Iran is considering its next moves in the Afghan war-without-end

#Afghanistan, #Afghanistan Iran, #Geopolitics, #Praveen Swami, #Taliban, #Taliban resurgence, #world, stern message, evictions of Hazara, pointed out

Taliban fighters in Kabul. (AP Photo/Rahmat Gul)

Eight months before the Islamic Emirate’s flag flew over Kabul, a small convoy of jeeps, stuffed with assault rifles and bundles of dollars, headed across the parched earth of the Dasht-e Margo, Desert of Death. The Taliban were waiting: the consignment, despatched by Iran’s intelligence services to the militia of Allahuddin Khan had been betrayed. The Taliban pushed forward troops and artillery to the border, and sent a stern message to Tehran: “we are fully prepared to go inside Iran and fight”.

The first blows in Tehran’s long, murderous secret war to overthrow the Taliban—a war it had long sought to avoid—had been exchanged.

A month after the rise of the second Islamic Emirate, Tehran’s early triumphalism has given way to apprehension. Iran’s new president, Ibrahim Raisi, had cheered the United States’ “military defeat and withdrawal”; now, with America out, the influential Shi’a cleric Grand Ayatollah Safi Golpaygani, has cautioned against “trusting a militia with a record of malice and murder”, while former president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has warned of the Taliban’s expansionist ambitions.

Tehran might have secured the eviction of its superpower adversary from Afghanistan—only to discover that in this case, victory holds out the dangers of defeat. The dilemma Iran now confronts, history shows, is disturbingly familiar.

Iran’s growing pessimism isn’t hard to understand. Large-scale evictions of Hazara—a constituency long cultivated by Tehran—have been reported, allegedly by Taliban commanders with links to Kuchi nomads who have long eyed these lands. Ethnic Hazaras, and Tajiks in the Panjsher valley, have also been subjected to large-scale killings. Taliban leaders simply ignored Iran’s demands to end their assault on Panjsher.

In spite of Tehran’s aid to the Taliban insurgency, moreover, there are no signs that the Taliban are willing to consider a power-sharing deal that would give Iran’s clients in Afghanistan a share of power. Even Taliban  commanders considered close to Iran, like Zakir Qayyum, have been given only low-grade ministerial offices.

There’s no sign, either, that the Taliban is severing its links with jihadists hostile to Iran and the wider Shi’a world, like al-Qaeda.

When the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan in 1979, Iran was occupied on its west. Egged on by the United States and Saudi Arabia, Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein had attacked Iran in 1980. An Iranian counter-offensive evicted Iraqi troops from its territory by 1982. Instead of using the opportunity to make terms with Husain, though, the clerics who led Iran dragged the country into six more years of war.

Even in the midst of this crisis, though, Iran began crafting a response. “The most revealing aspect of Iran’s Afghan policy was not what Iran did” the scholar Mohsen Milani has perceptively pointed out, “ but what Iran did not do”.

Athough it was strongly critical of the Soviet intervention, Iran chose to stay away from the United States-Saudi axis funding the mujahideen groups arrayed against the Soviet Union. In spite of his ideological hostility to Soviet communism, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, Iran’s supreme ruler, saw Saudi-funded Islamism—“America’s Islam”, he derisively called it—as a fundamental threat.

In response, Tehran reached out to historically-oppressed communities like the Hazaras and Qizilbash, providing the finance and military resources which allowed them to coalesce into a disciplined and cohesive force by 1987.

This card, Tehran played adroitly. Iran’s decision to remain away from the anti-Soviet axis in Afghanistan was reciprocated by Moscow, which gave little support for Tudeh party communists fighting against the regime in Tehran. The Soviets also limited arms supplies to Iraq, and maintained a light footprint in the Hazarat region of Afghanistan, the stronghold of the country’s Shi’a communities.

Iran appeared well-poised to dominate Afghanistan’s political life in April, 1992, when ethnic-Tajik leader Ahmad Shah Masud, along with the ethnic Uzbek Abdul Rashid Dostum, formed an alliance with several Shi’a groups to take power in Kabul. Ethnic strains, combined with communal Shi’a-Sunni strains and warlordism, soon led this alliance to fall apart, though.

From at least 1994, the contours of the challenge to Iranian influence began to unfold. That year, terrorists bombed the shrine of Imam Reza in Meshad, a key centre of the Shi’a faith; twenty-six people were killed. Although Iran officially blamed the opposition Mujahideen-e-Khalq for the attack, there was reason—even at the time—to suspect it was carried out by al-Qaeda.

Even worse, from Iran’s point of view, the Taliban emerged to sweep aside the coalition it had crafted in Kabul. In 1995, the Iran-backed Hizb-e Wahadat leader  Abdul Ali Mazari, under siege from Masud’s armies, struck a deal with the Taliban. The deal ended badly—Mazari was, by some possibly apocryphal accounts, flung out alive from a helicopter after being tortured—but the Taliban ascendance proved unstoppable. The warlord Ismail Khan surrendered to the Taliban—as he did last month—and Herat fell.

Islamabad—with the quiet backing of the United States and Saudi Arabia—threw their weight behind the Taliban. The strategic reasoning for American support wasn’t hard to understand: even if the Taliban harboured al-Qaeda, it stood for the eviction of Iran and Russia from the region. Zalmay Khalilzad, later the United States’ special representative on Afghanistan, admitted in 1996 that there were “common interests between the United States and the Taliban”.

Following a crucial battle in 1997, the capital of the Iran-backed Northern Alliance, Mazar-e-Sharif, finally fell.  Ethnic Hazara, Tajik, and Uzbek civilians were massacred. Eight Iranian diplomats were also kidnapped, and later murdered, by the Taliban.

Iran responded by massing over 200,000 troops on on its eastern borders, and lashed out at both the Taliban and Afghanistan. The country’s top leadership, though, saw little profit in intervention.  Iran’s top Ayatollahs, Ali Khameini and Hashemi Rafsanjani, backed president Muhammad Khatami’s decision not to go to war. “Afghanistan is like a swamp”, Rafsanjani is said to have warned, “anyone can fall into it, but a few can get out of it safely and undamaged”.

The lesson for the Taliban was simple: Iran’s threats were, ultimately, empty. Through the brief life of the first Islamic Emirate, until 9/11, it pursued resolutely anti-Iran policies, even blocking the waters of the Helmand river.

Following 9/11, Iran cooperated with the United States’ war in Afghanistan, aiding the campaign against al-Qaeda’s leadership. Iran also sought, through Swiss diplomats, to craft a grand bargain, which would trade-off long-term counter-terrorism and geopolitical cooperation in return for an end to United States sanctions, imposed in 1979. The government of President George Bush, though, designated Iran part of an “axis of evil”. Fearing its regime would be targeted for annihilation, Iran responded by slowly escalating support for the Taliban.

Tehran understands the dangers ahead. Islamist terror groups like al-Qaeda and the Islamic State, nested under the Taliban’s wing, have long been active in Sistan-Baluchistan province, operating from across the Afghan and Pakistan border. In Iraq and Syria, moreover, Iran found itself forced into fighting gruelling anti-terror campaigns against the Islamic State and al-Qaeda. For Tehran, these forces constitute an irreducible existential threat.

Iran, moreover, has long faced the consequences of state collapse in Afghanistan: massive refugee flows, and a tidal wave of heroin which has claimed the lives of tens of thousands of young people in the country.

To act, however, would come with its own consequences. Iran is better positioned to fight an anti-terrorist campaign than it was during the first Islamic Emirate—its Fatemiyoun and Zainabiyoun militia, which include thousands of Afghan Shi’a, helped crush the Islamic State in Iraq. Yet, a long war would mean more crisis in the region, with unpredictable consequences for the Iran itself. The country fears that, like the United States, it could crush the Taliban—yet mired in a hopeless morass.

For Iran, then, the end of the Afghan war nowhere in sight: as it weighs its next moves, it knows many more Acts of this savage theatre lie ahead before the curtain finally falls.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Latest: FBI Confirms Items Belonging to Brian Laundrie, Human Remains Found in Florida Park

Update 4:37 P.M.: In a press conference held in Florida, the FBI confirmed that there were in fact human remains found in the Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park on Wednesday morning. Octavio Jones | ... Read more »

Top 3 Dunia: Potensi Energi Terbarukan RI, Transgender AS Raih Bintang Empat

© Copyright (c) 2016 TEMPO.CO foto TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – Berita top 3 dunia kemarin dimulai dari Wakil Presiden Uni Eropa yang menyebut Indonesia memiliki potensi energi terbarukan luar biasa. Itu ... Read more »

Berkeley students willingly pledge money to the Taliban in shocking video

American college students have a soft spot for charitable giving — even when the recipient is the Taliban. In his shocking new video “Students Fund the Taliban,” New York-based filmmaker ... Read more »

Taliban fighters and Afghan soldiers treated side-by-side at rehab center

Striking new photos show Taliban fighters and former Afghan Army soldiers who once fought against each other now being treated for war wounds side-by-side at the same rehab center in ... Read more »

Approach planned: Villa eyeing "quality" £7.2m-rated machine, he's perfect for Smith - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Aaron Hickey battling for the ball Aston Villa are keen on making another approach for Bologna defender Aaron Hickey in the upcoming transfer window. What’s ... Read more »

The Freedom to Vote Act is almost certainly doomed

Congress has repeatedly tried and failed to pass comprehensive voting rights reform this year, even though the Democratic Party holds the majority. Now Democrats are trying again to hit back ... Read more »

National Security Adviser defends UK response to Afghanistan crisis

The UK had expected a Taliban-led regime to take over in Afghanistan since 2020 but no-one had forecast the speed with which the group would sweep to power, the Government’s ... Read more »

How Small Finance Banks can reform the fabric of rural India's finance ecosystem

Financial security is a fundamental need of a person, much needed in order to survive and thrive in the world today. The pandemic has taught us about the uncertainty and ... Read more »

Taliban to reward suicide bombers' families with cash, land

Afghan men remove broken glass inside a Shiite mosque in Kandahar on October 15, 2021, after a suicide bomb attack during Friday prayers that killed at least 33 people and ... Read more »

Small Finance Banks - A Progressive Journey through the Technological Prism

One of the key learnings from the pandemic was the digital quotient of an organization, in the backdrop of accelerated adoption of technology across sectors, especially banking. Today’s banking ecosystem, ... Read more »

Anand Mahindra Tweets Video Of ‘Driverless' Bike, Twitter Issues Red Flag

Image credit: Screengrab from video tweeted by @DoctorAjayita It could well have been a scene straight out of actor Ajay Devgn’s iconic stunt from “Phool Aur Kaante”. Except that it ... Read more »

Female Judges in Afghanistan, Now Jobless and in Hiding

When Nabila was a judge in Afghanistan’s Supreme Court, she granted divorces to women whose husbands were sometimes jailed for assaulting or kidnapping them. Some of the men threatened to ... Read more »

Watch: ex pilot with Parkinson's flies plane in “final wish”

Image credit: Screengrab from NowThis News An elderly woman in the United States, with Parkinson’s Disease, returned to the cockpit for perhaps one last time after her son got in ... Read more »

Storyboard | Leadership changes at Dentsu linked to its ‘transformation'

In 2020, Dentsu announced that it would cut the number of its global brands from 160 to six. (Image: ShutterStock) Accelerated ‘transformation’ of Dentsu International’s operations in India has led ... Read more »

Review | 'Succession' season 3 begins with Logan Roy's promise to "go full f*****g beast"

Season 2 of the best television drama series in recent times, HBO’s Succession, ended with a Shakespearean slam-dunk. Media moghul Logan Roy (Brian Cox) and his Prince Hamlet son Kendall ... Read more »

India, Taliban to hold talks at Moscow Format meeting today

Image: Wikipedia Indian and Taliban officials will meet face-to-face on October 20 at the Moscow Format meeting hosted by Russia. While India had its first formal contact with the Taliban in ... Read more »

In Kabul clinic, Taliban and the soldiers they fought confront wounds of war

After fighting each other for years, Taliban and former government soldiers now rehab together in Kabul By Jorge Silva KABUL (Reuters) – Former Taliban fighter Mohammad Ishaq, who spent years ... Read more »

Hello World | The importance of play at your startup

(Representative image) Atlassian founders Mike Cannon-Brookes and Scott Farquhar used rock-paper-scissors to make decisions they were tied on. Note to readers: Hello world is a program developers run to check ... Read more »

Russia hosts Taliban for talks amid IS group threat concerns

© Alexander Zemlianichenko, AFP Russia hosts the Taliban for talks in Moscow on Wednesday, seeking to assert its influence on Central Asia and push for action against Islamic State group ... Read more »

Goa charter flights allowed from mid-October; but international arrivals expected only from mid-November

(Representative image) Goa Tourism data show that 813 charter flights landed in Goa between October 2018 and May 2019. Russia alone accounted for 292 of these flights. Though the Directorate ... Read more »

SAFF Championship: India's title win also leaves behind pertinent questions

© Provided by Firstpost SAFF Championship: India’s title win also leaves behind pertinent questions The SAFF Championship trophy has been reclaimed! It’s back in India after six years. Igor Stimac has ... Read more »

Developing the Footwear Industry Amid the COVID-19 Pandemic

Unsplash Read more »

In Pics | India ranks 90 among 181 countries prone to natural disasters

Representative image The World Risk Index (WRI) 2020 report, released by the United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human Security (UNU-EHS), Bundnis Entwicklung Hilft and the University of Stuttgart ... Read more »

India to form economic cooperation forum with US, Israel, UAE

(Image: Reuters) India will soon team up with the US, Israel and the UAE to set up a forum for economic cooperation and explore possibilities for joint infrastructure projects in the fields of ... Read more »

The economy on the brink, Taliban rely on former technocrats

Afghanistan Economy (Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved) When the Taliban swept into power, they found Afghanistan's economy fast approaching the brink and were faced with harrowing predictions ... Read more »

Facebook plans to change its name: The Verge

Social media giant Facebook Inc. is planning to rebrand the company with a new name next week, the Verge reported on October 19, citing a source with direct knowledge of ... Read more »

Gita Gopinath to leave IMF, return to Harvard University in January

Gita Gopinath is the first-ever woman Chief Economist of the IMF. (File image) International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) Chief Economist and Director of the Research Department Gita Gopinath will leave her ... Read more »

US lawmakers say Facebook cannot be trusted to manage cryptocurrency

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg A group of United States lawmakers said Facebook Inc cannot be trusted to manage cryptocurrency and urged the social media platform to discontinue immediately a small ... Read more »

Rusia Janji Berikan Bantuan ke Afghanistan, Tetapi Belum Siap Akui Taliban

© Disediakan oleh foto TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – Rusia, Cina dan Pakistan bersedia memberikan bantuan ke Afghanistan, tetapi Kremlin mengatakan Rusia belum siap untuk mengakui pemerintah Taliban, kata Kementerian Luar ... Read more »

Americans best not rely on The New York Times' perverted coverage (and non-coverage) of Afghanistan

Afghan civilians wait outside a bank to withdraw money in Kabul. AP Now that the Biden administration’s shambolic Afghanistan bugout is (at least nominally) complete, the big question is: What ... Read more »

Zomato Terminates Employee Who Told a Customer 'Hindi Is Our National Language'

The ‘never-have-a-bad-meal’ food delivery company Zomato gave a bad experience to a customer. The company invited trouble after its employee slammed a customer, in a grievance redressal conversation, for not ... Read more »

New York City Officials Unanimously Vote to Remove Thomas Jefferson Statue From Council Chambers

In light of events such as the murder of George Floyd, people have been reckoning with the paradoxes of historical figures. Thomas Jefferson occupies one such gray area, as a figure who was ... Read more »

Shocking Video Shows Man Reaching Behind Counter at McDonald's, Stealing Over $1,000

A shocking new surveillance video is making its rounds in which a man can be seen reaching through the Covid-safe partition at a local McDonald’s to steal cash from the open register. NurPhoto ... Read more »

Rare Bird-Flu Outbreak Jumps to Mammals at Wildlife Center

As the world continues to grapple with the effects of Covid-19, a small but concerning virus has also started to make headlines: the H5N8 bird flu strain, which killed five ... Read more »

Amazon Accused of Lying to Congress

Five members of the U.S. House Judiciary Committee accused top Amazon executives of misleading or lying to Congress about the company’s business practices.  Bloomberg | Getty Images Reps. Jerrold Nadler, ... Read more »

Consumer Goods Giant to Raise Prices on More Staples, Blames Increase in Cost on Raw Materials

Procter & Gamble Co. said it will raise prices on a number of household staple goods as the cost for raw materials and freight has increased faster than it had ... Read more »

SEC's GameStop Report Investigates Role of 'Game-Like' Brokerage Apps

A report by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) released Monday that investigated the trading controversy surrounding GameStop earlier this year has challenged the role of “game-like” trading apps that may urge investors to ... Read more »

Southwest Pilots' Union Seeks Delay on Vaccine Mandate

The Southwest Airlines Pilots Association asked a federal court to grant a temporary restraining order to prevent the company from implementing a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for its employees. The mandate ... Read more »

India Will Use AI, ML To Achieve Sustainability Goals: Amitabh Kant

Last year, Google’s Sundar Pichai said the tech giant aims to power all its offices and data centers on sustainable energy 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Its ... Read more »

Bill Gates' Daughter, Jennifer Gates, Shares First Photos of Wedding Gown, Wedding Ceremony -- Take a Look at the Stunning Bride

It was a most-buzzed about wedding the past weekend in North Salem, New York as daughter of billionaire Bill Gates, Jennifer Gates, said ‘I do’ to longtime partner and equestrian ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic