Keir Starmer backs ‘women-only spaces' in ‘specific circumstances', amid Labour row

© Rosie Duffield won’t attend Labourconference in Brighton this week

Rosie Duffield said she was ‘not confident’ that Labour would maintain its policy

Trans women can be excluded from some “women-only spaces” in some circumstances, Keir Starmer says, as the controversy threatens to open a bitter row in the party.

The Labour leader’s spokesman said he remained wedded to the policy on which the party fought the last general election – and that there was “no reason to expect it is going to change”.

This meant backing “the implementation of the Equality Act, including the single-sex exemption which allows the provision of women-only spaces”.

The law “rightly assumes the inclusion of trans women, except in specific circumstances”, the spokesman said, normally thought to include prisons and refuges.

The stance comes after Labour backbencher Rosie Duffield – who has pulled out of the Labour conference over security fears – protested that she did not know where Sir Keir stood on the issue.

Last week, the Canterbury MP – who has received threats of violence after her comments on transgender rights – questioned whether Labour was about to change course.

She urged Sir Keir to maintain support for “biological females” to feel “protected” in prisons and domestic violence refuges, for example, but said she was “not confident” the policy would be upheld.

Ms Duffield held talks with the Labour leader yesterday, as he also met with Labour MPs in the party’s LGBT+ [Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Rights] group.

Amid the controversy over the abuse she has received, Sir Keir’s spokesman reiterated that “debate should always be held in an atmosphere of respect for all points of view”.

“Keir met with Rosie Duffield yesterday, following on from her request for a meeting,” he said, adding he also met the LGBT+ group separately.

On the party’s policy, he said: “Our position on this has not changed [from the 2019 manifesto].

“What we have said is that Labour would work to update the Gender Recognition Act to enable a process for gender identification.

“And we also continue to support the implementation of the Equality Act, including the single-sex exemption which allows the provision of women-only spaces. This law rightly assumes the inclusion of trans women, except in specific circumstances.”

In contrast, the Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey said trans women should be allowed to enter all public places, as he accused Boris Johnson of stirring up “a culture war” on the issue.

In 2019, Ms Duffield spoke powerfully in the Commons chamber about suffering domestic abuse during a previous relationship.

Last week, she said the Equality Act was not specific about women-only spaces, but laid down they should exist “where it is deemed necessary”.

“Of course, that’s open to interpretation, but I would have thought – at the very least – that implies domestic violence settings,” Ms Duffield told BBC Radio 4.

“Everyone has the right to be protected, and if biological females need more spaces that are just for them … we have the 2010 Equality Act and we have pledged as a party to uphold that.”

But, asked if that would be Labour’s policy at the next election, the MP replied: “I’m not confident. We haven’t had another discussion, debate.”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


MPs' safety: Dominic Raab reveals three threats to ‘life and limb'

The deputy prime minister, Dominic Raab, has revealed he has received three threats “to life and limb” in two years that have resulted in police intervention. Raab was speaking as ... Read more »

Rumah pekerja binaan musnah terbakar

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA LUMPUR – Tempat tinggal pekerja di sebuah tapak pembinaan di Persiaran Pertahanan di sini musnah dalam satu kebakaran pada Isnin. Komander Operasi, Penguasa Bomba ... Read more »

ADUN Kunak nafi akan keluar Warisan

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today ADUN Warisan, Norazlinah Arif nafi akan keluar parti itu. (Gambar Bernama) KUNAK: Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Kunak Norazlinah Arif menafikan dakwaan yang dia ... Read more »

TNB, LADA jalin kerjasama kurangkan emisi karbon

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) menerusi anak syarikat solusi tenaga hijaunya, GSPARX Sdn Bhd (GSPARX) akan menjalin kerjasama dengan Lembaga Pembangunan Langkawi (LADA) ... Read more »

MAFI bantu usahawan tempatan terokai pasaran Timur Tengah

© Provided by Sinar Harian KOTA BHARU – Kementerian Pertanian dan Industri Makanan (MAFI) sedia membantu usahawan tempatan yang mengeluarkan produk halal menerokai pasaran negara Timur Tengah. Timbalan Menteri Pertanian ... Read more »

‘I don't need to repent': Nur Sajat says from Australia

Nur Sajat on TikTok live. Photo: @NurSajat23/TikTok A well-known entrepreneur wanted in Malaysia on blasphemy charges revealed to her fans today that she is in Sydney, Australia. The 36-year-old transgender ... Read more »

Apple employee, who was vocal on discrimination, fired

© Provided by Al Jazeera Apple has recently experienced multiple instances of employee unrest [File: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg] An Apple employee who led fellow workers in publicly sharing instances of ... Read more »

UPDATE 1-Britain pays tribute to murdered lawmaker Amess

(Recasts headline and lead) LONDON, Oct 18 (Reuters) – Britain pays tribute on Monday to David Amess, the veteran lawmaker stabbed to death while meeting constituency voters, as police questioned ... Read more »

UPDATE 1-Myanmar junta leader blames opponents for prolonging unrest

* Says ethnic rebels, militias stoking violence * Some demands of ASEAN envoy non-negotiable * Shadow govt lauds ASEAN move, but wants recognition * Junta announces amnesty for 5,600 people ... Read more »

Victorian truck driver accused of spitting on and assaulting South Australian police refused bail

© Provided by ABC Business Trucks pulling up at a border checkpoint in the South East. (File: ABC South East SA) A Victorian truck driver accused of spitting at and assaulting ... Read more »

AFLW scare, AFL star blasts mandatory jabs

Melbourne premiership star Tom McDonald is strongly against mandatory vaccinations for AFL players, saying the move would be ethically wrong. © Dave Hunt/AAP PHOTOS Richmond are waiting for advice from ... Read more »

Inside Newcastle's strange first game under Saudi ownership as fans make feelings clear

First the celebrations, then the reality check. After 11 days playing fantasy football, speculating on which superstars could arrive, and director Amanda Staveley insisting the Saudi-Geordies are targeting the title ... Read more »

Christmas rations: The two food items supermarkets could put limits on

Let’s face it, Christmas is all about sitting down with your loved ones and enjoying an extravagant, hearty meal. Last year’s festivities were blown to pieces by the UK Government’s ... Read more »

Covid survivor: ‘I was so auto-immune compromised that I am sure it was the vaccine that saved my life'

A man (41) who was vaccinated against Covid-19 – but still ended up in ICU for six days fighting the virus – says he believes the vaccine saved his life. ... Read more »

Roast pumpkin soup with sage butter recipe

Roast pumpkin soup with sage butter – Yuki Sugiura I like to use Crown Prince for this as it has sweet flesh and a great colour, but butternut is fine ... Read more »

Queer Eye's Jonathan Van Ness schools ‘dumb f**k' Marjorie Taylor Greene on the reality of HIV

Queer Eye‘s Jonathan Van Ness stepped in to school Marjorie Taylor Greene after she attempted to draw comparisons between anti-vaxxers and those living with HIV. The infamously dreadful Republican congresswoman ... Read more »

Netflix's Mega-Hit ‘Squid Game' Will Generate Almost $900 Million In Value

Netflix projects the Korean-language megahit Squid Game will create almost $900 million dollars in value. In a confidential document reviewed by Bloomberg News, Squid Game generated $891.1 million in impact ... Read more »

Kenyan court allows police to hold husband of athlete for 20 days

© Reuters/Ibrahem Alomari FILE PHOTO: World Athletics Championships – Doha 2019 NAIROBI (Reuters) – A Kenyan court on Monday allowed police to hold the husband of long distance runner Agnes ... Read more »

Russian court to consider transfer of jailed ex-U.S. Marine Whelan to U.S. - TASS

© Reuters/MAXIM SHEMETOV Detained former U.S. marine Whelan attends a court hearing in Moscow MOSCOW (Reuters) – A Russian court will consider a request next month to transfer former U.S. ... Read more »

Jesy Nelson downs shots and cocktails on night out as Leigh-Anne Pinnock makes teary speech at birthday bash

JESY Nelson downed shots and cocktails as she hit the town with friends – while former bandmate Leigh-Anne Pinnock threw an epic birthday party. The Boyz singer, 29, let her ... Read more »

Passport warning as government announces new rules for 26 countries

THE government has updated their latest passport warning for Brits going on holiday to Europe. With families heading abroad this week during the summer half-term, many are being warned to ... Read more »

Jack Fincham joins Towie to confront Frankie Sims as the exes have explosive row on-screen

JACK Fincham is set to confront ex Frankie Sims on The Only Way Is Essex following their split in July. The Love Island champ, 30, reportedly filmed the scenes for ... Read more »

Opposition party writes to Agong over 12th Sarawak state election

© Provided by New Straits Times KUCHING: Parti Sarawak Bersatu has written an appeal to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah not to accede to any ... Read more »

UK MPs to pay tribute to slain colleague in parliament

© Adrian DENNIS Tributes have been paid to David Amess, since he was stabbed to death on Friday British lawmakers will on Monday pay tributes in parliament to their fallen ... Read more »

Military veterans to appear in court over hostage drama

© Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – 56 military veterans are expected to appear in connection with Thursday night’s hostage drama, at the St George Hotel in Centurion. The members of ... Read more »

Aren't you supposed to be ill? What ARE the rules around medical parole?

© Provided by CapeTalk – Jacob Zuma was spotted at a Durban casino on Friday, weeks after being released on medical parole – One does not need to be terminally ... Read more »

Ferrari: P3 in F1 championship clear target after gains on McLaren

© Charles Coates / Motorsport Images Carlos Sainz Jr., Ferrari SF21, Daniel Ricciardo, McLaren MCL35M Ferrari cut into McLaren’s advantage in the fight for third in the standings last time ... Read more »

Guantanamo Bay detainee could give evidence on torture

© MCT Zayn al Abidin Muhammad Husayn, a Palestinian known as Abu Zubaydah, is imprisoned at Guantanamo. (Department of Defense/Tribune News Service via Getty Images) A suspected high-ranking Al Qaeda ... Read more »

1 dead, 7 injured as US college endures two shootings in a week

© Provided by Khaleej Times 1 dead, 7 injured as US college endures two shootings in a week One person was killed and another seven were injured at a US ... Read more »

Australia's Queensland state to open to vaccinated travellers

© Provided by Khaleej Times Australia’s Queensland state to open to vaccinated travellers Australia’s Queensland state announced plans on Monday to open up to vaccinated travellers, ending the status it ... Read more »

Twins 'trying to see moon' fall to death from 25th-floor flat

© Provided by Khaleej Times Twins ‘trying to see moon’ fall to death from 25th-floor flat Two brothers, aged 13, died after falling from the 25th-floor balcony of their apartment ... Read more »

German greens vote to join coalition talks

© Martin Meissner A preliminary agreement in coalition talks calls for Germany to accelerate its exit from coal-fuelled power. Photo:AP Germany’s Greens have voted to enter coalition talks to form ... Read more »

Akifcafe instant coffee to enter Middle East market

© Provided by New Straits Times KOTA BARU: A Kelantan-based company which produces instant coffee powder, is spreading its wings into more Middle East markets. Deputy Agriculture and Food Industry ... Read more »

Sultan Selangor terima menghadap Menteri Kesihatan

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Sultan Selangor, Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah berkenan menerima menghadap Menteri Kesihatan, Khairy Jamaluddin Abu Bakar di Istana Bukit Kayangan pada Isnin. Menerusi ... Read more »

#Showbiz: Duet gets Namewee, Kimberley Chen blocked by Weibo

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Chinese social media platform Weibo has blocked the accounts of Malaysian singer-actor Namewee and Australian singer Kimberley Chen, for their satirical duet ... Read more »

#Showbiz: 'I have to talk loudly due to the voices in my head' - Janna Nick

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Award-winning actress Janna Nick who suffers from bipolar disorder, constantly hears voices in her head, which consequently cause her speak loudly. The ... Read more »

Ahmadinejad: ‘No War in the Region Will Have Any Winners'

US has helped install Taliban in Afghanistan which will lead to a resurgence of Al Qaeda, only to clash with Iran, but this plan will be foiled soon, Iran’s former ... Read more »

Dos penggalak untuk 'frontliners' Pulau Pinang bermula Isnin

© Provided by Sinar Harian GEORGETOWN – Program Imunisasi Covid-19 Kebangsaan (PICK) bagi dos penggalak untuk petugas barisan hadapan peringkat Pulau Pinang bermula pada Isnin. Ketua Menteri, Chow Kon Yeow ... Read more »

PH Melaka bawa isu pembuburan DUN ke mahkamah

© Provided by Sinar Harian MELAKA – Pakatan Harapan (PH) Melaka akan meneruskan langkah membawa isu pembubaran Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Melaka ke-14 ke mahkamah dalam minggu ini. Pengerusinya, Adly ... Read more »

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar unveils 'Bhoodan Grove' plaque at Jerusalem Forest in Israel

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Monday unveiled the “Bhoodan Grove” plaque at the Jerusalem Forest, bringing out lesser-known aspects of Indo-Israel relations before the establishment of full-fledged diplomatic ties ... Read more »