Kavanaugh cites landmark gay rights cases in argument about abortion restrictions

Asia's Tech News Daily

Lawyers who argued for LGBTQ rights in those landmark cases — Obergefell v. Hodges and Lawrence v. Texas — were conflicted on the validity of Justice Kavanaugh’s argument.

Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh seemed to suggest earlier this week that landmark LGBTQ cases could support overturning federal abortion rights.

The Supreme Court heard 90 minutes of oral arguments Wednesday concerning a Mississippi law that would ban almost all abortions in the state after 15 weeks of pregnancy.

A majority of the court’s conservative justices appeared prepared to uphold the law and possibly overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 landmark decision holding that women have a constitutional right to have an abortion before fetal viability, usually around 24 weeks.

The crux of Wednesday’s oral arguments centered around whether the justices should preserve or walk back on precedent, a court decision that is considered authority for subsequent cases involving similar or identical circumstances. The court’s liberal justices warned that reversing a decades-old ruling would politicize the country’s highest court.

However, citing two landmark gay rights cases — Lawrence v. Texas, which struck down state laws criminalizing consensual same-sex activity in 2003, and Obergefell v. Hodges, which resulted in the legalization of same-sex marriage across the United States in 2015 — Kavanaugh suggested that overruling the court’s previous opinions was standard procedure.

“If you think about some of the most important cases, the most consequential cases in this court’s history, there’s a string of them where the cases overruled precedent,” Kavanaugh said. “If we think that the prior precedents are seriously wrong, if that, why then doesn’t the history of this court’s practice with respect to those cases tell us that the right answer is actually a return to the position of neutrality and — and not stick with those precedents in the same way that all those other cases didn’t?”

The lawyers who argued in favor of gay rights in the landmark LGBTQ cases offered differing views on the validity of the argument by Kavanaugh, who was appointed in 2018 by then-President Donald Trump.

Mary Bonauto, who argued on behalf of same-sex couples in Obergefell v. Hodges and now serves as the Civil Rights Project director at GLBTQ Legal Advocates & Defenders, or GLAD, challenged Kavanaugh’s analogy.

“It’s a pretty thin interpretation of a reversal,” she told NBC News. “The reversals that Justice Kavanaugh is citing were about righting wrongs. They were centered on the rights of individuals and expanding constitutional protections to more individuals, not about taking rights away.”

When the court ruled in favor of same-sex couples in Obergefell v. Hodges, it effectively overturned its prior decision in Baker v. Nelson. That ruling centered on Jack Baker and Mike McConnell, who in 1970 were blocked from obtaining a marriage license. The high court rejected the men’s case in 1972 without ever hearing oral arguments.

Bonauto argued against Kavanaugh’s comparison of reversing Baker v. Nelson to the potential reversal of Roe v. Wade.

“There was no briefing, there was no argument. They just essentially utterly dismissed the case for basically: ‘There’s no way same-sex couples seeking to marry have claim under the Constitution.’ The end,” she said.

LGBTQ advocates largely agreed with Bonauto, saying that the landmark gay rights decisions in Obergefell v. Hodges and Lawrence v. Texas “reflected the growing societal understanding of our common humanity.”

“To that we say, NOT IN OUR NAME,” Sharon McGowan, legal director of the LGBTQ advocacy group Lambda Legal, said of Kavanaugh’s argument in a statement Wednesday. “Those landmark LGBTQ decisions EXPANDED individual liberty, not the opposite.”

But Paul Smith, who argued in favor of LGBTQ rights in Lawrence v. Texas — which overruled the court’s 1986 decision in Bowers v. Hardwick — suggested that Kavanaugh’s comparison was valid. Smith said that in order to win Lawrence v. Texas, he also had to bolster the argument for the court overriding precedent.

“We really, actually made those arguments ourselves in Lawrence because that was the whole point — we had to get rid of Bowers v. Hardwick,” Smith, who is now a professor at Georgetown University Law Center, said. “It is certainly one of the most prominent examples of an overruling that’s happened in the last 20 years.”

“People talk about stare decisis when they like the prior decision and not when they don’t,” Smith added, referring to the legal term for following what the court has ruled previously.

But during the oral arguments, Justice Sonia Sotomayor raised the question of whether overruling Roe v. Wade could open the floodgates for the court’s 6-3 conservative majority to overrule a broad swath of previous opinions it does not agree with.

“Why do we now say that somehow … Roe and Casey are so unusual that they must be overturned?” Sotomayor said Wednesday, referring to Planned Parenthood v. Casey, a 1992 opinion that affirmed Roe v. Wade.

Later, during the oral arguments, Justice Amy Coney Barrett pressed Mississippi Solicitor General Scott Stewart, who was defending the Mississippi abortion limits, to address Sotomayor’s assertion.

Stewart said that several of the other cases Sotomayor cited, including the LGBTQ cases, produced “clear rules that have engendered strong reliance interests and that have not produced negative consequences,” in contrast to Roe v. Wade.

But if the court does overrule the landmark abortion law, some legal experts warn that previous rulings, including the landmark LGBTQ decisions, would be in danger.

“You can be sure that the Alliance Defending Freedom has the lawsuit ready to file the day after the Supreme Court issues an opinion broadly overruling Roe,” Katherine Franke, the director of the Center for Gender and Sexuality Law at Columbia Law School, said referring to a Christian law firm with a decadeslong track record of litigating against LGBTQ rights. “They will file the next day challenging Obergefell and even Lawrence. I have every confidence that that is what they’re to do.”

The court is expected to decide on the Mississippi abortion law early next summer.

Follow NBC Out on TwitterFacebook & Instagram

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Charles Omenihu on difference from Texans to 49ers: “It’s not a circus show here”

The San Francisco 49ers acquired defensive end Charles Omenihu in a trade with the Houston Texans in November. Two months later, the Texans season is over and the 49ers are ... Read more »

Can you get fit in just 20 minutes? New Beachbody program focuses on short, effective workouts

You’d be hard-pressed to find someone who hasn’t heard of Beachbody workouts. Even those who aren’t into fitness have likely seen the late-night infomercials where people show off their dramatic ... Read more »

Reviewers Are Obsessed With This Foldable Treadmill, And It's Over $400 Off Now

Now that January is already *checks calendar* half-way over(!), you could be trying to get back to your pre-holiday routine or wanting to adopt some “new year, new you” hobbies. ... Read more »

Arthur Series Finale Will Feature Beloved Characters as Grown-Ups and 'What's in Store for the Future'

© Provided by People PBS Kids There are big, big plans in store for Arthur’s upcoming series conclusion. The long-running PBS children’s series will air its final four episodes as ... Read more »

How to style joggers 4 different ways, from sporty to sophisticated

Shop TODAY is editorially independent. Our editors selected these deals and items because we think you will enjoy them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, we ... Read more »

9 expert-approved storage solutions that will completely transform your garage

Shop TODAY is editorially independent. Our editors selected these deals and items because we think you will enjoy them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, we ... Read more »

10 Retinol Creams & Serums That Are Worth the Splurge

© Provided by E! News We independently selected these deals and products because we love them, and we think you might like them at these prices. E! has affiliate relationships, ... Read more »

Is Stress Making You Fat?

The Trigger That Causes the Most Trouble Our ancestors ate to survive. They ate because they were hungry or maybe to celebrate a victory over a warring tribe. Us? We ... Read more »

Bucks vs. Grizzlies prediction, odds, line: 2022 NBA picks, Jan. 19 best bets from model on 56-30 run

© Provided by CBS Sports Giannis Antetokounmpo and the Milwaukee Bucks host Ja Morant and the Memphis Grizzlies in a high-profile matchup on Wednesday. Milwaukee is 27-19 this season after a ... Read more »

Two broadcasters terminated after calling female high school athletes overweight and laughing about it

© From Google WHOU’s office in Houlton, Maine. Two broadcasters in Maine have been terminated, according to a statement posted on the WHOU Facebook page, after calling female high school ... Read more »

4 secrets to a better and healthier smoothie

If one of your goals this year is to eat more fruits and vegetables, congrats! Eating more produce daily is one of the best ways to get more fiber and ... Read more »

What Happened When I Tried Imperfect Foods Delivery Service

What would you think if someone asked, “Hey, do you want to buy a box of groceries that’s totally cool with calling itself, um, not-the-greatest?” For me, the answer would ... Read more »

Coca-Cola is giving its soda cans — including caffeine free ones — a total makeover

© Coca-Cola A new Coca-Cola can design was announced, adding new colors to the traditional cans. Coca-Cola has decided to give its cans a total makeover as it heads into ... Read more »

What to Know About Intermittent Fasting for Women

Fasting for women vs. men From weight loss to longevity, intermittent fasting comes with a long list of potential benefits. Now, a small but growing body of evidence suggests that ... Read more »

Jay-Z, Other Artists Back New York Lawmakers’ ‘Rap Music On Trial’ Bill

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — Jay-Z is one of many artists teaming up to block rap lyrics from being used in court. New York lawmakers introduced the “Rap Music On Trial” ... Read more »

The metaverse is everywhere: Here's what you need to know

© Provided by CNET Your entry to the metaverse doesn’t need to involve a headset mashed to your face. But it probably will. Getty Images You’ve probably heard a lot ... Read more »

State responds to new CDC guidance for schools

© Provided by KRQE Albuquerque State responds to new CDC guidance for schools SANTA FE, N.M. (KRQE) – The CDC is issuing new guidance when it comes to extra-curricular in ... Read more »

'When We Were Young' festivals' packed Vegas lineup sparks questions over logistics, safety

© Chris Pizzello Gerard Way of My Chemical Romance performs on stage at Spike TV’s Video Game Awards on Saturday, Dec. 11, 2010, in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello) LAS ... Read more »

Best reptile and amphibian food

Which reptile and amphibian Food is best? If you have a new pet turtle or frog, you must find the right reptile and amphibian food to ensure that they have ... Read more »

Coke unveils new cans and a new flavor for its coffee line

© Coca-Cola Coca-Cola is updating Coke’s look and launching a new Coke with Coffee flavor. Coca-Cola is fighting for your attention. The company is unveiling a new look for flavored ... Read more »

The One Secret You Need to Lose Weight (That Isn’t Diet or Exercise!)

Say goodbye to those gross dieting fads and pricey gym memberships. Turns out, weight loss starts right in your kitchen—but it isn’t (technically) a diet. According to journalism professor Michael Easter, ... Read more »

20 Best Face Serums for Men

This article was produced in partnership with Blu Atlas A men’s skincare routine can range from being super simple (sticking to three basic steps—cleanse, moisturize, and protect) or it can ... Read more »

I want to lose fat and gain energy. A dietitian said to eat more well-balanced meals including breakfast.

© Getty A small breakfast while working is better than no breakfast, Tai Ibitoye said. Getty A 29-year-old woman submitted an average day of eating to be reviewed for Insider’s ... Read more »

New Year's resolutions: Use this expert tip to achieve more in your life

© Monkey Business Images/Adobe Stock Doing yoga before you go to sleep is a great exercise to calm the body and mind. Sleep longer. Eat healthier. Exercise more. Becoming a ... Read more »

Orange crop is set to be the smallest since WWII, sending OJ prices surging

© Anthony Behar/Sipa USA/AP Half a shelf sits empty of orange juice at a Target store in the Queens borough of New York City, NY, on October 19, 2021. Oranges ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell to file request for retrial over juror’s revelation

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Elizabeth Williams/AP Ghislaine Maxwell’s legal team was poised on Wednesday to file detailed documents requesting a new trial following revelations that a juror may ... Read more »

Danone's Silk introduces 'Nextmilk' in a plant-based play for dairy lovers

Plant-based brand Silk is trying to capture the hearts of dairy lovers with a faux-dairy innovation, Nextmilk. Beginning on January 19th, the new offering will debut on store shelves, including ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell formally requests new trial after juror reveals past sexual abuse

© Jane Rosenberg/Reuters Ghislaine Maxwell is seen in a courtroom sketch from her trial. Jane Rosenberg/Reuters Ghislaine Maxwell filed a motion on Wednesday requesting her conviction be overturned and a ... Read more »

What It’s Really Like to Follow the Ketogenic Diet (Hint: It’s Crazy Easy)

© Rawpixel.com/Shutterstock What-Its-Really-Like-to-Follow-the-Ketogenic-Diet-Hint-Its-Crazy-Easy_481738963 What is a ketogenic diet? It’s actually really simple: The diet is high fat, moderate protein, and low carbohydrates. I decided to give it a try because ... Read more »

Nattokinase Benefits: 6 Reasons To Try This Asian Superfood (Plus, a Chef’s Tips)

Pickled Beets See more videos What to watch next What to Eat to Feel Energetic Start stocking up on these foods to snack on when you need a boost of ... Read more »

How the Keto Diet Plan Helped Me Kick My Sugar Habit

© Lisovskaya Natalia/Shutterstock I’ve never met a candy bar I didn’t like. For years, I finished every meal with a little something sweet. At holidays, people knew the way to ... Read more »

Ask a Pediatrician: My Kid Refuses to Eat Vegetables. Should I Be Worried?

© Jose Luis Pelaez Inc/Getty Images I have a 5-year-old who just hates vegetables (unless, you count french fries and ketchup, that is). How worried should I be about this ... Read more »

Posture check: Do these 2 exercises if you’re slouching in your desk chair

“Sit up straight.” “Stop slouching.” From a young age the importance of posture is ingrained in us. But fast-forward a couple decades and most of us spend the majority of ... Read more »

4 Ways to Uncover the Motivation to Lose Weight

Swimsuits, skinny jeans, doctors’ orders: Which is most on your mind? The promise to commit to a fitness plan is always a personal one, yet one we break time and ... Read more »

4 Arkansas inmates are suing a jail and its doctor, claiming they were given ivermectin for COVID-19 without their consent

© Provided by INSIDER Four inmates are Soumyabrata Roy/NurPhoto via Getty Images Four inmates in Arkansas are suing a jail and its doctor for giving them ivermectin without consent. The ... Read more »

Kaia Gerber shows off slender frame in athletic wear after a workout

She is known for her love fitness, including regular Pilates classes in West Hollywood. On Wednesday, Kaia Gerber was seen stepping out after yet another workout, as she took a ... Read more »

I'm an ER nurse who's comforted panicked COVID-19 patients as they beg to live. Too often, they die anyway.

© Courtesy of Thad Cummings Thad Cummings. Courtesy of Thad Cummings Thad Cummings, 31, is a registered nurse who works in emergency rooms in Michigan and North Carolina. He told ... Read more »

An NFL player turned chef says grilled vegetables are key for pro-athletes. Here's how he seasons them to elevate the flavor.

© Provided by INSIDER John Parra/Getty Images for SOBEWFF Former NFL player Eddie Jackson is a celebrity chef with his own cooking show.  One of Jackson’s areas of expertise is ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic