Julian Knight: Online Safety Bill is ‘simplistic and bad politics', Tory MP tells Boris Johnson

Asia's Tech News Daily

Banning anonymous social media accounts is “simplistic and unworkable”, the chair of the Commons Culture, Media and Sport committee has told i.

Julian Knight also took aim at Boris Johnson in a wide-ranging interview, for seeking to rush through the Online Safety Bill in the wake of the murder of Sir David Amess.

The new Culture Secretary, Nadine Dorries, wrote in the Daily Mail on Saturday that the Bill would “end anonymous abuse, because it will end abuse, full stop”.

But Mr Knight warned that people should still be able to “speak truth to power” and use anonymous accounts to disclose wrongdoing.

“I’ve received important information – for instance on my local health services – via anonymous Twitter,” he said.

“Anonymity shouldn’t be outlawed; I don’t think that’s possible given [social media’s] global nature and just the number of anonymous accounts on those platforms, particularly Twitter.”

Julian Knight: Online Safety Bill is ‘simplistic and bad politics’, Tory MP tells Boris Johnson
© Provided by The i Read More – Featured Image

While saying that a ban was “simplistic and unworkable”, Mr Knight agreed that reforms were needed.

“The right of social media companies to have anonymity should come with strings attached that they have a duty of care and our robust regime. I would like to see compliance officers in place and paid for by them.”

The MP for Solihull raised concerns that the new Bill, which will address huge issues such as online anonymity, free speech, and access to pornography would get “torn apart” if it was rushed through.

“It’s really bad politics,” he said. “Suddenly, in the bat of an eyelid – in understandable circumstances given the emotion and under pressure from the Opposition – the Prime Minister decides we will have it prior to Christmas.”

“We must be careful that in our grief we don’t conflate the issue of terror and online abuse, and online abuse of those in power.”

‘How much do you want your government to know about you?’

Julian Knight, a former journalist who heads the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport Committee, knows how to turn a phrase and make a story.

In recent weeks, he has called Alan Shearer an “apologist” for the Saudi regime, Facebook “a bit of a cult” and accused the BBC of having a “collective nervous breakdown” over Brexit. As legislation to regulate social media finally reaches Parliament later this year, we are going to be hearing a lot more from Knight, an influential figure on the debates ahead.

Boris Johnson made the commitment to speed up the legislation in the wake of the murder of Sir David Amess that highlighted the increasing threat posed to MPs and abuse amplified by social media.

Knight worries that the Online Safety Bill, which will address huge issues such as online anonymity, free speech, and access to pornography, will get “torn apart” if it is rushed through.

For three years, says Knight, the Government “prevaricated” because it wanted to avoid the “hospital pass” of being the first major developed economy to seek to impose new limits on the hugely powerful industry.

“It’s really bad politics,” he says. “Suddenly, in the bat of an eyelid, in understandable circumstances given the emotion and under pressure from the Opposition, the Prime Minister decides that we will have it prior to Christmas.

“We must be careful that in our grief we do not conflate the issue of terror and online abuse, and online abuse of those in power.”

Julian Knight: Online Safety Bill is ‘simplistic and bad politics’, Tory MP tells Boris Johnson
© Provided by The i Nadine Dorries said the Online Safety Bill would end anonymous abuse (Photo: Ian Forsyth/Getty)

He immediately adds, however, that while social media companies co-operate in “acute situations” such as terror investigations, way too much is left to firms’ “judgement calls”. MPs who struggle to have content removed that compromises their security – such as pictures of their homes – soon

realise the limit of their power.

But as Britain tries unilaterally to bring the big tech firms in the US and China to heel, the Government risks merely exposing its own weakness. “The Government has always been stuck between a rock and a hard place,” says the 49-year-old Tory MP. “They want the UK to be a centre of data sharing and products but then react to groundswells in opinion.”

Knight is not in favour of banning online anonymity – “simplistic and unworkable” – but says it should come “with strings attached”, including a requirement for social media firms to recruit and pay for compliance officers to police tough, new regulations that impose on them a duty of care to wider society not just their own profits.

He agrees that the legislation will expose a split among Tory MPs over the limits of free speech, with libertarians like David Davis determined to resist what they describe as a “censor’s charter”.

Mr Knight says: “It’s not just free speech but this will raise questions about how much do you want your government to know about you. Are we going to see a ‘porn law’ where there is age verification, not just assurance, to access certain websites? Where do you rely on algorithm and where demand ID?”

Julian Knight: Online Safety Bill is ‘simplistic and bad politics’, Tory MP tells Boris Johnson
© Provided by The i Read More – Featured Image

The MP for Solihull was elected chairman of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee after promising to take a harder line on the BBC than the previous incumbent, Damian Collins.

He admits that any hope of killing off the licence fee when the BBC’s current charter runs out at the end of the decade died when Johnson was forced to abandon his pledge to get full-fibre broadband into every home.

Knight is chivvying the corporation to do more to prepare for life after the licence fee, especially since revenues relentlessly decline as viewers migrate to subscription services. He acknowledges the BBC’s efforts to address concerns that it lost touch with its viewers during Brexit but warns that new divisions loom.

“I think areas like the trans[gender] debate are where we are going to see a real challenge for the BBC,” he says, adding that he detects a difference of approach between its news website and Radio 4 to one of the most contentious issues of the day.

The BBC faces accusations that it has allowed the LGBTQ+ lobby group Stonewall too much influence from those who oppose its stance on gender and identity. Entering that minefield, even the tough-talking Knight drops his visor, saying: “I’m disquieted by the influence Stonewall has had on the BBC.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

UK construction sector gathers more speed - PMI

LONDON (Reuters) – Growth in Britain’s construction industry hit its strongest pace in four months in November after a slowdown caused by global supply chain problems and labour shortages, while ... Read more »

5 Krishna's Teachings For The Millennials

Lord Krishna is the eighth avatar of Vishnu and is one of the most widely admired deities in Hinduism. Lord Krishna is a true spiritual guru as he has reformed ... Read more »

Ssumier S. Pasricha steps out of his comfort zone with 'Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui'

© IANS Ssumier Pasricha. Mumbai, Dec 6 (IANS) Actor Ssumier S. Pasricha, who is also fondly remembered for his character ‘Pammi Aunty’, will be soon seen in Ayushmann Khurrana and ... Read more »

Aishwarya Rai Bachchan to play the protagonist in an International project as she signs her next film?

© Provided by Pinkvilla Aishwarya Rai Bachchan is one of the most gorgeous actresses of Bollywood. It is always a delight and a visual treat for her fans to watch ... Read more »

Defence policy is based on 'over-simplified' hype about cyber warfare, experts warn

General Sir Nicholas Carter pictured in 2014 – Heathcliff O’Malley Britain's defence policy is based on “over-simplified” hype about cyber warfare, experts have claimed in a new book. Defence experts ... Read more »

Omicron Is Here. Should You Cancel Your Trip?

Travelers queue for check-in at La Guardia airport in New York, Nov. 21, 2021. (DeSean McClinton-Holland/The New York Times) To cancel or not to cancel. That is the question that ... Read more »

Dancing, dressing up and fighting over music: Prince William on life with George, Charlotte and Louis

Photo credit: Comic Relief – Getty Images Whenever images or footage have been released of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge and their children, they tend to paint a picture ... Read more »

Robert Saleh left Jets unprepared for Eagles' quarterback switch

For once, there were a minimum of rookie mistakes from Zach Wilson, and Saleluhah to that. Because these are forever the Jets, or the Jets forever, or according to C.J. ... Read more »

European shares bounce after volatile week

Oil stocks helped drive a rebound in European stocks on Monday after sharp losses late last week when fears about the Omicron variant and the U.S. monetary policy outlook weighed ... Read more »

‘Stalker 2': Xbox store lists game's ‘approximate size' as 180GB on Xbox Series X/S

From the “Stalker 2” gameplay trailer | Photo credit: Xbox / YouTube screenshot “Stalker 2” is one of the most anticipated games on Xbox Series X/S. The game is still ... Read more »

House elects new sergeant-at-arms

Batasang Pambansa Complex Batasan The House of Representatives elected a new sergeant-at-arms of the chamber on Monday. During the plenary session, lawmakers accepted the resignation of Sergeant-at-Arms Mao Aplasca. GMA ... Read more »

South Africa prepares hospitals as COVID cases surge

© Provided by Al Jazeera South Africa’s daily infections surged last week to more than 16,000 on Friday from roughly 2,300 on Monday [File: Luc Gnago/Reuters] South Africa’s President Cyril ... Read more »

Eric Zemmour: Far-right French presidential candidate put in a head-lock by protester

© AFP via Getty Images Far-right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour holds first rally – AFP via Getty Images French far-right candidate Eric Zemmour, who announced his bid for presidency last ... Read more »

World's worst boss stuns 900 workers by sacking them ALL on Zoom call weeks before Christmas

THE CEO of a mortgage startup sacked 900 workers during a Zoom call just weeks before Christmas. Vishal Garg fired nine percent of Better.com's workforce – including the entire diversity, ... Read more »

Unvaccinated first-time mother, 25, who had an emergency C-section at 27 weeks after contracting Covid while pregnant says she was admitted to ICU within a WEEK of first falling ill with a 'runny nose'

Paige Bliss, 25, from Birmingham spent five days in intensive care after coronavirus put her in a critical condition as her foetus was taking her nutrients Beautician, who hadn't been vaccinated, underwent an emergency C-section in August but was unable to meet her newborn baby girl Miley until she recoveredManaged come home just in time for Christmas with her miracle baby - who is now 16-weeks Read more »

Moment Prince William chokes back tears as he recalls how air ambulance dash to accident involving a boy close to George's age left him feeling 'like the whole world was dying' in extraordinarily candid podcast

The Duke described how he was deeply affected by what he experienced in extraordinarily frank podcastIt is understood he was referring to car accident which left Bobby Hughes, aged five, brain damaged in 2017 Prince William: Time To Walk was recorded for Apple series in which celebrities share memories and songs   Read more »

Flaunting its curves! Porky bear waddles past camera with its belly almost touching the ground at Minnesota national park

Tubby bear spotted at Voyageurs National Park on October 7 in north Minnesota  Porky figure is seen slowly swaying across the ground while stomach wobbles Bears need to eat almost constantly in autumn to prepare for winter hibernation  Read more »

We're not responsible for the state of Richard E. Grant's fish and chips! Minister blasts complaining Withnail and I star after he posted video saying he felt 'punished' in £228-per-night UK quarantine hotel with 'grim food'

Actor Richard E. Grant said he felt 'punished' after staying a quarantine hotel He stayed in Gatwick Holiday Inn, charged at £228 a night and served 'grim food' It came after the UK changed Covid travel rules in wake of the Omicron variant  But a minister today said it was not the government's job to improve hotel meals Kit Malthouse said: 'The government is responsible for a lot of things but not for the state of his fish and chips on a Friday night!' Read more »

Mark Warburton reveals what QPR lacked in Stoke City loss

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Queens Park Rangers v Blackburn Rovers Queens Park Rangers manager Mark Warburton has admitted his side lacked the quality in attack to ... Read more »

Minister admits he would be ‘surprised' if parliament didn't have illegal drug use

© PA General view of Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament – PA Boris Johnson’s policing minister has admitted he would be “surprised” if people weren’t taking illegal substance ... Read more »

Strictly's AJ and Kai accused of cheating in dance off to send Dan Walker home

Strictly Come Dancing fans have accused AJ Odudu and her dance partner Kai Widdrington of cheating after they survived Sunday night’s dance off against Dan Walker and Nadiya Bychkova. The ... Read more »

Keira Knightley's ‘creepy' Love Actually fan interaction: ‘It was awkward and I was stuck'

Back in 2003, Keira Knightley shot to fame after starring in Bend It Like Beckham, Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl and Love Actually. In the ... Read more »

"The end goal is professionalising the whole league" - say Hibs Women captain Joelle Murray ahead of Glasgow City clash

© Hibernian’s Joelle Murray is relishing the growth of the Scottish women’s game. (Photo by Ross MacDo… Capped a total of 48 times by the Scotland national team, Joelle Murray ... Read more »

SDUSD vaccine mandate moves forward

Parents react as the 9th District appellate court upholds the district wide vaccine mandate Read more »

Nigeria accuses Britain of 'travel apartheid' after being added to Covid red list

Sarafa Tunji Isola – Dominic Lipinski/PA Nigeria has accused Britain of a “travel apartheid” by adding the African country to its red list, forcing all arrivals into quarantine. Sarafa Tunji ... Read more »

Congo Hold-Up: on the trail of Joseph Kabila's mystery company

A leak of millions of documents and transactions at BGFIBank reveals some of the activities of former President of Democratic Republic of Congo, Joseph Kabila. Nineteen media outlets and five ... Read more »

More than 300,000 housebound Britons yet to receive booster vaccines as GPs opt out of home visits

Booster vaccines – Neil Hall/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock Nearly two-thirds of housebound people are yet to receive Covid booster vaccines after many GPs opted out of delivering top-up jabs, The Telegraph can reveal. ... Read more »

U.S. congressman posts family picture with guns, days after school shooting

A U.S. congressman on Saturday posted a Christmas picture of himself and what appeared to be his family, smiling and posing with an assortment of guns, just days after four ... Read more »

Asia power index: Australia weathers China trade sanctions but diplomatic influence wanes

Photograph: Indonesian Presidential Palace/AP Despite gains from vaccine diplomacy, border closures ‘weighed heavily on external views of the country’, Lowy Institute thinktank finds Get our free news app; get our ... Read more »

House Republican posts photo of his family holding guns days after Michigan school shooting

WASHINGTON — Rep. Thomas Massie, R-K.Y., is facing backlash from Democrats after he posted a Christmas photo of his family smiling and posing with an assortment of guns just days ... Read more »

How Last-Mile Delivery Can Make or Break Your Business

© Provided by MoneySmart Lalamove Singapore – Last Mile Delivery Singapore This post was written in collaboration with Lalamove. While we are financially compensated by them, we nonetheless strive to ... Read more »

Fortnite down & players ‘left shaking for hours' as game goes offline to update and leaves characters ‘floating'

FORTNITE has stopped working leaving players “shaking for hours” as the game went offline to update. Gamers have reported that their characters were left “floating” in the middle of the ocean ... Read more »

Hong Kong's Doo Hoi-kem and Wong Chun-ting bow out of WTT Cup Finals as coach laments lack of killer instinct

Olympic bronze medallist Doo struggles against Hina Hayata of Japan a day after upsetting China world No 4 Wang Manyu Wong almost takes world No 5 Tomokazu Harimoto to fifth ... Read more »

Peningkatan kemahiran dan latihan semula amat penting untuk ekonomi, kata pakar

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Peningkatan kemahiran dan latihan semula membantu melindungi pekerjaan dan membuka pintu peluang pekerjaan baharu. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: Peningkatan kemahiran (upskilling) dan latihan semula ... Read more »

Masalah teknikal, PKR tukar calon Satok saat akhir

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Nor Irwan Ahmat adalah calon PKR bagi Parlimen Petrajaya pada PRU lalu. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING JAYA: PKR melakukan pertukaran calon bagi kerusi Dewan Undangan ... Read more »

Moto Edge X30 specifications officially revealed ahead of December 9 launch event

Motorola is launching the Moto Edge X30 in China later this week. The Moto Edge X30 is arriving on December 9 and will be the company’s first smartphone to feature ... Read more »

Jennifer Lawrence shows off baby bump at Don't Look Up premiere

© Taylor Hill – Getty Images Jennifer Lawrence gave fans a glimpse of her growing baby bump over the weekend as she walked the red carpet for her upcoming movie, ... Read more »

Prince William Says He's Still Actively Cringing About His Impromptu 2013 Duet With Taylor Swift

There are two kinds of people in the world—there are people with normal human levels of nervousness when meeting members of the royal family for the first time and then ... Read more »

Marshall Motor's board backs £325m takeover offer from We Buy Any Car-owner Constellation Automotive

Constellation made a formal offer of 400p per share last Monday It is a 41.3% premium to the closing price of 283p on 26 NovemberThe Marshall family, which owns 64.4% of the firm, have accepted the offer Read more »

BBC Sound Of 2022: Wet Leg, Tems, PinkPantheress and Priya Ragu make female-dominated longlist

Wet Leg, PinkPantheress, Priya Ragu, Central Cee and Tems are among the 10 artists on the BBC’s female-dominated Sound of 2022 longlist. © Press Image Top left clockwise: Wet Leg, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic