Is It Good Public Policy to Prop Up the Stock Market?

Should policymakers prop up the stock market when it appears to be in danger of crashing down?

Federal Reserve, stock prices, CAPE value, interest rates

PIX1861 / Pixabay – Valuewalk

Q3 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

This comes up in regard to the Federal Reserve all the time. Even Buy-and-Holders get anxious about the stock market when prices reach insanely high levels. But a lowering of interest rates can cause people who don’t want to remain in the stock market to remain in the stock market on grounds that the low returns available on safe asset classes are flat-out unacceptable. Price crashes do lots of economic damage. So an argument can be made that, when members of the Federal Reserve see evidence that stock prices are about to crash, they should do something to prevent that from happening.

Other policymakers face similar pressures. President Biden has a number of reasons for wanting to keep inflation in check. So he could promote anti-inflation measures without even taking into consideration their effect on stock prices. But it is unlikely that that effect would not at least be mentioned when Biden’s advisers were meeting to determine which measures to advance. Stock price crashes are widely viewed as a negative. So a policy that keeps stock prices up while also combating inflation is generally perceived as better than a policy that only combats inflation.

Policymakers Should Not Prop Up The Stock Market

I generally do not go along with this widespread view. The market should be permitted to price stocks properly, which it cannot do if policymakers knowingly promote policies that they believe will keep stock prices up. So, no, policymakers should not prop up the stock market. If anything, at a time when prices are above fair-value levels, policymakers should promote policies that will bring stock prices down to levels closer to their fair value. I can not recall ever hearing a policy advocated on grounds that it will bring stock prices down. I think that’s unfortunate. We should all want stocks to be priced properly. When prices are too high, we should all at least generally favor policies aimed at bringing them down.


It’s not quite that simple.

Today’s CAPE level is 39. The fair-value CAPE level is 17. A government policy that caused stock prices to fall to fair-value levels would wipe out more than half of the value of the stock market. That would cause a dramatic contraction of our economic system. Hundreds of thousands of businesses would go under. Millions of workers would be thrown out of work. Political frictions would be exacerbated. I would love to see a CAPE value of 17. But not that way. If a genie gave me one wish, I would not wish for stock valuations to drop to fair-value levels.

At least not in a rush.

I would indeed like to see stocks priced properly. There are all sorts of benefits that would flow from that. But how we get there matters. If someone learns when she is going 70 miles per hour on the highway that her brakes have failed, she desperately wants the car to stop so that she can get out of it. But there’s a big difference between stopping the car by crashing into something and letting it slow gradually to a stop by not applying any more pressure to the accelerator.

We need to bring stock prices down gradually, not all at once.

Interest Rates And Stock Prices

The only way that I can see to do that is through educational efforts. I was dismayed a few months ago to see an article written by Robert Shiller that argued that, given today’s low interest rates, today’s stock prices are not quite as absurd as they might appear to be when only the CAPE value is considered. The claim is accurate. Low interest rates pressure people not to sell their stocks. So there is a correlation between low interest rates and high stock prices. But a lowering of interest rates is a desperate way to keep stock prices up. I view the lowering of interest rates as a long-term negative for the stock market because there will be a time when prices will fall anyway and a lowering of interest rates will not then be available as an option for stabilizing the market.

I believe that the high stock prices that applied at the last time interest rates were lowered should have been taken into consideration as a reason not to lower them. Had interest rates not been lowered, we might well have seen a significant drop in stock prices by now. That would have diminished the odds that we will see a more dramatic price drop at some future date. Which would be good news all around.

Perhaps the members of the Fed did indeed take that possibility into consideration when they discussed whether to take actions to lower interest rates. But, if they did, it was not widely perceived that that is what they were doing. For such actions to have their desired effect, investors need to know both that such actions are being taken and why they are being taken. It is sound public policy to keep stock prices from getting out of hand\. But most investors do not see things that way today. High stock prices are viewed as good and low stock prices are viewed as bad.

It’s big price drops that are bad. Big price drops are caused by high stock prices. So we all should view high stock prices as bad. Policymakers feel a lot of pressure not to let today’s high stock prices collapse. Their job is to walk a narrow line. They should do everything they can to prevent a devastating crash. The most important thing they can do to achieve that goal is to encourage a gradual drop in prices that takes us to a place where stock prices are at least no longer entirely insane.

Rob’s bio is here.

News Related


5 Simple, Proven Ways to Improve Contract Management

Back-office operations are crucial for keeping your company running smoothly, and adequate management of your business’s contracts will keep your efforts on track, helping your team hit deadlines and improve productivity while ... Read more »

5 Tips to Transform Your Business in the Hybrid-Work Era

Last year, thousands of companies were forced to adopt remote work in the interest of operational continuity and worker safety. The resulting ad hoc models weren’t always pretty or perfect, ... Read more »

The Power of Purpose: How a Mandatory Staff Meeting Brought My Team Closer Than Ever Before

After I announced a mandatory staff meeting for December 17 one year, some members were upset. Getting together on the cusp of the holidays would conflict with some holiday travel plans, ... Read more »

Bob Dylan's Entire Music Catalog Sold for Estimated $200 Million

Sony Music Group has long been an entertainment industry giant that has continued to purchase and gain ownership over major music catalogs. Dave J Hogan | Getty Images Just last ... Read more »

Analysts Predict Elon Musk Will Earn Billions This Year Despite Not Taking Home a Salary From Tesla

If predictions for Tesla are correct, CEO Elon Musk is going to have a really good 2022.  FREDERIC J. BROWN | Getty Images Analysts predict that Tesla will report strong financial ... Read more »

The Top SEO Trends for 2022

A new year is a perfect opportunity to take a close look at your website and make sure your SEO is doing all the work it can be. Best SEO ... Read more »

IMF cuts world growth forecast due to omicron, other woes

The International Monetary Fund is downgrading its forecast for the world economy this year, citing the spread of COVID-19’s omicron variant, higher energy prices, an uptick in inflation and financial ... Read more »

Lofoten: 4.9 billion kroner contract for the operation of hydrogen ferries finalized

The Norwegian Public Roads Administration has signed a contract with Torghatten Nord to operate hydrogen ferries between Bodø and Lofoten. The contract has a value of NOK 4.9 billion. Torghatten ... Read more »

US stocks remain volatile as Federal Reserve meeting kicks off

Many investors are exiting riskier stocks. Getty Images US stocks appear set for another round of extreme volatility in Tuesday trading as investors brace for the Federal Reserve’s guidance on ... Read more »

Why I think this cheap FTSE 250 stock looks set to accelerate higher

Business development to success and FTSE 100 250 350 growth concept. Worldwide, the FTSE 250‘s TI Fluid Systems (LSE: TIFS) is one of the leading players in the automotive industry. ... Read more »

Markets are on a roller coaster ride. Here' what to keep in mind as stocks whiplash

Morsa Images | E+ | Getty Images The U.S. stock market has been on a rollercoaster ride of late. Stocks slumped again on Tuesday after a wild trading session a ... Read more »

4 Ways to Level Up Your CEO Game

When your business is in its infancy, it may seem impossible to attain the success of execs like Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk. But, of course, even these standouts have ... Read more »

Paul McCartney's Handwritten 'Hey Jude' Notes to Be Auctioned as NFT

NFTs have certainly made a splash as of recently, with everything from original artwork, to social media posts to event tickets being sold digitally to respective owners. Dimitrios Kambouris | ... Read more »

SEC chair eyes tougher cyber rules to protect investors against hackers

SEC chairman Gary Gensler testifies before a Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee hearing on Sept. 14, 2021 in Washington.Evelyn Hockstein-Pool/Getty Images Securities and Exchange Commission chairman Gary Gensler ... Read more »

3 investing lessons from the 1929 stock market crash

Tired or stressed businessman sitting on the walkway in panic digital stock market crash financial background As investors pay close attention to what might happen next in stock markets, I ... Read more »

3 U.S. States, D.C. Sue Google for 'Deceptive' Location Tracking

Texas, Indiana, Washington State and the District of Columbia each filed suit against Google in their respective state courts on Monday, alleging that the company has implemented “dark patterns” and deceptive ... Read more »

12 Ways to Boost Your Confidence in 2022

Confidence is one of the most important qualities to have in life. It impacts you on a personal level, professionally and even socially. While it’s easy to assume confident people ... Read more »

What Colorado's Marshall Fire Taught Me About Building Safe and Healthy Homes

As the Marshall Fire, the most destructive fire in Colorado history, tore through Boulder County last month, those of us who are homebuilders in the area watched anxiously to see ... Read more »

4 Ways to Motivate Your Startup Team and Get Major Results

You’ve got smart, ambitious employees, clear project goals and great perks, but something in your company isn’t quite right. Maybe the startup culture you envisioned is fading, or never really kicked ... Read more »

European stocks rebound, Wall Street sinks as Fed meets

Representative Image Wall Street stocks sank at the start of trading on Tuesday as the Federal Reserve began a two-day monetary policy meeting, while European stocks rebounded. The Dow shed 1.0 ... Read more »

What's next for the IAG share price in 2022?

Aircraft wind on the sunrise sky background. Might we be reaching the Covid end-game sooner than expected? That should be good news for travel companies like International Consolidated Airlines (LSE: ... Read more »

Wall Street heads lower as Fed, Ukraine capture investor attention

U.S. stocks continued their downward trend on Tuesday, opening sharply lower as safe havens gained ground amid investor nerves about tensions between Russia and the West and the prospect of ... Read more »

This Game-Changing Investment App Will Help You Build Long-Term Wealth and Satisfy Your 'Voyeuristic' Desire to See Where Other People Put Their Money

Women are better investors than men, a 2021 Fidelity study found. Yet some estimates suggest that as few as 26% of women have invested in the stock market, a staggering ... Read more »

Here are options if you aren't eligible for Navient's student loan forgiveness settlement

For years, many student loan borrowers have suffered under the weight of excessive debt. Some 66,000 borrowers finally got relief when the recent Navient settlement erased their balances. (Here's how ... Read more »

US digital currency is ‘inevitable,' Bank of America says

Analysts at Bank of America have said that it is inevitable that the United States will establish a national digital bank. Budrul Chukrut/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images The United States ... Read more »

IMF says UK should consider 'well-targeted' action on energy prices

IMF Chief Economist Gita Gopinath speaks in her office during the Spring Meetings of the World Bank Group and IMF in Washington (Reuters) – Britain should consider more support for ... Read more »

Is DatChat Stock a Buy After it Sent a Letter of Intent to Buy Avila Security?

Communications software company DatChat (DATS) made its stock market debut on Aug. 13, 2021 and has garnered significant investor attention in the wake of a letter of intent it sent ... Read more »

Vajro Secures $8.5 Million In Series A

Vajro, one of the fastest growing automated mobile app builders in the world, has raised $8.5 million in Series A round. Company handle Vajro enables e-commerce store owners and service ... Read more »

General Electric (GE) Q4 Earnings and Revenues Miss Estimates

General Electric (GE) came out with quarterly earnings of $0.82 per share, missing the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $0.83 per share. This compares to earnings of $0.64 per share a ... Read more »

Logitech (LOGI) Tops Q3 Earnings Estimates, Raises Sales View

Logitech LOGI on Monday reported better-than-expected third-quarter fiscal 2022 results. The company’s third-quarter non-GAAP earnings of $1.55 per share surpassed the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $1.31. However, the bottom line ... Read more »

A. O. Smith (AOS) to Report Q4 Earnings: What's in the Cards?

A. O. Smith Corporation AOS is scheduled to report fourth-quarter 2021 results on Jan 27, before market open.The company delivered an earnings surprise of 16.82%, on average, in the trailing ... Read more »

Is ResMed a Buy Under $250?

Currently trading at less than $250, ResMed Inc. (RMD) exhibited solid fundamental performance in its last reported quarter based on its strong sales growth across its product portfolio. So, given ... Read more »

Grab These 3 Real Estate Mutual Funds for Sparkling Returns

Mutual funds are the cheapest and most convenient option for investors looking to park their money in the real estate sector. This category of funds offers solid protection against inflation. ... Read more »

Your Answer to This Crucial Question Will Make or Break Your Business's Growth

Do you want to be the Queen or do you want to be the Bank? In other words, as a business owner, do you want to have control or do ... Read more »

This Is Why Chevron (CVX) is Set for Strong Q4 Earnings

Chevron Corporation CVX is set to release fourth-quarter results before the opening bell on Jan 28. The current Zacks Consensus Estimate for the to-be-reported quarter is a profit of $3.07 ... Read more »

3 Stocks that Are Thriving in an Inflationary Environment

Inflation is one of the biggest threats facing the economy. One profitable strategy during this period of high inflation is to focus on stocks that have pricing power, as these ... Read more »

Explore These 5 Momentum Stocks Using Driehaus Strategy

Investors who tend to take higher risks can think of investing in momentum stocks to boost their gains. In this respect, the Driehaus strategy can be used to choose the ... Read more »

3M (MMM) Tops Q4 Earnings and Revenue Estimates

3M (MMM) came out with quarterly earnings of $2.31 per share, beating the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $2.03 per share. This compares to earnings of $2.38 per share a year ... Read more »

Annuities vs. Mutual Funds: Which One is Best for Retirement?

Deciding how to save for retirement is a tough choice. There are so many different ways to set your money aside and make it grow over the years to have ... Read more »

Is State Street a Buy Under $100?

State Street (STT) reported better-than-expected top- and bottom-line results in its most recent quarter. But the stock plunged in price after the company announced the planned retirement of the CEO ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic