Jack steps back

Jack steps back
© Photo by MARCO BELLO/AFP via Getty Images

One day in 2011, Jack Dorsey called an all-hands meeting at Twitter. The company was in the middle of a push to redesign Twitter’s mobile apps, and the effort had led to anger and burnout. Dorsey, who had co-founded the company in 2006 with Ev Williams, Biz Stone, and Noah Glass, was then serving as its executive chairman.

The company prepared for what it assumed would be a pep talk from the most eccentric of Twitter’s co-founders. And they got one, of a sort. As the meeting began, the lights at Twitter headquarters dimmed. An acoustic guitar began playing over speakers. Dorsey encouraged everyone to listen to the lyrics.

Blackbird singing in the dead of night

Take these broken wings and learn to fly

All your life

You were only waiting for this moment to arise

Sitting in the dark, no one was entirely sure what meaning Dorsey found in the Beatles’ “Blackbird.” A decade later, people I spoke with about the incident still weren’t entirely sure. From his earliest days at the company, Dorsey was an enigma: on one hand, a visionary leader with an uncanny grasp of what the future holds; on the other, a distant and often inscrutable manager whose slowness in making decisions would hobble the company for almost half a decade.

The song concluded. Afterward, people debated what it meant, to no real end. The company finished the sprint. Jack Dorsey returned to the company as CEO a few years later. This Monday, he announced that he was quitting.

Almost nobody thought this moment would arrive today — a day that Twitter had told employees to take as “a day of rest.”

Elliott wins in the end?

The two questions you want to ask when a CEO steps down are: why now? And what next?

Let’s start with the first one.

On one hand, this is a genuine surprise. By many metrics, this has been a banner year for Twitter. Revenue is up, and so is the user base. It shipped more individual products than perhaps at any other time in its history. (Most notably, it cloned Clubhouse at impressive speed, leaving that once-buzzy social audio platform moribund.) After spending half a decade stuck in the mud, there was a sense that Twitter finally had real momentum. From that perspective, Dorsey’s position at the company looked secure.

But Twitter is publicly traded, and its slow growth (particularly in comparison to the behemoth Facebook) has long rankled investors.

I wrote Jack Dorsey was in for the fight of his life. It turns out he was.

Last spring, the activist investor Elliott Management Corp. took a 4 percent stake in the company and announced its intention to replace Dorsey as CEO. While little known to the public, Elliott — a hedge fund controlled by the billionaire Paul Singer — is among the most feared investors in the world. When the news hit, I wrote here that Jack Dorsey was in for the fight of his life. As it turned out, he was.

The odd part is that it seemed like Dorsey had won. Days after Elliott made its move, Twitter surrendered, agreeing to add three new board members and form a committee to review its governance and evaluate a succession plan. Elliott partner Jesse Cohn joined Twitter’s board, but stepped down in June in what I took to be a sign that the firm was satisfied by Twitter’s progress.

The catch was that Elliott had set several aggressive growth targets for Dorsey. Under the agreement, Twitter had to grow its user base by at least 20 percent in 2020, accelerate revenue growth, and gain market share as a digital advertiser. While it has made some progress, it is not close to hitting its updated goals. (The company wants to add 100 million more daily active users in the next year, for example, increasing its user base by a third — a tall order for a 15-year-old company that is a household name and has already churned through much of the world’s population.)

The stock price has been sliding throughout the fall, and today sits just a few dollars higher than it did at the time of the company’s initial public offering. Meanwhile, Elliott’s partner in the original plan to oust Dorsey, the private equity firm Silver Lake, maintains a seat on Twitter’s board.

There were no outward signs of the board’s unhappiness. But looking at these facts, it’s easy to imagine two scenarios: one in which Dorsey saw a revived fight coming his way and deciding to leave before it happened; another in which the board told him his time was up and to bow out gracefully.

I don’t know which of those two scenarios is more likely; I do believe, however, that it was most probably one of them that led to today’s news. (The fact that the news leaked early, perhaps from the board itself, suggests to me that maybe someone worried Dorsey might have changed his mind before going through with it.)

“This was my decision and I own it,” Dorsey said in an email to employees. “I’m really sad … yet really happy. There aren’t many companies that get to this level. And there aren’t many founders who choose their company over their own ego. I know we’ll prove this was the right move.”

not sure anyone has heard but,

I resigned from Twitter pic.twitter.com/G5tUkSSxkl

— jack⚡️ (@jack) November 29, 2021

Elliott, for its part, blessed the decision.

“Having gotten to know both incoming Chairman Bret Taylor and incoming CEO Parag Agrawal, we are confident that they are the right leaders for Twitter at this pivotal moment for the company,” Cohn and senior portfolio manager Marc Steinberg said in a statement.

The “duh” explanation

Another explanation for Jack Dorsey leaving Twitter, which may or may not be related to Elliott Management Corp., is the relative lack of evidence that Jack Dorsey wanted to be CEO of Twitter. It is at least possible he woke up one recent morning and decided he wanted to leave.

Here’s a story about not really wanting to be CEO: I’m told Dorsey was ambivalent about the company’s decision to build Fleets, its ephemeral product that mimicked Snapchat Stories. But he let the team launch it anyway at the end of last year. A while later, during an all-hands meeting, someone asked what he thought of the product. He basically shrugged, one person told me. “It’s not my thing” — that was the gist.

Dorsey’s section of the Q&A was immediately followed by the Fleets team presenting their progress.

When Twitter decided to kill Fleets this year, Dorsey — who may not have ever posted a public Fleet — dispatched it with a tweeted waving-hand emoji that some internally took to indicate “good riddance.”

There are a lot of Dorsey stories like this. In the areas where he was most focused, product teams could expect lots of time, attention, and valuable feedback. In areas where he was not focused, teams could expect little to no feedback at all. He set the vision and let his deputies handle the rest. This had pros and cons, but it drove a lot of people crazy — particularly when teams were divided on the path forward, and he refused to break the tie.

There are benefits to having a CEO who cares about only a few things, and pushes on them relentlessly. At Square, for example, Dorsey pushed executives to focus on Cash App for peer-to-peer payments and cryptocurrencies for the future of finance. Square has thrived as a result, and its market capitalization is now nearly triple that of Twitter.

But Twitter under Dorsey has suffered from a comparable lack of focus. Its top priorities at any given time have rotated between user growth, revenue growth, conversational “health,” “serving the public conversation,” and other abstractions. People who worked with him directly, when I would ask recently how engaged Dorsey was with the core product, would tell me that they didn’t know.

There’s a joke about Dorsey that says everyone at Twitter thought he was working more on Square, and everyone at Square thought he was working more on Twitter. This served to elide the question of how much he was working at all. One reason Elliott appears to have launched its attack was Dorsey’s declaration that (pre-pandemic) he intended to spend most of 2020 in Africa, to no apparent work purpose or shareholder benefit.

Dorsey knew he was perceived as distant and indecisive; he told employees that he was too slow to make decisions. But people believed him when he said — as he did Saturday, in a line that may have presaged today’s events — “I love Twitter.” He was undeniably charismatic, the kind of guy who could get his employees to drink the salt juice. A complicated figure, but one who leaves a void.

The new guy

Into that void steps Parag Agrawal, a 10-year Twitter veteran who rose through the ranks as an engineer to become its chief technical officer. Multiple people told me that “CTO” doesn’t fully capture the breadth of Agrawal’s contributions. Internally, he is perceived by many employees as a sharp technical leader; an uncommonly long-term thinker; and intensely focused on the operational side of the company.

One person told me that Agrawal was among the few people internally who could regularly get Dorsey to change his mind.

Given his long tenure as an engineer, Agrawal is highly respected by the technical side of Twitter, and has personal relationships with many of its most senior individual contributors. That could help the company retain its engineering core during the kind of organizational shift that often results in an exodus from the company.

Agrawal has his detractors, too. A core complaint is that he was too close to Dorsey — and, if you’re among the Twitter employees who think Dorsey had become a liability for the company, Agrawal’s appointment may not appear to be the clean break you were hoping for.

In any case, Agrawal is likely to surface another cultural tension inside the company. He is among the executives who has been most focused on cryptocurrencies, and encouraged Dorsey to allow Twitter to explore decentralization and other related technologies. The company has so far announced Bluesky, which could turn Twitter into a decentralized protocol; Bitcoin-based tips; and (maybe eventually) NFT profile pictures.

it makes sense Dorsey would want to hand the reins to a fellow believer

Given Dorsey’s religious devotion to Bitcoin, it makes sense that he would want to hand the reins to a fellow believer. But given how polarizing crypto culture is generally, it bears watching how many Twitter employees will come along for the ride — and what may fall by the wayside as a result. Of course, that depends in part on how hard Agrawal leans in. But the early indications are that it’s a high priority for him.

He’ll also have to work on Elliott’s wish list, of course: more users, more revenue, a bigger share of the ad market. And he’ll have to navigate other, unrelated transitions at the company. Its head of communications, Kelly Sims, left Twitter last week after less than four months at the company, in what is a highly difficult role to fill. And Sara Beykpour, who joined the company in 2012 and has lately been leading its Twitter Blue subscription product, announced recently that she is leaving the company as well.

Notably, she’s married to Kayvon Beykpour, Twitter’s head of product, who was likely on the short list for CEO. I’ll be curious to see how much longer he stays at the company, given that he is already one of the company’s longest-serving product chiefs.

In the meantime, Twitter now has something it hasn’t had since 2015: a full-time CEO. Time will tell how Agrawal fares in the role. But by that measure alone, he is already an improvement on his predecessor.

Note: This article is based on conversations (some very long, others quite short) with 13 current and former Twitter employees, who requested anonymity so as to preserve their professional relationships.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Cycling-Bernal taken to hospital after training crash in Colombia

© Reuters/JENNIFER LORENZINI FILE PHOTO: Giro d’Italia (Reuters) – Colombian rider Egan Bernal suffered a crash in training and was taken to hospital on Monday, his Ineos Grenadiers team said. ... Read more »

Lange can replicate Digne masterclass as AVFC plot move for “phenomenal” £10m dynamo - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast lingard With three players added to their senior squad earlier in the current January transfer window, Aston Villa still have enough time to strengthen their ... Read more »

Antonio Conte handed January transfer boost as Fabio Paratici solves historic Tottenham problem

Tottenham will be hoping that their struggles of naming both a Premier League and European squad are finally a thing of the past. Only allowed to name a maximum of ... Read more »

Russian Duma takes its time over call for east Ukraine 'independence'

© Reuters/SPUTNIK FILE PHOTO: Russian President Putin attends an extraordinary meeting of CSTO leaders, via a video link outside Moscow By Maria Tsvetkova MOSCOW (Reuters) – A proposal to ask ... Read more »

Reliable journalist drops interesting West Ham transfer claim as Calvert-Lewin talk emerges

© GiveMeSport West Ham United boss David Moyes in the dugout The Daily Mail’s chief football reporter Sami Mokbel has serious doubts as to whether West Ham United will be willing ... Read more »

Ogilvy India (South) names Puneet Kapoor as chief creative officer

© Provided by The Financial Express Kapoor will work alongside Ogilvy India’s chief creative officers and the president of Ogilvy India (South) Ogilvy India announced on Monday that Kiran Anthony ... Read more »

Frankie Bridge insists she gets on with everyone on Loose Women amid Coleen feud claims

Frankie Bridge has spoken about getting on well with her Loose Women colleagues after feeling “nervous” joining the show following recent feud rumours among the co-hosts. The 33 year old ... Read more »

Merrill Lynch wealth adviser arrested, fired after calling teen smoothie shop worker an ‘immigrant loser' and throwing a drink at her

Merrill Lynch wealth adviser arrested, fired after calling teen smoothie shop worker an ‘immigrant loser’ and throwing a drink at her ‘Our company does not tolerate behavior of this kind,’ ... Read more »

Everything you need to know about 'Snowpiercer' before watching season 3

© David Bukach / TNT “Snowpiercer” stars Daveed Diggs, Katie McGuinness, Mickey Sumner and Rowan Blanchard. David Bukach / TNT “Snowpiercer” season three premieres today on TNT. The dystopian series ... Read more »

Budget session to commence with strict Covid protocol, different timings for Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha

© Provided by DNA Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha will have staggered timing during the budget session of parliament beginning March 31 as part of measures against COVID-19 amid a ... Read more »

Flying of Parachute Regiment flags ahead of Bloody Sunday anniversary condemned

Unionist politicians have criticised the flying of Parachute Regiment flags in Londonderry and called for their removal, ahead of the 50th anniversary of Bloody Sunday. As parts of Derry city ... Read more »

Aldi is selling a heated dressing gown to help beat the cold - and we need one

We all have that one trusty dressing gown which gets us through the cold winters, but do you have one with a built-in heater? We take that as a no. ... Read more »

Inside Dele Alli's Tottenham fall and Daniel Levy's plans for midfielder reboot

Back in the summer of 2018, Dele Alli went to the World Cup as one of England’s biggest stars. Four years on ahead of the next World Cup, Alli is ... Read more »

'Sheena Bora is alive,' says Indrani Mukerjea in plea before Mumbai court

© Provided by Zee News Former media baron Indrani Mukerjea on Monday submitted a hand-written application before a special court here claiming her daughter Sheena Bora, whom she is accused ... Read more »

Join Squidge and The42 Rugby Weekly crew for our members' Six Nations preview

RESTRICTIONS HAVE BEEN kicked to touch, stadiums can be filled to the brim once more and the four provinces have reached the knockout stages of the Champions Cup. Who could ... Read more »

Chelsea are forced to increase the size of the away dressing room

Chelsea have been ordered to increase the size of the away dressing room at Stamford Bridge after complaints from visiting teams including Liverpool and Brighton. Liverpool made their point to ... Read more »

Benedict Cumberbatch 'loved' being in lockdown with his family

© Bang Showbiz Benedict Cumberbatch says lockdown was an enjoyable period of his life Benedict Cumberbatch “loved” being in lockdown. The 45-year-old actor – who has children Christopher, six, Hal, ... Read more »

ITV The Chase: Bradley Walsh secret method to stop himself laughing at questions

Bradley Walsh is known for his laughing fits while presenting ITV’s daytime quiz show The Chase. Who can forget the moment the Fanny Chmelar question came up and Bradley struggled ... Read more »

Punjab police arrest man for sacrilege bid at Patiala temple; attempt to disrupt peace, says CM Channi

Punjab sacrilege attempt Police in Punjab have arrested a man for allegedly attempting sacrilege at the Kali Devi temple in Patiala. The incident was captured on CCTV and a video ... Read more »

Novelis to raise $300-350 mn from Axis Bank in GIFT City

MUMBAI: Novelis, the overseas subsidiary of Hindalco , is raising about $300-350 million in offshore loans from Axis Bank, seeking to trim multiple credit lines through part repayment of earlier ... Read more »

Boris Johnson 'reconsidering' VAT cut on energy bills for every household

Boris Johnson is understood to be reconsidering a VAT cut on gas and electricity – cutting every household energy bill by 5% as prices surge to record levels. Though no ... Read more »

Palin COVID-19 tests delay libel trial against NY Times

NEW YORK (AP) — An unvaccinated Sarah Palin tested positive for COVID-19 Monday, forcing a postponement of the start of a trial in her libel lawsuit against The New York ... Read more »

I'm a self-confessed catfish – people say I'm the reason men have trust issues but at least I've already got a husband

A WOMAN got a strong reaction from followers after showing herself on camera without any make-up and then sharing a glammed up “catfish” snap. Viewers of the dramatic transformation couldn't ... Read more »

Consumer Reports: Testing Tesla & Ford Driver Monitoring Systems

© InsideEVs wmTuamHeedA Only two automakers passed Consumer Reports’ driver monitoring tests: Ford and GM. According to Consumer Reports, Tesla’s camera-based driving monitoring system doesn’t work to keep a driver’s ... Read more »

Sweden's RGNT Motorcycles Will Sell Its Electric Bikes In The U.S.

© RideApart.com Copyright RGNT No. 1 – Scrambler – Left Side Beauty in all its nuts and volts. Back in 2019, Swedish electric motorcycle startup RGNT released its extremely striking ... Read more »

Diego Carlos: Newcastle will have to stump up at least £37.9m to sign Sevilla defender

Diego Carlos has attracted £30m offers from Newcastle and a London Premier League club; Sevilla want £37.9m (€45m) if they are to part company with the defender; Newcastle still pushing for Jesse Lingard with talks over loan move from Manchester United on going Read more »

Desi, healthy winter desserts to keep you warm this January

© Provided by The Indian Express Festival time in India is synonymous with good food, and desserts top the list of most-favourite foods. As we celebrate one festival after another, ... Read more »

Fed to signal rate hike as it launches risky inflation fight

On Location: January 24, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press WASHINGTON — With inflation punishing consumers and threatening the economy, the Federal Reserve this week ... Read more »

Israel's top Arab police officer takes leave pending probe

JERUSALEM — The highest-ranking Arab Muslim in Israel’s police force has taken leave, the police said Monday, after video emerged showing him tripping over a stabbing victim as he left ... Read more »

Apex's third anniversary will give players Packs for Octane, Wattson, and Valkyrie just for logging in

© Provided by Dot Esports To celebrate its third anniversary, Apex Legends is giving players three thematic Apex Packs for three different legends and a special Legendary Pack at the ... Read more »

FDA approves 2 self-test antigen kits

FDA Deputy Dir. Gen. Oscar Gutierrez at Jan. 24, 2022 briefing The Philippine Food and Drug Administration has approved two self-administered COVID-19 antigen test kits, officer-in-charge Oscar Gutierrez said Monday. ... Read more »

Delhi to have only three ‘dry days' in 2022

Delhi to have only three ‘dry days’ in 2022 The Delhi government, in an official notification on Monday, stated that the union territory will have only three ‘dry days’ this ... Read more »

SolChicks guide: How to make money in the play-to-earn crypto game

SOLCHICKS is gaining popularity as one of the leading fantasy play-to-earn gaming ecosystems on the Solana blockchain. The game features adorable “battle chicken” characters, which players can acquire to win ... Read more »

When is ranked play coming to Call of Duty: Vanguard?

© Provided by Dot Esports After months of anticipation, ranked play is finally on the way to Call of Duty: Vanguard. A ranked ladder was confirmed back in October by ... Read more »

Your own CIA jail? Lithuania to sell secret U.S. 'rendition' site

© Reuters/JANIS LAIZANS A building used by CIA to house Iraq and Afghanistan extraordinary rendition prisoners, in Vilnius By Andrius Sytas ANTAVILIAI, Lithuania (Reuters) – A huge steel barn outside ... Read more »

Kabore, Burkina's consensus-builder and onetime beacon of hope

© JULIEN DE ROSA Kabore, seen during 75th anniversary celebrations of UNESCO in Paris in November, vowed to stem jihadist violence but his failure to do so has hit his ... Read more »

Kate packt das Baby-Fieber – kommt nun das vierte Kind?

Bei einem Besuch in Lancashire mutierte Herzogin Kate kurzerhand zum Kindermädchen für das Baby einer Besucherin. Dabei zeigte sie sich so entzückt von dem kleinen Geschöpf, dass selbst William ins ... Read more »

Call of Duty: Warzone and Vanguard Season 2 Operators reportedly leak

© Provided by GamePur Call of Duty: Warzone Pacific and Vanguard have had their second seasons delayed due to ongoing bugs and weapon balancing issues, but that doesn’t necessarily mean ... Read more »

Apex Legends Season 12 is called Defiance, stars Mad Maggie as new Legend

© Provided by GamePur The new season of Apex Legends has been coming for a while now, but players have been speculating about who the new character would end up ... Read more »

Respawn Entertainment Reveals Newest Legend Mad Maggie and Apex Legends Season 12

Respawn Entertainment revealed the latest Stories from the Outlands, highlighting the next Legend to join the fray. Players should be well aware of who Mad Maggie is since Fuse was ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic