Katy Perry refused to ‘soften up' in trademark fight with Sydney designer Katie Perry, court hears

Asia's Tech News Daily

US pop sensation Katy Perry referred to an Australian fashion designer in a “derogatory term” and told her manager “not to soften up or apologise” in emails over the use of trademarks in Australia, a court has heard.

Sydney-based designer Katie Jane Taylor is suing the I Kissed A Girl singer in the Federal Court over the sale of clothes in Australia and what she claims is trademark infringement.

Ms Taylor, a mother of two, has operated a clothing label under her birth name Katie Perry since 2006 and held the trademark in Australia for over a decade.

However, the Sydney designer is now suing the singer – whose real name is Katheryn Elizabeth Hudson – in the Federal Court, claiming she infringed her trademark by using one that was “substantially identical to, or deceptively similar”.

Katy Perry refused to ‘soften up’ in trademark fight with Sydney designer Katie Perry, court hears

Camera IconSydney-based designer Katie Jane Taylor is suing the I Kissed A Girl singer in the Federal Court over the sale of clothes in Australia and what she claims is trademark infringement. Rohan Kelly Credit: News Corp Australia

Ms Taylor claims the singer was using the trademark in Australia since at least 2013, selling products not only at her concerts, but also at shops such as Myer and Target.

During the first day of hearing on Monday, Barrister Christian Dimitriadis SC told the court Ms Taylor had been designing clothes in Australia for almost 15 years.

“That isn’t easy in Australia … the name of her label is Katie Perry, which is her birth name and she has traded since 2007,” Mr Dimitriadis said.

He told the court the designer began her business “well before” she knew who the singer was, and first heard Perry’s song on the radio in 2008.

Mr Dimitriadis said there was “no room for doubt” Perry had infringed Ms Taylor’s “exclusive rights”.

“Ms Taylor is the rightful owner of her trademark in respect of clothes in Australia,” he told the court.

He said his client had resisted “heavy handed threats of litigation” in 2009 in the form of cease and desist letters which were sent to the budding designer.

Ms Taylor first began designing clothes in November 2007 when they were launched at a school charity event, then sold them at Sydney markets in May 2008. She had already registered her business and domain name “Katie Perry” in 2007.

It wasn’t until later that year Ms Taylor first heard I Kissed a Girl on the radio and proceeded to purchase the song on iTunes because of the similar name, the court heard.

“Ms Taylor was aware she was a musical based US artist, but had nothing to do with clothes,” Mr Dimitriadis said.

Perry’s lawyers filed the cease and desist letters against Ms Taylor in 2009, which was a major “shock” to the designer.

“Ms Hudson and her advisers attempted to use their greater sophistication and financial might to snuff out Ms Taylor‘s business,” he said.

“It caused Ms Taylor significant distress and it was a shock; she tried to seek legal assistance but she couldn’t afford it.”

In 2009 Ms Taylor went public with the legal battle in the form of a video message to the superstar on YouTube which prompted an email from Perry’s manager, Steven Jensen, to say the situation was “blown way out of proportion”.

Mr Dimitriadis read a response email to the court from Perry, who told her manager “not to soften up or apologise”.

“She referred to Ms Taylor in a derogatory way in that email that I won’t repeat,” he told the court.

Katy Perry refused to ‘soften up’ in trademark fight with Sydney designer Katie Perry, court hears

Camera IconMs Taylor posted a YouTube video in 2009 asking Katy Perry to let her continue her fashion business. Credit: Supplied

Ms Taylor did not concede and was not prepared to hand over the rights to her name after the lawyers attempted to negotiate “co-existence”.

Lawyers for the singer threatened to sue the Australian designer, which would have put her out of business, the court heard.

Mr Dimitriadis told the court Perry was a dedicated businesswoman who was involved in “control over her business empire”.

The singer sold branded clothing and merchandise during two nationwide tours in 2014 and 2018, as well as at Target and Myer from 2014 – 2016.

Perry’s lawyers claim the singer did not infringe Ms Taylor’s trademark because she “used her own name in good faith”.

They claim the singer took on the name Katy Perry in 2002 in an attempt not to be confused with Hollywood actress Kate Hudson.

Ms Taylor launched litigation proceedings in October 2019 and is expected to give evidence on Tuesday during the hearing, which will last for about five days.

She established her fashion label in 2007 to meet the need for womenswear that mixes style with comfort.

Up until October 2019, Ms Taylor never thought to fight the superstar, as she did not have the financial resources to take on Perry, but with the support of Litigation Capital Management, she has the funding to take action.

“This is a real David and Goliath fight,” Ms Taylor said in a statement.

“The singer has ignored my trademark and continued to sell infringing goods unlawfully in Australia.

“I am fighting not just for myself, but for all small businesses in this country who can be bullied by these overseas entities who have much more financial power than we do.”

The hearing will continue on Tuesday.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Doreen Langham, Gary Hely: Date set for inquest into Qld house fire deaths

A date has been set for an inquest into the death of a woman who perished in a Queensland house fire alongside her ex-partner in a suspected domestic violence killing. ... Read more »

Shane Huici to stand trial after alleged sex attack at Geelong aged care home

A man accused of raping an elderly woman in her bed after breaking into a Geelong nursing home has been committed to stand trial in a Victorian court. St Albans ... Read more »

Moment man wields frying pan in shop brawl at Manor Lakes

Dramatic footage has emerged of a wild brawl at a suburban shopping centre. The chaos unfolded inside Manor Lakes Central shopping centre in Melbourne’s southwest on Thursday night at about ... Read more »

Horror as Melbourne hit with deadly night of violence

A six-year-old girl is among five people who have died during a horror night of violence across Melbourne. The girl was allegedly stabbed at Mill Park in Melbourne’s northeast with ... Read more »

NSW records 63,018 new cases and 29 deaths in its deadliest day yet

NSW has reported 63,018 new Covid-19 cases on Friday including 37,938 rapid antigen test results. A record 29 deaths of people with Covid-19 have been confirmed in the latest reporting ... Read more »

Man allegedly stole from Sydney Louis Vuitton store at 3am using wheelie bins

A man has been charged after he allegedly stole almost 100 luxury goods worth more than $460,000 from a Sydney store on New Year’s Day. Police allege the man forced ... Read more »

Top temperature at Onslow Airport WA's hottest day on record, equal hottest ever in Australia

Temperatures at Onslow Airport in Western Australia’s Pilbara region have hit a staggering 50.7C – the state’s hottest day on record and the equal hottest ever in Australia. That was ... Read more »

Guilty plea to murder 33 years after gay hate crime ‘bewilders' Scott Johnson's family

The brother of an American man pushed off a cliff in a gay hate crime in Sydney 33 years ago says he is “bewildered” his killer has pleaded guilty. Scott ... Read more »

‘I'm guilty': Scott White pleads guilty to 1988 murder of Scott Johnson

A man accused of a historic gay hate murder has “emphatically” pleaded guilty to the charge after previously denying it, in a bombshell court appearance. Scott Phillip White, 50, pleaded ... Read more »

Concerns over QR code claim from anti-vaxxer Monica Smit

A vocal anti-vaxxer accused of inciting protests during Melbourne’s lockdown made some concerning comments about QR code check-ins, a court has been told. Monica Smit appeared before the Melbourne Magistrates ... Read more »

Former NRL star Craig Field released from prison after serving eight years for one-punch death

A former rugby league star convicted of killing a man with a single punch has been released from prison, nine years after the incident changed multiple lives forever. Former South ... Read more »

‘Bemused': Judicial registrar's quip in Machine Gun Charlie's ‘Lawyer X' case

A champion kickboxer and convicted drug trafficker known as ‘Machine Gun Charlie’ is back in court over the infamous “Lawyer X” scandal. Dragan Arnautovic has spent various stints behind bars ... Read more »

Covid-positive man fled his West Australian hotel as the state shuts its borders to the country

Western Australia is on high alert after a Covid-positive man allegedly breached hotel quarantine to go to hospital and get a PCR test. The confirmed case somehow escaped his hotel ... Read more »

Victoria records 37,169 cases, 25 Covid deaths

Victoria has recorded 37,169 new cases and 25 Covid deaths in the past 24 hours. There are now 953 infected people in Victorian hospitals, with 111 in intensive care and ... Read more »

Four charged, $8 million seized following alleged money laundering syndicate across Sydney

Police have seized more than $8 million in cash and charged four people over an alleged money laundering syndicate involved in the supply of drugs across Sydney. Strike Force Trobriand ... Read more »

Unions push for wage increases as workers safety amid Omicron remains in focus

Australian unions will ruthlessly seek pay rises this year, with key figures saying workers are fed up of being underpaid and are “itching” to strike in support. Three union leaders ... Read more »

Footage of dead fur seal sparks new debate over NSW's controversial shark nets

Distressing footage of a dead fur seal caught in netting has reignited debate over NSW’s shark meshing program, two days after a three-metre great white forced several Sydney beaches to ... Read more »

Sydney banker Fredrick Blencke granted bail after spending one month behind bars

A high-profile investment banker charged with multiple domestic violence offences has been granted bail to attend marriage breakdown counselling after spending more than a month behind bars. Fredrick Blencke was ... Read more »

Gunman on the loose in Perth after man dies in shooting at his own home

A gunman is on the loose after a 47-year-old man was shot dead at his own home in Perth’s northern suburbs. Police were alerted to a “disturbance” about 2am on ... Read more »

Helicopter operator argues Sydney Metro should pay $23.8 million for acquiring land near Parramatta

The NSW government says a helicopter company that helped fight the Black Summer bushfires should get less than $400,000 in compensation after it forced the operation to move to make ... Read more »

WA Police launch new appeal to solve 1999 homicide of Andrew Podpinka

The homicide of Andrew Podpinka has been an unsolved mystery in Perth for more than 20 years, but cold case detectives are now hoping to finally crack the case. Mr ... Read more »

Patricia Hadjia: Instagram influencer ‘Torpedo Trish' high-range drink-driving

Shocking new details about an Instagram influencer’s drink-driving rampage have been revealed, with a court told she refused to stop driving despite crashing into multiple cars. Patricia Hadjia was behind ... Read more »

Father and daughter tie themselves to a tree for two days to survive raging floodwaters

A father and his nine-year-old daughter have survived floodwaters after spending two nights clinging to a tree in Queensland‘s Gympie region. Craig Mortensen and daughter Kira were travelling to their ... Read more »

Former Home And Away star to remain behind bars on remand after string of alleged offences

A former soap star will remain behind bars after he was accused of committing violent offences across Sydney’s inner suburbs. Lawyers for Home And Away actor Felix Dean did not ... Read more »

Video shows Omar Elomar being kidnapped from the front of his Condell Park home

Terrifying footage shows the moment a man was kidnapped by four attackers outside his southwest Sydney home before they demanded a $3 million ransom. Omar Elomar was farewelling a visitor ... Read more »

Connor Tolson: $1m reward to solve Melbourne musician's death in house fire

A million-dollar reward is being offered over the suspected murder of a budding Melbourne musician in 2015. Connor Tolson, 21, was found dead in the backyard bungalow of his mother’s ... Read more »

Former Tasmanian MP escapes conviction for possessing unregistered handgun

A former Tasmanian Liberal MP has escaped a conviction for possessing an unregistered handgun and ID cards after his initial eight charges were dropped. Adam Richard Brooks greeted waiting media ... Read more »

Back to school: Australian parents' $20.3b expenses bill for students in 2022

Australian parents can expect to pay a collective $20.3 billion this year on all school expenses, according to new data research. A report from the comparison website Finder found supplies ... Read more »

Fresh push to ditch Queen Elizabeth from Australian Republic Movement

A plan to replace Queen Elizabeth as the nation’s head of state has been revived as the nation’s republic movement ramps up its push to scrap the monarchy‘s hold on ... Read more »

Truck causes traffic chaos on Sydney's M5, crashing into embankment and spilling milk

Traffic on a major Sydney highway has been thrown into chaos after a truck full of milk swerved off the road and hit an embankment. Emergency services rushed to the ... Read more »

Man charged over alleged involvement in carjackings and assaults across Sydney's northwest

A man has been charged over his alleged involvement in carjackings and armed robberies at gunpoint in Sydney’s northwest over the weekend. Strike Force Bellinger was established to investigate a ... Read more »

13-year-old boy fatally stabbed on NSW Central Coast, another boy arrested

A 13-year-old boy has died in hospital after he was fatally stabbed on the NSW Central Coast on Tuesday night. Emergency services were called about 11pm to Langford Drive, Kariong, ... Read more »

Man and woman charged with murder, torture after 8yo girl's death in Toowoomba

A man and a woman have been charged with murder over the death an eight-year-old girl in Queensland on the weekend. The pair, who police say were known to the ... Read more »

Federal election: Labor promises to redirect $200m towards disaster prevention

Anthony Albanese has promised to redivert millions from a $4.7bn disaster recovery fund towards actually preventing damage and devastation in the first place. In a major election pitch that follows ... Read more »

Butterfly Foundation warns of dangerous diet and exercise videos circulating on social media

Dangerous videos are being shared on social media about restrictive eating and exercise, while sponsored influencer posts are promoting unsafe weight loss and muscle bulking methods, a powerful federal inquiry ... Read more »

Trevor ‘Noombah' King: Tragic cause of Indigenous man's custody death revealed by coroner

WARNING: CONFRONTING DETAILS An Indigenous man who died in police custody received “suboptimal” care from paramedics despite being critically unwell following his arrest, a coroner has found. Townsville man Trevor ... Read more »

Scott Morrison speaks on phone with Serbian Prime Minister Ana Brnabić

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has spoken on the phone with his Serbian counterpart about the Novak Djokovic situation. Serbian Prime Minister Ana Brnabić sought the call with Mr Morrison on ... Read more »

Transcript reveals Novak Djokovic's first interview with ABF official at Melbourne Airport

Novak Djokovic’s reaction to the moment he was told he would be detained as an “unlawful non-citizen” and revelations about his vaccination status have been revealed in a transcript of ... Read more »

Peter Clarence Foster: Alleged conman quarantining in prison on remand while awaiting next court date

Alleged conman Peter Foster has been placed in isolation at a Brisbane prison while awaiting his next court appearance. Mr Foster is charged with multiple counts of fraud relating to ... Read more »

Dion Papanakos, 20, remembered after tragic Coogee cliff fall

A young man who fell to his death in a horrific accident at a popular Sydney beach on the weekend while his devastated girlfriend watched on is being remembered as ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic