It's clearer to India than ever that Quad is no military alliance. Everything's a bit AUKUS

© Provided by The Print

Prime Minister Narendra Modi will undertake his first post-pandemic international trip to the US to meet other leaders of the Quad – US President Joe Biden, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga – on 24 September. But with the Australia-UK-US, or AUKUS, alliance startling the world this weekend, several questions abound. Here are a few:

First, does AUKUS expand the Quad tent of democracies or does it diminish it? Second, since AUKUS is a nuclear submarine-based security alliance focussed on countering China and Quad isn’t – as US Secretary of State Antony Blinken maintained during his recent Delhi visit – is the US likely to concentrate its mind on AUKUS rather than Quad?

Third, is the US need to ally with nations to counter China a manifestation of its decline as a global power? (After all, if the US was so strong, why would it need to partner with others?) Conversely, with AUKUS and Quad leaders meeting in quick succession next week in Washington DC, is the US trying to burnish its credentials as a global power in the wake of its shambolic exit from Afghanistan?

Also read: Quad tent just got bigger with AUKUS. China’s aggressive behaviour will be under watch

French fury

Meanwhile, with France recalling its ambassadors to the US and Australia after Canberra cancelled the $60 billion conventional submarine deal with Paris last week – and French foreign minister Jean Yves le Drian decrying the plot as an exercise in “duplicity, a major breach of trust and contempt”, some are beginning to ask why Paris is throwing such a big global tantrum.

Or, as they might say in Bollywood, France ko itna gussa kyon aata hai. Why does France get so angry?

Certainly, France’s fury against AUKUS has shaken the globe. But of that, in a moment. What is interesting in both the Quad and AUKUS groupings is that except for India, all the other nations have military alliances of one or another sort with the other.

In AUKUS, the US and UK are NATO allies – as was the rejected partner, France – while Australia and the US have a security treaty relationship. In the Quad, like the US and Australia, US and Japan have a security alliance. Only India stands alone.

Certainly, France is believed to be furious that the US pushed Australia to pick one NATO ally (UK) over the other (France). Certainly, the English-speaking world won against the non-English speaking world. Remember that the Five Eyes, the world’s primary intelligence-sharing alliance between the US, UK, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand — which is believed to have given the intelligence regarding security threat to New Zealand that made its cricket team pull out of the Pakistan tour – dates back to the Second World War and is a partnership between the English-speaking democracies. (It is only in recent years that nations like South Korea, Japan, and India are being considered for minor partnerships in this grouping.)

France, arguably, is upset that it has lost out to the Anglosphere – it has reason to be. It fancies itself as a Pacific power, through control over territories like New Caledonia. Britain is certainly trying to climb back on the coat-tails of its more powerful cousin across the Atlantic to return to the Pacific – it lost all pretence of being a truly international player when it gave up Diego Garcia to the US in 1966.

Also read: India bumbled along while China grew its navy. Now, embracing the West is the only option

US-China duel

It’s not clear when AUKUS was thought up – all we know is that the deed was finalised on the margins of the G-7 summit in Cornwall in June. Masterminded by the US, it is the new game in town. The Afghanistan and Iraq wars over the last 20 years have clearly dented US power to go it alone, but AUKUS has demonstrated US ability to mobilise middle powers to mount a serious challenge to Beijing.

In fact, even as it declines, the US has shown that it can both throw cold water on France’s pretensions to be a global power and put Australia on notice about shedding its final hesitations about challenging China – remember that China has been Australia’s largest trading partner over the past decade, accounting for over 32 per cent of Australian exports, despite Australia echoing the US demand in 2020 to investigate the origins of the coronavirus.

Only 10 days ago, the Chinese lobbied the Australian Parliament to recommend its admission into the Trans-Pacific Partnership, citing the runaway success of the China-Australia Free Trade Agreement.

In fact, a decade ago, Australia had put the Quad “on ice,” according to Reuters, because of China’s objections to the Quad’s joint naval exercises.

Today, the Quad is back on track and the US has created a new security alliance. Australia’s turnaround is fair warning that the world is once again dividing itself up, this time with China as the key antagonist.

Also read: Why India could gain ‘major leverage’ as Australia, UK, US join hands to take on China

Quad and India

So, what is the Quad? Let’s first see what it is not. It is not, for example, a nuclear submarine-based alliance, like AUKUS. Officials say the Quad will deal with “non-military determinants” of global security – such as supply chain diversification, climate change, vaccines, and technology among others.

That in itself is impressive. To be part of a global conversation, for example, that seeks to reduce its exposure to China and build alternative supply chains, is an ambitious venture.

Except that the pandemic has been so cruel to India that India’s exposure to Chinese goods has gone up – not come down. The economy may have finally emerged from the demonetisation woods, but key links remain broken because of the pandemic’s fury.

Under the circumstances, India’s participation in the Quad is a hugely significant step – but let us not pretend that it catapults India into the centre of global realpolitik. It doesn’t. India certainly leads the developing world ably, but a yawning gulf of many light years separates it from the big boys. In that world, cutting a deal is par for the course – you win some, you lose some.

Which is why Blinken’s comments to the US Congress last week that the US is in talks with India for a staging post to undertake “over the horizon” strikes inside Afghanistan are interesting.

Was Blinken fudging the truth or did he mean what he said? Having partnered with Pakistan these past few years to deliver the Taliban in Kabul, is Blinken now teasing Pakistan with its sudden interest in India and Afghanistan? Is the US Secretary of State indicating that Biden and Modi could write a new chapter on Afghanistan? Watching this space just became more interesting.

Lastly, France’s anger at AUKUS also holds lessons for India: It is imperative to build your national strength to afford, like Paris, to throw a histrionic fit. The world will take India less seriously if it undercuts its democratic credentials within and refuses to engage with regional economic partnerships like RCEP abroad.

Also, France is likely to sooner than later make up with the US — NATO allies can’t afford to squabble so long and so publicly. Moreover, France knows that it would have done exactly the same if it was offered the opportunity to earn $60 billion so quickly.

That’s why “everyone is naked in the hamam” principle applies so readily to global politics.

As for India, it will welcome an AUKUS-Quad shoe in and will keep her relationship with France in fine fettle — more Rafale fighters are on their way, anyway.

PM Modi’s outing to Washington DC, the first time in a couple of years, is a good opportunity to feel the world’s pulse and the direction in which it is headed.

Jyoti Malhotra is a senior consulting editor at ThePrint. She tweets @jomalhotra. Views are personal.

(Edited by Prashant)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


As a football player, there is no better school than the Ajax academy: Darren Sidoel

For six years Darren Sidoel lived in the moment climbing through the ranks of the famous youth football programme at Ajax. It is only now when he looks back that ... Read more »

Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh Live Score, T20 World Cup: Bangladesh peg Sri Lanka on back foot with quick wickets

© Provided by Firstpost Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh Live Score, T20 World Cup: Bangladesh peg Sri Lanka on back foot with quick wickets 18:30 (IST) DROPPED! FOUR! Liton Das drops ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif's video shows 'hardworking' pair of Akshay Kumar, Rohit Shetty

© IANS Katrina Kaif’s video shows ‘hardworking’ pair of Akshay Kumar, Rohit Shetty Mumbai, Oct 24 (IANS) The promotions of Akshay Kumar and Katrina Kaif-starrer ‘Sooryavanshi’ are in full swing. ... Read more »

Africa tries to end vaccine inequity by replicating its own

CAPE TOWN, South Africa (AP) — In a pair of Cape Town warehouses converted into a maze of airlocked sterile rooms, young scientists are assembling and calibrating the equipment needed ... Read more »

International Olympic Committee to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 50% by 2030

© Provided by WION The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has announced that it will cut its direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions by 50 per cent by 2030, as part ... Read more »

Sports Media World Reacts To Adrian Wojnarowski News

© Provided by The Spun ESPN NBA insider Adrian Wojnarowski on set with Rachel Nichols. Adrian Wojnarowski is typically the one breaking the news. However, this week, a story surfaced ... Read more »

Lahiru Kumara and Liton Das engage in war of words during Bangladesh vs Sri Lanka T20 World Cup clash, WATCH

© Provided by Zee News Sri Lanka pacer Lahiru Kumara and Bangladesh opener Liton Das were involved in a heated verbal exchange during their T20 World Cup 2021 match on ... Read more »

Michael Vaughan PREDICTS winner of high-octane T20 World Cup match

© Provided by Zee News Former England skipper Michael Vaughan feels Pakistan can beat any team when they are playing in UAE but backed India to come out with flying ... Read more »

Injury Report: Warriors' Jonathan Kuminga (strained patellar tendon) cleared for return to practice

© Provided by WarriorsWire Through the first two games of the regular season, the Golden State Warriors have been missing their top draft pick from the 2021 NBA draft. After ... Read more »

US diplomat urges North Korea to halt missile tests, resume talks

The senior U.S. envoy to North Korea, Sung Kim, called on the isolated country to cease missile tests and to return to nuclear negotiations. © Getty US diplomat urges North ... Read more »

Covid news - live: Ministers reject calls for immediate plan B measures amid warnings NHS ‘in terrible place'

© PA Coronavirus – Wed May 27, 2020 LIVE – Updated at 13:30 Shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves said the government should introduce its so-called Plan B to tackle the rising ... Read more »

Drunk police escort vehicle driver threatens public after getting caught

A VIP police escort vehicle driver in Chennai’s Arumbakkam was caught by the alert public on Saturday, October 23, for allegedly being drunk. They stopped him when they saw that ... Read more »

Rishi Sunak admits only a fraction of £7bn transport 'levelling up' cash is new money

Rishi Sunak was forced to admit that only a fraction of his £7billion investment package to level up transport across the country is new money. Ahead of this week’s Budget, ... Read more »

Here's how to get your hands on tickets to this year's Late Late Toy Show

© Provided by It’s that time of year once again where the Late Late Toy Show is fast approaching, and when the latest offering hits our screens on November ... Read more »

Remains of Missing 5-Year-Old Boy Elijah Lewis Likely Found in Abington, Mass., District Attorney Says

Remains found in a wooded area in Abington, Mass., on Saturday are believed to belong to missing 5-year-old Elijah Lewis, according to Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz. © Provided ... Read more »

Manchin to meet with Biden, Schumer in Delaware

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) will meet with President Biden and Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) on Sunday morning in Delaware to discuss the Democrats’ spending bill, a person familiar ... Read more »

Polizei löst illegales Treffen von Autoposern in Dübendorf auf

© Keystone/CHRISTIAN BEUTLER Die Polizei hat in der Nacht auf Sonntag in Dübendorf ZH ein illegales Treffen von Autoposern aus der ganzen Schweiz aufgelöst. Vier Fahrzeuge wurden wegen verbotenen Tunings ... Read more »

Brentford vs Leicester, live! How to watch, stream, TV, odds, prediction

© Provided by NBC Sports Brentford vs Leicester: The Bees and the Foxes are set for what should be a sensational footballing affair at the Brentford Community Stadium on Sunday ... Read more »

Erdogan says Turkey set to banish 10 envoys

Turkish President Tayyip Erodgan on Saturday said he ordered the foreign ministry to expel 10 envoys from Western countries. If carried out, that would mark the deepest diplomatic rift with ... Read more »

Erdogan's Latest International Spat May Deal Fresh Blow to Lira

1 / 2Erdogan’s Latest International Spat May Deal Fresh Blow to Lira (Bloomberg) — Turkey’s latest diplomatic row may have given currency traders another reason to dump the struggling lira. ... Read more »

Part of the family: Why domestic violence victims won't leave unless their pets are safe

Domestic violence affects everyone who resides in a home where it occurs. That includes humans and pets. Ninety-five percent of Americans consider their pets to be part of the family. ... Read more »

Death of 32-year-old inmate at Lansing prison not believed to be COVID-19: Kansas DOC

A 32-year-old man who was imprisoned at the Lansing Correctional Facility has died while in state custody, according to officials with the Kansas Department of Corrections. Lawrence A. Brown, Jr. ... Read more »

Hurricane Rick heads toward Mexico's Pacific coast

MEXICO CITY (AP) — Hurricane Rick headed for Mexico’s southern Pacific coast Sunday and is forecast to reach land by Monday. The U.S. National Hurricane Center said Rick had winds ... Read more »

Rishi Sunak set to raise minimum wage to £10 an hour by next election

PAY could go up to as much as £10 an hour in three years' time as an initial increase to the minimum wage is expected this Wednesday. It's expected to ... Read more »

Deadly blast in Ugandan capital 'seems to be a terrorist act': President Museveni

A deadly blast in Kampala late on Saturday appeared to be an act of terrorism, Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni said on Sunday. He said the explosion in the capital killed ... Read more »

Plan to scrap printed train timetables triggers safety fears

Rail operators are scrapping printed timetables as part of a multi million-pound cost cutting exercise, sparking claims that passengers’ personal safety is being put at risk. © Provided by The ... Read more »

'The Gravedigger's Wife': Somali story wins Africa's top film prize

© ISSOUF SANOGO Aida Benelkadir, a representative for Somali director Khadar Ayderus Ahmed, poses with the Stallion of Yennenga Grand Prize trophy for ‘The Gravedigger’s Wife’ at the 27th Pan-African ... Read more »

Classic ballet 'The Legend of Love' comes to Dubai

© Provided by Khaleej Times Classic ballet ‘The Legend of Love’ comes to Dubai Ballet enthusiasts in the UAE can look forward to a timeless masterpiece by renowned Russian choreographer ... Read more »

Poor countries to be offered extra funding to break Cop26 impasse

Poorer countries are to be offered billions of dollars more in funding in an effort to break the impasse between developed and developing countries at the UN Cop26 climate summit. ... Read more »

Manchester United's Cristiano Ronaldo hints at date of international retirement from Portugal

Manchester United’s Cristiano Ronaldo has claimed that it’s not ‘his time’ to retire from international football. Ronaldo, 36, completed a sensational return to United on deadline day and he’s since ... Read more »

Trending Entertainment News Today: Ishaan Khatter visits rumoured GF Ananya Panday's home with flowers, Shah Rukh Khan's manager gives Aryan Khan's 'medical and educational information' to NCB and more

© Provided by It is time to walk you through the trending entertainment news of the day. Here’s a look at the top trending entertainment news today. Ishaan Khatter ... Read more »

Ankita Konwar urges people to concentrate on love in new video. Watch

Ankita Konwar and Milind Soman are quite active on Instagram. They often share pictures and videos with each other from their vacations and day-to-day life. Their loved-up pictures are extremely ... Read more »

Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021, Today's Match at Sharjah: Saifuddin Strikes to Remove Wanindu Hasaranga

© Provided by News18 Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021, Today’s Match at Sharjah: Saifuddin Strikes to Remove Wanindu Hasaranga Sri Lanka vs Bangladesh Live Cricket ... Read more »

Dozens killed in fighting between Somalia army and former allied group

(Corrects dateline to Oct 24, not Oct 23; adds TV and PIX to story slug) By Abdi Sheikh MOGADISHU (Reuters) – At least 30 people died and over 100 were ... Read more »

Woman, 21, left with huge lips after centipede BITES her after crawling onto face as she slept

A WOMAN ended up with huge lips after a centipede crawled on to her face and bit her on the mouth while she slept. Nataly Galdino, 21, from São Vicente, ... Read more »

Family forced to sleep on sofa with two children for TWO YEARS plead with council to find them bigger home

A COUPLE are at “breaking point” after sleeping on the sofa with their baby and toddler for two years as they plead with the council to find them a bigger ... Read more »

Man traumatised as his house was infested with flies and maggots after neighbour lay dead for weeks

A MAN was left traumatised when his flat became infested with maggots and flies “like a scene from a horror film”- after his neighbour's dead body lay undiscovered for weeks. ... Read more »

10 deals you can't miss on Sunday: $93 memory foam mattress, first Apple Watch S7 deal, more

© Provided by BGR Amazon Deals Early Black Friday sales are now in full swing, but there’s something you need to know. All of the hottest deals we’ve seen so ... Read more »

'Devastated' Alec Baldwin 'cancels upcoming projects' after fatal Rust movie shooting

Alec Baldwin has reportedly called all of his upcoming projects following the fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. The 63 year old Hollywood actor was filming for the upcoming Western ... Read more »

Eight arrested in murder probe after two teenage boys killed in Brentwood

© Stephen Huntley/HVC Police and medics at the scene in Brentwood – Stephen Huntley/HVC Eight people have been arrested on suspicion of murder after the deaths of two teenage boys. ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic