Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson is lone dissenter as Supreme Court vacates abortion ruling

The U.S. Supreme Court vacated a federal court decision on Monday that upheld a minor’s right to go to court for permission to obtain an abortion, with Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson authoring the lone dissent in the case.

In its decision, the high court overturned lower court ruling that said a state court clerk could be sued for denying a pregnant teenager’s request for permission to get an abortion without her parents’ consent. The Supreme Court remanded the case to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit with instructions to dismiss the case as moot.

In her dissent, Jackson criticized the court’s application of Munsingwear vacatur, a legal doctrine that addresses what should happen to a court decision when the appealed case becomes moot while it is pending review by a higher court. The doctrine says such decisions should be vacated, with an important exception for cases where the party adversely affected by the vacated decision was not responsible for rendering the case moot.

“I am concerned that contemporary practice related to so called ‘Munsingwear vacaturs’ has drifted away from the doctrine’s foundational moorings,” Jackson wrote in her dissent.


This case stemmed from a lawsuit in Missouri alleging that court clerk Michelle Chapman violated a 17-year-old pregnant teenager’s rights. Missouri law requires a pregnant minor to obtain permission from her parents to have an abortion. In certain circumstances, the law allows a minor to get court permission to bypass parental consent.


When the teenager, referred to as Jane Doe, went to court in 2018 seeking permission to get an abortion, Chapman told her the court would have to notify her parents about the hearing. Doe instead traveled to Illinois, where she obtained court permission and later had an abortion.

Chapman claimed immunity from the suit, but both a federal district court in Missouri and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit rejected her claim. However, the Supreme Court vacated the 8th Circuit’s decision, agreeing with Chapman that the ruling should have been thrown out because the case was made moot by the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs vs. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade and ended the constitutional right to an abortion.


In her dissent, Jackson argued that Munsingwear vacatur should only be extended to “extraordinary” or “exceptional” cases. She wrote that this case became moot when Chapman and the teenager agreed to have their original case in Missouri district court dismissed, asserting that “Chapman contributed to the mootness of this case insofar as she stipulated to its dismissal.”

As such, Jackson said it was not unfair to deprive Chapman of her right to appeal.

“Indeed, Chapman’s only argument in support of vacatur is that the Eighth Circuit’s opinion was wrongly decided. But mere disagreement with the decision that one seeks to have vacated cannot suffice to warrant equitable relief under Munsingwear,” Jackson wrote.


justice ketanji brown jackson is lone dissenter as supreme court vacates abortion ruling

The United States Supreme Court began its 2022-2023 term on Oct. 3, 2022. Kent Nishimura / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

“In my view, it is crucial that we hold the line and limit the availability of Munsingwear vacateur to truly exceptional cases,” she insisted, calling Chapman’s case, “far-from-exceptional.”

“To do otherwise risks considerable damage to first principles of appellate review,” she said.

News Related


2 killed, 12-year-old injured after crash caused by possible intoxicated driver in northeast Houston

HOUSTON – Houston police are investigating a fatal crash in northeast Houston. The crash happened in the 7000 block of Waxahachie Street at the intersection of Boyles Street around 6 ... Read more »

Stunning UFO crash retrieval allegations deemed ‘credible,’ ‘urgent’

Stunning UFO crash retrieval allegations deemed ‘credible,’ ‘urgent’ According to explosive reporting, the powerful internal investigative body that oversees the nation’s intelligence agencies found a whistleblower’s claims of an illegal government UFO crash ... Read more »

Delta showcases new seat design for passengers with reduced mobility

Delta Air Lines Delta unveiled a new seat prototype aimed at helping wheelchair users and others with reduced mobility on flights. The Delta Flight Products team debuted the design at ... Read more »

Rising comedian Matt Rife to perform in Sugar Land during 115-date world tour

HOUSTON – Sugar Land, are you ready to laugh? Rising star Matt Rife will be making a stop in the Greater Houston area later this year during his 115-date world ... Read more »

Stanley Cup Final: Carter Verhaeghe leads Florida Panthers to OT win over Vegas Golden Knights

Florida Panthers forward Carter Verhaeghe scored his second overtime winner of the postseason to beat the Vegas Golden Knights in Game 3 of the Stanley Cup Final on Thursday in ... Read more »

Russia's 'Smoking Gun' on Ukraine Dam Collapse

Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a ceremony to mark the 75th anniversary of the Federal Medical-Biological Agency in Moscow on November 9, 2022. On May 30, a week before the ... Read more »

5 Things You Should Always Buy at Costco—and 5 You Can Skip

With low prices on bulk-sized items, Costco has attracted thousands of loyal customers willing to spend at least $60 per year for its membership fee. The wholesaler is ranked No. ... Read more »

The Federal Reserve May Pause Its Interest Rate Hiking Campaign. What That Means for You

The Federal Reserve is expected to pause its interest rate hiking campaign at the end of its two-day meeting next week. Consumers will still feel the effects of higher rates ... Read more »

Prince Harry Took to the Witness Stand in UK Court This Week: Here's What's Going on

Prince Harry became the first high-ranking British royal to take to the witness stand in more than 130 years this week. Harry spent a day-and-a-half giving evidence to London’s High ... Read more »

China targets AirDrop, Bluetooth in proposed rules to limit file sharing

China’s proposed law limiting AirDrop and Bluetooth after protesters used Apple’s iPhone to organize there. File Photo by John Angelillo/UPI June 9 (UPI) — The Chinese government moved to shut ... Read more »

Facebook owner to push ahead with plans to launch Twitter rival

Photograph: Caroline Brehman/EPA Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta is pushing ahead with plans to launch a rival to Twitter because public figures reportedly want a similar platform that is “sanely run” with ... Read more »

Kentucky's Basketball Program Reportedly In 'Complete Disarray' Right Now

LEXINGTON, KY – FEBRUARY 28: John Calipari the head coach of the Kentucky Wildcats gives instructions to his team against the Ole Miss Rebels during the game at Rupp Arena ... Read more »

Intense battles in Donetsk Oblast, there are results – Zelenskyy

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that there are fierce battles going on in Donetsk Oblast, he is constantly in communication with military commanders. Source: President in his evening address ... Read more »

Mortgage rates dip after weeks of climbing: Freddie Mac

Some uncertainty remains over the Federal Reserve's next move on interest rates Read more »

Biological Women Phrase Sparks Uproar: Student Takes on ‘Wokeness' Indoctrination in University of Cincinnati's Freedom of Speech Showdown

The city of Cincinnati is currently caught in an educational storm as the University of Cincinnati becomes a battlefield for free speech and academic freedom. At the heart of the ... Read more »

Ben Foster signs one-year Wrexham contract following promotion to EFL

Ben Foster signs one-year Wrexham contract following promotion to EFL ByESPN June 9, 2023, 7:49 AM Ben Foster has signed a new one-year contract at Wrexham, the team announced on ... Read more »

GM investing $500 million to build big new internal combustion-powered SUVs

The full-size trucks are among the automaker's best-sellers Read more »

Official says two migrants drowned trying to reach Spain in two boats, 132 arrive safely

Official says two migrants drowned trying to reach Spain in two boats, 132 arrive safely A Spanish government official says the bodies of two migrants were found on a beach ... Read more »

California investigators suspect Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis planned the flight carrying 16 migrants who were 'dumped' outside Sacramento church

Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom of California criticized the policies of Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida, in an interview with Insider. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images and Wilfredo Lee/AP Photo Sixteen migrants ... Read more »

‘10 dollars an hour is crazy’: Viewers defend teenage Pizza Hut worker who makes $10 per hour

woman preparing pizza at pizza hut Working as a teenager can be liberating. Earning your own money, building skills that many don’t obtain until their mid-20s, and gaining a measure ... Read more »

'Stop Cop City' activists pack Atlanta City Hall ahead of crucial vote

Protesters gather outside Atlanta City Hall ahead of a council vote over whether to approve public funding for the construction of a proposed police and firefighter training center, Monday, June ... Read more »

New York Yankees Could Lose Aaron Judge to Injured List Again With New Ailment

A fantastic play has come with consequences. New York Yankees superstar Aaron Judge is dealing with a right big toe injury that could potentially land him back on the injured ... Read more »

Jake Tapper Creeped Out by Brianna Keilar’s Analogy for Crowded GOP Race: ‘I Do Not Thank You for That’

Jake Tapper did not care for Brianna Keilar’s analogy for the growing 2024 Republican primary field on Monday’s edition of CNN News Central. This week, a handful of candidates are ... Read more »

You Can Download the iOS 17 Developer Beta on Your iPhone Right Now

iOS 17 was announced Monday at WWDC 2023. Tharon Green/CNET Not wanting to lose any time, Apple has just released the first developer beta for iOS 17, shortly after announcing ... Read more »

Why 22.8 Million Americans Might Have Just Gotten a Big Credit Score Boost

A person typing on a laptop while sitting comfortably on a couch. There are different factors that go into calculating a credit score. These include length of credit history, new ... Read more »

Bannon Goes to War With House Republicans, Wants Primary Opponents for MTG, Jim Jordan, and Others Over Debt Vote

Bannon Goes to War With House Republicans, Wants Primary Opponents for MTG, Jim Jordan, and Others Over Debt Vote Former Trump campaign manager Steve Bannon declared Monday that he wants ... Read more »

Florida officials mum as second migrant flight arrives in Sacramento

“[Ron DeSantis] you small, pathetic man,” California Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote in a tweet Monday. TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A second plane full of migrants from the Texas border landed in ... Read more »

Texas sheriff calls for charges after DeSantis migrant flights

Texas sheriff calls for charges after DeSantis migrant flights The sheriff’s office in Bexar County, Texas, has filed a criminal case with the county’s district attorney over a 2022 incident ... Read more »

‘They are way more dangerous than anybody knows’: Mom almost loses child to water bead toy. She says Target marked it on sale and restocked the shelves

Woman Holding Baby. Target Retail Store A mother claimed that after her infant child nearly died from accidentally ingesting a singular water bead, the company sent their condolences and Target ... Read more »

AI should be licensed like medicines or nuclear power, Labour suggests

Photograph: Yuichiro Chino/Getty Images The UK should bar technology developers from working on advanced artificial intelligence tools unless they have a licence to do so, Labour has said. Ministers should ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự