Judge blocks Arizona laws banning school, city mask mandates

 									arizona								,  									Coronavirus								,  									schools

In this Dec. 2, 2020, file photo, Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey speaks at a press conference in Phoenix. AP

PHOENIX — A judge on Monday struck down Republican-passed Arizona laws that block schools from requiring masks and restrict the power of local governments to impose COVID-19 requirements, the latest turn in a nationwide legal battle over pandemic rules.

If it withstands a promised appeal, the ruling by Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Katherine Cooper could clear the way for Arizona cities and counties to enact mask requirements. At least 29 public school districts had defied the laws and enacted their own mask requirements.

Cooper’s sweeping ruling also struck down a number of non-virus provisions that were slipped into the state budget and an entire budget measure that had served as a vehicle for a conservative policy wish list. They included a required investigation of social media companies and stripping the Democratic secretary of state of her duty to defend election laws.

The ruling comes as the fight over school masks and other COVID-19 restrictions has moved into courtrooms across the US. Lawsuits have been filed in at least 14 states either for or against masks in schools. They directly challenge either state rules banning masks or local school board policies mandating them.

In Texas, dozens of school districts have defied Republican Gov. Greg Abbott’s mask mandate ban, but the state’s highest court sided with him last month. In Florida, an appeals court overruled a lower court this month and allowed Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis’ ban on school mask mandates to go back into effect. The case has ping-ponged between federal and state courts.

A federal judge in Iowa blocked a state law that bans school masks.

Parents are split, with some scared that their children could be exposed to the coronavirus without a mask mandate and others saying their children are at little risk and that mask requirements harm their kids. The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends mask-wearing in schools, and children 12 and under are not yet eligible for vaccines.

In Arizona, a coalition of educators and allies had sued to challenge laws prohibiting public school districts from imposing mask requirements, colleges from requiring vaccinations for students, and communities from establishing vaccine passports for entry into large events, businesses and other places. It also challenged a broad invalidation of any other local virus measure.

The coalition argued a large number of Arizona children would get sick with COVID-19 if the new laws weren’t blocked. The restrictions had been written into state budget measures that were passed near the end of the legislative session with only support from majority Republicans.

The judge said the laws violate constitutional requirements that the content of legislation is described in its title and is confined to a single subject. State attorneys argued that all the provisions had something to do with spending for education or health and that the Legislature didn’t need to be more specific.

“That is not correct,” Cooper wrote. “The Legislature has discretion to title a bill but, having picked a title, it must confine the contents to measures that reasonably relate to the title and to each other to form one general subject.”

A spokesman for Republican Gov. Doug Ducey called the ruling “clearly an example of judicial overreach” and vowed an appeal.

“Arizona’s state government operates with three branches, and it’s the duty and authority of only the legislative branch to organize itself and to make laws,” C.J. Karamargin said in a statement. “Unfortunately, today’s decision is the result of a rogue judge interfering with the authority and processes of another branch of government.”

The law barring mask mandates at public schools was scheduled to take effect Wednesday. The ruling was a relief for the districts that required masks, accounting for more than 334,000 students and nearly 500 schools.

The court action has far-reaching ramifications for the Legislature, which has long ignored the constitutional requirement that budget bills only deal with spending items. Lawmakers have packed with them policy items, and this year majority Republicans were especially aggressive.

An entire budget measure that served as a catch-all for a wish list of conservative policies was found to be unconstitutional Monday as well other laws unrelated to COVID-19 prevention efforts. One prohibits the use of state money for teaching critical race theory, a way of thinking about America’s history that centers on the idea that racism is systemic in the nation’s institutions and they function to maintain the dominance of white people.

The judge pointed to the single-subject rule to overturn SB1898, the bill filled with GOP policy wishes. It included what she called “multiple, unrelated subjects” like dog racing, the governor’s emergency powers, local COVID-19 measures and much more.

“None of these subjects have any logical connection to each other nor ‘fall under some one general idea,’” Cooper wrote.

Other parts of that law would have let the state Game and Fish Department to register voters and would have set up a special legislative committee to review the results of the Arizona Senate’s partisan audit of the 2020 election.

An attorney representing the state said the Constitution does not require lawmakers to specify each item they include in budget bills that direct spending and that a ruling agreeing the Legislature violated the Constitution could upend years of budget measures that added unrelated policy items.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Himachal Pradesh-Uttarakhand tragedy: Army recovers bodies of 5 trekkers, rescues 2

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Army on Thursday (October 22, 2021) recovered five bodies and rescued two people from snow in a rescue operation with Indo-Tibetan Border Police ... Read more »

Queen Elizabeth II spent night in hospital after scrapping trip: Buckingham Palace

Buckingham Palace said Thursday that Queen Elizabeth II spent a night in a hospital after being advised by her doctor to rest. The palace said the 95-year-old British monarch went ... Read more »

SGX Nifty up 20 points; here's what changed for market while you were sleeping

After a three-day beat down, the domestic equity market is likely to regain some strength on Friday. Asian stocks opened lower, before gaining some strength, whereas US stocks settled with ... Read more »

Asian tech shares jump, China property stocks rally as Evergrande makes payment

TOKYO: Tech stocks climbed in Asia on Friday, following U.S. peers higher, while Chinese property stocks rallied following a surprise interest payment by debt-ridden property developer China Evergrande Group. Meanwhile ... Read more »

RIL shareholders approve appointment of Saudi Aramco Chairman as independent director

© Provided by Business Today RIL shareholders approve appointment of Saudi Aramco Chairman as independent director Reliance Industries sought the approval of its shareholders to appoint Saudi Aramco chairman Yasir ... Read more »

Qantas moves up flights as Australia expects tourists soon

1 / 4Virus Outbreak AustraliaHairdresser Caroline Shamoon of Joey Scandizzo Salon works on a client’s hair in Melbourne, Friday, Oct. 22, 2021. Melbourne, Australia’s most populous city after Sydney, came ... Read more »

Friday's top brokerage calls: JSW Steel, Asian Paints, LIC Housing and TVS Motor

© Provided by CNBCTV18 © Provided by CNBCTV18 Jefferies on JSW Steel, jsw steel, jsw steel price, stock market, brokerage calls Jefferies on JSW Steel | The brokerage sees the ... Read more »

Parents share safety, security concerns at Mansfield ISD town hall in wake of shooting

Parents and community members on Thursday shared concerns over safety, security and communication in schools during a town hall hosted by the Mansfield school district. The town hall, held two ... Read more »

FBI says human remains found in Florida belong to Brian Laundrie

© Provided by dw.com Brian Laundrie was a person of interest in the death of his girlfriend Gabrielle Petito, but was never criminally charged The FBI confirmed on Thursday that ... Read more »

Nissan ex-chair Ghosn set on restoring reputation

© Copyright 2021The Associated Press. All right reserved Japan Carlos Ghosn – Copyright 2021The Associated Press. All right reserved Carlos Ghosn, the former auto industry superstar whose career screeched to ... Read more »

Blake Lively blasts Instagram account for posting image of her children

© Provided by Cover Media Blake Lively Blake Lively has called out an online fan account for posting an image of her children. Earlier this week, the people behind an ... Read more »

Agent was ‘insistent' for Emiliano Sala flight to go ahead, court told

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Aaron Chown/PA A plane operator organised the flight in which the footballer Emiliano Sala was killed after a Premier League agent made “insistent” phone ... Read more »

Woman dies after actor Alec Baldwin fires prop firearm on film set

A woman has died and a man has been injured after Alec Baldwin discharged a prop firearm on a film set, officials have confirmed. © Sky According to Santa Fe ... Read more »

4 of 10 Singapore IT leaders not confident with cyber-security

© Provided by Singapore Business Review Nearly 4 out of 10, or 43% of Singaporean IT leaders, said that they are not fully confident in their ability to deal with ... Read more »

NY Fed's Williams says rising home prices don't pose financial stability risks

© Reuters/CARLO ALLEGRI John Williams, CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, speaks at an event in New York (Reuters) – U.S. home prices are rising rapidly because ... Read more »

Taiwan delegation irks China with eastern Europe tour

A Taiwanese government delegation is visiting three eastern EU members to the dismay of China, which is irritated by any signs of Taiwan acting as an independent country. © SAM ... Read more »

Biden at pains to explain how he'll convince Manchin and Sinema to support budget and infrastructure bills

At a town hall hosted by CNN on Thursday, President Biden was repeatedly asked about the status of contentious budget negotiations with Democratic Senators Joe Manchin of West Virginia and ... Read more »

Biden says U.S. has ‘commitment' to defend Taiwan from Chinese attack

President Joe Biden on Thursday didn’t hesitate when asked whether the U.S. would come to Taiwan’s defense if China attacked. © Evan Vucci/AP Photo President Joe Biden participates in a ... Read more »

Husband of Missing Calif. Mom Maya Millete Pleads Not Guilty to Her Murder

© Provided by People Facebook May “Maya” Millete Larry Millete, the husband of missing California mom May “Maya” Millete, has pleaded not guilty to her murder. The plea was entered ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin fatally shoots crew member in prop gun ‘misfire' on New Mexico film set

Alec Baldwin fatally shot a movie crewmember with a “prop firearm” during a film shoot in New Mexico, authorities said Thursday. The shooting also injured the film’s director, a county ... Read more »

Recovering Paine eyeing return to cricket

Tim Paine is targeting a return to cricket through a second XI game for Tasmania as the Australia captain strives to prove his fitness ahead of the first Ashes Test. ... Read more »

Districts with over 5% positivity rate fall to 51 from 55 in October 14-20 week

The number of districts reporting over 5% positivity rate – a criteria used internationally to gauge the Covid-19 spread – have further declined from 55 to 51 in the October ... Read more »

SC to Centre: How did you fix Rs 8 Lakh as EWS quota ceiling?

The Supreme Court has asked the Centre to explain how it fixed ₹8 lakh as income limit for determining whether someone qualified for seats reserved for Economically Weaker Sections. After ... Read more »

Duterte eyes deeper ties with Saudi, 7 other countries

President Rodrigo Duterte sought deeper cooperation and friendship with Saudi Arabia and seven other countries. Duterte expressed this intent as he received the credentials of ambassadors from Saudi Arabia, Belgium, ... Read more »

Three to go in Dublin 2 – ‘Googletown' apartments from €735,000

Hanover Court, Grand Canal Dock, Dublin 2 Agent: Lisney (01) 6382700 There are just three two-bedroom apartments left at Hanover Court at Grand Canal Dock in Dublin 2. Built by ... Read more »

Legion-hosted concert will benefit reconciliation fund, raise awareness

The sounds of the Tragically Hip will echo through  the Aurora branch of the Royal Canadian Legion this Saturday for Rockin’  for ReconciliACTION, a concert benefiting the Gord Downie and ... Read more »

Narendra Modi Address LIVE Updates: Day After India's 100-Cr Covid Jabs Milestone, PM Set to Deliver Speech at 10 AM

© Provided by News18 Narendra Modi Address LIVE Updates: Day After India’s 100-Cr Covid Jabs Milestone, PM Set to Deliver Speech at 10 AM Narendra Modi Address LIVE Updates: Prime ... Read more »

'Damaging and disheartening:' California teacher on leave after being filmed chanting in faux Native American headdress

A Southern California high school teacher was placed on leave after a video recorded by a student showed her chanting and dancing around her classroom in a faux Native American ... Read more »

Crew member dead, another injured after prop gun discharged by Alec Baldwin accidentally misfires on set

UPDATE 10:15 p.m. ET: Halyna Hutchins, 42, the film’s director of photography, and Joel Souza, 48, the film’s director, were the individuals shot, according to the Santa Fe County Sheriff’s ... Read more »

Rapper Young Thug sues apartment complex where he lives over stolen songs, money

Hip-Hop artist Young Thug has sued his apartment complex accusing its employees of letting an unknown person take his designer bag that had unreleased songs and more than $100,000 worth ... Read more »

AP FACT CHECK: Biden overstates his record on COVID vaccine

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden botched the numbers behind the COVID-19 vaccine rollout Thursday as he stretched to take all the credit for the surge of shots once he ... Read more »

Trump's new venture

The former president has announced the launch of a new social media company, “TRUTH Social.” ABC News’ Andrew Dymburt has more. Read more »

Trump Plans to Regain Social Media Presence With New Company

Trump Plans to Regain Social Media Presence With New Company (Bloomberg) — Former President Donald Trump on Wednesday announced a deal that would enable him to regain a social media ... Read more »

Pandemic, climate change to dominate Asia-Pacific ministers' meeting

(Reuters) – Ministers from the Asia-Pacific trade group APEC will meet virtually on Friday, hoping to chart a path forward for the region to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic and ... Read more »

Roma dibelasah kerana kesilapan Mourinho

© Provided by Sinar Harian PENGENDALI AS Roma, Jose Mourinho bertanggungjawab selepas pasukan kendaliannya itu dibelasah kelab dari Norway, Bodo/Glimt 1-6 dalam aksi Liga Conference Europa pada awal pagi Jumaat. ... Read more »

Elegant Fresh Flower Cakes

If you’re looking for elegant homemade cakes perfect for all occasions, Puteri Nur Alia’s baking business, namely Alia & Her Cakes are sure to serve you some scrumptious treats! Based ... Read more »

China sticking with ‘zero-Covid', but is it a binary choice?

Illustration: Brian Wang A retired couple in China who tested positive for Covid-19 while touring the country’s north have sparked a race to track infections across multiple provinces and regions, ... Read more »

Filibuster reform: Biden says he's open to altering filibuster on voting rights and debt limit

President Joe Biden said Thursday he would be open to altering the filibuster to pass voting rights legislation, but said attempting to do so now would hamper his ability to ... Read more »

What people are saying about China Evergrande Group

© Reuters/ALY SONG Headquarters of China Evergrande Group in Shenzhen HONG KONG (Reuters) -China Evergrande Group wired funds to a trustee account on Thursday for a bond interest payment due ... Read more »

Evergrande has reportedly paid off $83.5 million worth of interest in dollar bonds ahead of deadline to avoid default

© Feature China/Barcroft Media via Getty Images) Evergrande Center in Shanghai, China. Feature China/Barcroft Media via Getty Images) China Evergrande has transferred funds to pay $83.5 million in bond interest ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic