It's Idaho's first time activating crisis standards of care. Here's what that means

BOISE, Idaho — Idaho’s Department of Health and Welfare this week activated crisis standards of care across the state for the first time as COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations surge.

© Nathan Howard/Getty Images North America/TNS Janice McGeachin speaks during a mask-burning event at the Idaho Statehouse on March 6, 2021, in Boise, Idaho.

It’s a dire situation health officials had been hoping to avoid.

Public officials are continuing to urge people to get vaccinated as a key way to reduce the strain on health care systems and prevent serious illness.

So how exactly does crisis standards of care work, and how could it affect you?

Our reporters answer questions submitted by the community:

—How does Idaho compare against available health care in other states?

Other states facing high numbers of COVID-19 cases are considering rationing care, even if not statewide like Idaho.

The largest hospital in Alaska recently adopted crisis standards, and such Western states as Nevada and New Mexico are expected to ration care in the near future. New Mexico had enacted crisis standards last December, but lifted them once hospitalizations subsided.

Intensive care units across the South are also near 100% capacity in several states, including Texas and Florida, according to data from The New York Times.

However, the Idaho Statesman could not find a state besides Idaho that had implemented crisis standards across all its health systems.

—Will vaccination status be considered when care is prioritized? How will care be prioritized?

Vaccination status is not listed as part of the considerations for prioritizing care. It is also against the law and against medical ethics for Idaho’s health care system to triage patients based on politics or whether people wore a mask.

“The goal of providing care quickly and efficiently must be guided by fairness, equality and compassion,” according to Idaho’s crisis standards of care plan. “As such, (this) is grounded in ethical obligations that include the duty to care, duty to steward resources, distributive and procedural justice, and transparency. Its guiding principle is that all lives have value and that no patients will be discriminated against on the basis of disability, race, color, national origin, age, sex, gender, or exercise of conscience and religion.”

Under the plan, people who have a higher likelihood of survival will be given care before those who are more likely to die.

Should there not be enough of a certain resource, care could be prioritized in the following order:

1. Children up through 17 years old.

2. Pregnant women with a viable pregnancy, at more than 28 weeks of gestation.

3. Adults by age, from younger to older: age 18-40, age 41-60, age 61-75 and 76 and older.

4. Patients who “perform tasks that are vital to the public health response of the crisis at hand, including, but not limited to, those whose work directly supports the provision of acute care to others.”

5. A lottery, or “random allocation,” if there is still a tie after going through the first four priority criteria.

Dr. Steven Nemerson from Saint Alphonsus Health System said Thursday that so far, he doesn’t know of a single patient who has been taken off a life-support therapy so that therapy could be given to another patient with a better prognosis.

“While that has yet to occur,” he said, “if we continue on this path, it will.”

—What is an example of crisis standards of care?

Under crisis standards of care, the focus is on saving as many lives as possible, according to Health and Welfare. So patients who are more likely to survive could be treated first.

According to the standards, patients could be given a priority score based on a number of factors.

For example, if the demand for ventilators is exceeding supply, hospitals could put into place universal “Do Not Resuscitate” orders. That means if an adult patient goes into cardiac arrest, they could “receive NO attempts at resuscitation,” according to Health and Welfare’s strategies for scarce resource situations.

“The likelihood of survival after a cardiac arrest is extremely low for adult patients. As well, resuscitation poses significant risk to health care workers due to aerosolization of body fluids and uses large quantities of scarce resources such as staff time, personal protective equipment, and life-saving medications, with minimal opportunity for benefit.”

—Is there any data on the transmission of the virus in schools? Are schools able to test, quarantine and contact trace?

Many school districts are tracking COVID-19 cases among students and staff. But school districts track their cases in different ways, and the rules for who has to quarantine across districts also vary.

For example, the Boise School District, which mandates masks, this week has reported 125 positive cases among students and staff. In the two previous weeks, the district has reported 93 and 121 cases, respectively. Those case numbers are far higher than the numbers the district reported most weeks last school year. The district is also following strict quarantine guidelines from Central District Health, and has had hundreds of people quarantining each week since school started.

District officials told the Idaho Statesman earlier this month, though, that most of the quarantines for exposures — based on their contact-tracing efforts — were prompted by exposure outside of school, not in the classroom. They said they weren’t seeing spread in the school system in a “major way.”

But other districts are taking different approaches. The Nampa School District, which has a mask-optional policy, isn’t contact tracing. Kathleen Tuck, the district’s spokesperson, told the Statesman earlier this month if it did, it would have to send home “pretty much the whole classroom” when students test positive.

Already, many schools have had to close in the region due to high numbers of students and staff out due to the virus.

Public health officials had warned, given how transmissible the delta variant is, that there could be significantly more spread in schools this year than there was last year. Although younger people are more rarely hospitalized for the virus, they could spread it to friends and family who are more vulnerable and not vaccinated.

It’s difficult to track exactly how much spread is occurring in schools, though, as many districts are not actively contact tracing.

—What is Gov. Brad Little doing in response? What rules have been put in place?

Little issued a statement Thursday saying Idaho had “reached a historic point,” and that the state had taken “many steps” to prevent hospitals from reaching this level of crisis.

However, no new mandates or restrictions have been announced, and none were in place before Thursday’s announcement. Little has announced the state will set up three centers for monoclonal antibody treatment, which have shown to be effective in treating COVID-19.

After President Joe Biden announced last week that businesses with more than 100 employees would have to require vaccines or weekly testing, Little said the state would seek avenues to legally fight the order.

He did call on more Idahoans to choose to get the vaccine, which he called the best defense against COVID-19. He also has taken actions to help with staffing at hospitals, including a National Guard activation.

—Is it safe to still be going to large events, such as football games or festivals?

The short answer: no.

“It is not safe to have those events, but we don’t know that we can change the trajectory,” Dr. Nemerson said. “The best thing would be if people are going to attend those events that they cover their faces and stay separate, but we’ve seen that that doesn’t happen.”

He suggested changing the conversation.

Instead of addressing people he believes won’t change their behaviors, he recommended speaking to those who are “responsible” and want to take steps to protect themselves from COVID-19.

“People can select not to attend those events, even with a mask,” he said, “and people can also select to frequent businesses that practice COVID-safe behaviors.”


Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Trump's new social media platform won't let users criticize the site, according to its terms of service

© Win McNamee/Getty Images Former President Donald Trump. Win McNamee/Getty Images Trump announced plans Wednesday to launch a new social media platform. TRUTH Social was created to “give a voice ... Read more »

Voucher scheme verification emails 'are genuine'

Emails reporting identification issues with the high street voucher scheme are genuine, the Department for the Economy has confirmed. © Getty Images Data given in the initial application is automatically ... Read more »

VALORANT player pulls off ace with Sova's Shock Bolts

We’ve seen some impressive VALORANT aces before without guns. But a recent Sova player managed to pull off something special, taking out the entire enemy team using only Shock Bolts. ... Read more »

Ronaldo insists Man United 'never give up' after goal in comeback win

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Cristiano Ronaldo scored the decisive goal in a sensational Manchester United comeback in the Champions League to send Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s side top ... Read more »

United have to 'grab on to emotion' of Atalanta win, says Ferdinand

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Manchester United must focus on their second-half comeback against Atalanta rather than worry about their woeful opening 45 minutes ahead of this weekend’s ... Read more »

Solskjaer: Ronaldo answered critics with winner in comeback victory

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Cristiano Ronaldo crowned another sensational Manchester United comeback in the Champions League to send Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s side top of Group F. Ronaldo ... Read more »

Apellis (APLS) Gets CHMP Nod for Rare Blood Disorder Drug (Revised)

Apellis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. APLS and its partner Swedish Orphan Biovitrum AB (Sobi) announced that the European Medicines Agency’s (EMA) Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (“CHMP”) has rendered a ... Read more »

Hermès Revenues Jump 31.5% in Q3 as Asia Remains Strong

© Delphine Achard/WWD Click here to read the full article. PARIS – Hermès International said revenues jumped 31.5 percent year-on-year in the third quarter, helped by a “remarkable” performance in ... Read more »

Taliban strike journalists at Kabul women's rights protest

The Taliban struck several journalists to prevent media coverage of a women’s rights protest in Kabul on Thursday.  © BULENT KILIC The Taliban struck several journalists to prevent media coverage ... Read more »

T20 World Cup memories, forgotten goals and indoor mountain biking

1) The first round of the T20 World Cup is currently in session in the United Arab Emirates and Oman. Treat yourself to the official anthem here. What’s the moment ... Read more »

Fans on social media aren't excited by Newcastle's interest in Mesut Ozil

Newcastle United are set for relegation as things stand as they sit 19th in the Premier League table, but the Magpies are now the richest club in Europe after their ... Read more »

Stat Nerd Thursday: Unvervalued players and teams heading into week 7

Subscribe to the Yahoo Fantasy Football Forecast Apple Podcasts • Spotify • Stitcher • Google Podcasts Matt Harmon and Dalton Del Don get together to go over some of their ... Read more »

Ronaldo's shirt grabbed by a pitch invader after United beat Atalanta

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Manchester United stewards were forced to wrestle a pitch invader to the ground after a supporter raced on and tugged on Cristiano Ronaldo‘s ... Read more »

Timberwolves' Anthony Edwards told Rockets' coach to 'call a damn timeout' after hitting back-to-back 3s

© Provided by CBS Sports Anthony Edwards has only just begun his second season in the NBA, but the former No. 1 overall pick has already established himself as one ... Read more »

People share snaps of hilarious frustrating mishaps

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Sometimes it seems like nothing in life is going your way, but these very unlucky people are sure to make you feel much ... Read more »

Evan Engram tuning out boos and trade talk, focused on Giants

© Provided by NBC Sports New York Giants tight end Evan Engram heard boos from the home fans during the team’s loss to the Atlanta Falcons in late September. He ... Read more »

As India Enters 100-Crore Covid Vaccine Club, Survey Finds 61% Ready to Take Third Shot if Available

© Provided by News18 As India Enters 100-Crore Covid Vaccine Club, Survey Finds 61% Ready to Take Third Shot if Available As India achieved the historic milestone of completing 1 ... Read more »

Blues/Golden Knights Recap

First Period Highlights: © Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images William Karlsson got the Golden Knights on the board first in this one. The Knights came in on Jordan Binnington on ... Read more »

Covid Plan B measures ‘set to be rolled out in 20 UK hotspots within days'

SOME parts of England are set have Plan B rules introduced as coronavirus infections continue to rise, it has been claimed. It comes as Health Secretary Sajid Javid last night ... Read more »

NFL and former players reach deal to end race as factor to decide payouts in concussion settlement programme

It follows public outrage over the use of "race-norming" - a practice which assumes black players start with lower cognitive function than white players, which critics said made it difficult for black retired players to qualify for payouts. Read more »

Australia sets $1 million reward for missing four-year-old

Australian authorities on Thursday offered Aus$1 million (US$750,000) for information leading to the discovery of a missing four-year-old girl feared abducted from a remote campsite last weekend. © Provided by ... Read more »

With Virginia governor's race looming, Biden takes to CNN town hall to pitch his agenda to voters

WASHINGTON – President Joe Biden will take center stage in Baltimore Thursday as he looks to sharpen his pitch on his multi-trillion-dollar infrastructure and social spending plans, the centerpiece of his domestic agenda that Democrats ... Read more »

Dodgers' Bats Leave Little Hope for Another Awakening

Los Angeles again trails Atlanta 3–1 in the NLCS. This time, its offense doesn’t look up to the task for a comeback. View the original article to see embedded media. ... Read more »

U.S. Backs Vaccine Mixes; India Hits Billion Doses: Virus Update

(Bloomberg) — U.S. regulators approved the mixing of vaccines as they cleared boosters for the shots made by Moderna Inc. and Johnson & Johnson. Most Read from Bloomberg Google’s Biggest ... Read more »

El Salvador Congress upholds total abortion ban

El Salvador’s Congress voted on Wednesday to uphold the country’s complete abortion ban, ruling against terminations even in exceptional circumstances. © MARVIN RECINOS People march demanding the decriminalization of abortion ... Read more »

Virals: Liverpool target Youri Tielemans 'rejects latest contract offer'

© Michael Regan/Getty Images Sport Leicester City v Wolverhampton Wanderers – Premier League Liverpool were widely expected to sign a midfielder during the summer transfer window in order to suitably ... Read more »

Hina Khan's Latest Post is All About The Importance of Mental Health Over Physical Fitness | Read on

© KS Swati | Lifestyle Staff Hina Khan’s Latest Post is All About The Importance of Mental Health Over Physical Fitness. Picture Credits: Instagram (@realhinakhan) Mental health has gained ... Read more »

Israeli minister sees opportunity at UN climate conference

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel’s new environmental protection minister has set some ambitious goals: She believes she can use her office to play an important role in the global battle against ... Read more »

How To Close Down Your Vegetable Garden for the Winter

We winterize our kitchens and cars, so why not winterize our garden as well? © PaulMaguire/Getty Images The truth is, most of us do it without really thinking about it. ... Read more »

How long is Nick Chubb out? Injury timeline, return date, latest updates for Browns RB

No running backs, big problems for the Browns. Nick Chubb was absent in the Browns’ Week 6 matchup with the Cardinals, after it was revealed the prior Friday that he ... Read more »

'Oh Joe!' Biden surprises Kamala Harris with birthday flowers

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Vice President Kamala Harris accepted flowers from the president and was serenaded by a roomful of staffers as she celebrated her 57th birthday ... Read more »

8 Items to Put in Your Fibromyalgia Winter Care Kit

I have been diagnosed with fibromyalgia for about a year and a half now, but I have been living with it for many years before I received an official diagnosis. ... Read more »

Belgium braces for another surge in COVID-19 cases

1 / 2Virus Outbreak BelgiumFILE – In this Friday, Nov. 6, 2020 file photo, Medical personnel work in the intensive care ward for COVID-19 patients at the MontLegia CHC hospital ... Read more »

Report: Eagles had “recent discussions” with Texans about Deshaun Watson trade

NFL trade rumors are heating up with the November 2 deadline fast approaching. The latest buzz indicates that Deshaun Watson might be headed to the Miami Dolphins. Longtime NFL reporter ... Read more »

What time is the NFL game tonight? TV schedule, channel for Browns vs. Broncos in Week 7

“Thursday Night Football” has started at the same time for the entire 2021 NFL season. That won’t change in Week 7. The Browns and Broncos have the honors of starting ... Read more »

How long is Kareem Hunt out? Injury timeline, return date, latest updates for Browns RB

The Browns will be hunting for running back production on Thursday night. Kareem Hunt, half of Cleveland’s 1-2 punch in the backfield, is out for quite a bit after suffering ... Read more »

Flights cancelled, schools closed as China fights virus outbreak

Authorities in China cancelled hundreds of flights, closed schools and ramped up mass testing on Thursday to try and stamp out a new Covid-19 outbreak linked to a group of ... Read more »

Nearly 200 perish in India, Nepal rains

Nearly 200 people have died in floods and landslides in India and Nepal, officials said Thursday, with whole families buried in their homes and two young girls swept away as ... Read more »

Breast cancer: Four misconceptions about mammograms debunked

© Provided by The South African October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month and going for your annual breast cancer screening is vital. WHAT ARE MAMMOGRAMS AND BREAST SONARS? There are ... Read more »

Virals: Matt Jones posts hilarious GIF in response to transfer claim

Popular Everton podcaster Matt Jones has taken to social media to light-heartedly ridicule reports that Dominic Calvert-Lewin could be leaving the club. © Mike Hewitt/Getty Images Sport Brighton & Hove ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic