attributed the achievement to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. “Congratulations India! ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic