Jewish couple kicked off American Airlines flight for refusing to put prayer shawl on floor

Asia's Tech News Daily

A Jewish couple who were kicked off an American Airlines flight for refusing to store their sacred prayer shawl on the floor have filed a lawsuit against the airline.

Jewish couple kicked off American Airlines flight for refusing to put prayer shawl on floor
© Joe Raedle/ Getty Images

An American Airlines plane lands at the Miami International Airport

– Joe Raedle/ Getty Images

Roberto and Elana Birman, a couple in their 70s, were flying from Miami to New York on flight 322 in August when they claim the incident occurred.

A flight attendant allegedly pulled Roberto’s Tallit bag, a 8.5 inch-by-8.5-inch clear plastic bag holding his prayer book and shawl, out from the overhead bin and asked who it belonged to.

When the pair indicated it was theirs, the crew member allegedly threw the bag on his lap and said it had to go under his seat.

Roberto claims he told the member of staff that, as an Orthodox Jew, he could not put the shawl on the floor, explaining, “It’s a religious item, it cannot go under the seat,” and removing his baseball cap to show his kippah.

But the flight attendant said it didn’t matter, the couple claim.

“She was screaming at me and pointing her finger,” Roberto told the New York Post.

“I couldn’t believe this was happening to me in America.

“We use these items every single day to pray.”

When they refused, they were eventually ushered off the plane.

Elana called the incident “embarrassing”, adding that her husband “was devastated” by what happened.

“Nobody said a word. Nobody defended us,” she said. “What are we, criminals?”

The couple, who have been married for 52 years and have five children, say they were left without Roberto’s diabetes medications, which were stowed in their checked luggage, and were offered no help with finding accommodation for the night by AA.

They are now suing the carrier for unspecified damages.

“My clients were ejected from the flight based on the prejudices and complete lack of sensitivity of American Airlines employees for reasons wholly unrelated to security,” said their lawyer, Brad Gerstman.

“The flight attendant and pilot’s conduct was as offensive as it was illogical.”

American Airlines is reviewing the lawsuit, according to a spokesperson.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Pioneering study finds generational link between smoking and body fat

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: UK Stock Images Ltd/Alamy Women and girls whose grandfathers or great-grandfathers began smoking at an early age tend to have more body fat, research ... Read more »

Royals will 'breathe sigh of relief' if Meghan and Harry don't come, says expert

If Meghan Markle and Prince Harry decide not to return to the UK, members of the Royal Family will “breathe a sigh of relief”, an expert has said. Palace officials ... Read more »

Flamboyant American rock star Meat Loaf dies at 74

© Ralph Orlowski, Reuters Meat Loaf, the flamboyant American rock star who rose to global fame with his debut “Bat Out of Hell” album, has died aged 74. The singer and ... Read more »

Olly Alexander wants 'erotic superhero' role

© Bang Showbiz Olly Alexander hopes to play an ‘erotic superhero’ Olly Alexander wants to play an “erotic superhero”. The Years & Years singer was praised for his acting in ... Read more »

Fernando Alonso says Alpine should be in a stronger place for 2022 than last season

Two-time Formula 1 world champion Fernando Alonso has said that Alpine could be more competitive than they were in 2021, but says there are still improvements that are needed on the ... Read more »

Special Oireachtas committee on international surrogacy to be established

© Shutterstock nerudol A SPECIAL JOINT Oireachtas committee on international surrogacy is set to be established, the Government has confirmed.  In a statement, it said Justice Minister Helen McEntee, Health ... Read more »

Anna Kendrick and Bill Hader have been ‘quietly dating' for over a year and fans are shocked

© Getty Anna Kendrick and Bill Hader – Getty Social media users can’t believe Anna Kendrick and Bill Hader have been ‘quietly dating’ each other for over a year. On ... Read more »

Frozen musical extends West End run - how to get tickets

It’s official – the Frozen musical is extending its run in London’s West End. Having previously announced shows at the Theatre Royal Drury Lane up to the end of June, ... Read more »

Referee in Africa Cup of Nations goes viral for his brilliantly bizarre running technique

Football fans that have been watching the Africa Cup of Nations have been treated to a fantastic spectacle so far. There have been so many talking points in Cameroon – ... Read more »

Bolton Wanderers boss Ian Evatt on Shrewsbury Town, Jon Dadi Bodvarsson and Kyle Dempsey latest

Bolton Wanderers are aiming to make it back to back wins in League One this weekend when they take on Shrewsbury Town. Wanderers head to Shropshire to take on Salop ... Read more »

Foo Fighters drop song for Fraggle Rock revival soundtrack

© Bang Showbiz Foo Fighters release Fraggle Rock Rock Foo Fighters have released a new song for the revival of children’s classic ‘Fraggle Rock’. Dave Grohl and co have released ... Read more »

A Christmas Story sequel in development

© Bang Showbiz A sequel to ‘A Christmas Story’ is being developed A sequel to ‘A Christmas Story’ is in the works. Legendary and Warner Bros. have reportedly closed a ... Read more »

Top US, Russian envoys discuss Ukraine at 'critical moment'

© Provided by Associated Press U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, left, shake hands with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, right, prior to their meeting in Geneva, Switzerland, Friday, Jan. ... Read more »

Norway mass killer tests limits of lenient justice system

1 / 10Norway Justice Too SoftFILE – Convicted mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik looks on during the last day of his appeal case in Borgarting Court of Appeal at Telemark ... Read more »

Not guilty: Sailor on nearby ship who dozed through Titanic distress calls did NOT cost lives, says movie director James Cameron's favourite historian as he overturns history's damning 110-year-old verdict

Cyril Evans manned the telegraph equipment on the SS Californian Evans, condemned by history, went to bed at 11.30pm on April 14, 1912Titanic struck an iceberg minutes later, leading to loss of more than 1,500 lives But expert Parks Stephenson said Evans could not have lessened the death tollSaid normal sign-off time for wireless operators was 11pmMr Stephenson co-authored book with James Cameron, director of film Titanic  Read more »

China brings back anal swab testing for Covid two weeks before Winter Olympics begin

At least 27 people underwent anal swab tests at apartment building in BeijingThey lived in Haidian district where city's first Omicron case has been detectedWinter Olympics are two weeks away, but organisers has imposed restrictions Read more »

FIFA 22 Team of the Year: FUT Leaker Reveals TOTY Moments Sergino Dest SBC

The FIFA 22 Team of the Year promo finally goes live at 6PM GMT on Friday 21st January 2022 and we have all the latest information around leaks which have ... Read more »

WATCH: Javonte Williams' highlights from rookie season

© Provided by Broncos Wire After being selected by the Denver Broncos in the second round of the 2021 NFL draft, running back Javonte Williams had an excellent rookie season, ... Read more »

Sheffield Wednesday stance over player deal clarified as Wigan circle

Both Sheffield Wednesday and Nathaniel Mendez-Laing are keen to agree new terms to keep the winger at the Yorkshire club amid interest from Wigan Athletic, according to Alex Miller from ... Read more »

Video: Chris Sutton insists Arsenal were 'schooled' by Liverpool in their Carabao Cup semi-final defeat and warns the Gunners are still 'a mile off competing for major trophies' in a brutal assessment

Read more »

Sheffield United man would be the ideal Jed Wallace replacement for Millwall: Opinion

© Provided by Football League World FA Cup Third Round – Wolverhampton Wanderers v Sheffield United Millwall are currently on edge over the future of Jed Wallace at present, with ... Read more »

The Six Nations 2022 power rankings

The Six Nations is around the corner, with the squads having been announced for the northern hemisphere’s showpiece. But who are the ones to beat? Can Wales defend their crown? ... Read more »

Donald Trump Says Joe Biden's Remarks Gave Russia the 'Green Light' on Ukraine

© MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images Then-US President Donald Trump boards Air Force One before departing Harlingen, Texas on January 12, 2021. Trump on Thursday said he believes that President Joe Biden ... Read more »

Ghana explosion: Almost entire town leveled after explosives delivery truck crash

© Prestea Huni-Valley Municipal Assembly People sift through debris from Thursday’s explosion in Apiate, in western Ghana. At least 17 people were killed in a blast in western Ghana on ... Read more »

UAE, Turkey to ink new agreements during Erdogan’s upcoming visit

© Provided by Khaleej Times The UAE and Turkey are expected to sign new agreements and “renew previous commitments” during the anticipated visit of the Turkish President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, ... Read more »

"He's just dragging this out": Transfer insider drops Ramsey, Nketiah and Crystal Palace update

Journalist Dean Jones has revealed there are still ‘a few things that are waiting’ to be completed before Crystal Palace can progress with deals for Aaron Ramsey and Eddie Nketiah.  ... Read more »

‘The Greens want to take our meat away’: Europeans go to war over their dinner

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Denis Doyle/Getty Images A row over meat consumption in Spain over the last month is just the most recent eruption of the debate all ... Read more »

Dubai Police return €33,600 to transit passenger who lost cash at airport

© Provided by Khaleej Times Supplied photo Dubai Police recently returned €33,600 (Dh140,000) to a transit passenger after the man lost the cash during his outbound journey via the Dubai ... Read more »

Covid in UAE: Pakistani engineer-turned-security guard wins Dh100,000 in Mahzooz draw

© Provided by Khaleej Times The 60th weekly live Mahzooz draw transformed the lives of its winners and changed their perceptions about hope and luck. For Pakistani national Mubashir, winning ... Read more »

Coronavirus: UAE reports 2,921 new cases and three deaths

© Provided by The National Dubai, United Arab Emirates: A health worker showing a swap at a newly opened low cost PCR testing tent that has the capacity to do ... Read more »

West Ham knocked back in Jesse Lingard transfer bid with Man United unwilling to loan midfielder to rival

© Manchester United via Getty Imag Jesse Lingard jan 22 West Ham have been dealt a blow in their bid to sign Jesse Lingard this month, with Manchester United refusing ... Read more »

Neymar gets paid £23m with insane Puma boot deal - more than both Messi & Ronaldo

The business of being a professional footballer can be a rather lucrative one. Just one look at Cristiano Ronaldo‘s glittering car collection, or Lionel Messi‘s sweeping real estate portfolio will ... Read more »

Stirling Albion relishing bumper Rangers Scottish Cup tie ahead of Ibrox clash

Stirling Albion’s glamour Scottish Cup fourth-round tie against Rangers at Ibrox takes place tonight live on Premier Sports with a 7.45pm kick-off. And the players are determined to give a ... Read more »

‘Could be the perfect place to thrive' – Millwall weighing up move for Norwich City player: The verdict

This article is part of Football League World’s ‘The Verdict‘ series, which provides personal opinions from the FLW writers regarding the latest breaking news, teams, players, managers, potential signings and more… Millwall ... Read more »

160 PS bei 15 Kilo Gewicht als Motorradmotor - Astron Omega 1 Turbinenmotor

Ein Startup aus den USA hat einen spektakulären Kreiskolbenmotor entwickelt. Die Maschine leistet 160 PS bei nur 15 Kilogramm Gewicht. Ist das der perfekte Motorradmotor? © Astron 90 Jahre und ... Read more »

'Anonymous', 'So poor': Many LFC fans slam 'invisible' ace who had 20 less touches than Kelleher

A number of Liverpool supporters have slammed Jordan Henderson’s performance against Arsenal, despite the Reds reaching the League Cup final. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Liverpool’s Jordan Henderson Jurgen Klopp’s ... Read more »

Workers dismantle London's Marble Arch Mound

© Jeremy Selwyn MarbleArchMoundDismantled200122v1 The much-maligned Marble Arch Mound is finally being dismantled after a petition to save the £6million attraction failed. Works have already begun to take apart the ... Read more »

Russian space debris came within 47ft of knocking out China satellite

Space debris from a Russian anti-satellite missile test came within 47 feet (14.5 metres) of knocking out China’s Tsinghua science satellite this week, Beijing claims.  The near-miss between Tsinghua and ... Read more »

Swansea City signings, Jamie Paterson resolution and more exits to come in final 10 days of transfer window

There are just 10 days to go until transfer deadline day. Swansea have already been firmly active in the winter market, with Hannes Wolf following Andy Fisher and Cyrus Christie ... Read more »

Wayne Rooney 'confirms' current Everton stance as Duncan Ferguson claim made

Everton’s search for their next manager continues today with a new frontrunner emerging, according to sources. Rafa Benitez was sacked after a poor start to the season, leaving Everton 16th ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic