Is clean eating right for you? It’s good for fat loss, muscle building and improving your mental health – just don’t take it too far

now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Cassie Jullienne first heard the term “clean eating” about four years ago, when her husband went on the paleo diet. She adapted that way of eating to suit her lifestyle and nutrition needs, eliminating processed foods along the way.

These days, her meals typically consist of a variety of proteins, vegetables, fruit, nuts and grains, in as close to their natural state as possible.

Eating “clean” has been central to helping Jullienne stay in shape. Two years ago, she started training at the Athletic Club in Hong Kong. Her fitness trainer, Ivan Corsi, was aware of her diet and advised her to eat more lean proteins to help her develop and strengthen her muscles.


It paid off, with the 50-year-old, American-born mum-of-three now enjoying a strong, lean physique.

now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Cassie Jullienne typically eats a variety of proteins, vegetables, fruit, nuts and grains, in as close to their natural state as possible. Photo: Edmond So

There’s nothing gimmicky about clean eating. Someone who eats clean avoids foods that are refined and processed and that contain certain preservatives and additives. They may also avoid foods treated with hormones, antibiotics and pesticides or choose not to eat confectionery. Their overall goal is to eat whole, natural foods, such as lean proteins, whole grains, healthy fats, vegetables and fruit.

This way of eating is popular with people who have specific health, fitness or training goals. Corsi says the diet can have a positive impact on both fat loss and muscle building, and improve mental health at the same time.


now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Ivan Corsi says clean eating can have a positive impact on fat loss, muscle building and mental health. Photo: Athletic Club

However, while there’s no disputing that consuming whole, natural foods is good for you, some people can take the diet too far when they start becoming too picky about what goes on their plate.

“It’s actually not that difficult to be picky, especially when your career is tied to how fit you are or how your body looks, or when the media is encouraging you to be strict about what you eat,” says Gabrielle Tuscher, a dietitian, psychologist and certified eating-disorder specialist based in Hong Kong.

“Although you may begin a diet with the simple intention of improving your health, this focus and pickiness can become extreme, with your life revolving around what you can and cannot eat, and rules about meals becoming more structured. That, in turn, places such a high value on controlling your food intake – and often telling others how to control theirs – that your self-worth gets tied to what you do or don’t put into your body.

“You may even feel guilty if you eat something that you deem ‘unclean’ or ‘imperfect’ – something with additives, for example.”

This fixation on “righteous eating” is known as orthorexia nervosa. Unlike people with anorexia or bulimia, orthorexia sufferers are seldom focused on losing weight and are more concerned about the quality, rather than quantity, of their food. They’re also fixated on the benefits of healthy eating.


Tuscher adds that vegetarianism or veganism is sometimes a cover for clean eating – the individual starts by cutting out meat, seafood, eggs and dairy products, their eating habits becoming more restrictive over time.

Since orthorexia is not a diagnostic eating disorder, it’s hard to tell exactly how many people have it, or whether it’s a stand-alone eating disorder, an existing type of eating disorder like anorexia, or a form of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Gabrielle Tuscher is a dietitian, psychologist and certified eating disorder specialist. Photo: Gabrielle Tuscher

Tuscher says studies have found that many people with orthorexia also have OCD. Other risk factors for orthorexia include tendencies towards perfectionism, high anxiety and a need for control.

“As with other eating disorders, the eating behaviour involved – ‘healthy’ or ‘clean’ eating in this case – is used to cope with negative thoughts and feelings or to feel in control,” she says. “Someone using food in this way may feel anxious or guilty if they eat something unhealthy or ‘unclean’.”

now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Some people can take clean eating too far when they start becoming too picky about what goes on their plate. Photo: Shutterstock

Orthorexia can also cause physical issues, because someone’s beliefs about what’s healthy may lead to them to omit essential nutrients or even entire food groups. Eventually, Tuscher says, the diet becomes so restrictive and the rules so complex within the disorder that sufferers become malnourished or emaciated, developing the traits of anorexia.

“If someone has symptoms of orthorexia they may be diagnosed with anorexia if they display those symptoms, too,” Tuscher says. “Eating disorders that can’t be diagnosed as anorexia, bulimia or binge eating disorder might be diagnosed as ‘other specified feeding or eating disorder’ or Osfed.”

All eating disorders are serious mental illnesses and should be treated as soon as possible to give the sufferer the best chance of recovery. Someone who displays symptoms of orthorexia may not be officially diagnosed with the condition, but an eating disorder specialist will give them psychological treatment and nutrition rehabilitation tailored to their needs.

now enjoying a strong, lean physique, antibiotics, whole grains, mental health, orthorexia nervosa, veganism, anorexia, muscle building

Jullienne considers herself a balanced person, not taking anything in her life to extremes or following anything too strictly. Photo: Edmond So

How do you embark on a healthy eating plan that is easy to stick to, nourishes your body and mind, delivers the results you want, such as weight loss, weight maintenance or muscle building, and doesn’t require you to take your eating habits to the extreme?

Tuscher recommends asking a few questions first. Why are you taking this approach and are you doing it for the right reasons? Does your new eating plan allow for flexibility and fun? Can you maintain it over the long term without sacrificing your health in the process? Can you respect others’ choices even when they don’t line up with yours?

“Eating clean may not always be the best approach for one’s health,” she points out. “Balanced eating means allowing for all foods, no matter where they come from. If eating crisps [potato chips] fills you with guilt or shame then you need to question the emotion and not the food itself.”

Corsi understands that some of his clients may have non-negotiable foods – that is, foods they cannot give up – so he helps them manage their intake of these foods and looks at where else they may be able to cut back. He believes that following a clean diet is about making compromises so that you can incorporate this way of eating into your lifestyle for the long term.

Although Jullienne’s diet is mostly made up of whole, nutrient-dense foods, she considers herself a balanced person, not taking anything in her life to extremes or following anything too strictly.

A typical meal may consist of baked chicken, steamed broccoli and a salad. If she needs more carbohydrates – because she has a tennis match the next day or has just finished playing tennis – she may have a quinoa salad with sweet potatoes or some extra fruit. On weekends, she enjoys a glass of wine with a meal, and may have a blueberry muffin after a tennis game.

If she’s hungry between meals, she’ll snack on carrots and hummus. Twice monthly or so, she orders a cheeseburger and fries or a chicken burger from a fast-food restaurant.

“I enjoy eating healthily but I also like to indulge myself,” she says. “I don’t want to feel deprived of the foods I love because I know this can lead to cravings or poor eating decisions down the road.

“Following this philosophy, coupled with living an active lifestyle, makes me feel good. When I feel good, I find that I make better food choices overall.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

China credit slowdown ‘happening faster than expected’ even as bank loans rose unexpectedly in May

China’s new bank loans unexpectedly rose in May from the previous month but broader credit growth continued to slow, as the central bank seeks to contain rising debt in the world’s second-largest economy.… Read more »

Jill Biden’s ‘love’ jacket on trip to Britain with US President Joe Biden stands in stark contrast to former first lady Melania Trump’s message of not caring

Jill Biden is sending a sartorial message of “love” as she accompanies her husband President Joe Biden overseas. The first lady wore a black jacket with the word “love” outlined on the back… Read more »

Singapore’s GIC injects USD 70 million into Hong Kong-listed digital asset platform BC Group

Hong Kong-listed BC Group, the operator behind crypto trading platform OSL, said on Friday that it notched HKD 543 million (USD 70 million) from Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund GIC via a private placement.… Read more »

How Singapore’s restaurants are weathering the Covid-19 storm, some better than others

Last month Mauro Colagreco arrived in Singapore ready to roll up his sleeves for a three-month residency at Mandala Club. Colagreco is chef of the three-Michelin-star Mirazur in Menton, France, and the stint… Read more »

Bitcoin trading volume and exchange fees dive amid Beijing’s ongoing crackdown in the name of financial stability

Bitcoin trading volumes are continuing to plummet in response to pressures from a cryptocurrency crackdown in China, the location of most of the world’s bitcoin mining capacity, amid a bearish market for the… Read more »

Battlefield and Madden NFL publisher EA says source code was stolen, as US Senate announces probe into recent cyberattacks

Electronic Arts Inc is investigating a recent data breach, where some of its game source code and related tools were stolen, the video game publisher said on Thursday, becoming the latest victim of… Read more »

‘Run to the moon’ to raise mental health awareness, and funds for charity, offers Hongkongers big prizes

Hongkonger Roger Chan looks fresh and energised as he bounds into the foyer of Soho House in Sheung Wan, on Hong Kong Island. It’s hard to believe that earlier in the day he… Read more »

K-drama review: Sell Your Haunted House – exorcism drama ends with emotional finale

This article contains spoilers. 3.5/5 stars Throughout its 16-episode run, the real-estate-themed exorcism drama Sell Your Haunted House delighted viewers with a series of compelling cases. Each featured daring exorcists Hong Ji-a (Jang… Read more »

Bring back Tasty Toobs: Iconic snack food to return to supermarket shelves

Iconic snack food Tasty Toobs are returning to supermarket shelves. In news certain to brighten the day of the thousands of people subscribed to ‘Bring Back Toobs’ groups throughout the internet, the manufacturer… Read more »

Eateries scramble to adjust reservations, cancel supply orders, with dining in set to resume only from June 21

Cantonese restaurant Yan at the National Gallery had received 30 reservations for dine-in next week. SINGAPORE – Food and beverage (F&B) operators scrambled to reorganise reservations and cancel orders from suppliers, after the… Read more »

[Around the Hotels] Promotions and Packages

Sheraton Grand Incheon Hotel celebrates World Environment DaySheraton Grand Incheon Hotel in Songdo has partnered with social venture Tree Planet to raise awareness of environmental protection. “Green Project” will see the hotel plant… Read more »

Coles trials ‘bring your own container’ scheme to slash plastic waste

Coles is trialling a ‘bring your own container’ system at an inner-city Melbourne store in a bid to reduce plastic use. The test at the Coles Local store in Fitzroy will apply to… Read more »

Belmont seafood restaurant’s western rock lobster dishes win over readers

THE WA restaurants serving our favourite western rock lobster dishes have been revealed, with the narrowest of margins separating the venues we’re most cray-cray about. The Cray Seafood & Grill Restaurant in Belmont… Read more »

All staff at Four Leaves bakery in Ion Orchard quarantined after Covid-19 case found; outlet closed temporarily

The Four Leaves outlet in Ion Orchard on June 9, 2021. SINGAPORE – All staff at the Four Leaves outlet in Ion Orchard have been quarantined, and the outlet has been closed temporarily,… Read more »

Berry tasty! How to make Flaky Berry Pie Squares — a gluten-free, vegan version of a childhood fave

If the sight of these sweet treats reminds you of a favourite snack from your childhood, then this recipe is for you. Consider this from-scratch recipe a grown-up version. These Flaky Berry Pie… Read more »

NSW government’s Dine and Discover voucher scheme extended for a month

The NSW government is set to extend its Dine and Discovery scheme after learning thousands of vouchers had gone unclaimed just weeks before they were due to expire. The vouchers are accessible through… Read more »

All about mangos: How to choose, eat and cook with this succulent fruit

If you're not already familiar with the names Badami, Chaunsa, Julie, Sindhri, and Alphonso, it's time to get acquainted. With mango season in full swing in the warmer parts of the world, we'll… Read more »

Food manufacturing group OTS Holdings launches IPO for Catalist listing

(From left) Managing director Ong Bee Chip, executive director Ong Chew Yong, sales director of Golden Bridge and Ellaziq Singapore Ong Bee Song. SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – Food manufacturing group and brand… Read more »

Singtel-owned HungryGoWhere F&B portal to cease operations after 15 years

F&B portal Hungry Go Where said it would be closing on July 11, 2021. SINGAPORE – Food and beverage (F&B) portal HungryGoWhere will cease operations on July 11, the Singtel-owned subsidiary said on… Read more »

Rome gets its first pizza vending machine, but will Romans bite?

Ms Fabrizia Pugliese collects her order at the first automatic pizza vending machine in Rome on May 6, 2021. ROME (NYTIMES) – Romans eat pizza all the time. They have pizza a taglio,… Read more »

Kitchen scraps composting device costly to run, ‘one of the poorest choices’ eco-conscious could make: Choice

A Breville kitchen appliance that promises an easy way to compost food scraps has been declared “one of the most illogical” ever tested by consumer advocacy group Choice. The $499 FoodCycler pulverises and… Read more »

Hearty, meat-free beetroot soup

For a hearty meat-free soup, try making beetroot soup. Beetroot is the star of this medley of vegetables. It has vitamins A and C, potassium and folate, but the red hue of the… Read more »

Getting onto food delivery platforms eats into already-thin profit margins, say hawkers

The commission cost can be about 30 per cent of a total food order. SINGAPORE – Food delivery platforms may not be the easy answer to solve the current woes faced by hawkers… Read more »

Tar Pau Nation: Nonya bentos for one

Each bento comprises rice and three dishes comprising a main, tahu goreng and a vegetable. SINGAPORE – I love Peranakan food, but many of my favourite Nonya restaurants do not have delivery menus… Read more »

MasterChef Australia 2021: Josh Niland creates entree, main and dessert with one fish

Lamingtons coated in fish scales are on the MasterChef dessert menu this Sunday night as seafood guru Josh Niland shows contestants how to make the most out of one fish. The St Peter… Read more »

Sydney Eat Street: Sydney Solstice festival food and drink events

From June 8-20, the new Sydney Solstice festival will light up the city and its surrounding suburbs, with a focus on food and entertainment. Take a tour of Sydney’s best eateries right here… Read more »

Korea publishes book on kimchi amid Chinese claims over dish

Kimchi masters who have received the Presidential Award present their kimchi. (Yonhap) A national promotional agency has published a book on kimchi and how it is perceived around the world amid a continued cultural… Read more »

As comfort foods go, Chinese congee has no equal. It is the food of love, health, home, and the number one mood lifter

Just the other day, some friends and I were discussing which country has the best comfort food. We couldn’t decide on a dish or a country, but we all agreed that each culture… Read more »

What makes chocolates at bedtime so enticing and why some hotels are going a step further

Supposedly it was Hollywood hunk Cary Grant who started it all. Some time in the early 1950s the Anglo-American actor arranged a rendezvous with a woman in a suite at the Mayfair Hotel… Read more »

McDonald’s BTS Meal with special sauces delights Hong Kong fans of the K-pop superstars, as it has those around the world

Hongkongers are lovin’ it – the BTS Meal, that is. The collaboration between McDonald’s and the K-pop superstars, launched in the city on June 3, is the company’s latest celebrity-themed combo meal. The… Read more »

The Victorian lockdown dining guide you never wanted

Make Out Meals delivers meal kits where you can cook recipes from your favourite restaurants. Photo: Sammy Green  We may be intimate partners with lockdown by now, but even a long break hasn’t… Read more »

10 of Australia's best restaurants with views

The Stokehouse in St Kilda. Photo: Supplied From kangaroos to beachside views, here are some of the best tables, and tableaux, around Australia. Arc Dining, Brisbane, QLD Brisbane-born young gun Alanna Sapwell moved back… Read more »

How to win at winter: Cooking tips and tricks for the cooler months

One-tray wonder: Neil Perry’s braised chicken with lemon, oregano and olives. Photo: William Meppem How to make the perfect pumpkin soup Winter is the best time of the year for cooking, and for gathering around our… Read more »

How to make the perfect pumpkin soup

Roast pumpkin soup with chickpeas and merguez sausage. Photo: William Meppem Roast pumpkin soup with chickpeas Warm, velvety and simple to make, pumpkin soup is your cold-weather friend. And by adding chickpeas and… Read more »

Wine life: Is Australia looking at another wine glut?

Will Australia experience another wine glut this year? Photo: Illustration: Simon Letch News straight from the grapevine. Wine is coming Remember the last time we had a wine glut in Australia? Remember the… Read more »

Why spiced rum is hot right now

The real heat this winter is brought to you by botanical-infused spiced rum. Photo: iStock Raising the temperature really is rum’s game. If the tropical vibes don’t thaw your chill, the sugarcane spirit… Read more »

4 gastropubs in Hong Kong for superior bar food, creative cocktails and a friendly neighbourhood vibe

“A bar is not a good bar unless it serves good food,” proclaims John Nugent. It’s a bold statement, given that many terrific bars focus on drinks, but one that speakeasy-style The Diplomat… Read more »

The Melbourne restaurants helping casual workers with free waffles, tacos and French onion soup

Elisa Mariani from Mayday Cafe in Richmond is giving away free waffles for stood-down workers. Photo: Joe Armao When Elisa Mariani and her team at Richmond’s Mayday Cafe heard about Melbourne’s lockdown extension… Read more »

[Around the Hotels] Promotion and Packages

Paradise Hotel Busan offers ‘Early Sumcance’ packageThe Paradise Hotel Busan in the city’s celebrated Haeundae-gu is offering the “Early Sumcance” package for guests to enjoy the early summer temperatures. With the package, guests… Read more »

Quarantine meals in Hong Kong hotels: why I’m worried what I’ll eat, and bookmarking food delivery services I can call on

What comes to mind when you hear the phrase “me time”? A nice day at the spa being pampered? Taking a day off work to do exactly what you want to do when… Read more »

Lune Croissanterie's new cruller-slinging sibling Moon lands in Fitzroy

Moon in Fitzroy is selling crullers, like the love child of a canele and a doughnut. Photo: Jake Roden Pastry perfectionist Kate Reid has opened Moon, just 250 metres from her Lune Croissanterie… Read more »

DIY pizza taste test: What's the best supermarket base, sauce and mozzarella?

What are the best supermarket products for your next pizza party? Photo: James Brickwood Whether it’s a Friday night quick-fix or a weekend tomato party, making your own pizza is never not fun.… Read more »

How to make Sichuan-style soft bean curd with century egg - cooling and delicious

This vegetarian dish of soft bean curd with century egg and Sichuan spicy sauce is a light and cooling main course. I love it because it has a lot of flavours and textures:… Read more »

Ten reasons to visit Margaret River, Western Australia

West Australian Gourmet Escape is an extended long weekend of beach barbecues, dinners and tastings. Photo: Ord Photo One of Australia’s great eating and drinking destinations is more compelling than ever. How long… Read more »

The Chinese and Japanese extra-virgin olive oil producers beating Italians and Spanish at their own game

Top-quality extra-virgin olive oil (EVOO) evokes images of sunny Mediterranean countries such as Spain, Greece and Italy – places where olive trees have been grown for millennia for their precious essence. However, thanks… Read more »

Most eel eaten in Hong Kong sushi restaurants is from endangered species, study finds

Sushi restaurants are popular in Hong Kong, a city known for its vast food and beverage scene. But many diners may not realise they might be consuming an endangered species when they eat… Read more »

Eating bugs, anyone? With fried cicada sushi roll, Hong Kong-born chef in US promotes sustainable food and farming

After 17 years underground, swarms of cicadas are emerging across the eastern United States – and for one Washington chef, the rare bug invasion was his cue for a cookout, with a side… Read more »

‘Like being a football coach’: Four Seasons Tokyo hotel chef Daniel Calvert on running the kitchens for two restaurants

Daniel Calvert, formerly head chef at Belon, misses the food in Hong Kong. No, he corrects himself, he misses everything about the city. Still, the Briton (who left the neo-Parisian restaurant in August)… Read more »

The secret’s out about these off-the-menu dishes at three Hong Kong restaurants thanks to social media

When a chef gets to know a restaurant’s regular patrons, there is some leeway to cook them special, off-the-menu dishes made with seasonal ingredients or ones that have just been delivered, or to… Read more »

Croissant or toast? Famed pastry chef and cronut inventor combines both ahead of new store opening

French celebrity pastry chef Dominique Ansel misses Hong Kong terribly and would like, as soon as it’s safe to travel, to come back to visit the city. “I miss the team and I… Read more »