‘It's very culty': the bizarre billion-dollar downfall of fashion company LuLaRoe

Roberta Blevins first heard about the leggings in the fall of 2015, in a post by a fellow member of a motherhood-themed Facebook group. They were loudly patterned, buttery soft, interesting – clothing functional for chasing around young children, accommodating of changing bodies post-birth, and cute enough to be socially acceptable outside the home. The woman who advertised the leggings said she bought them wholesale from a company called LuLaRoe, and sold them for double the price.

Blevins was intrigued. She was struggling with the alienation of young motherhood and looking to supplement her family’s income, and LuLaRoe offered an alluring, soothing promise: sign up to be a retailer, and you could run a successful virtual boutique out of your home while still being present for your kids.

Related: ‘The point is ambition’: are we ready to follow Netflix into space?

LuLaRoe seemed to offer “this built-in community, where I knew I could have an instant friendship”, she told the Guardian. As Blevins recalls in LuLaRich, a four-part Amazon docuseries on the beleaguered multi-level marketing company, LuLaRoe women added her to Facebook groups, texted her, invited her to parties that doubled as fashion sales, and showered her with encouragement. By March 2016, Blevins paid $9,000 to become a LuLaRoe consultant and receive a starter package of clothing to sell.

At first, things went well – she was enthusiastic about the clothing, and made money selling LuLaRoe on Facebook out of her home in suburban San Diego, California. But Blevins quickly felt the strain of the company’s precipitous growth, owing to its emphasis on recruiting new “consultants” – people on the “downline” whose start-up costs traveled up the ranks as “bonus checks”. By the end of 2016, what had started in 2012 as a homespun business selling maxi skirts out of the trunk of a car by two Mormon grandmothers had reached over $1.3bn in sales with over 60,000 consultants – and faced lawsuits alleging that LuLaRoe founders Mark and DeAnne Stidham misled retailers and ran a pyramid scheme.

Over four episodes, LuLaRich, directed by Jenner Furst and Julia Willoughby Nason (makers of Hulu’s Fyre, on the spectacular meltdown of the scammy music festival), surveys the warp speed growth of a company that preyed on millennial, overwhelmingly white women’s sense of purposelessness, repackaged the fallacy of “having it all”, and saddled thousands in debt and broken promises while the company’s top brass raked in millions. The company appealed, said Furst, to the “middle America millennials who don’t have the same opportunities that their parents had, who are facing a lot of different struggles, who are susceptible on one hand to the patriarchal nuclear family structure but then also the pitch to be a girlboss and to be empowered and to be a feminist who is selling these leggings”.

Blevins, like several of the former LuLaRoe consultants who appear in the series, was at first convinced by the promise of running her own business. The company hammered home the perks of being not just a LuLaRoe retailer, but a member of a movement – a “boss babe”, “part-time work for full time pay”, contributing to household income without going to an office. Or, as Mark puts it to Nason and Furst in the first episode: “Take your creativity, your passion, your excitement for life, and here’s a place that’s a pure meritocracy.”

“They saw me, they’re like she’s bubbly, she’s energetic, she knows how to use social media, she’s an asset to moving this forward,” Blevins said of the “love-bombing” grooming process that convinced her to join LuLaRoe. “At that point, I was just another walking dollar sign.”

Slowly, inconsistencies began to pile up. Blevins would visit “home office” in Corona, California, or attend company events, which increasingly took on the feel of pop religious festivals (corporate events included performances by Kelly Clarkson and Katy Perry), and Mark would start reciting passages from the book of Mormon. “I thought we were selling leggings?” Blevins recalled thinking. “It just seemed strange.” Blevins received an order of merchandise that reeked of mold; quality was slipping, and some leggings straight-up poorly designed, with prints that resembled anatomy at the crotch. Now with several consultants down-line of her, Blevins passed questions up the chain, “and they would give me an answer that made sense,” she said.

“You reach up inside the organization [for answers]. You don’t reach outside the organization for information or to have your questions answered. It’s very culty.”

Through interviews with former and current consultants, employees, and even Mark and DeAnne themselves, LuLaRich takes a bird’s eye view to what Blevins couldn’t see at the time: the company, allegedly designed to make money not on clothing but through the unsustainable recruitment of new members, was collapsing under its own weight. Mark and DeAnne, who married in 1998, trademarked LuLaRoe in 2013, and staffed it with members of their large extended family. In 14 months from 2015 to 2016, the company grew from $70m in sales to over a billion. The profits for those who joined early in the company, and whose down lines flowered into the thousands, were astounding: some in the series claim to have received bonus checks of anywhere from $20,000 to $70,000 a month.

Meanwhile, the majority of LuLaRoe consultants struggled to make ends meet – encouraged to take on debt and saddled with merchandise they couldn’t sell. With a glut on the market of LuLaRoe consultants, most buckled under the weight. “A lot of people lost their marriages, their lives were in shambles, people were selling breast milk for startup costs – are you kidding me?” LaShae Kimbrough Benson, who started as an administrative assistant at the company’s headquarters in 2015, told the Guardian. “People were taking out loans, all kind of stuff. And [Mark and DeAnne] knew that.”

The lopsided margins were by design of multi-level marketing companies – essentially, pyramid schemes legal under the guise that they’re selling a product rather than membership – according to experts featured in the series such as Robert FitzPatrick, author of Ponzinomics: The Untold Story of Multi-Level Marketing. Legal MLMs have to have a buyback policy, and prohibit buying new inventory until retailers have sold 70% and have at least 10 new customers. As Benson and other former employees recall, LuLaRoe more than skirted this line. “We always had a quota to hit,” said Benson, who eventually worked for the “onboarding” team for new members.

The Stidhams maintain that LuLaRoe, which is still in business (though startup costs are down 90% and the commission structure altered), was never a scam, but a meritocratic ladder reflective of personal effort and character. The couple participated in an initial interview with the film-makers to detail the origin story behind the company and their values of entrepreneurism while maintaining a traditional family structure; they declined a second interview to specifically address claims made against the company in 50 lawsuits filed since 2016, as well as some of the more outrageous elements of corporate culture – that they pressured consultants to get weight-loss surgery in Tijuana and received kickbacks from the doctor, for example.

The company instead offered a statement presented at the end of the series: “We continue to bring greater focus to our mission of improving lives and strengthening families through the principles of entrepreneurism while continuing to educate small business owners about the opportunities found in personal responsibility and individual choice.”

“It’s that dual-edged sword of personal responsibility,” said Furst of the statement. “That’s what the MLMs feed off of in the first place: if you’re a failure, it’s your fault.”

Blevins felt the stigma as she began to lose faith in the company over the course of 2017. The last straw was joining a Facebook support group for ex-LuLaRoe consultants and “having every little thing that I had ever complained about, any question I had, all answered”, she said. She read through the posts and cried.

“There’s a process of grief that you go through when you leave an MLM,” said Blevins, who left LuLaRoe in September 2017 and now advocates against MLMs through her own podcast. “There was a lot of ex-communication, a lot of harassment, a lot of people telling me I was crazy, or saying ‘You’re going to ruin your life by leaving.’”

The internal pressure to stay quiet and avoid “negativity” was something that dogged many women who participated in the series, according to co-director Julia Willoughby Nason. “There was just tons of the behind the scenes peer pressure and bullying, and blowback that these women had already experienced, and I think that they were very scared of the repercussions if they were going to have a platform like a multi-part docu-series,” she said.

In February, LuLaRoe agreed to pay $4.75m to the state of Washington to settle a 2019 consumer protection lawsuit alleging the company operated a pyramid scheme that made “unfair and deceptive misrepresentations regarding the profitability” of being a retailer. Through its collation of first-person testimony, LuLaRich offers an “invitation, tacitly, to attorney generals around the country to do what Washington did, protect their consumers” said Furst. In the meantime, the company still promises a “community of lasting love and fellowship” on a website that pitches “creating freedom through fashion” over a single button: “Join LuLaRoe.”

  • LuLaRich is now available on Amazon Prime

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Guardian view on the Nobel prize in literature: beauty out of universal loss

Photograph: Linda Nylind/The Guardian If one of the roles of the Nobel prize for literature is to shine a light on someone who has been less visible than they warrant, ... Read more »

Casal lança polémica após usar tigre para revelar sexo de bebé no Dubai

Tigre crava as garras num globo, acabando por revelar que os pais esperam uma menina. Veja as (polémicas) imagens. Um casal foi alvo de uma forte contestação após ter usado ... Read more »

Mthethwa congratulates newly crowned Miss SA, Lalela Mswane

© Twitter. Lalela Mswane was crowned Miss South Africa 2021. JOHANNESBURG – Sports and Arts Minister Nathi Mthethwa has joined South Africans in congratulating Lalela Mswane as the country’s new ... Read more »

Kendall Jenner and Hailey Bieber step out for dinner in Malibu

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo BFFs Kendall Jenner and Hailey Bieber were spotted leaving Nobu in Malibu on Saturday night.  The two women wowed in equally cool and ... Read more »

Battling ghosts from the past and building walls: ‘An Island' by Karen Jennings

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved “The sea is History.” – Derek Walcott According to Karen Jennings, her latest novel, An Island, was extremely difficult to write. ... Read more »

8 Styling-Fehler, die Sie ungepflegt aussehen lassen

Auf diese Dinge sollten Sie bitte unbedingt achten, damit Sie im Alltag nicht ungepflegt erscheinen © istockphoto Styling-Fehler ungepflegt istockphoto Ungebügelte Kleidung Ja, Bügeln ist nicht jedermanns Sache, aber es ... Read more »

'Squid Game' nos recreios lança alerta em vários países da Europa

Espanha, Bélgica e Reino Unido já reportaram casos em que as crianças imitam os jogos da série da Netflix. Escolas fazem alertas aos pais. © Netflix Espanha, Bélgica e Reino ... Read more »

Prince William and Kate arrive at Earthshot Prize ceremony

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have arrived at Alexandra Palace in London for the inaugural Earthshot Prize Awards Ceremony. The Earthshot Prize was launched by Prince William in October ... Read more »

Why Kate Middleton really wore a 2011 recycled gown for Prince William's Earthshot Prize

© Provided by Hello! kate-middleton-earthshot The Duchess of Cambridge looked beautiful as ever on Sunday evening as she arrived at the Earthshot Prize Awards with her husband Prince William. MORE: Kate ... Read more »

Why Kate Middleton really wore a recycled gown for Prince William's Earthshot Prize

© Provided by Hello! kate-middleton-earthshot The Duchess of Cambridge looked beautiful as ever on Sunday evening as she arrived at the Earthshot Prize Awards with her husband Prince William. MORE: Kate ... Read more »

La revancha de Solsona sobre Núñez

© EL PAÍS El gol de falta de Solsona en el Barça-Valencia (0-3) de 1980. EL MUNDO DEPORTIVO El 27 de septiembre de 1980 el Barça recibía al Valencia en ... Read more »

Carol Vorderman's curve-hugging wedding guest dress is so glamorous

© Provided by Hello! carol-vorderman-wedding-guest Another day, another fabulous outfit choice for Carol Vorderman, who stunned fans in a seriously figure-flattering black dress on Sunday.   RELATED: Everything you need to know ... Read more »

Naisen erikoinen tapa syödä nuudeleita jakaa mielipiteitä - nokkelaa vai outoa?

Nainen jakoi videon omalla TikTok-tilillään. © Shutterstock Naisen erikoinen tapa syödä nuudeleita jakaa mielipiteitä – nokkelaa vai outoa? TikTokissa on nähtävillä nuudelivideo, joka saa mielipiteet jakautumaan vahvasti. Sen on jakanut ... Read more »

Matalan shoppers praise 'very flattering' £12.50 animal print dress

Matalan shoppers are loving one of the retailer’s new dresses after spotting it online. Since the autumn weather has well and truly arrived, many shoppers will be looking to change ... Read more »

Psychological ‘specialness spirals' can make ordinary items feel like treasures – and may explain how clutter accumulates

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved Years ago, I bought a blouse at Target. That same day, I considered putting it on, but for no particular reason ... Read more »

Yasmien Kurdi, handang-handa nang magka-baby number two

© Provided by PEP.ph GORGY RULA Matagal nang gusto ni Yasmien Kurdi at ng asawa niyang si Rey Soldevilla na masundan ang anak nilang si Ayesha, pero hindi pa sila ... Read more »

‘At once intolerable and addictive': five wellbeing courses and apps, road-tested

Australians are the world’s biggest consumers of health and wellness apps, punching well above our per capita weight in our quest for peak physical and mental condition, according to research ... Read more »

4 Things You Should Do for Your Partner Every Single Day

© Twenty20 Life (that tricky devil) has the tendency to get hectic on us, and our romantic relationships are often the first to suffer. But you don’t have to let ... Read more »

Teens fully vaccinated against COVID-19 are now allowed in cinemas for Phase 4 states and Sarawak

Teens who are fully vaccinated against COVID-19 are finally able to watch movies in cinemas in selected states. Prior to this, only fully vaccinated adults aged 18 years old and ... Read more »

Tokyo Is the Best City for Nightlife, According to Study

© Provided by Esquire Philippines MrQ, an online casino, has just released a study on the best cities for sociable students. As part of the study, the site released an ... Read more »

Layering perfume scares me a bit so I do this instead

© Provided by Evoke.ie In the beauty industry, there is a lot of talk about layering perfume, the art of wearing one scent on top of another to create a ... Read more »

BBC: Safari v Keni je bezohledný masový hon na divoká zvířata a může se vymstít

Nairobi – Poklid keňské přírodní rezervace Maasai Mara, kde se pasou pakoně, na větvích osamělé akácie se shlukují ptáci a poblíž se procházejí zebry, náhle přeruší vysílačka. Řidič terénního auta ... Read more »

Spectacular natural choreography: how the ocean put on a show of blue bioluminescence around False Bay and Hermanus

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved Cape Town beaches lit up in blue with a natural phenomenon called bioluminescence – light from a living organism – on ... Read more »

Dad who watched his toddler get crushed to death talks about his pain

Four years on from a tragic accident a doting father has spoke to Wales Online about his unrelenting heartbreak and fight for justice. Paul Black’s daughter Pearl was just one ... Read more »

Nordstrom's Selling a $20 Kid Made Modern Advent Calendar Kit for Crafty Kids

© Image: Media Punch/IPx; Design: Ashley Britton: SheKnows. For the kiddos that love to craft, Nordstrom has the best gift in store for them. This holiday season, Nordstrom is offering ... Read more »

Sarawak updates interstate travel SOP, mandatory COVID-19 test not required for fully vaccinated travellers

The Sarawak state government has updated its SOP for incoming visitors into the state which will take into effect starting Monday, 18th October 2021. Some requirements that were introduced last ... Read more »

Man puts his wife ‘on a budget' to curb her ‘spending sprees' and people are divided

© Getty Images/iStockphoto Man and women arguing A man has explained how he put his wife on a budget to stop her from spending so much money and people don’t ... Read more »

Un Rayo desatado

© J.J. Guillén (EFE) Sergio Guardiola dispara a puerta en el partido del Rayo Vallecano contra el Elche de la Liga Santander. Acabó el partido y el Rayo se vio ... Read more »

European Union Clinken Dejon Adams overtreft Steve Reich

Twee titanen van de Amerikaanse muziek stonden zaterdag in de schijnwerpers bij NPO Radio 4.’s Middags vierde de NTR Zaterdag Matinee de vijfentachtigste verjaardag van Steve Reich, met twee klassiekers ... Read more »

Food Network star Anne Burrell gets married: 'Luckiest girl in the world'

© Provided by TODAY Food Network star Anne Burrell is a married woman! The 52-year-old chef and co-host of “Worst Cooks in America” wed fiancé Stuart Claxton and spent the ... Read more »

Emotioneel afscheid van een vader die vertrok in'Daddy'

Op het met rook gevulde podium kruipt er een in het wit gehulde figuur (Jinko Adams) uit eenluikje. Hij beweegt in hypnotiserende hiphopdans over de speelvloer en ontfermt zich over ... Read more »

La ménopause : un frein dans la carrière professionnelle, selon une étude britannique

La ménopause obligerait les femmes à quitter leur emploi ou renoncer à des promotions, selon cette étude britannique. © NickyLloyd / Getty images La ménopause obligerait les femmes à quitter ... Read more »

Skincare ingredients you need to count on to take ageing process on a slow ride

Being harsh on your skin by flooding it with 10 products just because you see wrinkles, and less glow isn’t the right thing to do. While there’s no direct ticket ... Read more »

Inside My Wedding: NI couple's beautiful big day in Newcastle

An NI couple have shared an insight into their beautiful wedding day in Newcastle. Q Radio Breakfast Presenter Declan Wilson (28) and wife Kelly (27) got engaged on December 26, ... Read more »

Jethro Watson-Pickering: Army names soldier killed after tank overturns during military training exercise

© Yorkshire Regiment/Facebook Jethro Watson-Pickering was one of the crew members operating an armoured vehicle that flipped over in Wiltshire on Friday – Yorkshire Regiment/Facebook A soldier who was killed ... Read more »

Yhdistelmä, joka on noussut muotiväen suosioon - antaa pienen säväyksen arkilookiin

Neuletakki on tämän vuoden suurin hitti. Neuletakki on vaatekappale, joka toimii monenlaisissa asuissa. Viime aikoina neuletakkilookeja onkin nähty runsaasti muotivaikuttajien Instagram-kuvissa, joissa on ollut nähtävillä myös yksi hauska yksityiskohta. Yhä ... Read more »

Baby Elephant Thanks Forest Official With 'Trunk Hug' After Reuniting With Mother

© Provided by News18 Baby Elephant Thanks Forest Official With ‘Trunk Hug’ After Reuniting With Mother Animals may not know man-made languages but they surely know the language of empathy ... Read more »

Príncipe Carlos presta homenagem ao filho William: "Estou muito orgulhoso"

O filho da rainha Isabel II mostrou a sua admiração nas redes sociais. © Fama Show Apesar de ser bastante reservado, o Príncipe Carlos mostrou a sua admiração pelo filho ... Read more »

O champô natural com três ingredientes que escurece os cabelos brancos

Sim, leu bem! © Shutterstock Sim, leu bem! O cabelo branco é uma consequência inevitável do envelhecimento, porém muitos de nós desejamos manter a cor original dos fios. E se ... Read more »